Key Takeaways
- Steady quarter, shadowed by a leadership transition: Profit after tax fell 9% YoY and QoQ, driven entirely by lower other income from MTM losses, while core operating metrics held firm.
- The Prashant Jain era ends: The CIO's resignation after 19 years is the quarter's defining event; management moved quickly to name internal successors and stressed the team's depth, but the market will watch for any impact on the ~43-44% of AUM he directly managed.
- Flows are bifurcated: Equity inflows stayed healthy, with positive net flows into ~90% of actively managed funds, while fixed income suffered a second consecutive quarter of heavy outflows as rising rates bite.
- Market share is stabilizing, not yet recovering: The active equity market share held flat sequentially, with gross flow share improving and redemption share falling, but net new flow share must rise above 11.5% to actually gain ground.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of the nine planned ETF launches, any early signs of debt flow stabilization, and whether the new equity leadership can sustain the performance-to-flows recovery that was just beginning.
Leadership Transition
- Prashant Jain resigned after 19 years as CIO, announced on the day of the call. The role of CIO will not be filled: Chirag Setalvad will lead the equity team and Shobhit Mehrotra will lead fixed income, both reporting directly to Navneet Munot.
- Rahul Baijal joined the equity team from Sundaram Mutual Fund, bringing over 20 years of experience. Management cited the combined experience of the equity investment team at 230-240 years.
- AUM concentration will fall as Prashant Jain's ~43-44% of AUM is split across one, two, or three managers, a structural de-risking of the portfolio.
Munot: "The HDFC AMC investment team is known to be amongst one of the best in the country. I have now spent nearly a year and a half at HDFC AMC and can vouch for the processes and depth that is second to none."
Flow Environment
- Equity flows moderated but stayed strong: Industry net equity inflows were ₹78,300 crore, down from ₹96,800 crore QoQ, though the headline includes index funds for both equity and debt, which distorts the comparison.
- Fixed income bled again: The industry lost ₹117,800 crore in fixed income funds, following ₹104,600 crore of outflows in the prior quarter. Management attributes this to rising rates making returns less attractive and shrinking systemic liquidity.
- SIP flows held up: SIP inflow reported on a cash flow basis was ₹1,280 crore. Management noted that daily transaction data shows investors buying more on days the market corrects sharply.
- Performance-to-flows lag is working in HDFC AMC's favor: Management described a four-stage cycle where good or bad performance is ignored for a couple of quarters, then noticed but believed temporary, then distributors and investors plan action, and real action follows over the next couple of quarters. Market share is stabilizing, redemption share is falling, and gross flow share is improving.
Munot: "My experience tells me that performance either way, good or bad tends to be ignored for couple of quarters. It then gets noticed but there is a belief that the phase is temporary. Investors and distributors will then start planning an action, but the real action would follow over the next couple of quarters."
Market Share & Competitive Dynamics
- Active equity market share held flat sequentially, ending a run of quarter-on-quarter losses. For share to actually improve, net new flow market share must exceed 11.5%.
- Commissions remain elevated but rational: Competition is intense and the NFO cycle has restarted, but the industry has realized it makes sense to do business at a rational price. Banks are the most expensive distribution channel, followed by national distributors, then MFDs.
- SIP registration catch-up underway: The company lost a large number of SIP registrations during the last couple of years due to slightly muted performance, but traction is now improving. Management is hopeful of regaining market share over the next couple of quarters to couple of years.
- Distributor engagement has gone up substantially across all channels: banks, national distributors, and MFDs.
Kanuga: "Industry as a whole has kind of realized that it makes sense to do business at a rational price."
Yields & Revenue
- Overall yields improved sequentially and YoY, driven by a marginal change in mix and some rounding effects. Management cautioned not to read much into it; yields are in line with previous quarter commentary. Zero NFOs in the quarter meant lower revenue flow into AUM was lower.
- Active equity yield dilution will continue as more money comes in: the legacy book yields mid-70s basis points while new flows are nowhere near that number. The pace of dilution may slow because the AUM denominator is now larger (~₹18-19 trillion vs ₹13 trillion) relative to similar gross flow levels.
- Debt yields are expected to remain more or less constant, somewhere between 25 and 30 basis points. Migration toward debt index funds may dilute any yield uplift from increased YTM on credit risk funds.
- Other income fell dramatically due to lower MTM gains on debt mutual funds (rising interest rates) and MTM losses on mandatory equity mutual fund investments due to market volatility and the skin-in-the-game circular.
Kanuga: "If you look at our book, somewhere at mid-70s versus the flows that are nowhere near that number. So, absolutely, you are right. There is going to be dilution in yield as more and more money comes in."
Costs & Margins
- Employee cost (ex-ESOP, non-cash) was ₹67.7 crore vs ₹65.9 crore YoY, a modest increase. Sequential growth of 13% reflects appraisals and normal year-end compensation increases; over three years, the expense CAGR is only 6%.
- Other expenses rose 27% YoY, but the base quarter (Q1 FY22) had reduced operations due to lockdown. Compared to a normalized pre-COVID quarter (Q1 FY20: ₹40.6 crore), expenses grew at a CAGR of ~9% to ₹52.5 crore, driven by business promotion, technology spend, and a return to normal activity like distributor training and travel.
- Management will keep investing: Costs in some form and shape will be there, and the trend is expected to continue. The company will be mindful of spending but will not shy from investing in technology, data security, and IT infrastructure.
- Effective tax rate fell to about 18.4% due to a reduction in deferred tax charge on MTM losses and reversal of deferred tax liability on certain investments sold and set off against carried forward losses.
New Initiatives & Product Pipeline
- Nine ETFs approved and proposed to be launched during the course of the quarter, following a regulatory embargo on new scheme launches that was in place for Q1. More ETFs and index funds have been filed and will launch as approvals come.
- Four sectoral/thematic funds are awaiting clearance and will be launched over time subject to approvals.
- Category-II AIF filed: A PPM was filed with SEBI in early June for a fund of funds investing across early-stage VC (~half), mid-market/growth funds (balance half), and some buyout funds. Screening of underlying fund managers has started.
- GIFT City subsidiary is progressing well, with go-live expected over the next couple of quarters. The strategy is to create products showcasing domestic investment management capabilities to global investors; inbound is a larger angle than outbound.
- Filed for a fund tracking the MSCI Emerging Markets Index.
Munot: "Inbound is a larger angle."
Capital Allocation
- Dividend payout ratio for the last financial year was just under 65%. Management expects the payout ratio to have an upward trajectory going forward; the slope should move upward. The board is cognizant and will continue to evaluate the best possible options.
- Cash requirements include setting aside funds for SEBI's skin-in-the-game regulation, seeding AIFs, and putting capital into funds to be set up in GIFT City. No specific cash threshold for higher dividends was given.
- Investment book: A very large part of the ₹5,500 crore investment book is invested in the company's own fixed income funds, with no aggressive calls on interest rates or duration.
Munot: "You would know that our dividend payout ratio for the last financial year was just a shade under 65% and I would like to believe that they should slope upward."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| ETF launches | Launch all nine approved ETFs | During the course of the quarter |
| GIFT City subsidiary | Go-live | Over the next couple of quarters |
| Dividend payout ratio | Upward trajectory; slope should move upward from just-under-65% level | Going forward |
| Active equity market share | Net new flow market share must exceed 11.5% for share to improve | No date; stabilization underway |
| SIP market share recovery | Regain lost share | Over the next couple of quarters to couple of years |
| Debt fund flows | Money may return when people believe rates are stabilizing | Conditional on rate stabilization |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | 3% YoY growth and 1% QoQ growth |
| Profit after tax | 9% decline YoY and QoQ, driven by lower other income |
| Effective tax rate | ~18.4%, lower due to reduced deferred tax charge on MTM losses and reversal of deferred tax liability |
| Employee cost (excl. ESOP) | ₹67.7 cr, vs ₹65.9 cr in Q1 FY22 |
| Other expenses | ₹52.5 cr, +27% YoY; 9% CAGR over 3 years from ₹40.6 cr in Q1 FY20 |
| Dividend payout ratio (FY22) | Just under 65%, expected to slope upward |
| Overall closing AUM | ₹396,600 cr, market share of 11.1% |
| Closing AUM market share (ex-ETF) | 12.4% on closing AUM, 12.3% on quarterly average |
| Actively managed equity AUM market share | More or less constant vs March 2022 |
| B-30 AUM market share | 11.4%, distant number 2 in the industry |
| Systematic transactions (monthly) | ₹1,280 cr in June 2022, vs ₹1,230 cr in March 2022 |
| Active equity book yield | Mid-70s bps as of June 30, 2022; new flows at yields better than 40 bps but nowhere near 75 bps |
| Debt yield | Late 20s bps, expected to remain between 25–30 bps |
| AUM concentration (Prashant Jain) | ~43–44% of total AUM, expected to decline post-transition |
| SEBI skin-in-the-game requirement | ₹388 cr invested: ₹258 cr in equity, ₹130 cr in debt |