Key Takeaways
- Volume hit from competition and logistics, but QoQ recovery visible: Volumes fell YoY as aggressive competitor pricing and warehousing issues bit, yet a near-10% QoQ improvement signals the worst may be behind.
- Fuel cost is the margin story: Power and fuel costs drove EBITDA down to ₹339 per ton, but imported petcoke and coal prices are softening, and management expects a tailwind from the March quarter onward.
- Trade share sacrificed in the price war: Trade share dropped to ~75-76% from 83% QoQ as the team chose not to chase low prices; management frames this as a temporary tactical loss in an ongoing competitive battle.
- Growth levers are being built, not bought: A new mine won at 100% premium, a clinker debottlenecking approved, and a Gujarat greenfield project entering the environmental clearance phase all point to a multi-year capacity build.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Central India pricing firms post-Holi as promised, the pace of fuel cost relief flowing through the P&L, and any progress on the stalled June application.
Competitive Dynamics & Volume
- Aggressive competition hit volumes: Some competitors brought prices very low in Central India, and the team was not prepared to suddenly change its product mix or pricing strategy to match, leading to a volume loss.
- Logistics disruption added to the pain: About 10 days of impact in some local high-volume areas due to warehousing and logistic issues, though management says these problems are now behind them.
- Trade share sacrificed: Trade share declined to ~75-76% from 83% in Q2 FY23, and premium product share also fell, as the company chose not to chase low-priced non-trade volumes.
- QoQ trajectory improving: Volumes improved almost 10% QoQ, and management expects Q4 volumes to be positive, stating they "should not be anywhere in negative."
- Future focus on trade: Despite expectations of more infrastructure push and non-trade cement demand in 2024, management intends to focus more on trade going forward, noting the trade/non-trade mix can always be rejigged.
Management: "Some competitors become very aggressive. So, some people are there who have hit our volumes adversely by bringing prices at very low prices. So, the team was not prepared all of a sudden to change its product mix or I would say the pricing strategy and that is how we get impacted, but these are all temporary I would say these are tactical issues any new brands comes sometimes we are unlucky, somebody else will be unlucky, somebody will focus in my market, somebody next time I will focus in their market. So, it is a battle which keeps going on in a fair and competitive working environment..."
Costs & Margins
- Fuel cost the dominant drag: Q3 fuel cost per ton was ₹1,260 versus ₹980 in the December 21 quarter, and the 9-month YTD fuel cost is up ~40% YoY, driving the EBITDA drop to ₹339 per ton.
- Higher-cost inventory a temporary overhang: Despite improving consumption factors, input cost was higher because of higher-cost inventory carried; management calls this temporary and expects it to reverse soon.
- Fuel cost relief arriving: Petcoke pricing softened in December over September, and imported petcoke and coal prices have reduced, translating to the domestic market; Coal India has also increased coal availability for cement companies.
- March quarter tailwind expected: Management sees an 8% QoQ fuel cost reduction as a safe estimate for Q4, with no further increase foreseen and further softening likely.
- Other expenditure lumpy due to shutdowns: Other expenditure rose QoQ because of scheduled kiln plant shutdowns involving stores, spares, consumables, refractories, and grinding media changes; the per-ton impact was magnified by a 2-3% volume decline, but absolute spend was similar to the December 21 quarter.
- GST incentive expiry a small headwind: Incentives expiring in February will set back costs by about ₹40 per ton.
- Mission Possible program embeds gains: The calendar 2022 program using 10-year historic data and best demonstrated practice benchmarks delivered permanent improvements; future gigajoule consumption is targeted at ~3.07-3.06 and power at ~70 units.
Pricing & Realization
- Realization under pressure: Realization was down 2.5% QoQ in the December quarter due to volume pressure from festivities and price pressure from new capacity coming on stream in Central India.
- South leading the price recovery: Prices in the South region have gone up by about ₹125-130 per ton on average very recently, and management expects this trajectory to continue and eventually influence Central India.
- Central India still flattish: January pricing was flattish, and while February should improve, not too much improvement has been seen so far.
- Post-Holi demand catalyst: Management expects government spending in February-March and significantly improved rural demand post-Holi (April) to support pricing, with Rabi crop being good and expected to pep up rural demand.
- GST reduction a potential silver lining: Management sees a probability of GST reduction and believes cement manufacturers should pass it to consumers to increase consumption rather than taking a share, making cement more affordable.
Management: "There is one silver lining here there is a probability of GST reduction, but yes I say that there will be a reduction, but the cement manufacturers will be responsible for giving away this GST back to the consumers. So, if it becomes more affordable if he can increase the consumption alone by this method I think we should not become greedy about taking any share out of the GST and we should look at increasing the consumption of cement that would be my way of looking at it."
Capacity Expansion & Growth Projects
- New limestone mine won: Selected as successful bidder for a new mine adjoining existing operations at 100% premium; extends plant life significantly and opens scope for expansion, though documentation and mining lease execution will take 2-2.5 years.
- Clinker debottlenecking approved: Line #3 at the Central India plant given the go-ahead for 200,000 tons of additional clinker capacity, resulting in ~3.5 lakh tons of cement; equipment orders to be placed this year, expected on-stream in 2024 (FY25).
- Gujarat greenfield project advancing: Environmental data collection ongoing, completing in February; report expected by March; Terms of Reference application targeted for May; project size 0.3 crore tons with limestone reserves described as huge and expandable; estimated 3.5 years to 4 years to completion.
- Damoh new line under study: Opportunity to scrap the old 1,600 TPD Line 1 and build a new, more fuel-efficient line supported by new mines; decision expected ~24 months down the line after agreements and land acquisition.
- Management capability drives output beyond guarantees: The kiln rated at 5,000 TPD is running at 5,700 consistently, and management expects similar outperformance from the debottlenecking.
- Merger with Zuari progressing: The group is working on merging Heidelberg and Zuari under one entity for financial fungibility; might take another year.
Management: "It is a long-time process will take place, it will not happen overnight although the project we are roaring to go on this, but then there are some limitations always there because statutory clearances and all these things are not within our hand."
Demand Environment & Outlook
- Central India demand weak but poised to recover: Weakness attributed to MP government being weak on government demand, but Rabi crop is good and rural demand is expected to improve significantly post-Holi; FY24 demand growth expectation is ~7%.
- Election-year government spending: Cement demand in government projects is expected to increase in 2023 due to elections in 2024 and budget support.
- Central India capacity addition continuing: 0.4-0.5 crore tons per year of capacity addition may continue for the next 2-3 years; the market is currently running short of clinker, with people selling more clinker than cement.
- Management unfazed by competitor capacity: The company positions itself as "senior citizens of this state" and aims to retain channel partners and customers better than newcomers, welcoming the prosperity new entrants bring.
- Top-line growth expectation: 3-5 year compounded growth expected at more than 10% (5% volume plus 5% inflation), with price increases expected to follow with a 6-12 month lag.
Management: "I always tell my team we should not be bothered about what the competition comes in, we are the senior citizens of this state we have been here, we should not be able to we should be able to retain our channel partners and our customers better than anybody else can do, a new comer should not be a threat to us, I would say is welcome to us at least they will bring some prosperity to the state."
Product & Operational Updates
- Mycem Primo launched: New product positioned at ~₹15/bag premium to fill the vacuum between Mycem Power (₹45/bag premium from 1st January) and the normal bag; good traction reported with no cannibalization of Mycem Power.
- Green power increased: Team focused on CO2 commitment and future-readiness, with green power share rising.
- Limestone mine life extended: Extended by almost 7 years by using limestone rejects supplemented with sweetener, though some geological miscalculation at certain mine sites caused higher LSF improvement needs and higher sweetener usage in the quarter.
- Working capital discipline maintained: Company continues to operate on negative working capital.
- LC3/calcined clay cement not a near-term priority: Management cited low literacy levels among masons and the user community, a lack of responsible behavior on the field, and lack of proximity to suitable clay blocks as barriers to launching specialized products that require correct application.
- Leadership transition underway: MD Jamshed Naval Cooper to demit office on 31st March; Joydeep Mukherjee (currently COO) to take over as MD.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume recovery | Q4 volumes positive, "should not be anywhere in negative" | Q4 FY23 |
| Fuel cost reduction | ~8% QoQ reduction taken as safe side; no further increase foreseen | Q4 FY23 |
| Clinker debottlenecking | 200,000-250,000 tons clinker capacity addition, ~3.5 lakh tons cement | FY25 (on-stream 2024) |
| Gujarat greenfield project | 0.3 crore tons capacity; ToR application targeted for May | 3.5-4 years to completion |
| Merger with Zuari | Two units merged under one entity for financial fungibility | ~1 year |
| Sustainable CAPEX | ~₹40 crore current and next fiscal; additional ~₹15 crore next year for debottlenecking; total ~₹55 crore including AFR | FY23-FY24 |
| Top-line growth | 3-5 year compounded growth >10% (5% volume + 5% inflation) | 3-5 years |
| Damoh new line decision | Decision on scrapping old Line 1 and building new fuel-efficient line | ~24 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA | ₹339 cr, drop mainly due to higher power and fuel cost |
| Cost increase | ~9%, partially offset by price increase |
| Net cash | ~₹150 cr |
| Working capital | Negative, maintained |
| Volume | 0.11 crore tons, +10% QoQ but YoY decline (per an analyst's math) |
| Volume decline (9 months) | 9.5% (per an analyst's math) |
| Trade share | 76%, declined from 83% in Q2 FY23 (per an analyst's math) |
| Premium product share | declined from 55% in Q2 FY23 (per an analyst's math) |
| Realization change | -2.5% QoQ |
| Price difference, trade vs non-trade | >₹600 to ₹650/ton |
| Fuel cost per ton of cement | ₹1,260, vs ₹980 in Q3 FY22 and ₹1,350 in Q2 FY23 |
| Fuel cost increase, 9 months YoY | ~40% on per ton basis |
| Kilo calorific value cost | ~₹2.85 paisa, slightly lower than September quarter |
| Coal and petcoke cost | ~660 to 670 per gigajoule |
| Petcoke landed price | ~₹20,000 to ₹21,000/ton, down ~₹2,000–2,500 from last quarter |
| Expected fuel cost reduction, Q4 FY23 | ~8% QoQ, management's safe-side estimate |
| Clinker capacity, Central India | 0.31 crore tons, to increase by 2,00,000–3,00,000 tons via debottlenecking |
| Total clinker capacity | 3.5 crore tons, including Karnataka |
| Cement capacity | 0.63 crore tons, to increase by ~0.035 crore tons with debottlenecking |
| Debottlenecking timeline | FY25 |
| Central region demand growth, FY24 expectation | ~7% |
| Central region demand growth, FY23 estimate | ~5.5% to 6% |
| Central India capacity addition | 0.4–0.5 crore tons/year, may continue next 2–3 years |
| Road volume share | ~49–50% |
| Lead distance | ~350 |
| Mycem Power premium | ₹45/bag above normal bag from 1st January |
| Mycem Primo premium | ~₹15/bag above normal bag, positioned between normal and Mycem Power |
| GST incentive expiry impact | ~₹40/ton (₹2/bag) setback |
| Sustainable capex, FY23 and FY24 | ~₹40 cr each year |
| Debottlenecking capex, FY24 | ~₹15 cr, total FY24 capex ~₹55 cr including AFR |
| Q3 capex | ~₹5–7 cr |
| UP government loan repayment, FY23 | ₹336 cr and ₹629 cr, two tranches |
| Limestone mine life, existing | ~24–25 years, extended by ~7 years via rejects with sweetener |
| Gujarat Greenfield project size | 0.3 crore tons |
| Top line compounded growth expectation, 3–5 years | >10% (5% volume + 5% inflation) |