Key Takeaways
- EBITDA per ton halved, but management calls the bottom: At ₹476, down 50% YoY, driven overwhelmingly by a 50% surge in power and fuel cost. Management expects a bounce-back from here, citing price increases already underway.
- Volume hit by unseasonal Central India rains, not structural loss: A 19% YoY volume decline stemmed from flood-like conditions in UP and MP. Management treats this as a one-off and expects pent-up demand to lift November and December.
- Premium product mix jumped to 55% of trade sales: The newly launched Mycem Primo brand captured aspirational customers, accelerating the shift from a prior 20–25% share and supporting realizations.
- Fuel cost is the swing factor, and the company is positioned to benefit quickly: Petcoke now dominates the mix at 69–70%, and low fuel inventory means softening prices will pass through to costs with minimal lag.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-Diwali price increases of ₹4–5 hold and translate into the promised EBITDA recovery, and how new Central India capacity entering in H2FY23 affects pricing discipline.
Volume & Demand Environment
- Central India rains drove the miss: Incessant rains and flood-like conditions in UP and MP, combined with spoiled crops in July, crushed construction activity. Management noted that having market share in Bihar would have helped offset the geographic concentration.
- Pent-up demand expected post-festivals: October had three major festivals (Dussehra, Diwali, Chhath) that pulled labor away from sites. Management expects the next 15 days after Diwali to clarify demand, citing past patterns of strong rebounds after monsoon and holiday disruptions.
- Rural housing seen as a demand anchor: Government infrastructure spending is tapering steeply, which could push competitor material into retail, but management is confident in its retail foothold. Rural and Tier-2/Tier-3 housing demand, supported by the cultural priority of homebuilding, is expected to provide a floor.
- Multi-year volume stagnation attributed to strategy, not loss: Volumes have not grown much since FY15 while the industry grew at 4–5% CAGR, per an analyst's math. Management attributed this to a deliberate shift toward premium products and brand building, which caused temporary volume displacement, not permanent market share loss.
Cooper: "It is unfortunate that, you know, we had to suffer because we are focused more on Central India. Now at this point of time, we possibly think that had we had some market share in Bihar, probably, we would have done better."
Costs & Margins
- Fuel is the story: Power and fuel cost inflicted a ₹670 per ton impact, driving the 50% EBITDA decline. Management stated flatly that fuel "has gone through the roof" and is the main factor that "killed us."
- Fuel mix flipped rapidly to petcoke: Petcoke consumption rose to 69–70% from a reverse situation last year because petcoke became cheaper than coal. The technical team adapts the mix dynamically, and low fuel inventory means the company is quickly impacted by price rises but also quickly benefits from softening.
- Fuel cost per kilo cal was ₹3.13 in Q2: This was slightly lower than the June quarter due to softening of coal and petcoke prices. Management expects marginal tapering or at least stability in H2FY23, with no sharp increase.
- Green power share at 34% provides insulation: The 34% level of in-house and green power sourcing is expected to be sustainable and insulates against grid power price hikes.
- One-off litigation provision spiked interest expense: A significant increase in interest expenses this quarter stemmed from a provision of around ₹10 crore taken on account of an old litigation where a court judgment arrived during the quarter.
- Raw material cost rise is an inventory artifact: Per an analyst's math, per-ton RM cost rose ~11% QoQ. Management explained this is largely due to inventory change effects: the June quarter had a large pre-monsoon inventory build-up, while the September quarter inventory increase was only ₹4.4–4.5 crore. Adjusting for inventory changes, there should not be a significant RM cost increase.
Cooper: "On cost side, it is not, we are not so bad, but it is basically the fuel which has killed us at this point of time."
Pricing & Realization
- Realization dropped ~3.3% QoQ: Per an analyst's math. Management did not confirm the exact percentage but discussed the dynamics, noting that the benefit in realization was not purely from premium products: price increases taken from time to time, branding exercises, and premiumization even on lower-end products also contributed.
- Post-Diwali price increases already underway: Prices increased by ₹4–5 in the last 10–20 days (₹1–2 on the 22nd, ₹1–2 on the 1st). Management expects more good price increases after Diwali, depending on order books overflowing.
- Management issued a blunt call for industry pricing discipline: Stating that the industry has lost the absorption ability to continue selling at current prices, management warned that compliances will grow and require CAPEX, and if cash reserves dry up, companies will struggle.
- New Central India capacity is a known disturbance, not a catastrophe: Management expects new capacities commissioning in H2FY23 to rock the boat but argues that new entrants want to earn money, not burn it, and will not be "aggressive or funny or stupid to bring down the prices." The responsibility to hold the market lies with established players.
Management: "The volume game is fine. Okay. Ultimately, it is the profit which you earn out of the business, sustainability of the cash flows. You know, today we are not understanding this very simple thing that compliances will grow. Okay, and compliances will require CAPEX, and this CAPEX is when you will have totally dried out on your cash reserves, then where will you go for this? It is high time the industry wakes up to this call."
Product & Brand Strategy
- Premium product share jumped to 55% of trade sales: This is up from a prior 20–25%, aided significantly by the introduction of Mycem Primo, an intermediate product priced between the normal bag and Mycem Power. It captured aspirational customers who wanted box-bottom packaging but not at the full ₹40–45 premium.
- Trade sales share held at 83%: When markets are soft, non-trade is typically pushed more, but this time unseasonal monsoon closed many sites and traditional loyal parties were not taking cement. Trade sales share for last year Q2 was restated upward to 86% because sales in MRP bags, even if sold in bulk or not for resale, are now classified as trade sales.
- Discount structure is fixed and transparent: A discount policy is issued in writing on 1st January each year, signed and acknowledged by dealers, and fixed for the full calendar year with no changes. Management stressed that no private discounts or off-scheme discounts are given.
- Aggregates and RMC entry not planned: Low entry barriers, high competition, lack of technical buying by customers, and absence of BIS specifications make the segment unattractive for now. The company may enter when India brings specifications; Heidelberg could potentially set standards as the global #1 in aggregates.
Management: "We have a very, very, very, very transparent discount structure. Probably, you won't find this in any other, anyone in the country. We on 1st of January issue a discount policy giving each and every discount in writing to the dealer and the dealer acknowledges, signs the copy of it, and hands it over to us."
Capacity Expansion & Competitive Landscape
- Debottlenecking to add ~4.5 lakh tons of cement: The project covers both lines 2 and 3, executed in two phases starting FY24 and then FY25, adding around 3 lakh tons of clinker and around 4.5 lakh tons of cement.
- Gujarat greenfield project is a FY27 story: Environmental work has started, with reports expected by next May–June. First phase capacity is about 0.35 crore tons, second phase another 0.3 crore tons, with CAPEX for phase one at a little more than 200 million euros.
- Unification of HCIL and Zuari under discussion: Work is ongoing with the group, with the goal of creating a bigger capacity and forum for financial flexibility. The company is also participating in mine auctions in different regions to put a foot there.
- Central India demand growth expected at 8–8.5% next year: This implies ~0.5 crore tonnes of incremental demand, sufficient to absorb new capacity and allow regional growth. 2023 may be the last year before the 2024 elections, supporting good demand.
- Adani entry seen as a margin-conscious player: Management noted that Adani's DNA is pure B2B businesses with margins above 50%, and questioned how they would satisfy themselves with cement margins of 16–18%. The expectation is that they would like to make money, not operate at unsustainably low utilization.
Management: "Adani family is totally a pure B2B businesses. Most of their business is their DNA as I understand... their margins, they are operating on products where the margins are more than 50%. How will they satisfy with margins of 16% and 18% here? I don't think they would like to be in such a state."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA recovery | Q2 EBITDA per ton of ₹476 is the bottom; expects to bounce back | Quarters going forward |
| Post-Diwali price increases | ₹4–5 already taken; more expected depending on order books | Post-Diwali |
| Fuel cost trend | Marginal tapering down or at least stability at current levels; no sharp increase | H2FY23 |
| Debottlenecking Phase 1 | ~3 lakh tons clinker, ~4.5 lakh tons cement (both lines) | FY24 |
| Debottlenecking Phase 2 | Second phase of debottlenecking | FY25 |
| Gujarat greenfield Phase 1 | ~0.35 crore tons capacity, CAPEX a little more than €200 mn; environmental clearance expected by May–June | Plant start FY27 |
| Replacement CAPEX | ~₹50 crores (50% of depreciation cost) | FY23 |
| Central India demand growth | Not less than 8–8.5% (~0.5 crore tonnes incremental) | Next year (FY24) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Volume | -19% YoY and -10% QoQ |
| Realization | +8% YoY, slightly down QoQ |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹476, 50% lower YoY (₹946 in Q2 FY22) |
| Operating margin | Not stated |
| Net debt | ₹10.9 cr as on date |
| Cash and bank balances | ₹237 cr as on September '22 |
| Total debt | ₹234.6 cr |
| Dividend per share | ₹9, already distributed |
| Interest expense | ₹20.6 cr, including ~₹10 cr one-off litigation provision |
| GST incentive booked | ~₹5 cr, normal quarterly amount |
| Premium products share in trade sales | 55%, up from 20–25% previously |
| Trade sales share | 83% (Q2 FY22 restated to 86% due to reclassification) |
| Sales volume split: rail vs road | 50-50 |
| Fuel mix: petcoke | 69–70%; coal 31% |
| In-house / green power share | 34% of power consumption |
| Ammasandra plant green power | >90% |
| Fuel consumption cost | ₹714 per Gigajoule, ₹3.13 per kilo cal, slightly lower vs Q1 |
| Capacity utilization | ~78–79% |
| Lead distance | ~250–350 km, consistent |
| Gujarat project Phase 1 capacity | 0.35 cr tons, CAPEX ~€200 mn, start FY27 |
| Debottlenecking: clinker addition | ~3 lakh tons; cement ~4.5 lakh tons, Phase 1 in FY24, Phase 2 in FY25 |
| Central India demand growth expectation (next year) | Not less than 8–8.5%, ~0.5 cr tons incremental demand |
| Replacement CAPEX | ~₹50 cr, 50% of depreciation |