Key Takeaways
- Record loss on coal shock: Q2 FY23 was the highest loss in company history, driven by an unprecedented coal cost surge that pushed variable cost from the ₹2,000–₹2,300 range to ₹3,600–₹3,700, a cost increase that could not be immediately passed on.
- Recovery bet rests entirely on price, not cost relief: Management expects no meaningful decline in coal cost and is explicit that margins will reappear "not because the coal cost is going down... because the cement price is going up."
- Post-Diwali demand is brisk, and price hikes are landing selectively: ₹30–₹40/bag increases achieved in southern states, but nothing in Maharashtra, Gujarat, MP, or Rajasthan East; management expects the industry to reach breakeven by end-November and turn profitable the following month.
- MP sale nearly closed, debt repayment ring-fenced: ₹500 cr of the ₹600 cr transaction received; all debt obligations will be repaid without touching the cash reserve from the sale.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the November and December price increases actually push the industry into the black, the pace of coal cost moderation toward the ₹3/Kcal target, and any movement on the pending CCI queries.
The Coal Shock & Its Aftermath
- Unprecedented cost escalation: Coal cost per ton jumped from ₹17,285 in Q1 to ₹20,552 in Q2, and per Kcal from ₹2.69 to ₹3.26, driving variable cost to ₹3,600–₹3,700 against a pre-shock range of ₹2,000–₹2,300.
- Factory performance was not the problem: Management stated factory efficiency was satisfactory and there was no other reason for the cost increase beyond coal.
- Coal cost outlook is flat to slightly better: The company has booked coal at current prices with a 2.5-month lead time, so no effective decrease for that period; beyond that, management expects coal closer to ₹3 per Kcal, maybe just under, which is lower than Q2's ₹3.26 but not a dramatic fall.
N. Srinivasan: "The second quarter India Cements incurred posted a loss, which is the highest in its history so far. What caused this? unprecedented rise in the cost of coal which naturally increase the cost of production which could not be compensated by an immediate price increase."
The Price Recovery Thesis
- The mechanism is price-led, not cost-led: Management was unambiguous that margin recovery depends on cement price increases, not on coal costs declining, and expressed conviction that the planned increases will materialize.
- Price hikes are landing unevenly: Increases of ₹30–₹40 per bag were achieved in southern states, but no increases materialized in Maharashtra, Gujarat, MP, or Rajasthan East.
- Breakeven by November, black by December: The expectation is that by end-November cement prices would have risen enough for all companies to be close to breakeven, and the following month's contemplated increase would push the industry into the black.
- Volume versus price discipline: Management framed the choice starkly: choosing volume over price creates a problem, and the company is prioritizing price.
- South India capacity additions are not a threat to pricing: Despite new grinding units being added in the South, management still expects pricing to be strong.
N. Srinivasan: "The margins will reappear not because the coal cost is going down. It is because the cement price is going up, which is what we expect."
Demand Environment
- Post-Diwali pickup: Demand is showing signs of picking up after the festive season and was described as brisk.
- The demand backdrop supports price action: The demand recovery is the foundation for the price increases management is counting on, though the call did not quantify volumes or provide a regional demand breakdown.
Invoice Price Discipline
- Management supports the Adani-suggested move toward invoice price respect: The company believes it is a good system for the industry and that participants will slowly change to it.
- Discounts are routed through credit notes: Most discounts are given only through credit notes; only a very small fraction are given as gold coins, and where gold coins are issued, tax is deducted and remitted under new Section 194R.
- No comment on competitor behavior: When asked why some mills are not adopting the discipline when it benefits everyone, management declined to answer for others.
N. Srinivasan: "You see, cement is a product where if one, I mean, you can choose volume; you can choose price. If you choose volume over price, you will have a problem."
Balance Sheet & Regulatory Updates
- MP asset sale: ₹500 cr of the total ₹600 cr transaction has been received; the remaining ₹100 cr is yet to be collected.
- Debt repayment ring-fenced: All debt obligations will be repaid without touching the cash reserve from the MP sale.
- CCI queries pending: The company has filed replies to CCI queries and is waiting for a response; no action has been heard.
- Consolidation view declined: When asked for a view on sector consolidation after Adani's entry, management declined to offer one, stating it is focused on increasing cement prices.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Industry breakeven | Cement prices to rise enough for all companies to be close to breakeven | End of November |
| Industry profitability | Contemplated price increase to push the cement industry into the black | Month following November |
| Coal cost moderation | Coal closer to ₹3 per Kcal, maybe just under (vs Q2's ₹3.26) | After 2.5-month lead time from current bookings |
| Debt repayment | All debt obligations repaid without touching MP sale cash reserve | Undated (transaction closing underway) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net loss | Highest in company history, driven by unprecedented rise in coal cost |
| Cement sales volume | 22.50 lakh tons, vs 22.53 lakh tons in Q2 FY22 |
| Clinker sales volume | 0.04 lakh tons, vs 1.07 lakh tons in Q2 FY22 |
| Total sales volume (cement + clinker) | 22.54 lakh tons, vs 23.60 lakh tons in Q2 FY22 |
| Average coal cost per ton | ₹20,552, vs ₹17,285 in Q1 FY23 |
| Coal cost per Kcal | ₹3.26, vs ₹2.69 in Q1 FY23 and ₹1.67 in Q2 FY22 |
| Fuel mix | Coal 84%, Petcoke 11% |
| Price increase achieved (South markets) | ₹30–₹40 per bag in Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka, Andhra, Telangana; zero in Maharashtra, Gujarat, MP, Rajasthan East |
| Additional price increase attempted | ₹15–₹20 per bag from 3 November |
| Shipping segment revenue | ₹14.43 cr, EBITDA ₹8.92 cr |
| Windmill segment revenue | ₹8.02 cr, EBITDA ₹6.61 cr |
| RMC segment revenue | ₹29.16 cr, EBITDA ₹2.28 cr |
| Total debt | ₹2,937 cr as of 30 September 2022 |
| MP business sale proceeds received | ₹500 cr received, ₹100 cr yet to be received |
| Expected coal cost per Kcal (forward outlook) | Closer to ₹3, maybe just under ₹3 per Kcal |