Key Takeaways
- Margin reset, not a crisis: EBITDA margin fell to 11% in Q4 (FY24: 12%) as employee and marketing costs rose, but management expects a 12–13% range going forward, funded by operating leverage and renewable energy savings.
- Wafer is the growth engine: Wafer revenue grew 40% YoY in Q4, carries a 4% gross margin premium over Namkeen/Gathiya, and management plans to sustain that pace while scaling mix to 12–13% and beyond.
- Core market stabilising: Gujarat volume was flat overall, but the YoY decline narrowed from 9% to 1% through the year, and Q4 improved on Q3; management now targets double-digit growth in the core.
- Focus markets delivering: Rajasthan, Maharashtra, MP and UP grew revenue 37% YoY in Q4, with volume up 18%; 80 distributors were added in the last 100 days and the target is 20%+ growth.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the core Gujarat market actually returns to double-digit growth, the pace of wafer mix shift, and whether the promised 12–13% EBITDA margin materialises as marketing spend rises toward 2% of revenue.
Margin Bridge & Cost Structure
- What drove the Q4 decline: Employee costs rose on new headcounts and annual increments, while marketing spend increased; together they compressed EBITDA margin to 11% from 13% a year ago.
- Raw material tailwind passed through: Palm oil prices fell 16% YoY while Chana rose 20%, yielding a net benefit of ~₹5 cr that was handed to consumers via a grammage increase on the ₹5 SKU (20g to 25g) and a retailer margin hike from ₹0.50 to ₹0.75.
- Employee cost trajectory: FY24 employee expenses were ₹102 cr; headcount additions are now complete, so FY25 will see only annual increments and inflation, with some optimisation of excess manpower.
- Operating leverage levers: The Nagpur and Modasa plants carry fixed overheads that will dilute as volume scales; solar, windmill and boiler investments will cut energy costs, and backward integration facilities are coming online.
- Subsidy income rising: Other operating income was ₹8 cr in Q4 and is expected to run above ₹10 cr going forward, with the Modasa facility subsidy starting in FY25 at ₹10–12 cr annually for the next 4–5 years.
- Wafer margin advantage: Wafer products carry a 4% higher gross margin than Namkeen and Gathiya, so as wafer mix rises, blended gross margin percentage will improve.
Mukesh Shah: "We have state-of-the-art facility at Modasa and the largest cold storage facility in India which gives us an edge in terms of quality as well as our cost of production is lower compared to any other player in this industry."
Segment & Product Mix
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Gathiya | ▲ Steady | Revenue grew 5% YoY in Q4; packet volume up 11%; management expects continued double-digit growth in ethnic snacks. |
| Wafer | ▲ Strong | Revenue grew 40% YoY; packet volume up 33%; negligible market share today, state-of-the-art Modasa facility and cold storage provide a cost edge; target is to sustain the pace and scale mix to 12–13% and beyond. |
| New products | ▬ Nascent | Products launched in the last 3–4 years contribute 7–8% of revenue; launches are demand-driven with no fixed pipeline. |
- Price-point shift underway: The ₹10 SKU grew 36% YoY in packets, while the ₹5 SKU remains the largest revenue contributor; retailer margin on the ₹5 SKU stays at ₹0.75.
- Recent launches: Kolapuri Bhadang (a regional Maharashtra product), Sabudana Chivda and Cornigo Ring were introduced in the past three months.
Geography & Distribution
- Core market (Gujarat): Volume was flat overall, but the trajectory improved through the year: the YoY decline narrowed from 9% to 1%, and Q4 was better than Q3. Management attributes the earlier softness to competition and "unhealthy way of doing business" and now targets double-digit volume and value growth by deepening penetration in the 25% of retail outlets where the company is still absent.
- Focus markets (Rajasthan, Maharashtra, MP, UP): Revenue grew 37% YoY in Q4 and packet volume rose 18%; 80 distributors were added in the last 100 days, taking the total to 667, and retail touchpoints crossed 5.5 lakh. The target is 20%+ volume and value growth.
- Next-wave expansion: The company plans to enter Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Telangana and Karnataka.
- Sales infrastructure: The ASM, RSM and national sales head roles are all filled, and the distributor network continues to expand.
Raj Hadvani: "We have a dominance of 30 years in Gujarat market and currently we are penetrated 75% only. And our focus is to do a deep penetration both from a product perspective where we have at least 25% of retail outlet where we are not present."
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Debt reduction: Gross debt fell from ₹107 cr to ₹67 cr during FY24, with cash from operations used for repayment and some capex.
- Temporary net debt: Net debt of ₹65 cr as of March 2024 is seasonal; the company was cash-surplus in December and borrowed only to stock chana and potato in Q4 when the annual crop arrives, to lock in price and quality. Inventory will be consumed in subsequent months.
- Working capital: The increase reflects lower EBITDA (reducing cash generation by ₹20–25 cr) plus the temporary inventory build, not a structural shift.
- Capex pause: Capacity utilisation is just 35–36%; revenue can double without major capex. No new capacity investment until utilisation reaches 75–80%, though small packing-unit spends may occur. Ordering on capex could begin in the second year forward, but the peak investment point is tied to that 75–80% threshold.
- ROE/ROCE trajectory: Expected to rise substantially as profitability improves with no major capex in the next one to two years.
- Dividend: The board declared a 25% dividend (₹0.25 per ₹1 share); management intends to distribute a good amount going forward but declined to commit to a policy, saying it depends on performance.
- Promoter holding: Promoters will dilute to meet the SEBI 75% requirement within three years, but no specific timeline was given.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin | Maintain at 27–28% | Going forward |
| EBITDA margin | Maintain in 12–13% range | Going forward |
| Marketing spend | Increase to ~2% of revenue (from <1%), offset by operating leverage and renewable energy savings | FY25 |
| Wafer growth | Sustain close to 40% pace; mix to reach 12–13% and rise substantially thereafter | FY25 and beyond |
| Core market growth | Double-digit volume and value growth | FY25 |
| Focus market growth | Close to 20%+ volume and value growth | FY25 |
| Employee cost | Only annual increments and inflation; no significant headcount increase | FY25 |
| Subsidy income | ₹10–12 cr annually from Modasa facility | FY25 and next 4–5 years |
| Capex | No new capacity investment until utilisation reaches 75–80% | Until threshold met |
| Promoter holding | Dilute to meet SEBI 75% requirement | Within 3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Operational revenue | 8% YoY growth |
| Gross margin | ~28%, stable YoY; absolute amount ₹101 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 11%, vs 13% in Q4 FY23 |
| Gathiya revenue growth | 5% YoY |
| Wafer revenue growth | 40% YoY |
| Focus markets revenue growth | 37% YoY (Maharashtra, MP, Rajasthan, UP) |
| INR10 SKU packet volume growth | 42% YoY |
| INR5 SKU retailer margin | ₹0.75, increased from ₹0.50 in Q2 FY24 |
| Marketing spend | ~₹4 cr in Q4; FY24 less than ₹10 cr |
| Other operating income | ~₹7 cr in Q4; PSI subsidy for Nagpur facility |
| Net debt | ₹65 cr as of March 2024, temporary CC credit for raw material purchase |
| Capacity utilization | 35% to 36% |
| ROCE | 31% |
| ROE | 26% |
| Asset turnover ratio | 6.6x |