Key Takeaways
- A 10-year MSA renewal locks in the base, at a price: Both major customers renewed the bulk of co-locations expiring through March 2023, securing a decade of revenue visibility. The trade-off is a marginal quarterly revenue reduction from revised rates, which management expects 5G loading to offset within 12–18 months.
- One customer’s distress forced a ₹1,230 crore provision: A delay in payments beyond the threshold period triggered a large doubtful-debt provision, masking an otherwise stable quarter where adjusted EBITDA was roughly flat QoQ. The provision is a prudent accounting move, not a write-off, but the underlying receivable continues to age.
- 5G is imminent and loading looks richer than 4G: Spectrum auctions concluded with active bidding, and management expects large-scale rollout on existing sites to begin in weeks. Average per-site loading is expected to exceed 4G levels for at least the first year of the massive deployment.
- The receivable overhang will get worse before it gets better: The customer’s proposed plan pays only part of monthly dues through December 2022, so the overdue balance will rise for a couple more months. If the situation deteriorates further, more provisions may follow.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the customer’s new payment plan is finalized on better terms, the actual pace of 5G equipment loading as rollouts begin, and any further provisioning against the aging receivable.
The MSA Renewal: A Decade of Visibility at a Discount
- What was agreed: A revised framework with both major customers renews the majority of co-locations expiring between March 2022 and March 2023. The renewal extends tenure by 10 years, with annual escalation unchanged at ~2.5% and loading charges intact.
- The price concession: Revised rates will cause a marginal reduction in quarterly Ind-AS 116 revenue. Management declined to quantify the billing-basis impact, citing customer confidentiality.
- The 9% exit option: Customers can exit up to 9% of sites without penalty, but management expects the actual number to be much lower, possibly 1% or sub-1%. Colour will come in future quarters.
- The offset thesis: Incremental revenue from 5G rollouts, future network solutions, and leaner towers is expected to absorb the discount. Management believes the 5G revenue lift will let the company “swallow” the MSA impact within a year to a year-and-a-half, leaving 7–7.5 years of growth with the 2.5% escalator.
- Future renewals: The same MSA framework will apply to tenancies coming up for renewal in subsequent years. The bulk of those renewals will be behind the company in the current and coming fiscal year.
Dayal: “I do believe that we have under the circumstances a great deal in which we have secured this for another 10 years. For an infrastructure business like this I think it is sealed for a good period of time.”
The Receivable Problem: One Customer, a Big Provision, and a Fragile Plan
- The provision: A ₹1,230 crore provision for doubtful debts was booked in Q1 because receivables from one customer crossed the overdue threshold. The policy is stringent: provision when aging exceeds the limit, reversal only when cash is collected.
- The underlying trend: Adjusted for the provision, trade receivables actually rose ₹420 crore due to a payment shortfall from that same customer. Monthly collections from the customer have been running at roughly 50–60% of billed dues in recent months, excluding security monetization money.
- The proposed plan: The customer has offered to pay part of the billed amount through December 2022, then 100% thereafter, with clearance of accumulated old dues phased between January 2023 and July 2023. Management is engaged at senior and Board level to negotiate a better plan.
- The near-term trajectory: If the current part-payment pattern holds, the overdue balance will rise for a couple more months. Management warned that if receivables worsen, it may need to provide more to keep managing the risk.
- The customer’s lifeline: The customer has a funding plan under discussion with lenders and is waiting for a government-related equity conversion that has still not happened. That conversion will have a huge bearing on its cash flows and ability to invest.
- Other customers: No major receivables issues exist beyond one non-JV customer with some old dues that are not material.
Poddar: “The customer has proposed a payment plan wherein they have conveyed the ability to pay part of the billed amount till December 2022 and 100% thereafter along with clearance in a phased manner between January 2023 and July 2023 of the old dues that would accumulate till December 2022.”
5G: The Loading Opportunity Is About to Begin
- Rollout timing: Large-scale 5G deployment on existing sites is expected to start almost in weeks from the call date, following the conclusion of spectrum auctions with active participation from at least two telcos across the 3.3 GHz and 26 GHz bands.
- Loading economics: Average per-site loading for 5G is expected to be higher than what was realized on 4G, at least for the first year of the massive rollout. The major loading will come from power requirements and antennas. Actual per-site loading will vary by customer and equipment type.
- The two-phase trajectory: The first 12–18 months will see massive broadband proliferation of 5G on existing sites. After that, the ultra-low-latency network will emerge, occupying street furniture much more and making tower companies even more relevant.
- Leaner towers: Demand for leaner towers continues to show strong traction and is expected to increase further with the imminent 5G rollout. These towers provide a limited loading opportunity and are not money-losing ventures, unlike historical single-tenant sites.
Dayal: “On an average we have seen that this is higher now what will the customers do to optimize this will actually happen when this rollout begins. In our trials this is what it is right now.”
Quarterly Performance: The Provision Obscures a Steady Core
- Revenue: Reported gross and core revenues fell QoQ mainly because the prior quarter included a ~₹550 crore provision reversal. After adjusting for that, gross revenue rose 3.4% QoQ while core revenue dipped 0.8% QoQ. Both QoQ and YoY numbers were also pressured by co-location renewals at competitive rates.
- EBITDA: Reported EBITDA declined sharply on the ₹1,230 crore provision. Adjusted EBITDA was up 2.9% YoY and down 0.8% QoQ.
- Energy margins: Remained negative, with Q1 hit by seasonal diesel consumption, partly offset by lower provisions from the annual revision in estimates.
- Net additions: Were impacted by higher co-location churn at 733.
- Free cash flow: Was pressured by the delay in payments from the one major customer.
Capital Allocation & ESG
- Dividend policy: Unchanged and linked to cash flow; management said it would be happy to distribute excess cash flow.
- ESG targets: Have been finalized across all dimensions and the company plans to announce them in coming quarters.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 5G large-scale rollout | Rollout on existing sites to begin; average loading higher than 4G for at least the first year | “Almost in weeks’ time” from call date |
| MSA renewal impact offset | Incremental 5G and other revenue to absorb the marginal quarterly revenue reduction | Within 12–18 months |
| Customer payment plan | Customer proposes part payment of monthly dues till Dec 2022, then 100% plus phased clearance of old dues | Jan 2023–Jul 2023 (proposed by customer; under negotiation) |
| Receivable trajectory | Overdue balance expected to rise for a couple more months if current part-payment pattern holds | Next few months |
| Further provisioning | Company will assess and may take a more stringent position if accounts receivable risk develops | Ongoing, no fixed date |
| 9% exit option actual impact | Expected to be much lower than 9%, possibly 1% or sub-1% | Colour to be shared in coming quarters |
| ESG targets announcement | Targets finalized; announcement planned | Coming quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Reported revenue | ₹6,900 cr, up 1.5% YoY; down 3.1% QoQ |
| Core rental revenue | ₹4,220 cr, up 0.3% YoY; down 11.0% QoQ |
| Core rental revenue (adjusted for exit revenue) | Up 2.2% YoY |
| Reported EBITDA | ₹2,320 cr, down 34.2% YoY and 42.9% QoQ |
| EBITDA margin | 33.7%, down 18.2 ppt YoY and 23.5 ppt QoQ |
| EBITDA (adjusted for exit revenue, provision for doubtful debts, and provision reversal) | Up 2.9% YoY; down 0.8% QoQ |
| Reported profit after tax | ₹480 cr, down 66.3% YoY and 73.9% QoQ |
| Profit after tax (adjusted for exit revenue, provision for doubtful debts, and provision reversal) | Up 2.9% YoY; down 4.7% QoQ |
| Provision for doubtful debts | ₹1,230 cr increase in the quarter, due to delay in payments from a customer |
| Cash flow from operating activities | ₹1,870 cr, compared to ₹1,960 cr in Q1 FY22 |
| Free cash flow | ₹550 cr, impacted by delay in payments from one major customer |
| Pre-tax return on capital employed (past 12 months) | 22.0% |
| Post-tax return on equity (past 12 months) | 29.5% |
| Total towers | 186,474, up 3.0% YoY and 0.6% QoQ |
| Total co-locations | 336,382, up 3.4% YoY and 0.2% QoQ |
| Net tower additions | 1,027 (excludes lean towers) |
| Net co-location additions | 591 (excludes lean tower co-locations) |
| Co-location churn | 733 |
| Leaner towers added | ~1,021 |
| MSA renewal discount impact | ~₹500 per tenancy on average, translating to ~₹900 per tower (on Ind-AS 116 basis) |
| Payment collection rate from stressed customer (recent months, excluding security monetization) | Roughly 50% to 60% of monthly dues |