Key Takeaways
- Margin reset on cost shocks: Standalone EBITDA margins fell from 17% to ~13%, driven by raw material inflation, logistics, energy, and an 8–8.5% rupee depreciation that more than offset any input cost relief.
- Overseas subsidiaries hit harder: Logistics-heavy cost structures meant overseas entities, especially EI Ceramics, suffered disproportionate margin pressure despite good sales expansion.
- Demand book still healthy: Most European operations carry very good order books and management sees no substantial demand impact going forward, even with some softening in certain European steelmaking areas.
- 15% EBITDA target reaffirmed, not abandoned: Management explicitly maintains its ~15% EBITDA margin target over a period, but recovery timing is conditional on global economic stability becoming clearer over the next 1–2 quarters.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether freight and raw material cost trends continue to ease as flagged, whether EI Ceramics' cost absorption improves on schedule, and any clarity on the two Independent Directors' removal.
Margin Walk: What Hit the Quarter
- Standalone margin collapse: EBITDA margins dropped from 17% to approximately 13% on the standalone entity, and this decline transferred directly into consolidated results.
- Raw material and logistics squeeze: Cost increases spanned all raw materials, plant consumables, and components used in manufacturing, with logistics playing an outsized role in overseas subsidiaries.
- Currency double-hit: Rupee depreciation of 8–8.5% against the dollar aggravated costs more than any input price reductions, while euro appreciation also pressured margins given the company's significant European export exposure.
- Import share rose with the dollar: The share of imported raw materials increased from ~50% to ~60% purely because the rupee weakened against the dollar, mechanically inflating the cost base.
- Freight costs stabilizing, but too late for Q1: Freight cost increases have stopped and a nominal reduction has been seen; some raw materials have also seen reductions, though others increased further.
McIntosh: "In EI Ceramics, we have now a good expansion in terms of the sales. Without a doubt, we are really being caught out with the scale of the cost increases that we face there. Not only the scale but also the speed at which they will hit the plant."
Overseas Subsidiaries: EI Ceramics Under Pressure
- Sales growth met cost shock: EI Ceramics delivered good sales expansion but was caught out by both the scale and the speed of cost increases hitting the plant, resulting in margin pressure.
- Gradual recovery expected: Management expects the situation to improve gradually over the next couple of quarters, bringing the subsidiary back to where it needs to be.
- Broader overseas margin pressure: Overseas subsidiaries as a group saw operating costs increase more than the parent company because logistics played a greater role in their cost structures.
Demand & Order Book
- European operations remain well-loaded: Most European operations still have very good order books, and management does not see too much impact going forward despite slight deterioration in steelmaking in certain areas of Europe.
- India-to-Europe supply softening, not collapsing: The Indian business supplying into Europe saw some areas of reduction in takeoff, but not substantially.
- Steel outlook supports volume: World Steel Association forecasts slight growth in steel for 2022 and normal growth for 2023, providing a constructive demand backdrop.
- Export proportion stable: Standalone export proportion is expected to stay about the same at 55–60%, supported by the Kandla expansion.
McIntosh: "I would say that most of our operations in Europe have still got very good order books and we don't see too much of an impact going forward there."
Pricing & Contract Dynamics
- Price hikes taken but not quantified: Management confirmed price increases were implemented to offset cost pressures but declined to quantify the magnitude, stating all pricing impacts will be discussed when contract renewals take place.
- Contract tenures shortening: Domestic contracts, historically 6 months to 1 year, have recently moved to 3–6 months because the user industry wants shorter terms amid price volatility.
- No factor-level margin breakup: When asked to disaggregate the gross margin decline into specific drivers (currency, raw materials, logistics), management stated they do not maintain that breakup and did not provide it.
Sarda: "The domestic contracts are generally on a 6 months to 1-year contract, but of late, it has been like a 3 to 6 months because the user industry wants a shorter term because of price volatility."
Capital Allocation & Strategic Initiatives
- CapEx timeline extends to FY24: Capital expenditure will come in phases, partly in FY23 but with the major part spilling over to FY24.
- Revenue multiplier on CapEx: Management expects approximately 3 to 3.5x of capital expenditure to convert into top-line growth over time.
- Vizag expansion product details withheld: Management declined to specify what new products the Vizag capacity expansion is targeting, asking to revisit the question in a few months when plans are finalized.
- ESG engagement launched: Signed an agreement with global consultants to focus on ESG, initially on Indian operations and then globally.
- Brand and digital refresh: Completed and rolled out a new brand identity; website modernization to be completed shortly, aimed at improving interface with customers, prospective employees, suppliers, and stakeholders.
- Domestic raw material sourcing push: The company is trying alternate domestic sources to replace imported raw materials, but management cautioned it will take time and is not very easy to replace.
Governance & Disclosure
- Independent Director removals not addressed: An analyst flagged the removal of two Independent Directors who own 15% of the company as a significant overhang on the stock; management declined to add anything beyond what is stated in the AGM notice.
- Private call transcripts requested: An analyst requested that management disclose transcripts of all private calls to enhance corporate governance; management acknowledged the point but did not commit, saying only "We will keep that in mind."
- Longer future calls promised: Management said they will try to have a longer call in future.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin target | Maintain ~15% EBITDA margins over a period | Recovery expected in next 2–3 quarters, conditional on global economic clarity in Q2–Q3 |
| EI Ceramics margin recovery | Cost absorption to improve gradually | Next couple of quarters |
| CapEx completion | Major part of current CapEx cycle to be completed | FY24 (phased, partly in FY23) |
| Export proportion | Standalone exports to remain at 55–60% | Ongoing, supported by Kandla expansion |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Standalone total income | ₹226 cr, +38% YoY |
| Consolidated total income | ₹360 cr, +30% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹28.5 cr, +3% YoY |
| Standalone EBITDA margin | 12.6%, down from 17% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹34.5 cr, -3% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 9.6%, down from 12.9% YoY |
| Standalone PAT | ₹12 cr, down from ₹13.4 cr YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹14.6 cr, down from ₹17.9 cr YoY |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹234 cr as of June 2022 |
| Consolidated capacity utilization | ~75% (per an analyst's math, management concurred) |
| Raw material sourcing mix | 60% imports, 40% domestic, shifted from 50:50 |
| Exports to Europe share | ~50% of total exports from India |
| Rupee depreciation vs USD | ~8% to 8.5% |
| CapEx completion timeline | FY24, major part spilling over into FY24 |
| Revenue to CapEx multiple assumption | 3 to 3.5x |