Key Takeaways
- Costs crushed earnings: EBITDA collapsed to Rs. 39 Crores from Rs. 165 Crores YoY as fuel costs per calorie nearly tripled while cement prices stayed flat, a dynamic management calls unprecedented.
- South-centric pain is acute: Southern companies, already running at 60-70% utilization versus near-full in the north, bore the brunt because the cost surge could not be passed on in a region with weaker pricing power.
- Volume offers a thin silver lining: Capacity utilization improved YoY and volumes held steady sequentially when they normally dip, but the benefit was entirely swamped by the cost explosion.
- Pricing relief is a bet, not a fact: Management is confident prices will rise in the next two months, yet concedes demand was not strong enough to push them up and monsoon has since dented key markets.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised price increase materializes, the trajectory of coal costs from their current plateau, and any fallout from the CCI investigation now underway.
The Cost Shock
- Fuel costs detonated the P&L: Coal cost per calorie surged from Rs. 1 to over Rs. 3, driving fuel consumption cost to Rs. 2.70 per kCal in Q1 versus Rs. 1.60 a year ago and Rs. 2.23 in Q4.
- Imported coal mix is broad but exposed: The fuel mix is roughly 65% imported coal and 35% pet coke, sourced from Indonesia, the US and Russia. The company has mitigated some pressure by importing Russian coal and using lower-quality Indonesian coal.
- Grid power became a cheaper fallback: As own-generation costs crossed Rs. 10 per unit, the company and others shifted to grid power at Rs. 7-8 per unit, a reversal of the normal economics.
- Transportation added a second squeeze: Diesel prices rose, lifting costs for both inbound raw material and outbound finished product, though the diesel increase was described as marginal.
- Coal costs have plateaued for now: Current coal costs are holding at the same level as Q1, but management offered no firm directional call, noting two competing views in the market: one expects a decline, the other expects firm prices.
Srinivasan: "The story of the quarter under review is a story of unprecedented increase in cost. The cement industry in India to my knowledge has never gone through such a serious increase in costs which has gone through the roof and prices have literally remained static."
Pricing Paralysis
- Costs could not be passed on: This is the first time management has seen a cost increase of this magnitude fail to translate into higher cement prices in the south.
- Demand was too weak to lift prices: Management stated plainly that demand was not strong enough to enable prices to be pushed up, and unprecedented monsoon rainfall in Andhra, Telangana and Karnataka subsequently took a further toll on demand.
- The north-south divide is structural: Northern companies, operating near 100% capacity utilization, were far less affected. Southern companies, stuck at 60-70% utilization, lacked the pricing leverage to recover costs. Companies that could increase blending and sell at shorter distances were the only ones that escaped the worst.
- A price rise is promised, conditionally: Management expressed confidence that prices will go up within the next one to two months, but this rests on demand recovering enough to absorb the increase.
Srinivasan: "The demand for cement was not strong enough to enable prices to be pushed up."
Volume & Demand Dynamics
- Volumes grew on a weak base: The company reported volume growth of 59% in the south and 17% outside the south, but this was against a low base in the same quarter last year. In absolute terms, volumes were only marginally higher.
- Sequential stability was a small positive: Volumes normally dip from Q4 to Q1, but this time they held steady, aided by some pent-up demand flowing through.
- Monsoon has since softened demand: Unprecedented rainfall across Andhra, Telangana and Karnataka has pulled demand down in key markets, adding a near-term headwind to any pricing push.
- Shipping dragged on the quarter: The shipping division was under maintenance, producing lower revenue of Rs. 3.3 Crores and a negative EBITDA of Rs. 1.4 Crores.
Mitigation & Operational Response
- Selling closer to the factory: The company will cultivate markets nearer to its plants to cut freight costs, with results expected in the next three to four months.
- Equipment upgrades are planned: Management intends to shift cement grinding from ball mills to vertical roller mills and install waste heat recovery systems where needed, though plans are contingent on a revenue-raising program.
- Industry capacity additions are slowing: Management noted that capacity additions going forward are far, far lower than in the past, a supply-side dynamic that could eventually support pricing if demand holds.
Regulatory Overhang
- CCI investigation is active: The Competition Commission of India has raised queries with 21 cement companies, and India Cements is in the process of replying.
- Management declined to characterize the probe: When asked whether the CCI's approach differs from past investigations, what period is under scrutiny, or whether it is historical in nature, management repeatedly declined to answer, calling it premature to comment.
- A broader regulatory tension was flagged: Management pointed to a contradiction where state governments demand detailed figures from cement companies while the competition commission says such information-sharing is wrong, suggesting the government should resolve which stance is correct.
Srinivasan: "See, at the moment if you look at it very carefully and in detail, every state government is asking every cement company to produce all kinds of figures and details about themselves, about other components, which competition commission says is wrong, so I think government should decide, which is right, which is wrong..."
Industry Visibility
- The fuel crisis has shortened the horizon: Management stated it cannot see the next six months in the cement industry because of the fuel crisis, noting that everyone is currently trying to sort out their immediate problems.
- Expansion plans were deflected: When asked about expansion plans in Central India, management declined to discuss them on the call, offering only to talk offline.
Srinivasan: "I am not able to see the next six months in the cement industry because of the fuel crisis. At the moment everybody is trying to sort out his immediate problem, at least we are."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Cement price increase | Confident prices will rise from current static levels | Next one to two months |
| Freight cost reduction | Cultivate markets closer to factories to reduce distance and cost | Results in three to four months |
| Equipment upgrades | Shift to vertical roller mills for cement grinding; install waste heat recovery where needed, subject to revenue-raising program | Plans chalked out, no fixed date |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated [1-10] |
| EBITDA (standalone) | ₹39 cr, down from ₹165 cr in Q1 FY22 |
| EBITDA (consolidated) | ₹50 cr |
| Total volume | 26.72 lakh tons including clinker |
| Clinker volume | 1.19 lakh tons |
| Volume growth in south | ~59% YoY |
| Volume growth outside south | ~17% YoY |
| Average coal cost | ₹17,300 per ton |
| Fuel consumption cost | ₹2.70 per kCal, up from ₹1.6 in Q1 FY22 and ₹2.23 in Q4 FY22 |
| Fuel mix | 65% imported coal, 35% pet coke (mostly local pet coke) |
| Realization | ~₹300 per bag, prices remained steady post June exit |
| Coal inventory | ~2 months |
| Shipping revenue | ₹3.3 cr, EBITDA negative ₹1.4 cr |
| Wind power income | ₹5.6 cr, EBITDA ₹4.4 cr |
| RMC income | ₹26 cr, EBITDA ₹1.5 cr |