Key Takeaways
- Costs overwhelmed pricing, crushing the quarter: Fuel cost per kCal surged from Rs.1.94 to Rs.2.30 QoQ, while the industry barely raised prices, leaving margins deeply compressed.
- The worst is over, management declares: With a concrete price-hike plan starting June 1 and a shift to longer-term coal sourcing, the company expects better production and results from June onwards.
- Receivables spike is an accounting change, not a cash problem: A policy shift to report receivables gross of security deposits inflated the headline number; on a like-to-like basis, trade receivables actually fell Rs.20 crores YoY.
- Asset monetization is the liquidity lever, but details are scarce: Management intends to sell non-core land to meet debt repayments, insisting it will not be a distress sale, but declined to provide any valuation or target.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the planned Rs.55 per bag price hike sticks in June/July, and if fuel cost per kCal indeed peaks near the guided Rs.2.6 in Q1.
Cost & Margin Pressure
- Fuel costs spiraled out of management's control: Coal costs shot up substantially, driving fuel cost per kCal from Rs.1.94 in Q3 to Rs.2.30 in Q4, with a further rise to around Rs.2.6 expected in Q1 FY23 as high-cost inventory flows through.
- Pricing lagged far behind the cost curve: The industry was slow to compensate for cost increases, with almost no price increase taken in April and May, forcing the company to absorb the full brunt of the fuel spike during the quarter.
- Market mix added to the cost burden: To maintain dispatch volumes amid low southern utilization, the company pushed into markets like Maharashtra where demand existed, but this market is mostly OPC, causing PPC production to fall, which increased costs and reduced volume potential.
- Logistics costs are a live concern: The company now mainly transports by road, making it more exposed to diesel prices, though management assumes diesel prices remain steady after recent government action.
N. Srinivasan: "If one were to sum up in one sentence, what was the Q4 results, it is a question of sharp increase in costs caused by factors not under the control of the management, and the fact that the slow reaction of the industry of us to compensate for these costs increases."
Pricing Strategy & Outlook
- A specific, public price-hike plan is now committed: Management intends to increase price by Rs.20 on June 1, another Rs.15 on June 15, and a further Rs.20 on July 1, stating this will adequately cover all cost increases.
- Confidence rests on industry-wide pain: Management believes the increases will be absorbed because every producer is suffering the same cost squeeze, and expects sanity to prevail with others also raising prices.
- Costs will keep rising, so pricing must too: The company is pushing prices precisely because it expects costs to go up further, not because the cost cycle has peaked.
- PPC production is the embedded cost lever: The company aims to improve PPC production going forward, which reduces cost and gives more volume, partially reversing the adverse mix shift of Q4.
N. Srinivasan: "I have confidence because everybody is suffering the costs increases. This time it will be absorbed."
Balance Sheet & Liquidity
- Debt repayments were refinanced, not reduced: The company paid scheduled repayments in FY22 but refinanced them, and could not repay debt this year due to huge margin pressure from an unkind industry environment.
- Land monetization is the stated liquidity solution: Management will monetize some non-core assets, mainly land, to improve liquidity, but will only complete projects already taken and will not embark on anything new.
- No distress sale, but no numbers either: Management insists land will be sold at a proper price as needed, not in distress, but declined to provide any target value or phased liquidation estimate when asked.
- Receivables quality is better than the headline suggests: A change in accounting policy now shows receivables at gross level with security deposits under liabilities; on a like-to-like gross basis, trade receivables actually fell by Rs.20 crores YoY.
Management: "We will monetize to the extent necessary at a proper price. This is not distress sale. So, there are very exciting possibilities. Let us wait and see."
Demand & Operating Environment
- Demand has been slightly sluggish in April and May, adding to the challenge of passing through price increases in a soft market.
- Southern utilization was hit by external shocks: Low capacity utilization in the South resulted from longer lockdowns and torrential rains in most markets, which disrupted normal business.
- Coal availability fears have receded, but price fears have not: Coal is now available, removing the earlier fear of not getting supply, but the question has shifted entirely to at what price.
- Longer-term coal sourcing is the mitigation: The company is now in a position to enter longer-term arrangements with coal suppliers, expecting to benefit from slightly lower coal prices going forward, even as its base assessment is that coal prices will still increase.
N. Srinivasan: "...it is our assessment that the coal prices will not go down, will still increase going forward."
Policy & Structural Asks
- Telescopic freight is the big government ask: The company has represented to the finance minister and government for telescopic freight on cement movement from south to north, which would allow southern plants to operate at much higher capacity utilization and supply cement-starved projects in the North.
- Conviction conveyed, outcome uncertain: Management believes it has conveyed conviction to the government and a recent media article mentioned the government looking to improve logistics, but the company will simply wait and see what happens.
- No comment on industry M&A: When asked about the competitive scenario evolving from a large M&A transaction in cement, management declined to comment, stating the South is not involved much.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Price increase | Rs.20/tonne on June 1, Rs.15 on June 15, Rs.20 on July 1 | June-July 2022 |
| EBITDA improvement | Combination of price hikes and cost measures to improve EBITDA | From June 2022 onwards |
| Fuel cost trajectory | Fuel cost per kCal expected around Rs.2.6 | Q1 FY23 |
| PPC production | Improve PPC production to reduce cost and increase volume | Going forward |
| Coal sourcing | Enter longer-term arrangements to secure slightly lower coal prices | Going forward |
| Capex restraint | Complete only Sankar Nagar cement mill and waste heat recovery; no new projects | Ongoing |
| Debt repayment | Ensure repayments are done as per schedule | As per schedule |
| Asset monetization | Monetize non-core land to improve liquidity, at a proper price, not distress | As needed |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Cement sales volume | 26.29 lakh tons |
| Total sales volume (cement + clinker) | 26.57 lakh tons, including 0.28 lakh tons of clinker |
| Clinker production | 19.63 lakh tons |
| Standalone gross debt | ₹3,063 crores, up from ₹3,000 crores last year |
| Consolidated gross debt | ₹3,085.58 crores |
| Scheduled debt repayment for FY23 | about ₹500 crores |
| Trade receivables (gross) | ₹921 crores, down from ₹941.24 crores last year on a like-to-like basis |
| Fuel cost per ton | ₹14,000 per ton, up from ₹12,600 in Q3 and ₹9,100 in Q4 FY21 |
| Fuel cost per kCal | Rs.2.30, up from Rs.1.94 in Q3 |
| Fuel cost per kCal estimate for Q1 FY23 | around Rs.2.6 |
| Shipping revenue | Rs.8 crores |
| Shipping EBITDA | Rs.4.2 crores |
| RMC revenue | Rs.33.5 crores |
| RMC EBITDA | Rs.5 crores |
| Wind revenue | Rs.0.78 crores |
| Land bank | 26,000 acres |
| Proposed price hike | ₹55 total, phased as ₹20 on 1st June, ₹15 on 15th June, and ₹20 on 1st July |
| Coal inventory | two to three months stock |