Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter in a weak market: Revenue grew 15% YoY despite a notable retail slowdown, with EBO volume up 10% and ASP up 7-8% from mix shift.
- Volume degrowth is the core soft spot: Same-store volume fell -4% as footfalls dropped; management expects this to reach zero in Q2, with the festive Q3 providing the real demand test.
- New stores are underperforming in this cycle: Stores opened in the last six months are running below the average new-store curve because weak consumer sentiment makes driving footfalls harder.
- Gross margin inched up on channel mix, not input costs: The 70 bps rise to 61.3% came from EBO share moving to 73%; the benefit of lower cotton prices is still locked in older, higher-cost inventory.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether volume degrowth actually hits zero as guided, the true run-rate of LFS revenue now that April disruption has normalized, and any early signal on festive demand.
Demand & Consumer Environment
- Footfalls drove the volume decline: Same-store volume degrowth of -4% was entirely a bill-cut story, with footfalls dropping at the store level. ASP growth of 7-8% cushioned the value impact, but only 1-1.2 percentage points of that came from legacy price hikes taken in December 2021; the rest was product mix.
- Services are absorbing the wallet: Management attributed the slowdown to consumer sentiment skewed toward services like travel, leisure and hotels over hard consumer goods. Metro and Tier 1 cities held up better than Tier 2 and Tier 3, and North India, led by Delhi NCR, posted the highest same-store sales growth in the quarter.
- New stores are bearing the brunt: Stores opened in the last six months performed below the average new-store curve. Management explained that newer stores suffer more than vintage ones in a tough environment because footfalls must be actively driven to reach maturity, and weak sentiment makes that harder.
- The Q2 bet is zero volume degrowth: Management expects the volume decline to narrow to zero in Q2, calling it a transition and revival quarter, with demand normalcy arriving by Q3. July is a complete end-of-season-sale month, so the company will have better clarity only by mid-to-late August.
Gautam Saraogi: "we are expecting to have more degrowth in volume... we would be hopeful that this coming quarter in Q2, we'll be able to make that negative as zero at least."
Store Expansion & Real Estate Strategy
- Store-opening target held at 120-130 for FY24: The company reiterated its plan to add 120 to 130 stores this year, with the ambition to scale that to 150 to 170 stores next year. Current bandwidth makes the lower number a given; hitting the higher number depends on building the business development team's capacity through this year.
- Store size is creeping up: The company has started signing slightly larger stores of 450 to 475 square feet, up from the historical 300 to 400 square feet, to accommodate additional sizes and SKUs. Management stressed that the decision factor remains rent, not square footage, and average store revenue of ₹80-90 lakhs should rise with the larger format without compromising EBITDA margin.
- BD team is being rebuilt for the next growth leg: The real estate business development team is being augmented; some people have joined, some are in training. Management expects the results, in the form of a higher flow of viable site options, to start showing from Q1 next year. The strike rate on evaluated properties stays at 12-13%.
- Cluster growth is paused, not stopped: No new clusters were added in the last three to four months; all growth is happening within existing markets. Management declined to set a target for annual cluster additions, calling it a by-product of store additions rather than a separate goal.
- Three stores closed in the quarter: One was a relocation where the older store was kept for three months after the new one opened. Two were high-street closures driven by very high rental costs in markets where sales have not recovered post-COVID.
Gautam Saraogi: "For me, my decision factor to open a store is on the basis of rent rather than square feet."
Channel & Revenue Mix
- EBO share rose, lifting gross margin: The EBO mix moved from 71% to 73% of revenue, and that channel shift was the primary driver of the 70 bps gross margin expansion to 61.3%. The benefit of reduced cotton prices has not yet flowed through because the company is in an inventory optimization phase and has not been purchasing much; cost of goods sold still reflects older, higher-priced raw material.
- LFS revenue per door fell 10%: The decline was partly because some portion of April was impacted by operational disruption. Management said things have normalized from a dispatch, operations and demand perspective, and that Q2 will show the true picture of how the LFS channel is growing.
- Volume growth split tells the story: Company-level volume growth was 7%, but that breaks down into EBO volume up 10% and LFS volume down 2%. The gap between same-store sales growth of 2.5% and same-channel sales growth of 16% reflects both cannibalization from cluster density and weak consumer sentiment; management estimates SSSG would have been 6-7% minimum after stripping out cannibalization.
- Product mix stayed steady: No single product stood out; the mix was similar to earlier quarters, with Chudidar leggings at a 45-50% contribution.
Gautam Saraogi: "Because we are in the stage of optimizing inventory, we have not been purchasing a lot of late. So our COG is largely based on the older RM price."
Costs, Margins & Cash Flow
- Operating leverage reversed on muted sales: Rent-to-revenue ratio rose to 15-16% from a normal 12-13%, and salaries-to-sales ratio also moved up, both purely because of muted revenue rather than any step-up in costs. Rent escalations remain standard at 5% annually or 15% every three years.
- Advertising was deliberately pulled back: Other expenses fell 7% YoY despite a 24% increase in store count, largely because of ad-spend phasing. Management's rationale was explicit: when consumer buying intention is low, high ad spends waste money. On an annualized basis, ad spend will be 2-3% of revenue this year, down from 3-4% last year.
- Cash conversion stayed strong: The company generated ₹25 crores of pre-Ind-AS operating cash flow, converting 65% of pre-Ind-AS EBITDA to OCF, helped by inventory efficiencies. On an annualized basis, management expects to deliver 50% conversion.
- Inventory is being worked down: Inventory reduced from ₹230 crores to ₹223 crores, with the reduction entirely at the warehouse level. Store-level inventory at 45-50 days was already adequate and was not optimized further. Management is targeting 90-95 inventory days by year-end, though Q2 may see a slight uptick due to festive stock building.
- Gross margin target set at 61% for the full year: Management expects to deliver approximately 61% gross margin on an annualized basis, up from 60% last year.
Gautam Saraogi: "when the consumer's intention of buying is not there, doing very high ad spends don't make sense. So the reason we didn't do ad spends was because we didn't want to waste money."
Branding & Digital Build-Out
- Branding and digital teams were strengthened this quarter: The company established a robust branding team and specifically strengthened its digital team, which played a pivotal role in crafting brand identity.
- Influencer marketing is now active: The company has started doing significant influencer marketing and launched a couple of denim styles with a good digital campaign.
- Supplier base expanded for scale: The number of suppliers increased materially, but management clarified this is about broadening the supplier base through CMT subcontracting and job-work partners as the company grows; existing supplier volumes and ratios remain unchanged.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume degrowth | Narrow to zero; hopeful for positive volume growth | Q2 FY24 |
| Same-store sales growth | 5% SSSG with no volume growth | Q2 FY24 (hopeful) |
| Full-year SSSG target | 10% value, 5% volume (original target maintained) | FY24 |
| Store additions | 120-130 stores | FY24 |
| Store addition capacity | Team in place to deliver 150-170 stores | Starting FY25 |
| Gross margin | ~61% on an annualized basis | FY24 exit |
| Inventory days | 90-95 days | FY24 exit |
| Ad spend | 2-3% of revenue (down from 3-4% last year) | FY24 annualized |
| Pre-Ind-AS EBITDA to OCF conversion | 50% | FY24 annualized |
| Annualized growth rate guidance | Will provide at end of Q2 | End of Q2 FY24 |
| LFS channel visibility | True growth picture visible | Q2 FY24 |
| BD team expansion results | Options from expanded team start flowing in | Q1 FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹190 cr, +15% YoY |
| Gross profit | ₹117 cr, +16% YoY; gross margin 61.3%, +70 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹64 cr, +21% YoY; EBITDA margin 33.8% |
| Pre-Ind AS EBITDA margin | 21.3% |
| Profit before tax | ₹35 cr, +9% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹26 cr, +8% YoY; PAT margin 13.8% |
| Same-store sales growth (SSG) | 2.46% |
| Same-cluster sales growth | 16% YoY |
| Volume SSG | -4% (per an analyst's math) |
| EBO volume growth | 10% |
| Company-level volume growth | 7% |
| Average selling price (EBO) | ₹771 |
| Full-price sales mix | 96% of sales |
| EBO count | 655 stores, net +25 in Q1 |
| City presence | 149 cities, +6 in Q1 |
| Store expansion plan | 120–130 EBOs per year |
| Inventory days | 107 days, reduced by 19 days QoQ; working capital days 136 days |
| Pre-Ind AS operating cash flow | ₹25 cr |
| ROCE (annualized) | 19.1% |
| ROE (annualized) | 19.8% |
| Ad spend | below 2% of revenue in Q1; full-year guidance 2–3% |
| Rent-to-revenue ratio | 15–16%, up from normal 12–13% due to muted sales |
| LFS revenue growth | 3% YoY |
| Revenue per LFS | declined 10% QoQ |
| Gross margin full-year guidance | ~61% |
| Store opening bandwidth target (next year) | 150–170 stores |