Key Takeaways
- NIM compressed ~60 bps, now stabilizing: The decline came from cost of borrowing, financial leverage, and higher cash; management expects NIM to settle in a 5.3%–5.5% range going forward.
- Asset quality improved, credit cost unsustainably low: Delinquencies improved across buckets, and credit cost fell to 10 bps due to recoveries from written-off accounts; the structural run-rate remains guided at 30–40 bps.
- Balance transfers are elevated but erosion is stable: BT Out rose as customers who absorbed three PLR hikes sought repricing elsewhere, yet total portfolio erosion held at 16%–18%, the same level as before.
- Spread guidance anchored at 5.0%–5.25% ex co-lending: Management expressed significant confidence in this range, supported by NHB funding, product mix, and a cost of borrowing that should plateau near 8.5%.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the planned cohort-level repricing exercise reduces BT Out without sacrificing growth, the pace of co-lending scale-up toward the 10% AUM milestone, and the insurance fee income ramp beginning mid-Q2.
Margin Walk & Profitability Outlook
- NIM compression decomposed: ~20 bps from cost of borrowing increase net of repricing, ~20 bps from financial leverage as the balance sheet grows, and ~20 bps from higher cash and cash equivalents held during Q4.
- Spread decline is a trailing story: Spreads have been falling since Q1 FY23 because cost of borrowing rose sharply while asset repricing lagged; that catch-up is now complete, so spreads should stabilize.
- Opex ratio artificially low this quarter: Opex to assets printed at 2.5% because of a one-time cleanup of old provisions during year-end financial closing; the sustainable run-rate remains ~3.0%.
- Credit cost benefited from recoveries: Close to ₹2.5 crores in recoveries from previously written-off accounts flowed through the credit cost line, pulling it down to 10 bps; management reiterated that the structural credit cost guidance is 30–40 bps, not 15–20 bps, because of higher ECL overlays carried on the book.
- ROA will drift lower on leverage: ROA will keep declining slightly each quarter as financial leverage rises; management anchors expectations around 3.5% plus/minus, which still delivers 16%+ ROE with leverage exiting close to 5x.
- Cost-to-income trajectory: The ratio will likely hover around 34%–35% for the next 1–2 years; from the third year onward, operating leverage should start pulling it down toward ~30% over the medium term.
Viswanathan: "The problem of co-lending spread and the reason we kind of split it out this time is that co-lending, we only keep 20% on our balance sheet. Let's say, when I said that the yield is 10%. And let's say, I am having a cost of borrowing of 8.75%. The spread is 1.25% but that's an incorrect way to look at it because you have to multiply that by 5. Therefore, the number becomes 6.50% or 6.75%. That is the right way to look at it."
Balance Transfers & Pricing Strategy
- BT Out elevated but erosion contained: Balance transfers ticked up because customers who received three PLR hikes over the last two years are more prone to shop for lower rates; however, total erosion including BT Out and own prepayments remains at 16%–18%, so the runoff rate has not increased.
- Pricing premium invites BT Out by design: Home loan to home loan, HomeFirst operates at much higher pricing in competitive markets than peers, making it structurally more exposed to balance transfers; management accepts this as a trade-off for delivering growth at those yields.
- Migration is to larger banks: BT Out flows predominantly to larger banks; new entrants do not target balance transfers as a core business.
- Cohort-level repricing planned: Management will review the book this quarter, repricing upward where customer risk has increased and downward where customers are prone to BT Out, rather than applying a blanket rate change.
- Rate-hike pass-through philosophy: The company avoids changing customer rates frequently to prevent agitation and budget disruption; when hikes are unavoidable, it extends tenure first, only increasing EMI when tenure crosses a limit. If cost of borrowing rises another 20 bps, management will absorb it; a 30–40 bps move would force a pass-through of ~50 bps at one go.
Viswanathan: "We have had an ideology that we do not want to change the rates too many times for the customer. Frequently changing the rates with the customer not only agitates the customer, but it's also upsets their planning, etc, which is why we want to hold on to the rates as much as possible."
Funding, Liquidity & Cost of Borrowing
- Cost of borrowing still inching up: On-book cost of borrowing was 8.3% and is expected to reach ~8.5% in 2–3 quarters, then flatline, assuming no policy rate change or significant debt capital market moves.
- NHB drawdown and outlook: The company drew ₹250 crores from NHB in April 2024 and expects a significant line in FY25, which will help manage the cost of borrowing; NHB refinance typically runs around 20% of the book, plus or minus 2%.
- Marginal cost convergence is not the goal: When asked when marginal cost of borrowing would converge with on-book cost, management answered "hopefully never," because NHB borrowing and other sources keep the marginal cost structurally lower.
- Cash balance elevated at quarter-end: The company has maintained ~2–2.5 months of disbursal in cash since the IL&FS crisis; quarter-end numbers are inflated because drawdowns happen late in the quarter to manage interest cost, so average cash holding is lower than the reported figure. A case for reducing cash may emerge 12 months from now, after liquidity improves and the next rating upgrade is secured.
- Rating upgrade: India Ratings upgraded the outlook, kicking off the journey toward the next rating category.
Patwari: "Sameer, hopefully never is the answer because we also have NHB borrowing."
Asset Quality & Portfolio Composition
- Delinquencies improved and stabilized: Asset quality strengthened across buckets; ECL provisions are now moving only for new growth, with a significant overlay carried from a risk management perspective.
- PCR decline is dilution, not release: The provision coverage ratio is falling not because absolute provisions are shrinking, but because new growth is being added; ECL provision as a percentage of principal outstanding sits at 0.8%–0.9%, which management finds comfortable.
- No state-led credit stress: Credit quality is driven by customer occupation and profile, not geography; early signals from new states like UP, MP, and Rajasthan are good and similar to the rest of the country.
- Customer income profile is resilient: Post-COVID stress has tapered out; jobs are available; customers are from service, manufacturing, and own-business segments, not heavily dependent on rural or agricultural incomes.
- LAP portfolio target: The LAP share is expected to reach 20% by March 2027, up from the current 13%, growing slightly faster than housing loans but not dramatically so.
Growth, Distribution & New Initiatives
- AUM growth target of 30%: Overall portfolio growth is guided at 30%, with LAP growing slightly faster than housing.
- Branch expansion accelerating: The company plans to add 20–25 branches and 60–70 touchpoints every year, with a focus on UP, MP, and Rajasthan. Hiring is heavily fresher-oriented, with 90% from campuses, so headcount additions come in large batches rather than a smooth curve.
- Gujarat share deliberately declining: Gujarat has fallen from 36%–38% to 31% of the book as part of an intentional diversification; the state is still targeted to grow at 20%–30%. The long-term vision is for the top 6–7 states to each contribute ~10%–12% of the book within 3–4 years.
- Ticket size rising, not segment-shifting: Average ticket size is increasing secularly due to higher incomes and aspirations in certain states, not because of a shift toward higher-end segments. New states carry lower ticket sizes of ₹10–12 lakhs, largely in self-construction, where yields run 20–30 bps higher.
- Co-lending milestone: Co-lending currently at 3% of AUM; the first milestone is 10%, at which point it merits separate disclosure. The spread math is attractive: a 1.25% spread on the 20% retained portion equates to 6.50%–6.75% on the asset, and as the interest rate environment improves, co-lending will add significantly to overall profitability.
- Insurance agency license secured: The corporate insurance agency license was obtained in February 2024; management is in advanced discussions with multiple insurers and hopes to sign one agreement this quarter, with full income of ₹5–6 crores per quarter visible from Q3 onward.
- Promoter exit to be gradual: Promoters True North and Aether Mauritius are likely to exit at roughly 10% per year, with transactions occurring only once annually; a six-month lock-in applies after the November transaction.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Credit cost | 30–40 bps | Ongoing structural guidance |
| Opex to assets | ~3.0% | Ongoing run-rate |
| Spread (ex co-lending) | 5.0%–5.25% | Medium term |
| NIM | 5.3%–5.5% | Going forward |
| Cost of borrowing | ~8.5%, then flatline | 2–3 quarters |
| ROA | ~3.5% (range 3.4%–3.6%) | Ongoing |
| ROE | 16%+ | Ongoing |
| AUM growth | 30% overall | Ongoing |
| LAP portfolio share | 20% | By March 2027 |
| Co-lending AUM share | 10% | Near future |
| Cost-to-income ratio | Decline toward ~30% | 3–5 years |
| State mix | Top 6–7 states each at ~10%–12% | 3–4 years |
| Branch/touchpoint expansion | 20–25 branches, 60–70 touchpoints | Every year |
| Insurance fee income | ₹5–6 crores per quarter | Full run-rate from Q3 FY25 |
| Promoter exit pace | ~10% per year | Annual, post lock-in |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements | ₹3,963 cr, grew 31.5% YoY |
| AUM | ₹9,697 cr, grew 34.7% YoY |
| PAT | ₹306 cr, grew 33.9% YoY |
| ROA | 3.8% for FY24 |
| ROE | 16.1% for Q4 FY24; 15.5% for FY24 |
| Spread (ex co-lending) | 5.4% |
| NIM | 5.3%, down ~20 bps YoY from cost of borrowing, financial leverage, and higher cash |
| Cost of borrowing | 8.25%, up 3 bps QoQ |
| Opex to assets | 2.5%, includes cleanup of old provisions; guidance ~3.0% going ahead |
| Credit cost | 10 bps, down 20 bps QoQ; includes ~₹2.5 cr recoveries from written-off accounts |
| Gross Stage 3 (GNPA) | 1.7%, flat QoQ; 1.1% prior to RBI Nov'21 circular |
| 1+ DPD | 4.2%, down 30 bps QoQ |
| 30+ DPD | 2.8%, down 20 bps QoQ |
| Total provision coverage ratio | 50.9%; 75.7% prior to NPA reclassification per RBI circular |
| CRAR | 39.5%; Tier 1 at 39.1% |
| Debt to equity | 3.4x |
| Networth | ₹2,122 cr |
| Book value per share | ₹239.7 |
| Co-lending volume | ₹68 cr in Q4; ₹214 cr in FY24 |
| Co-lending as % of AUM | 3%; milestone to reach 10% |
| LAP as % of portfolio | 13%; 3-year plan to reach 20% by March'27 |
| Branches | 133 physical branches; 321 touchpoints across 13 states/UT; 22 branches added in FY24 |
| Active connectors | ~3,000 |
| Relationship managers | ~700 |
| Customers registered on app | 95% as of Mar'24 |
| Loan sanctions via Account Aggregator | 47% in Q4 FY24 |
| Balance transfer (BT Out) rate | ~8% of total erosion |
| Total erosion rate | 18.5% for Q4; 16%–18% range |
| Origination yield target | ~13.5% |
| Spread guidance (ex co-lending) | 5.0%–5.25% medium term |
| Credit cost guidance | 30–40 bps; around 30 bps going ahead |
| AUM growth target | 30% |
| Branch expansion target | 20–25 branches per year; 60–70 touchpoints per year |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 34.1%; medium-term target ~30% |
| Promoter holding | 23.56% each for True North and Aether Mauritius; likely to exit ~10% per year |