Key Takeaways
- A reset quarter, not a recovery one: Volume fell because of internal working capital constraints, not weak demand, while the industry grew double digits. The Parli grinding unit sale and a coal cost tailwind set up a cleaner P&L from Q1 FY25.
- Coal costs are the margin story: Coal prices dropped from ₹3,500 to ₹3,050 per ton, and management expects further reductions. Combined with waste heat recovery and a new vertical roller mill, the cost base is structurally improving.
- Parli sale unlocks ₹315 cr and removes a drag: The unit was not making much EBITDA and had lost its tax benefit. The profit will be booked in Q1 FY25, and the lost capacity will be replaced at Malkapur for better contribution.
- Pricing is a yo-yo, but the direction is up: Prices rose smartly in April, diluted in May, and are expected to rise again in June after elections. Management expects a choppy quarter but a net improvement from March exit levels.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the profit from the Parli sale is disclosed, how much of the modernization CAPEX is actually spent, and whether June pricing holds after the election bump.
Volume & Demand
- Lost volume was self-inflicted: The company lost volume due to working capital constraints, not a demand problem. The industry grew double digits in the same period, so the shortfall was entirely internal.
- Utilization headroom is large: The company is operating at 61% utilization, leaving roughly 40% headroom on existing plant. Management says working capital constraints will not repeat, so volumes should out-turn much higher going forward.
- Q1 FY25 off to a slow start: Volume so far in Q1 FY25 has been very subdued due to elections, with April and May demand flattish. Management expects improvement only post-June.
- Industry growth may be flat for two months: Management's guess is that the first two months of Q1 FY25 will be flat for the industry as a whole.
Costs & Efficiency
- Coal cost tailwind has room to run: Coal prices dropped from ₹3,500 to ₹3,050 per ton a year ago, and management expects further reductions this year.
- Waste heat recovery at Chilamakuru: The project will substantially reduce power costs and increase output.
- Sankari vertical roller mill: The new VRM will allow the plant to use cheaper wet fly ash sourced from closer locations and in higher volumes, pushing the plant toward becoming a million-ton unit.
- BCG savings were one-off, not a program: Suggestions implemented in three plants achieved roughly ₹184 per ton in savings, but no new efficiency programs were carried out in FY24.
- Sankarnagar VRM is efficiency, not capacity: The vertical roller mill capitalized last year is a replacement of old cement mills with no capacity increase, purely an efficiency improvement.
N. Srinivasan: "The last few years we were in the boondocks. We had a tough time. Fuel prices shot up. Our costs were high."
Asset Monetization & Portfolio
- Parli grinding unit sold for ₹315 cr: The unit was not making much EBITDA, the market in that area was not strong, and the sale tax benefit had gone. The profit will be booked in Q1 FY25, though the amount was not disclosed.
- Lost capacity replaced at Malkapur: Grinding capacity will be added at Malkapur, where contribution is expected to be better, so volumes are not permanently lost.
- No further plant sales planned: Only non-core assets are being considered for sale going forward. Management will dispose of assets to the extent necessary but will not sell additional assets just for the sake of disposing.
- Land parcels under consideration: The company is looking at selling some land parcels when the right price and buyer emerge, but there are no fixed ideas or timelines.
N. Srinivasan: "As far as we are concerned, to the extent necessary, we will dispose off assets. But we will not dispose additional assets just for the sake of disposing."
Pricing
- April rise, May dilution, June hope: Prices went up smartly in April, then diluted in May. Current prices are slightly better than the March exit, and management expects them to rise again in June after elections conclude.
- A choppy quarter ahead: Management described the pricing trajectory as a yo-yo for this quarter, with the net direction expected to be positive once the election overhang clears.
N. Srinivasan: "Looks like in June again the prices will go up. So, this is what we expect. I think as the election thing gets over, I think the prices will go up in June is what we are expecting. It will be a yo-yo sort of a thing for this quarter."
CAPEX & Projects
- Modernization CAPEX to launch soon: Most of the money will be spent this year, with next year restricted to the balance and routine CAPEX.
- Project timelines vary: Some projects will take 6 to 8 months, others 12 to 15 months.
- Raasi plant group plans: Management said these will unfold as time goes on, offering no specifics.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Coal cost reduction | Further reduction from the current ₹3,050/ton level | This year |
| Parli sale profit recognition | Profit from the ₹315 cr sale to be booked | Q1 FY25 |
| Modernization CAPEX spend | Most of the modernization CAPEX to be spent | This year (FY25) |
| Volume recovery | Working capital constraints resolved; much higher quantity of cement to be out-turned | Years going forward |
| Pricing recovery | Prices expected to rise again after elections conclude | June 2024 |
| Sankari plant scale-up | Plant to become a million-ton unit via VRM benefits | No date given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated for consolidated cement; shipping ₹7.4 cr, RMC ₹27 cr, windmill ₹0.5 cr |
| EBITDA – Shipping | ₹1.7 cr |
| EBITDA – RMC | ₹2.2 cr |
| EBITDA – Windmill | Negative ₹1 cr |
| Cost per Kcal | ₹1.95 |
| Volume decline (YoY) | 12% decline, due to working capital constraints |
| Trade mix | 57% trade, balance non-trade |
| Utilization | 61% |
| Industry growth – South (full year FY24) | 9% to 10% |
| Industry growth – South (Q4 FY24) | 7% to 8% |
| Industry growth – Country (full year FY24) | Close to 10% |
| Parli Grinding Unit sale value | ₹315 cr |
| Efficiency improvement CAPEX planned | ₹500 cr over next two years |
| Routine CAPEX | ~₹100 cr per annum |
| WHR capacity at Chilamakuru | 8 MW |
| Company-level cost savings target (post-CAPEX) | ₹150 to ₹175 per ton |
| Cost savings achieved in 3 plants (FY24, BCG program) | ~₹184 per ton |