Key Takeaways
- Resilient volume growth despite tax headwinds: Individual WRP grew 10% (vs 8% industry), policy count rose 10%, and two-thirds of retail customers were new to the franchise, demonstrating broadening reach even as the >₹5 lakh ticket segment contracted.
- Protection and annuity now drive over half of new business: Retail protection surged 46% YoY, sum assured grew 61%, and annuities contributed 18% of NBP; together these two lines represent ~55% of new business premiums.
- Margins held flat at 26.2% through a year of digestion: Tax changes, the Exide Life integration, a ULIP mix uptick, and higher HDFC Bank counter share all netted out, leaving H1 new business margin unchanged; management expects a similar full-year outcome.
- The tier 2/3 bet is scaling and management calls it the "tip of the iceberg": These markets are growing at double the company rate, supported by the Exide Life footprint, new banca partnerships with small-finance banks, and simpler product designs suited to non-salaried customers.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the >₹5 lakh ticket-size segment recovers in H2 as promised, the pace of cost-ratio normalisation as growth rebounds, and any update on the ₹942 crore GST dispute where ₹250 crore has been paid under protest.
Volume, Ticket Size and the Tax Overhang
- The headline growth is volume-led: Individual WRP grew 10% and policy count grew 10%, both ahead of industry, while average ticket size stayed intact. The company is acquiring more customers and writing more policies, which management argues supports a mid-teens growth trajectory.
- The >₹5 lakh segment is the drag: Policies above ₹5 lakh saw de-growth, with the gap wider in private wealth partnerships. Policies up to ₹5 lakh grew double digits. The blended growth rate of ~9% reflects this split: ~18% growth in the smaller-ticket book offset by a ~20% decline in the larger-ticket book.
- Why the drag should ease: Management expects the >₹5 lakh segment to recover in H2 as distributors and customers adjust to the new post-tax IRR reality, supported by product launches. Agency and broking channels, which had higher dependency on this segment, are expected to re-coup some of that business.
- Non-par demand is deferred, not destroyed: Customers are parking money in short-term FDs and delaying non-par decisions; management sees this as cyclical and expects it to reverse when rates start falling, citing growing awareness of reinvestment risk.
Vibha Padalkar: "This year is a mixed year, in terms of digesting tax changes and investing in people, so that we can grow number of policies, and all of that is panning out."
Protection and Annuity: The Margin-Stability Engine
- Retail protection is the standout performer: Retail protection grew 46% YoY on an NBP basis, sum assured grew 61% for retail and 45% overall, and the company leads the private sector with an 18% share of sum assured.
- Annuity is a steady contributor: APE grew 17% and the line now contributes 18% of new business premiums. Together with protection, these two segments account for ~55% of NBP, providing a stable base that partly insulates margins from savings-product volatility.
- ROP share is rising with tier 2/3 expansion: Return-of-premium products are simpler, over-the-counter relevant designs suited to those markets. Management states ROP margins are not materially different from pure term margins and are not dilutive to protection profitability.
- Credit life grew 28% with a shift in form: Business moved from regular premium to single premium in certain partners, but management says the economics of the credit life book have not changed.
Margins: Flat Today, Subservient to Growth Tomorrow
- H1 new business margin held at 26.2%: Multiple cross-currents netted out: Exide Life started with low single-digit margins, ULIP mix ticked up to 28% (vs a desired ~25% range), HDFC Bank counter share rose, and costs stayed controlled despite investments.
- The cost ratio inched up on slower growth: Total cost ratio moved from 19.3% to 19.7% because fixed-cost absorption weakened when growth in specific channels slowed. Management expects this to normalise as growth rebounds toward pre-tax-change levels.
- Full-year margin outlook is flat, with an explicit priority order: The company expects to end FY24 with margins similar to FY23. If growth comes in stronger than anticipated, VNB growth will be protected and margin will be subservient to that objective.
- Investment variance swung sharply quarter-on-quarter: Q1 delivered ~₹300 crore of positive variance (equity up ~10%, short-end yields down ~20 bps). Q2 added only ~₹50 crore from equities and the interest-rate cycle reversed, nullifying the rate impact.
Niraj Shah: "If we see more growth than what we are anticipating at this point in time, our first objective will be to ensure that our VNB growth is in line with what we want and margin is going to be subservient to that."
Distribution: Bancassurance Powers Ahead, Agency and Broking Adjust
- Bancassurance grew 23% and is the growth engine: The channel benefits from deep investment in manpower at HDFC Bank and other key banca partners, plus product innovations. HDFC Bank counter share reached 62.2% for H1 and exceeded 70% in September.
- Agency and broking were hit by the >₹5 lakh slowdown: Agency grew in line with the company but takes more time to adjust because it is more retail. Broking had significant presence in wealth-segment partnerships (IIFL, ASK) that did significant >₹5 lakh business, and de-growth occurred there.
- Direct channel declined on structural shifts: Lower branch walk-ins due to technology and the remapping of Policybazaar from direct to broking in Q3 explain the drop. Management expects both the online business and branch business to expand going forward.
- 30,000 agents were added during the period, and the company will counter broking-channel degrowth by driving retail NOP growth through those same channels.
Suresh Badami: "In some sense, it has been a focused effort on both sides. We have invested in manpower over the last 5-6 months. There have been product innovations which have happened."
Tier 2/3: The Structural Growth Bet
- Tier 2/3 markets are growing at double the company rate: This has been a multi-year build, accelerated by the Exide Life acquisition (which brought significant tier 2/3 and southern-market presence) and new banca partnerships with AU Small Finance Bank, Ujjivan, Utkarsh and Bandhan.
- The proposition is purpose-built for these markets: Simpler products, underwriting measures for non-salaried customers, reinsurance arrangements, and local-language outreach. Customers in these markets are more amenable to buying protection and show more willingness to take longer-term policies.
- Persistency is managed through pricing, not avoidance: Management acknowledges that inherent persistency in tier 2/3 is generally lower than in the top 10 cities, but says the company is comfortable as long as pricing is right and expects persistency improvement within cohorts over time.
Vibha Padalkar: "I think that's the journey. This is just the tip of the iceberg, and I'm reasonably comfortable and confident that the journey will continue."
Product Mix and Pricing Discipline
- The target mix is balanced across savings categories: Management wants to stay within one-fourth to one-third each for ULIP, par and non-par, while continuing to grow protection and annuities. ULIP contribution is managed carefully in agency because ULIP needs high persistency to be profitable.
- Non-par pricing is deliberately conservative: The company looks at yields on a gross basis, adjusts IRRs, and keeps the marketplace in view, but wants sensible growth in terms of profitability and risk. Management explicitly stays away from aggressive pricing situations that occur in multi-tier markets.
- New product launches span protection and ULIP: HDFC Life Sanchay Legacy (whole-life, return-of-premium protection with increasing cover) and Click 2 Protect Elite (for affluent customers) were launched. A ULIP with a higher sum-assured multiple and a protection proposition attached has done well in the bank channel.
- H2 will bring more launches in other categories, which will then reflect in the product mix.
Niraj Shah: "We continue to maintain a fairly balanced approach. We definitely want whatever growth we can get, but it has to be sensible in terms of profitability and the risk we write on our books."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| APE growth | Mid-teens full-year growth, excluding the ~₹1,000 crore one-off post-budget business from March FY23 | FY24 |
| New business margin | Flattish vs FY23; H1 and H2 margins similar to full-year outcome | FY24 |
| VNB growth | Mid-teens, consistent with APE growth and flat margins | FY24 |
| >₹5 lakh ticket-size recovery | Improved traction expected on product launches and distributor/customer adjustment to new tax reality | H2 FY24 |
| Cost ratio normalisation | Increase from 19.3% to 19.7% should reverse as growth rebounds to pre-tax-change levels | When growth normalises |
| Margin trajectory beyond FY24 | Upward trajectory expected once the sector has digested tax changes | FY25 onwards |
| Margin vs growth priority | If growth exceeds expectations, VNB growth will be protected and margin will be subservient | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Individual WRP growth | 10% in H1FY24 vs 8% for overall industry |
| Market share (private sector) | 15.7% in H1FY24 |
| Market share (overall sector) | 10.3% in H1FY24 |
| Individual policies sold growth | 10% uptick in H1FY24, beating industry growth |
| Lives insured | More than 3 crore, YoY growth of 16% |
| New business margin | 26.2% in H1FY24 |
| Value of new business | ₹1,411 crores, 10% YoY growth in H1FY24 |
| Embedded value | ₹42,908 crore as on September 30, 2023 |
| Operating return on embedded value | 16.4% in H1FY24 |
| Profit after tax | ₹792 crores in H1FY24, YoY increase of 15% |
| Solvency ratio | 194% as on September 30, 2023, after ₹408 crore dividend pay-out |
| Total cost ratio | 19.7%, up from 19.3% |
| Protection growth (new business premium) | 28% in H1FY24; retail protection YoY growth of 46% |
| Annuity APE growth | 17% in H1FY24; contributed 18% of new business premium |
| Product mix (individual APE) | Non-par savings 28%, participating 30%, ULIP 28%, annuity 8%, protection 6% |
| Bancassurance partners YoY growth | 23% in H1FY24 |
| HDFC Bank counter share | 62.2% for H1FY24; September exit rate greater than 70% |
| Credit Protect growth | 28% in H1FY24 |
| Agents added in agency channel | More than 37,000 in H1FY24 |
| Growth in less than ₹5 lakh ticket size | ~18% at company level |
| Degrowth in channels with wealth customer bias | ~20% |
| Return of premium products share | ~30% of protection mix, up from ~20% in previous period |
| Pension subsidiary AUM | Crossed ₹58,000 crores; market share of 43%, up 370 bps YoY |
| HDFC International revenues | Over \$10 million, growth of 50% |
| Renewal collections YoY growth | 14% |
| Profit emergence from back book growth | 18% in H1FY24 |
| Agency channel persistency | Near 90% at an overall level |