Key Takeaways
- Volume growth, margin recovery: FY24 volumes rose 9% and EBITDA improved on lower power and fuel costs, though market price declines prevented the full benefit from flowing through.
- De-bottlenecking is the near-term growth lever: A clinker project at Damoh will add 200,000 tons of cement capacity by Q1 2025, the only confirmed volume catalyst before any greenfield clearance.
- Zuari merger remains stuck on stamp duty: Management is still unable to determine the stamp duty liability, so the process has not started; completion is unlikely before FY26 or FY27.
- Demand hit by elections, recovery expected in June: April and May saw double-digit industry degrowth, but management expects pent-up demand to lift volumes once the election concludes.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-election demand uptick materializes in June, the pace of green power cost savings from the new 16 MW agreement, and any movement on the Gujarat environmental clearance.
Volume & Demand Environment
- FY24 volume performance: Full-year volume grew 9%, with Q4 up 4%, driven by strong underlying demand in the company's markets.
- Election-led disruption: April and May volumes declined by double digits across the industry as election-related conservatism and labour shortages weighed on consumption. Management expects an uptick in June as pent-up demand releases.
- FY25 volume outlook: The company expects to grow in line with the industry at 6% to 7%, constrained by already running at 80%+ capacity utilisation, with no de-bottlenecking benefit until Q1 2025.
- Road dispatch shift: Road dispatches fell 2.8% year-on-year as the company began addressing new, more distant but profitable markets, a deliberate mix shift rather than a demand signal.
- Macro tailwind: Management cited India's strong GDP growth and cement's typical 1.1x to 1.2x multiplier as reasons for stable, strong demand that should absorb some overcapacity.
Mukherjee: "So the number that you indicated is right. I think the entire industry, all the major players, the degrowth would be in that range. It will be a double-digit degrowth for April and May, but we are looking at an uptick in June post the election dates are over, because there would be a lot of pent-up demand."
Costs & Margin Drivers
- Power and fuel tailwind: Fuel cost fell around 30% year-on-year in Q4 to approximately INR 1.8 per kilocalorie, the primary driver of the FY24 EBITDA increase. The near-term outlook is flat.
- Green power cost advantage: Green power is 30% to 35% cheaper than grid power. A new 16 MW agreement (8 MW + 8 MW) starts in Q1 FY25, with the benefit visible in the current quarter.
- Green power share ambition: The company targets more than 40% green power share in FY25, up from approximately 38% for the full year FY24, to optimise cost and reduce carbon content.
- Staff cost normalisation: Staff costs spiked to approximately INR 45 crores in Q4 from INR 36 crores in Q3 due to bonuses, increments, and retirement benefit valuations. The run rate is expected to revert to INR 41 to 42 crores in the June quarter.
- Alternative fuel ramp-up: TSR reached 10% in Q4 (8% for the full year) as AFR consumption increased gradually. A third phase of alternative fuel projects is ongoing to further optimise variable costs.
- Inventory impact clarified: The INR 14-odd crore change in inventory in Q4 is a mix of clinker and cement produced and does not impact the cost of production; profitability direction depends on market price and volume.
Expansion & Growth Projects
- Damoh de-bottlenecking: The project to increase clinker capacity from 0.31 crore tons to 0.33 or 0.34 crore tons has started and will deliver an additional 200,000 tons of cement volume per annum by Q1 2025. No delays are anticipated.
- Gujarat greenfield stalled: The planned 0.2 crore ton clinker and 0.3 to 0.35 crore ton grinding expansion remains pending environmental clearance. Management is unwilling to put a date on it, calling any timeline speculative. Once clearance is received, construction will take three years.
- Zuari merger in limbo: The stamp duty calculation remains unresolved despite the government settling the regulatory royalty issue in 2021. Management is still unable to determine the payout amount, so the merger process has not started. Even if it begins in FY25, completion is unlikely before FY26 or FY27.
- Growth appetite: Management stated it is open to both organic and inorganic growth and is actively looking, but declined to declare any specific plans beyond what has been disclosed.
Mukherjee: "This de-bottlenecking shall result in an additional cement volume of 200,000 tons per annum. And the project is well on its way, and we don't anticipate any delays in this, whatsoever."
Product Mix & Premiumisation
- Premium product push: Premium products rose 2.6% year-on-year, reaching a 34% share. The stated ambition is to reach around 45% in the next two years through constant mix optimisation.
- New product launch: A new functionally different, value-added cement has been launched, adding to the premium portfolio.
- Retail channel growth: The retail channel grew 0.6% year-on-year, consistent with the premiumisation strategy.
Market Structure & Pricing
- Pricing pressure from new capacity: Management observed that when new capacity enters the market, prices remain under pressure until utilisation reaches 65% to 70%, after which they tend to stabilise.
- Consolidation view: Management believes consolidation is the way forward for the industry but finds it difficult to put a timeline on the trend.
- Competitive intensity acknowledged: The market is described as fragmented with intensifying competition, alongside global headwinds that could pose risks.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Clinker de-bottlenecking completion | Additional 200,000 tons cement volume per annum | Q1 2025 calendar year |
| Green power share | More than 40% (from ~38% in FY24) | FY25 |
| New green power agreement benefit | 16 MW (8+8) starts, reducing power cost 30-35% | Current quarter (Q1 FY25) |
| Staff cost run-rate normalisation | Revert to ~INR 41-42 crores per quarter | June quarter FY25 |
| Premium cement share | Reach around 45% (from 34%) | Next 2 years |
| Volume growth | In line with industry at 6-7% | FY25 |
| Zuari merger completion | Process not started; completion unlikely before FY26 or FY27 | FY26/FY27 |
| Gujarat greenfield commissioning | 3 years from receipt of environmental clearance | Undated (clearance pending) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹659, up 16% YoY |
| Volume growth | 4% YoY (March quarter); 9% YoY (FY24) |
| Fuel cost change | Down ~30% YoY |
| Combined fuel cost per kilocalorie | ₹1.8 |
| Cement price change (April–May vs Q4 avg) | Drop of ₹6 per bag |
| Staff cost | ₹45-odd cr, up from ₹36 cr in Q3 FY24 due to bonuses, retirement benefit valuations, and annual increments |
| Change in inventory | ₹14-odd cr (total ₹115-odd cr) |
| FY25 volume growth guidance | 6% to 7% (industry growth estimate; company expects to grow in line) |
| FY25 capex guidance | ₹100–120 cr (₹50–55 cr for de-bottlenecking, ~₹50 cr sustainable) |
| Green power share | 38% of total power consumption (33% pure green plus ~5% from Open Exchange) |
| Alternative fuel rate (AFR) | 10% thermal substitution rate in Q4; 8% for full year FY24 |
| Premium products share | 34% of trade volume, up 2.6% YoY |
| Value-added product monthly volume | 8,000 tons; target 20,000–25,000 tons by end of 2025 |
| Value-added product price premium | ₹50–60 higher per bag vs regular product |
| Lead distance | 375 km |
| Fuel mix | 60% petcoke, 30% coal, 10% AFR |
| Clinker de-bottlenecking additional cement volume | 200,000 tons per annum (project completion by Q1 2025 calendar year) |
| Dividend announced | ₹8 per share |