Key Takeaways
- Equity flows held up, debt outflows eased: Net equity flows were materially lower industry-wide, but HDFC AMC’s Business Cycle NFO brought in ₹2,340 crore and SIPs stayed robust. On the debt side, outflows slowed and turned positive when index funds and ETFs are included.
- Revenue flat despite 15% AUM growth: Operating revenue rose only 2% YoY for the nine-month period, as TER dilution from funds crossing ₹5,000 crore AUM and MTM impact on equity yields compressed the top line. Operating profit was nearly flat.
- The margin-volume trade-off is explicit: Management believes AUM growth will more than compensate for margin loss over time, and the equity proportion of AUM should rise faster, but the near-term P&L shows the squeeze.
- Cost investments are peaking: Employee costs grew ~10% and other expenses picked up on NFOs, digital refresh, and the GIFT City subsidiary setup. With the core product range now full, NFO-related spend is expected to slow.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the SEBI fee study produces any regulatory change, the pace of HDFC Bank distribution synergy after the merger, and any stabilization in gross flow rates as a percentage of AUM.
Flows & AUM Dynamics
- Equity flows decoupled from market levels: Industry saw a negative short-term correlation where rapidly rising markets muted gross flows and increased redemptions. HDFC AMC’s flows were good across all products, with the Business Cycle Fund NFO adding a lump.
- SIP book remains the anchor: Systematic transactions continued to be robust, with 77% of the SIP book having a commitment tenure above 10 years. Management stated SIPs will remain a major focus area for several quarters.
- Debt outflows slowing: The rate of debt fund outflows decreased from the September quarter. Including debt index funds and ETFs, net flows turned positive at ₹10,300 crore. Management sees a possibility of investors returning to longer-dated debt funds if yields stay range-bound with a downward bias.
- Unique investor share reversed its decline: HDFC AMC added ~0.02 crore unique investors in Q3 against an industry addition of ~0.07 crore, capturing over 30% of incremental unique investors.
- B-30 contribution deepening: B-30 markets contributed 60% of the increase in SIP count over the nine months ending December 2022, up from under 50% in the prior year, though B-30 and T-30 growth rates were the same.
Navneet Munot: "No, it's not that somebody has done a three-year SIP and after the three years are over they will pull out that money, not necessarily. I think a lot of that money stays in the system and grows over a period of time."
Revenue & Margin Mechanics
- TER dilution from scale: Three large funds crossed the ₹5,000 crore AUM hurdle, each diluting overall TER by 2–3 bps. The pace of dilution was rapid last financial year; this year gross flows as a percentage of beginning AUM are in the early 20s versus ~45% last year, which should slow the dilution going forward.
- MTM impact on equity yields: A 3–4 bps yield dilution on equity funds from mark-to-market changes (one-year returns up 10–15%) shaved roughly 1.5 bps off the entire corpus. Despite equity AUM growing 15% YoY, operating revenue grew only 2% because margins contracted, though the asset mix shift toward equity partially offset the contraction.
- Debt yields stable: Not much change in debt yields quarter-on-quarter, though some money moving to debt index funds puts additional pressure. Standalone product margins are very similar to recent quarters.
- Other income held up: Q3 other income was similar to Q2 at ~₹100 crore, supported by gains on equity AUM (skin-in-the-game investments) and debt investments. No major MTM loss on the debt portfolio due to the duration positioning.
- PMS and specially managed accounts declined: A sharp YoY decline came from a couple of large accounts taking money off the table from India; those mandates were lost.
Navneet Munot: "I belong to the school of thought that states that volumes will more than compensate for loss in margins."
Costs & Investments
- Employee cost running at ~10% growth: Nine-month employee cost growth excluding ESOP charges was ~10%, attributed to post-COVID normalization of travel, events, and in-person engagement with investors, distribution partners, and employees. Q3 employee cost was slightly lower sequentially.
- Other expenses picked up on one-time items: The sequential increase was driven by NFO expenses, refreshing digital assets, setup of the GIFT subsidiary, new passive fund schemes, IT infrastructure investments, and incremental CSR. Management declined to break out these components.
- NFO spend expected to slow: With the core category product range now full and gaps in sector/thematic and international funds largely done, remaining launches (target maturity funds, a few passive products) do not require much business promotional or advertising expenditure.
- Cost culture framed as frugal investment: Management characterized the organization as "extremely frugal" and said any expenditure should be viewed as investments in the future. They keep an eye on flow movement and AUM growth prospects and adjust the cost trajectory accordingly.
Navneet Munot: "As a culture, we are an extremely frugal organization. That culture of frugality is so ingrained in our DNA, that will never go away."
Distribution & Market Share
- Sales market share lags performance: Management acknowledged that sales market share improves with a lag after investment performance gets recognized. Performance turned around starting mid-2021, one-year numbers started looking good around mid-2022, and the company was just beginning to see improvement in fund ratings, which tends to get funds onto selected lists of large banks and national distributors.
- Direct vs MFD mix stable: Direct share of equity AUM rose slightly from 21.5% to 22.1%, bank share was nearly constant at 13.5%, and national distributors moved ~20–30 bps. Management characterized this as "not a big change."
- HDFC Bank synergy potential: The share of flows from HDFC Bank remained at similar levels despite industry-leading performance. Management is incrementally positive on getting better flows over time as more products enter the recommendation list, and sees the bank as a "formidable distribution machine" with tremendous potential.
- Commission environment improving: Management believes the commission environment will "fall in balance over the next few quarters." The Business Cycle Fund NFO TER of 55–56 bps was still well below the desired TER. When AUM rises and TER is impacted, the company tends to moderate commissions on future flows, with a lag effect over 6–12 months.
Navneet Munot: "I think we also need to keep in mind, actually a low direct TER, which is due to high commissions, hurts our distribution fraternity in medium to longer term more than anyone else."
New Initiatives & Product Build-Out
- Product lineup now largely complete: Core category products, passive-side products, and gaps in sector/thematic and international funds are by and large done. A fund of funds launched during the quarter has seen encouraging initial response.
- GIFT City subsidiary taking shape: Two independent directors onboarded (ex-Chairman of Deloitte India and ex-co-CEO of Goldman Sachs India), a principal officer and one more resource identified. Setup costs have begun.
- Alternatives business being built for the long term: PMS launched with two strategies and a resource hired; AIF-related costs incurred. Management was explicit that these initiatives will not give a material kicker in the near term: even incremental fees of ₹20–30 crore over the next couple of years will not move the needle for a large top-line company. These are being established from a 3–5 year perspective.
Simal Kanuga: "We are a large top line company. So even if we kind of build these businesses with say 20, 30 crores kind of an incremental fees, even if that comes by over a period of next couple of years, won't really move the needle. But we are kind of establishing these businesses from a perspective of next three, five years."
Regulatory & Structural Watchpoints
- SEBI fee study underway: The regulator initiated a study of fees and expenses charged by mutual funds, announced via press release in late December 2022. It is currently being debated at various levels with industry body engagement. Management said the regulator is "mindful of all stakeholders" and will "do the needful which will hopefully benefit the entire ecosystem over time," but it is too early to expand.
- abrdn co-sponsor cessation pending: abrdn wants to cease being a co-sponsor; the application has been moved to the regulator and the company is awaiting a response. No timeline was shared.
- No open architecture push heard: Management has "not heard anything" on any regulatory push toward open architecture for bank distribution of own AMC products.
Navneet Munot: "I can definitely state that our regulator is very much open to discussion and constructive feedback. ... regulator is mindful of all stakeholders and we'll do the needful which will hopefully benefit the entire ecosystem over time."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NFO-related expenditure | Expected to "slow down quite a bit" since core product range is now full | Going forward |
| Employee cost growth | Expected to be in a "similar zip code" as the ~10% nine-month run rate, subject to full planning study | Next year |
| Commission environment | Believes it "will fall in balance" | Next few quarters |
| HDFC Bank distribution flows | Incrementally positive on getting better flows as more products enter recommendation list | Over time (no date) |
| New initiatives (alternatives, GIFT) materiality | Not expected to move the needle near-term; built for 3–5 year perspective | 3–5 years |
| Dividend payout | Prior year payout ratio was just under 65%; board cognizant of cash on balance sheet | No explicit commitment |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹1,626 cr (9M FY23), +2% YoY |
| Operating profit | ₹1,160 cr (9M FY23), vs ₹1,159.5 cr last fiscal |
| Profit after tax | ₹1,047.8 cr (9M FY23), vs ₹1,049.6 cr last year; quarterly PAT +3% YoY |
| Operating revenue margin | 50 bps of AUM (9M FY23) |
| Operating profit margin | 36 bps of AUM (9M FY23) |
| Total AUM | ₹448,100 cr, market share 11.2% |
| Actively managed equity AUM | ₹231,400 cr, market share 11.8% |
| Equity-oriented assets share of closing AUM | 54.5% |
| Market share excluding ETF (closing AUM basis) | 12.7% |
| Unique investors | 0.63 cr, up from 0.61 cr in Sep '22; ~30%+ share of industry incremental addition |
| Systematic transactions (monthly, Dec '22) | ₹1,570 cr from 0.41 cr transactions, vs ₹1,430 cr in Sep '22 |
| SIP AUM | ₹84,800 cr as of 31 Dec 2022 |
| SIP book commitment >10 years | 77% |
| Debt market share | 13.5% |
| Liquid market share | 14.9% |
| Business Cycle Fund NFO AUM | ₹2,340 cr, over 110,000 applications |
| Business Cycle Fund NFO TER | ~55–56 bps, vs ~40 bps for multi-cap fund launched Dec 2021 |
| Employee cost growth (9M FY23, ex-ESOP) | ~10% YoY |
| Other income (quarterly) | ~₹100 cr, similar to Q2 FY23 |
| Dividend payout ratio (last fiscal) | Just under 65% |
| B-30 contribution to SIP count growth (9M FY23, industry) | 60%, up from <50% in prior fiscal |