Key Takeaways
- Startling coal cost shock, now easing: Coal rocketed from ~\$60 to ~\$300, driving cost per calorie from Rs. 1 to Rs. 2.8. Management says the cost of coal is now coming down almost daily, offering the clearest path to margin recovery.
- Full production, broken pricing: The industry is running at full capacity but prices are at the lowest level, with a tendency to sell the last gram of cement at a poor price. Management believes once the urge to sell extra tons disappears, prices will rise.
- Land monetization to fund the fix: The company is looking to monetize 400-500 acres of unused land over the next 12-18 months, with proceeds directed toward CAPEX and potential debt repayment.
- ₹600 crore CAPEX program underway: Investments target grinding efficiency (roller mills), Pyroprocessing changes, and heat consumption reduction across three or four factories, to be completed in 18-20 months.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the coal cost decline actually flows into EBITDA, whether prices in Tamil Nadu and Kerala hold their modest improvement, and any concrete progress on land monetization.
The Coal Shock & Its Aftermath
- The damage: Coal cost skyrocketed from ~\$60 to ~\$300, pushing cost per calorie from Rs. 1 to Rs. 2.8, a burden management says cannot be borne by any management. The company could not run its own power plant because coal cost was so high, forcing acceptance of losses.
- The relief: Cost of coal is now coming down almost on a daily basis. Fuel cost is expected to come down to around 2.3 to 2.4 in Q1, and management sees cost of production, which went up by Rs. 1,700 per ton, beginning to reverse.
- Heat consumption ceiling: No real research has been done into the heat of reaction where limestone converts to clinker; improvements come only from machinery manufacturers reducing heat consumption. When heat cost goes up, little can be done, so the company has engaged FLSmidth and Krupp Polysius to advise on heat consumption reduction, with their report almost ready.
- APGPCL impairment: The company provided for an impairment in value on its share in APGPCL, a gas-based power producer that is not working now because gas prices went to ~\$10 per mmbtu and allocation was unavailable. Even at \$6.04 per mmbtu, power from APGPCL would be more expensive than grid power. The plant and machinery is in perfect condition and could work if gas prices return to \$2.50-\$3.
N. Srinivasan: "The results, if one can say are startling. When the cost of coal, which is our main fuel, skyrockets from about \$60 to \$300 there is very little that management can do except grin and bear it."
Pricing Paradox: Full Utilization, Low Prices
- The paradox: Demand is good and almost all companies are running full, yet prices are stagnant and cutthroat. The tendency among most companies is to sell the last gram of cement at not a good price.
- Southern capacity dynamics: Southern cement capacity is 18 crore tons, with estimated production in FY23 around 14-15 crore tons. Significant volumes move outside the South to Maharashtra, the Western side, Odisha and West Bengal. Companies are operating at close to full capacity in Tamil Nadu, the Nalgonda cluster, and the Tandur cluster.
- The coexistence thesis: Management describes a new model of coexistence with low prices, arguing that once optimal capacity is reached and the urge to sell extra tons disappears, prices will increase. As of now, marginal improvements have happened but the full pricing recovery is not yet visible.
- Price difference concept continues: The practice of invoicing then discounting persists with no change in marketing approach; management attributes price decline partly to weakness of the selling force.
- Current trajectory: Prices as compared to March have not slipped and are at the same level or better, though still at a very low level. Tamil Nadu and Kerala prices as compared to the March exit price are better, and current prices in the first half of Q2 are better than the March quarter.
N. Srinivasan: "This year the demand is good, in fact almost all the companies are running full. So, the tendency amongst the most companies is to sell the last gram of cement which is not a good price."
Volume Strategy & Market Choices
- Selective selling: Because the company is making losses, it is picking and choosing markets, selling more into core markets where volumes increased exponentially, though total volume looks low versus FY19.
- No surplus clinker in South: At the moment there is no surplus clinker available in the South, which constrains the ability to push incremental volume.
- Limestone constraint: Most limestone is already spoken for and used; there are not vast tracts unexploited, and the limestone situation will not support great expansion in the future. No limestone auction has taken place in the South; it is at a standstill.
- New capacity absorption: The 0.3-1 crore tons of new capacity coming can get absorbed by demand, and new capacity additions in the South will take another 1.5 to 2 years.
Efficiency CAPEX & Cost Reduction
- ₹600 crore program: CAPEX of about ₹600 crores to be completed in about 18 to 20 months, targeting three or four factories. The program covers changing roller mills to vertical roller mills for an enormous power drop, plus changes in Pyroprocessing.
- Heat consumption reduction: CAPEX program to reduce heat consumption by changing equipment at 2-3 plants, informed by the FLSmidth and Krupp Polysius report that is almost ready.
- Waste Heat Recovery: One plant has already initiated a WHRS project of 8 MW, at an approximate cost of ₹100 crores. Management will take a call on further WHRS depending on the shortage of power.
- Alternative fuels: Investments have been put in for AFR in all kilns, with a plan to go up to more than double digit for AFR usage at the company level, first by putting up the feeding system. Management declined to quantify the total AFR CAPEX outlay.
- Solar power: The company is going to put out a solar power plant in Tamil Nadu, already initiated.
Balance Sheet & Asset Monetization
- Land monetization: The company is looking at land monetization on standalone books, with about 400-500 acres expected to sell for a reasonable sum. Management sees a very good chance of monetizing over the next 12 to 18 months. Proceeds are earmarked for CAPEX and potential debt repayment.
- MP limestone mine sale proceeds: The ₹600 crores from the MP limestone mine sale was utilized partly for improving efficiencies in some plants, working capital requirements, and meeting the deficit in terms of cash flow.
- Debt repayment commitment: The company will repay the full Rs. 450 crores plus interest this year, with no default.
- Identified surplus land: The company has identified land not used by the cement factory for disposal to finance CAPEX and potential repayment.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Debt repayment | Repay full Rs. 450 crores plus interest, no default | This year |
| Efficiency CAPEX completion | ₹600 crores across three or four factories for grinding and Pyroprocessing changes | 18 to 20 months |
| Land monetization | 400-500 acres sold for a reasonable sum | Next 12 to 18 months |
| Fuel cost reduction | Fuel cost to come down to around 2.3 to 2.4 | Q1 |
| Heat consumption reduction | Change equipment at 2-3 plants based on expert report | Report almost ready; CAPEX timeline not specified |
| AFR usage | Go up to more than double digit at company level | After feeding system installed; timeline not specified |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| EBITDA per ton | Negative ₹175, compared to peers at ₹500–₹600 in the same region |
| Cost of production | ₹1,700 per ton, driven by elevated power and fuel costs |
| Net debt (standalone) | ₹2,919 cr, including working capital |
| Net debt (consolidated) | ₹2,939 cr |
| Cement volume | 27.85 lakh tons, including clinker of 0.10 lakh tons |
| Fuel cost per calorie | ₹2.7 in Q4, down from ₹2.95 in Q3; Q1 FY24 expected at 2.3–2.4 |
| Full-year FY23 cement and clinker sales | 98.93 lakh tons, clinker included 1.37 lakh tons |
| Full-year FY23 cement production | 97.3 lakh tons |
| Full-year FY23 clinker production | 73 lakh tons |
| Shipping segment revenue | ₹13 cr, EBITDA ₹5.6 cr |
| RMC segment revenue | ₹25 cr, EBITDA close to ₹1.8 cr |
| Windmill segment revenue | ₹0.73 cr, EBITDA practically nil |
| Principal repayment due in FY24 | ₹450 cr, plus interest; total outgo including some interest ₹540 cr |
| Annual interest cost | ₹200–250 cr |
| CAPEX plan (FY24–25) | ₹600 cr, to be completed in 18–20 months; includes WHR, mill upgrades, solar |
| WHR project | 8 MW at one plant, cost approx ₹100 cr |
| Land monetization target | 400–500 acres, proceeds to fund CAPEX and debt repayment |
| Extraordinary provision (APGPCL impairment) | ₹113 cr, for gas-based power joint venture that became unviable |
| APGPCL power capacity | 23 MW, previously supplied at lower-than-grid cost; now uneconomical at $6.04/mmbtu gas |
| Proceeds from MP limestone mine sale to JSW | ₹600 cr received, ₹3 cr pending; used for efficiencies, working capital, cash flow deficit |