Key Takeaways
- Record revenue, volume-led: Revenue grew 48% YoY to ₹166 crores, the highest ever quarterly revenue, driven by 34% volume growth and an improved product portfolio.
- Store rollout on track: 66 EBOs added in H1, with full-year guidance of 120–130 stores reaffirmed; the pipeline for H2 is another 60–65 stores.
- Margins steady despite EOSS drag: Gross margin held near 60% as the EBO mix shift was gradual; PAT margin guidance of 13–14% was given.
- Cotton tailwind is coming, but slowly: New inventory will be sourced at lower cotton prices, but the benefit will take a few quarters to flow through to gross margins.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive-season Q3 delivers the expected sequential lift, the pace of store additions in H2, and any signal on when lower cotton costs begin to ease margin pressure.
Top-Line Performance & Drivers
- Volume, not price, did the work: Overall volume grew 34% YoY and 37% vs pre-COVID Q2 FY20; like-to-like volume growth in same stores vs pre-COVID was 8%, which management called "a very good number."
- ASP reflects mix, not markdowns: H1 FY23 ASP was ₹709, rising continuously on value-added products. The sequential Q2 dip was purely from 3–4% of sales coming from EOSS, not a price correction.
- Full-price strength: 96% of H1 EBO sales were at full price, underscoring the essential-product, low-discounting model.
- SSSG anchored to pre-COVID: SSSG per EBO stood at 31% vs pre-COVID Q2 FY20; management compares to FY20 because last year was COVID-impacted.
- Monthly run-rate: Average monthly revenue run-rate is ₹55 crores, with October trending higher than September on festive demand.
Gautam Saraogi: "We delivered 8% volume growth compared to pre-COVID... we have done a 8% volume growth, which as management, we feel is a very good number."
Seasonality & Sequential Patterns
- Q2 is structurally weak: Q3 is the best quarter, followed by Q1; Q2 and Q4 are the weakest quarters in apparel retail. August and September in Q2, and February and March in Q4, are dull months.
- Same-store sales fall QoQ is normal: There is typically a double-digit fall in same-store sales value from Q1 to Q2 for both EBO and LFS; ASP was impacted more in EBO due to EOSS, but absolute sales value on volume or value basis sees a double-digit fall for same stores present in both quarters.
- Festive lift underway: Q3 October revenue was higher than August and September; the Q2 trend is continuing and improving in Q3.
Gautam Saraogi: "Q3 is the best quarter, followed by Q1, Q2 and Q4 are usually the weakest quarters in retail in general for apparel."
Store Expansion & Channel Strategy
- EBO rollout pace: 36 EBOs added in Q2, 66 in H1; full-year guidance of 120–130 stores maintained, implying 60–65 more in H2. Total EBO count reached 569 as of 30 Sep 2022.
- Where new stores go: 50% to 60% of incremental EBO stores are expected from Tier 1, top 2 and top 8 cities.
- BD pipeline being built: The BD team options pool is targeted to increase from ~1,000 to ~1,500 per year, but building the team will take at least 1 to 2 years.
- LFS as a market-entry tool: Reliance and Pantaloons provide entry into newer towns where the company does not have an EBO; growth is selective based on market weakness or opportunity. Reliance offers an opportunity of ~800 additional stores out of ~2,000, while Pantaloons presence can grow from 30–40 stores out of 200+.
- Tier demand is steady: No divergence seen between Tier 2/Tier 3 and Tier 1; performance is in line with recent quarters, with Tier 2/Tier 3 improving but no real shift.
- Tier definitions updated: The company internally reclassified Tier 1, Tier 2, Tier 3 city definitions based on updated population criteria; Tier 4 is now defined as less than 1 lakh population.
Margins & Cost Structure
- Gross margin held near 60%: Q2 GP margin at 59.6% was affected by EOSS in July, which is higher than in other quarters. The EBO mix improved only slightly YoY (72% to 74%), so the channel mix shift was not dramatic enough to lift the gross margin materially.
- PAT margin guidance intact: Management maintained PAT margin guidance of 13% to 14%.
- Steady-state target: Post-IND AS, the steady-state EBITDA margin target is 31% to 32% on an annualized basis.
- A&P spend front-loaded: Full-year A&P spend will be between 3% and 4% of sales; H2 spend will be considerably lower because the majority was deployed before the festive season. Spend will not cross 4.5% in any year.
- Long-term A&P anchor: Advertising spend will be maintained at 2.5% to 3% of sales long-term, occasionally up to 3.5% or 4%, with strategy reviewed annually.
Gautam Saraogi: "But one thing I can tell you out of certainty is that we will not be crossing the 4.5% mark. Because that is something which we don't look at."
Cotton & Pricing Strategy
- Lower cotton costs are coming: New inventory sourcing will be at lower cotton prices, but the transition will take a few quarters; gross margin benefit will eventually come if cotton prices stay low.
- Pricing is cautious: Management will wait and watch for a few months of sustainability of lower cotton prices before using them as a benchmark for new products; current pricing is based on older, higher cotton prices.
- High-cost inventory not quantified: Management declined to quantify how many days of high-cost inventory remain, stating cotton and yarn price movements have been haphazard and estimation is very difficult.
- ASP outlook is mix-dependent: Year-end ASP is very difficult to estimate because it depends on new products, new pricing, and which product sells more (regular chudidar vs jeggings, etc.). ASP is expected to remain in the range of ₹715 to ₹730.
Gautam Saraogi: "We'll probably wait and see for a few months of sustainability of these lower prices. In these prices turn out to be sustainable at these lower prices, then the future products, what we are going to be launching, we are going to be taking the lower cotton prices into benchmark."
Balance Sheet & Strategic Initiatives
- Working capital improved sharply: Working capital days reduced to 137 days as of 30 Sep 2022 from 190 days as of 31 Mar 2022, with further reduction targeted.
- Cash flow positive: Positive operating cash flow of ₹36 crores delivered in H1 FY23.
- Brand-building investment: Three films launched on a Pan-India platform during the quarter, each showcasing individual triumphs and journeys of women. The association with Spring Marketing Capital was a one-time project for film creation with no ongoing retainer or investment.
- Omni-channel and technology focus: Management is looking at omni-channel engagement for seamless consumer experience, building a technology-driven growth strategy, and leveraging technology for cost efficiency. A warehouse upgrade is planned to optimize inventory and supply management.
- Customer acquisition push: Focus will be to target customer acquisition to drive sales to the website and online marketplaces.
Gautam Saraogi: "It was just a onetime association with springcapital or the creation of the item... there is no ongoing association with spring. Also, the just further correct on this, we also consult many companies without investment."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Store additions | 120–130 new EBOs in FY23; 66 opened in H1, 60–65 more in H2 | FY23 |
| Revenue | Greater than ₹625–630 crore on a conservative basis | FY23 |
| PAT margin | 13% to 14% | FY23 |
| ASP range | ₹715 to ₹730 | FY23 |
| A&P spend ceiling | Will not cross 4.5% of sales in any year | Ongoing |
| Steady-state EBITDA margin | 31% to 32% on an annualized basis, post-IND AS | Steady-state (no date) |
| BD team options pool | Increase from ~1,000 to ~1,500 per year; team build takes 1–2 years | 1–2 years to build |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹166 cr, +48% YoY, highest ever quarterly revenue |
| Revenue vs pre-COVID (Q2 FY20) | +55% |
| Gross profit | ₹99 cr, +50% YoY; gross margin 59.6% |
| EBITDA | ₹49 cr, +40% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 29.8% |
| Profit before tax | ₹25 cr, +37% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹19 cr, +44% YoY |
| H1 FY23 revenue | ₹331 cr, +131% YoY |
| H1 FY23 EBITDA margin | 31.0% |
| H1 FY23 PAT margin | 13.2% |
| FY23 revenue guidance | >₹625–630 cr on a conservative basis |
| FY23 PAT margin guidance | 13% to 14% |
| Steady-state EBITDA margin target (post Ind-AS) | 31% to 32% annualized |
| Same-store sales growth (SSSG) per EBO vs Q2 FY20 | 31% in value terms |
| Like-to-like volume growth vs Q2 FY20 | 8% |
| Overall volume growth vs Q2 FY20 | 37% |
| Volume growth YoY | 34% |
| EBO stores added in Q2 | 36 |
| Total EBO count | 569 as of 30 Sep 2022 |
| FY23 store addition guidance | 120 to 130; 66 added in H1, 60–65 expected in H2 |
| EBO sales mix | 74% of revenue, up from 72% |
| Full-price sales (H1 FY23 EBO) | 96% of sales |
| Average selling price (H1 FY23) | ₹709 |
| ASP estimate range | ₹715 to ₹730 |
| A&P spend (H1 FY23) | 4.5% of sales |
| A&P spend guidance (FY23) | 3% to 4% of sales; will not cross 4% |
| Working capital days | 137 days as of 30 Sep 2022, down from 190 days as of 31 Mar 2022 |
| Operating cash flow (H1 FY23) | ₹36 cr positive |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹131.4 cr as of 30 Sep 2022 |
| ROCE (annualized) | 20% |
| ROE (annualized) | 18% |
| Rent paid (H1 FY23, before Ind-AS) | ₹43 cr |
| Ind-AS bottom-line impact (annual) | ₹8–9 cr |
| Promoter share pledge loan amount | ₹150 cr, no change |
| LFS counters added in H1 FY23 | Nearly 180 |
| Reliance store penetration | Present in ~1,200 of close to 2,000 stores; opportunity of ~800 more |
| Pantaloons store presence | Present in 30 to 40 of more than 200 stores |
| Monthly revenue run-rate | ₹55–60 cr |
| Inventory at older (higher) cotton price | More than 90% |