Key Takeaways
- Asset quality turnaround drives profit surge: PAT jumped 153% YoY to ₹37 crores, powered by provision reversals after conservative March '22 recognition; gross Stage 3 halved from 13.6% to 7.9%.
- AUM still shrinking despite disbursement ramp: Overall AUM declined 3% QoQ to ₹7,669 crores because repayments outpaced new loans, even as disbursements rose 56% QoQ to ₹522 crores.
- Used CV pivot is reshaping the P&L: ~90-95% of disbursements now flow to used CV in Tier 3/4 markets, lifting NIMs materially; management targets at least a 2x CV loan book in the next couple of years.
- Infrastructure built, growth paddle not yet pressed: Monthly disbursement capacity stands at ₹300-350 crores against ~₹150 crores actual; management held back to test new processes and a revamped loan origination system before scaling.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 disbursements hit the ~₹750 crores consolidated target, the pace of AUM turning positive, and any concrete update on HFC value unlocking or promoter stake reduction.
Asset Quality & Provisioning
- Conservative March '22 recognition now unwinding: Management flagged that Stage 2 and Stage 3 recognition in March '22 financials was "very conservative," and ongoing provision reversals are the direct result. Collections against the ARC-sold pool give confidence of further write-backs in coming quarters.
- Gross Stage 3 trajectory: Consolidated Stage 3 fell from 6.4% to 3.6%; standalone gross Stage 3 dropped from ₹1,203 crores (13.6%) in March '22 to ₹537 crores (7.9%) in December '22. Stage 2 reduced from ₹1,770 crores to ₹991 crores over the same period.
- ONAN norms added ~₹45 crores to Stage 3: Net of the "Once an NPA always an NPA" implementation, Stage 3 would have been ~₹480-485 crores. Housing finance adopted ONAN from 1st October 2022, with gross Stage 3 still improving to 1.65% (from 1.8% in March '22).
- Percentage deterioration is a denominator effect: The reduction in the overall loan book (from ₹6,857 crores to ₹6,719 crores) mechanically pushed up asset quality ratios; it was not necessarily driven by fresh slippages.
- Collection efficiency at an all-time high: Gross collection efficiency reached 137% in Q3 (135% in Q2), with 9M at 152%; gross total collections of ₹937 crores in Q3, up 8% QoQ.
Karthikeyan Srinivasan: "Our first focus has been on stabilizing the asset quality, we do believe the problem is now behind us and we also continue to believe in the market opportunity."
AUM & Disbursement Dynamics
- AUM still contracting despite disbursement growth: Overall AUM declined 3% QoQ to ₹7,669 crores. Disbursements rose to ₹522 crores (from ₹334 crores QoQ), but collections and repayments outpaced new lending. Vehicle Finance AUM fell 4% QoQ to ₹3,469 crores for the same reason.
- Disbursement ramp plan is explicit: Management plans to scale parent CV disbursements from ~₹330 crores in Q3 to ~₹500 crores in Q4, with consolidated Q4 disbursement expected around ₹750 crores. The monthly run-rate target is to reach ₹300 crores gradually from the current ~₹150 crores.
- Infrastructure built for scale, growth held back deliberately: The company has capacity to deliver up to ₹350 crores of disbursement per month. Growth was conservative over the last three quarters to ensure processes, policies, and technology systems were relaid and tested before pressing the "growth paddle."
- Corporate book in runoff mode: Loan book down 2% QoQ to ₹1,218 crores; the ₹80 crores disbursed in Q3 were drawdowns against old sanctions, not fresh ones. The endeavor is to reduce corporate to less than 15% of AUM by end of FY24.
- SME book also shrinking, strategy shifting: AUM reduced from ₹1,541 crores to ₹1,432 crores on lower disbursements. The segment is being reoriented toward priority sector lending around the captive CV customer base, with smaller ticket sizes and working capital funding against property.
- Housing finance disbursements turning a corner: Disbursements increased 30% QoQ to ₹107 crores (vs ₹82 crores in Q2) after slow recent quarters; AUM grew 2% QoQ to ₹1,526 crores. Management has shifted focus back toward ramping disbursements alongside sustained asset quality.
Vinod Panicker: "Our infrastructure has the capability of delivering up to INR 350 crores of disbursement a month, we were conservative to ensure that the processes were well laid out and tested before we press the growth paddle."
Used CV Strategy & Market Opportunity
- Disbursement mix has swung decisively to used CV: ~90-95% of disbursements now go to used commercial vehicles in Tier 3 and Tier 4 markets, where yields are significantly better. This shift has driven the material NIM improvement this quarter.
- Market tailwind from scrappage policy: The used vehicle segment is expected to double by FY25, driven by the 15-year vehicle age limit under the scrappage policy. Organized sector share is expected to increase from a base where up to 60% of financing is currently unorganized.
- CV loan book growth target: Management expects the CV loan book to grow by at least 2x from the current base in the next couple of years, reaching around ₹5,000 crores by end of March 2024, implying roughly ₹3,500-4,000 crores of incremental disbursement.
- Tier 3/4 gap remains open: These markets are still not served completely by organized players, and Indostar sees an opportunity to fill that gap. The new digital process launched this quarter is designed to increase market presence and reach smaller geographies and rural markets.
- CV segment resilience argument: Management believes the consumption-linked nature of these vehicles provides a floor: even in a bad recession, the consumption segment typically does not decline too drastically.
- Sourcing is predominantly in-house: ~80% of CV sourcing comes through in-house relationship managers, with the balance from connectors (brokers) and customer referrals. Housing finance sourcing is ~75% in-house RMs and ~25% connectors.
Karthikeyan Srinivasan: "More importantly, with a small base, we can grow strongly over the coming many years at a much higher pace than the industry."
Profitability & Operating Metrics
- PAT surge masks operating income pressure: PAT rose 153% YoY to ₹37 crores (9M: 7.5x to ₹149 crores), but this was overwhelmingly driven by lower provisioning and provision reversals, not core operating performance.
- PPOP collapsed 59% YoY: Pre-provisioning operating profit fell to ₹25 crores in Q3 (9M: down 14% to ₹126 crores). The drivers: AUM drop leading to lower revenue, rising interest costs, lower disbursements causing idle funds and negative carry cost, and higher fixed cost from infrastructure built for ₹300-350 crores monthly disbursement capacity.
- Revenue and net total income declined: Consolidated revenue decreased 2% YoY to ₹282 crores; net total income fell 10% YoY to ₹147 crores due to lower AUM and higher interest costs. Finance cost rose 8% YoY to ₹135 crores, driven by rising interest rates.
- NIMs improved substantially: The shift to used CV in Tier 3/4 markets improved overall yields and spread. Cost of funds stood at 10.2% in Q3 and is expected to remain reasonably steady; management believes improving volumes and profitability will help convince lenders to reduce rates going forward.
- Opex rose ~20% YoY: The increase to ₹122 crores was mainly due to securitization costs, professional fees, and some increase in employee cost. Management expects rationalization and control in coming quarters.
- Employee headcount reduction reflects field-level churn: The bulk of employees are field-level relationship managers where high industry-wide churn exists; branch count has not been reduced, only rationalized. The current 423-branch infrastructure can handle 2.5x existing volumes.
Management, Process & Governance Reset
- CEO transition underway: Mr. Deep Jaggi stepped down due to personal reasons; the NRC and Board accepted his decision on February 14. New CEO Karthikeyan Srinivasan is now in place, with a stated focus on growth of the book and ensuring compliance.
- Significant senior management churn in CV business: There have been changes in senior management of the CV business over the last three quarters, alongside the broader process and technology overhaul.
- Process and technology overhaul executed: Over the last three quarters, the company relooked at all processes and policies; upgraded technology systems across loan origination, credit appraisal, disbursal, and collections; and strengthened controls. A new loan origination system with a business rule engine was implemented and tested before ramping up disbursements, designed to prevent past errors from recurring.
- Housing finance senior hires: Leading industry professionals were onboarded to manage key functions of finance, HR, and technology during the period.
- Funding milestone achieved: ₹683 crores raised in Q3, including a ₹400 crores NCD issuance fully subscribed by Tata Capital; past lenders are returning.
Karthikeyan Srinivasan: "We will focus on growth of our book and ensuring compliance, these are the 2 things which as CEO I want to take forward so that IndoStar becomes 1 of the top-performing NBFC."
Housing Finance & Value Unlocking
- Housing finance AUM target is ambitious: Management expects AUM to reach ₹3,500-4,000 crores by end of FY25, implying over 2.5x growth in the coming two years from the current ₹1,526 crores.
- Asset quality in housing remains clean: Gross Stage 3 improved to 1.65% (from 1.8% in March '22) despite ONAN adoption; net Stage 3 is close to 1.2%. The company has a clear line of sight on liquidity and a robust funding pipeline.
- Value unlocking under contemplation, no timeline: The Board is contemplating various options to unlock the housing finance subsidiary's value, but management declined to give any timeline, calling it "very difficult to predict."
- Promoter stake reduction is a separate workstream: Steps are being taken to adhere to the minimum public shareholding norm (reduce promoter stake to 75%); updates will be shared as progress is made. Management did not directly address whether Brookfield might reduce its stake below 51%.
Karthikeyan Srinivasan: "So while we continue to invest behind it, but at the same time, the Board is contemplating various options to unlock its value. And at this stage, there's nothing more to add beyond that whatever was already mentioned in the press release."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CV loan book growth | At least 2x from current base | "Next couple of years" |
| CV AUM target | Reach ~₹5,000 crores (implies ~₹3,500-4,000 crores of incremental disbursement) | End of March 2024 |
| Corporate book reduction | Less than 15% of AUM | End of FY24 |
| Housing finance AUM | ₹3,500-4,000 crores (over 2.5x growth) | End of FY25 |
| Q4 consolidated disbursement | ~₹750 crores (parent CV: ~₹500 crores) | Q4 FY23 |
| Monthly disbursement run-rate | Scale to ₹300 crores per month (from ~₹150 crores) | Gradual, no fixed date |
| Opex rationalization | Securitization costs, professional fees, employee cost to be controlled | "Quarters to come" |
| Promoter stake | Reduce to 75% to meet MPS norm | No timeline; updates to be shared as progress is made |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹282 cr, -2% YoY |
| Net total income | ₹147 cr, -10% YoY |
| Operating expenses | ₹122 cr, ~20% higher YoY, includes securitization costs and professional fees |
| Pre-provisioning operating profit | ₹25 cr, -59% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹37 cr, +153% YoY |
| Consolidated AUM | ₹7,669 cr, -3% QoQ from ₹7,908 cr |
| Retail AUM share | 84% of total AUM, at ₹6,143 cr |
| Disbursements | ₹522 cr, up from ₹334 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Gross collection efficiency | 137%, vs 135% in Q2 FY23; 9M FY23 at 152% |
| Gross Stage 3 (standalone) | 7.9%, down from 13.6% in March 2022; absolute ₹537 cr including ~₹45 cr ONAN impact |
| Consolidated Stage 3 | 3.6%, down from 6.4% as of 31 March 2022 |
| Stage 2 assets | ₹991 cr, down from peak of ₹1,770 cr in March 2022 |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 33%, vs regulatory requirement of 15% |
| Debt-to-equity ratio | 1.8x |
| Cost of funds | 10.2% for the quarter |
| Vehicle finance AUM | ₹3,469 cr, -4% QoQ |
| Housing finance AUM | ₹1,526 cr, +2% QoQ from ₹1,489 cr |
| Housing finance gross Stage 3 | 1.65%, improved from 1.8% in March 2022 |
| Housing finance capital adequacy | 86.5% |
| CV segment yield | ~18% |
| Infrastructure disbursement capability | up to ₹350 cr per month |
| Q4 FY23 disbursement target | ~₹750 cr consolidated |
| CV AUM target by March 2024 | ~₹5,000 cr |
| Housing finance AUM target by FY25 | ₹3,500–4,000 cr |