Key Takeaways
- A brutal coal shock, not a demand crisis: Delivered coal prices doubled to \$230/tonne, pushing many peers into losses. India Cements survived but saw margins compress sharply, while a one-off employee gift and plant refurbishment added to the cost burden.
- Self-help pivot is now explicit: Management has engaged Krupp Polysis and FLSmidth to redesign processes and cut variable costs, targeting a potential outlay of ₹1,500 crores upwards, funded entirely by selling non-cement assets rather than debt.
- The Springway sale delivered a clean gain: The divestment closed with a profit of ₹294.28 crores, and the company used tax provisions to offset the gain against business losses, resulting in zero tax outflow on the transaction.
- Pricing power remains absent: Prices did not increase over the last 3–6 months and likely declined in January, even as management expresses hope for a near-term recovery.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised variable cost reduction plan firms up into a quantified, time-bound roadmap once the consultants’ reports arrive, and whether cement prices actually move up.
The Coal Shock & Cost Structure
- Coal price doubled: Delivered coal prices surged from \$100 to \$230 per tonne, an increase the industry could not manage, leaving many companies in the red. Availability of coal was also difficult.
- One-off employee cost: Employee expenses included a ~₹7 crore one-off gift for the company’s Platinum Jubilee (75th year), which was the primary driver of the quarter’s employee cost increase.
- Refurbishment lifted other expenses: Stores and repairs expense rose to ~₹44 crores this quarter from ~₹34 crores in September and ~₹26 crores in the same quarter last year, driven by refurbishment activity.
- Fuel cost easing in Q4: The fuel cost run rate in Q4 is around ₹2.75 per kilo cal, implying a roughly 10% reduction from Q3 levels.
N. Srinivasan: "The main fuel for cement industry is coal, and the price of coal shot up from \$100, delivered price of coal, it went to \$230. So, this increase could not be managed by the cement industry, many of the companies were in the red."
Variable Cost Reduction Plan
- Consultants engaged: India Cements has asked Krupp Polysis and FLSmidth to submit reports on what can be done to reduce variable cost, specifically energy cost, coal and power. The reports are expected in the next three to four days.
- Potential outlay: The cost of the exercise is difficult to predict now but may range from ₹1,500 crores upwards. The company will decide what to implement once the reports are received.
- Funding without debt: Management stated clearly that the company is not intending to borrow anything for this exercise, and has enough non-cement assets it can dispose of if necessary to raise the funds.
- Timeline: The variable cost reduction changes are expected to take about eight to nine months for the early part, and can go up to 11 to 12 months.
- Scope of changes: The plan involves plain and simple changes to various pyroprocessing processes, not experimental technology. The overall aim is to reduce variable cost, increase overall cement volume, and achieve a lower production cost.
N. Srinivasan: "We are quite confident of achieving this, because we are not going to, in a way we are not going to any rocket science ideas. These are plain and simple changes to the various Pyroprocessing processes."
Demand, Pricing & Volume
- Demand slightly better: Demand in the South has been slightly better than earlier, giving hope that it will pick up sufficiently for prices to move up.
- Pricing still weak: Prices did not increase over the last 3–6 months and probably declined in January, per an analyst’s observation that management agreed with. Management expressed every expectation that prices will go up in the near future.
- Volume growth lagged the region: For the nine-month period, India Cements’ volume growth of ~11% trailed the regional growth of ~13%.
- FY24 outlook tied to elections: Management expects growth to be good in the South because it is a pre-election year, with growth expected to remain at around double-digit numbers in the South.
Product Mix & Trade Strategy
- Blended cement push: The company is going to increase the percentage of blended cement produced and is quite confident it can sell it, which will reduce the cost of production. The target is to increase blended cement mix from 55% to 65%, mostly through the trade segment.
- New varieties: The company is also looking at producing different, newer varieties of cement that have already gained market share in the industry.
- Trade mix increase: Increasing the trade mix is part of the new strategy.
- Plant refurbishment: A major refurbishment exercise is planned for plant equipment, separate from normal annual capex of ~₹100 crores. The cost will be known in the next few days or within a week, and the amount will not be excessive. The company will refurbish all its plants without any borrowing, as a medium-term to long-term step.
Asset Monetization & the Land Question
- Springway sale completed: The sale of the Springway investment was completed with a total sales value of ₹476 crores and a profit on sale of ₹294.28 crores booked. The gain was set off against business losses under IT Act provisions, resulting in no tax outflow on the long-term capital gain.
- Land monetization intent: The company intends to sell only surplus land not usable for cement or byproducts, and will raise as much money as needed for refurbishment. Lands are bunched together and also separate, and the company is in a position to sell depending on what is needed.
- No valuation provided: Management declined to provide any valuation of the land portfolio, stating they have not made a valuation and it is difficult to satisfy the curiosity. Land in Vizag could see value increases after the Chief Minister’s declaration of Vizag as the next capital, but lands were bought at the time of the company’s formation and are in different parts, making prediction difficult.
- Regulatory delays: When asked what is holding back land monetization after 3–4 years of discussion, management attributed the delay to a lot of little regulations and formalities to be followed that are taking time, without providing specifics or a timeline.
Management: “I will tell you, what is holding is not the company's intention. But there are a lot of little regulations and formalities to be followed. So, that is taking a little time.”
Labour & Wage Settlement
- Independent wage settlement: India Cements signed a wage settlement for non-management workers covering April ’22 to March ’26, with a ₹5,000 per month increase split into two ₹2,500 installments. The settlement was done independently rather than as part of an industry-wide arrangement.
- Rationale for going solo: The industry-wide arrangement was taking too long, and almost one year had passed. India Cements felt it could come to a settlement quite quickly and did not want to make employees wait. The settlement was signed in half a day.
Management: “The only way to read is that trying to get an arrangement for the entire cement industry was taking time. India Cements felt that they could come to a settlement quite quickly. So, in half a day, actually, this settlement was signed.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Variable cost reduction plan | Receive reports from Krupp Polysis and FLSmidth on energy cost, coal and power reduction | Next 3–4 days |
| Variable cost reduction implementation | Early part of changes completed | 8–9 months |
| Variable cost reduction implementation | Full changes completed | Up to 11–12 months |
| Plant refurbishment cost known | Cost of the major refurbishment exercise quantified | Next few days / within a week |
| Blended cement mix | Increase from 55% to 65%, mostly through trade segment | No date (strategy underway) |
| Volume growth outlook | Double-digit growth in the South, aided by pre-election year spending | FY24 |
| Fuel cost run rate | ~₹2.75 per kilo cal, implying ~10% reduction from Q3 | Q4 FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Cement and clinker sales volume | 21.82 lakh tons |
| Clinker production | 17.12 lakh tons |
| Profit on sale of investment (Springway) | ₹294.28 crores |
| Net profit for the quarter | ₹114 crores, after setting off capital gain against nine-months loss of ₹450 crores |
| PBT excluding capital gain | negative ₹180 crores (loss) |
| Deferred tax provision | ₹23 crores |
| Total gross borrowings | ₹2,980.6 crores at end of December |
| Fuel cost per kilo cal | ₹2.95, down from ₹3.26 in Q2 FY23 |
| Fuel cost run rate (Q4 FY23) | around ₹2.75 |
| Trade mix | 55% trade, 45% non-trade |
| Blended cement mix | 55%, target 65% |
| Volume growth (nine months FY23) | ~11% for India Cements, vs ~13% for the South region |
| Employee cost (quarterly run rate) | ₹92 crores, includes one-off Platinum Jubilee gift of close to ₹7 crores |
| Stores and repairs expense | ₹44–45 crores, up from around ₹34 crores in Q2 FY23 and nearly ₹26 crores in Q3 FY22 |
| Shipping segment turnover | ₹15 crores, EBITDA around ₹8.6 crores |
| RMC segment turnover | ₹28.36 crores, EBITDA around ₹2.3 crores |
| Windmill segment turnover | ₹1.3 crores, EBITDA practically nil |
| Trade union settlement impact on annual employee cost | ₹4–5 crores for the full year, covering ~500 non-management workers |