Key Takeaways
- A quarter of two halves: Reported revenue grew 15.9% YoY and PAT fell 44.1% YoY, but both were distorted by a ₹1,770 crore provision for doubtful debts and ₹1,100 crore in deferred revenue recognition. Adjusted for these, core revenue grew 3.5% YoY and EBITDA grew 1.1% YoY.
- The customer problem is now on a payment plan: The primary customer agreed to pay a substantial part of monthly billing through December 2022 and 100% thereafter, with all accumulated overdue cleared by July 2023. The security previously held has been fully monetized and is no longer available as a backstop.
- 5G loading begins, standalone sites are distant: Initial 5G revenue from loading equipment on existing sites is expected to build from next quarter, with rental loading revenue contributing 5% to 10% of average revenue over time. Standalone 5G sites are not expected for about 18 months.
- Deferred recognition has run its course: The ₹1,100 crore boost to reported revenue from past settlements is now fully recognized and all related payments have been collected. Average revenue per tenancy should normalize going forward, offset by 5G loading growth.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the payment plan holds and receivables peak by December 2022 as guided, the pace of 5G loading revenue, and whether provisioning needs to become more stringent again if collections stall.
The Customer Receivable Situation
- A payment plan is in place: The customer agreed to pay a substantial part of monthly billing through December 2022, then 100% of monthly billing from January 2023 plus clearance of all accumulated outstanding dues as of December 31, 2022 over seven months through July 2023.
- Past issues settled, security exhausted: ₹1,100 crore was collected in Q2 toward past dues, and deferred revenue was recognized upon full collection. The primary pledge and security previously held, approximately ₹3,700 crore monetized in March plus additional funds in July, is now completely gone and no longer available.
- Provisioning is a moving target: The ₹1,770 crore Q2 provision appears optically large, but ₹1,100 crore of collections in the quarter were toward settlement of past issues. Had those collections been applied to current receivables, the provision would have been approximately ₹670 crore. Management will reassess in Q3 and may adopt a more stringent ECL approach if the payment plan is not progressing as expected, though significant provisions already taken provide a "very significant hedge" on the balance sheet.
- Receivables peak expected by December: Adjusted receivables increased by ₹940 crore in Q2 due to collection challenges from the one customer. Management expects receivables to peak out by December 2022 and then only decrease, based on the payment plan.
- No write-offs currently expected: The payment plan envisages collection of full dues, and management is not currently expecting any write-offs.
- Customer-specific details withheld: Management declined to disclose the original total receivable before the Q1 write-off, the outstanding after Q2 provision, total receivable position still outstanding, ageing, or the percentage of revenue contributed by the customer, citing inability to share customer-wise information.
- Convertible debentures not on the table: Management has not considered accepting convertible debentures as a payment option, unlike what the customer offered to another tower company, and wants to see the existing payment plan materialize first.
- Confidence rests on external signals, not specifics: Management cited the reforms package, government support, the customer's participation in 5G auctions, and indications that the customer is working on a funding plan and is close to finalizing it, but provided no specific financial assurance or details on that funding plan.
Poddar: "We have not really considered this as an option. We already have payment plan agreed with the customer which we have already shared. So, we would really want to see that payment plan materializing and so far we have not really considered any option of convertible debentures."
5G Rollout: Loading Now, Sites Later
- Loading revenue starts next quarter: Initial 5G revenue will come from loading 5G equipment on existing sites as orders are received and RFAIs are underway. Positive revenue development is expected in the next quarter as loading builds.
- Standalone sites are 18 months out: Standalone 5G sites are expected only after about a year and a half, once data traffic builds and capacity expansion is needed.
- Coverage path mirrors 4G: Over an 18-month window, operators may cover approximately 50% to 60% of sites with 5G, based on initial understanding, with operators still finalizing plans. Over a longer period, 5G will cover 100% of operator sites, similar to the 4G rollout pattern.
- Loading revenue premium over 4G: Rental loading revenue from 5G is expected to be 5% to 10% of average revenue over time, higher than 4G loading revenue because of higher power load on sites and additional antenna loading, especially for 700 MHz which requires separate antennas.
- Capex requirement is incremental, not transformational: Some sites may need electrical infrastructure upgrades or additional mounts to host 5G equipment, particularly where capacity is already at the edge. Investment will be an averaged-out cost across towers.
Kalra: "We see a positive development on our revenue in the next quarter once the loading builds up on these existing sites and then after about a year and a half or so some more standalone 5G sites coming up as well."
Revenue Quality: Deferred Recognition Distorts the Quarter
- Reported growth was inflated: Reported revenues grew 15.9% YoY to ₹7,970 crore because of a deferred recognition impact of ₹1,100 crore on gross revenues and ₹550 crore on core revenues. Adjusted for exit revenue tapering and deferred recognition, gross revenue grew 2.1% YoY and core revenue grew 3.5% YoY.
- Deferred recognition has ended: The jump in average revenue per tenancy to ₹47,000 was overstated due to deferred recognition. That deferred recognition has "pretty much come to an end" and all payments pertaining to those settlements have been received. Going forward, average revenue should return to more normal levels.
- Renewal discount already baked in: Average revenue per tenancy already reflects a renewal discount of approximately ₹500 per tenancy agreed with customers.
- Future renewals benchmarked: The renewal agreement already reached serves as a benchmark for all future renewals, and no major change is expected. Future renewals will be on similar lines.
- Energy margin benefited from a one-time tailwind: Energy margin in Q2 was "very positive" because of the deferred recognition of ₹550 crore in past energy dues, which had no corresponding cost in the quarter. Large lump-sum recognitions like this are not expected to recur, though some reversals and recognitions will keep happening due to ongoing expected-vs-actual gaps in the diesel world, but not in such large quantums.
Poddar: "This renewal discussion and agreement that we have reached is a very good reference point, is a very good sort of benchmark for all future renewals, and we do not expect any major change to happen."
Tower Additions and the Lean Tower Opportunity
- Macro additions healthy: Net addition of 1,452 macro towers and 1,746 co-locations in Q2. Tenancy ratio was largely flattish at 1.80.
- Lean towers accelerating: Lean tower co-location additions rose to 1,535 in Q2 from 1,021 in Q1, driven by rising densification requirements. The cumulative base is now 3,000+. Lean towers are a small segment, not included in reported macro tower counts, and are expected to grow "much faster in the coming quarters."
- Densification is the structural driver: Constantly growing demand for data and upgradation to 4G and 5G should continue to drive demand for capacity addition through both loading and new sites. Demand for leaner structures is expected to grow further with increasing densification requirements.
Margins, Cash Flow and the Balance Sheet
- Adjusted EBITDA flat, reported down sharply: Reported EBITDA declined 22.7% YoY to ₹2,810 crore because of the ₹1,770 crore provision for doubtful debts, partially offset by the ₹1,100 crore settlement payment. Adjusted EBITDA was up 1.1% YoY.
- Free cash flow turned negative: FCF was ₹-470 crore because of collection challenges and higher capex cash flows during the quarter.
- Energy margin is structurally volatile: Energy margin fluctuates because of gaps between actual cost incurred and expected cost, driven by seasonality, weather disturbances, high diesel consumption during grid outages, and timing differences in electricity bills. These gaps cause reconciliation challenges with customers and get ironed out over time. Continued focus on reducing diesel consumption through diesel replacement solutions and improving grid EB availability is expected to help bring energy margin under control.
- NCD issuance for compliance, not distress: The Board approved a ₹2,000 crore NCD issuance to comply with the regulator requirement for large corporates to raise a minimum 25% of incremental long-term borrowing via debt securities. This applies on a block of two years starting FY22, and FY23 is the second year of compliance. Funds will be used toward investment in growth and capex as rollout activities pick up.
- Dividend policy unchanged: Dividend is linked to free cash flow and will be assessed at year-end. Management is fully committed to the policy.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Receivables peak | Receivables should peak out and then only decrease, based on the payment plan | By December 2022 |
| Customer overdue clearance | 100% of monthly billing plus clearance of all accumulated outstanding dues as of Dec 31, 2022 | January 2023 to July 2023 |
| 5G loading revenue | Positive revenue development from loading 5G equipment on existing sites | Next quarter (Q3 FY23) |
| Standalone 5G sites | New standalone 5G sites to begin coming up | After about 18 months |
| 5G site coverage | Operators may cover 50% to 60% of sites with 5G | Over an 18-month window |
| Provisioning reassessment | May adopt a more stringent ECL approach if payment plan is not progressing as expected | Q3 FY23 assessment |
| Average revenue normalization | Average revenue per tenancy to return to more normal levels as deferred recognition has ended, offset by 5G loading growth | Going forward |
| Future renewals | No major change expected; the reached agreement serves as a benchmark | All future renewals |
| NCD funds usage | Funds to be used toward investment in growth and capex | As rollout activities pick up |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Reported revenue | ₹7,970 cr, +15.9% YoY and +15.5% QoQ |
| Core rental revenue | ₹4,780 cr, +12.5% YoY and +13.3% QoQ |
| Adjusted gross revenue growth | +2.1% YoY, +1.4% QoQ (excl. exit revenue and deferred recognition) |
| Adjusted core revenue growth | +3.5% YoY, +2.3% QoQ (excl. exit revenue and deferred recognition) |
| Reported EBITDA | ₹2,810 cr, -22.7% YoY and -21.1% QoQ |
| Reported EBITDA margin | 35.3%, -17.6 ppt YoY and +1.6 ppt QoQ |
| Adjusted EBITDA growth | +1.1% YoY, +2.1% QoQ (excl. one-off items) |
| Reported PAT | ₹870 cr, -44.1% YoY and +82.7% QoQ |
| Adjusted PAT growth | -3.5% YoY, +6.4% QoQ (excl. one-off items) |
| Provision for doubtful debts | ₹1,770 cr in Q2; ₹1,100 cr of collections were toward past settlements, implying ~₹670 cr toward current receivables |
| Energy margin | 14.6% |
| Operating cash flow | ₹1,120 cr, vs ₹1,940 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| Free cash flow | ₹-470 cr, impacted by collection challenges and higher capex |
| Pre-tax ROCE (trailing 12 months) | 19.2%, lower YoY and QoQ |
| Post-tax ROE (trailing 12 months) | 24.2%, lower YoY and QoQ |
| Trade receivables increase (adjusted) | ₹940 cr (adjusted for provision and past-issue settlement receipts); reported increase ₹250 cr |
| Net macro tower additions | 1,452 |
| Net macro co-location additions | 1,746 |
| Total macro towers | 187,926, +2.4% YoY |
| Total macro co-locations | 338,128, +1.7% YoY |
| Tenancy ratio | 1.80, largely flattish |
| Leaner tower co-location additions | 1,535 in Q2, vs 1,021 in Q1 |
| Cumulative leaner tower base | ~3,000 or slightly over 3,000 |
| Average revenue per tenancy (adjusted) | ~₹41,500 for the past two quarters, after adjusting for one-time revenue (per an analyst's math) |
| Renewal discount baked into revenue | ~₹500 per tenancy from overall portfolio perspective |
| 5G loading revenue expectation | 5% to 10% of average rental revenue over time |
| Global 5G subscriptions | 69 cr in June quarter, expected ~440 cr by end-2027 |
| India 5G penetration estimate by 2027 | 40%, about 50 cr subscriptions |
| India average data consumption per user per month | >19 GB, +19% YoY; expected to rise to 40–50 GB in next 5 years |