Key Takeaways
- Collections drove a provision write-back, not operations: Reported EBITDA jumped 42% YoY, but adjusted for the ₹1,080 crore doubtful debt write-back, EBITDA grew only 6.9% YoY. The underlying business added towers and tenancies at a slower pace than Q1.
- The second customer is finally paying: Over ₹2,300 crore collected against past overdue in 12 months, with 100% monthly billing collection sustained. The remaining provision stands at ~₹3,500 crore, and management is pushing for faster clearance.
- Tower additions slowed, but the pipeline is broadening: 3,748 macro towers added vs 6,832 collocations in Q1, partly due to severe weather. Incremental tenancies from other major customers and 4G-to-5G loading are expected to supplement growth as the largest customer's 5G blitz normalizes.
- Energy margins are a seasonal drag with a promised H2 rebound: Heavy monsoons hit Q1 and Q2; management expects recovery in Q3 and Q4, supported by solar additions crossing 25,000 sites and ongoing indoor-to-outdoor conversions.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Vodafone Idea's active equipment rollout begins by mid-to-end Q3 as indicated, the pace of past-overdue collections, and the actual recovery in energy margins.
The Vodafone Idea Overdue: Progress and Residual Risk
- Collections turned a corner: The company collected more than ₹2,300 crore against past overdue in the last 12 months and sustained 100% collection against monthly billing from the major customer. This triggered the ₹1,080 crore provision write-back that flattered reported EBITDA.
- The remaining exposure is still material: Provision for doubtful debt now stands at about ₹3,500 crore. Trade receivables decreased by only ₹90 crore despite the large collection, indicating the gross overdue remains substantial.
- No timeline commitment for full clearance: Management is in constant discussions and wants the overdue paid "as fast as possible," but declined to give any look-ahead on whether the AGR verdict changes the payment trajectory from quarterly instalments to a lump sum.
- Net finance cost is hostage to this: Finance income from interest collected on the overdue makes net finance cost unpredictable; gross finance cost is stable, but the income side swings with collections.
Vikas Poddar: "…it is very difficult to predict because the net finance cost is also dependent on the finance income which is nothing but the interest that we collect on the overdue right."
Growth Drivers: Loading, New Sites, and a Broadening Customer Mix
- Loading is the near-term engine: Core rental revenues grew 8.5% YoY to ₹4,710 crore, driven by collocation additions and loading. 4G-to-5G loading and 2G-to-4G conversions have started to materialize, with momentum expected to pick up in coming quarters.
- New site demand is the next leg: Management expects loading revenues to be gradually supplemented by demand for new sites once a certain penetration level is achieved to aid network decongestion. Tower and tenancy growth momentum is expected to continue.
- The customer base is diversifying: Incremental tenancies are anticipated from other major customers in the near term, acting as a fillip to growth. Colocation additions from customers beyond the largest one are starting to show and momentum is expected to pick up.
- Vodafone Idea's active equipment deal is a pending catalyst: The USD 3.6 billion vendor deal contributed nothing in Q2. Tenancy is expected to start showing up when equipment comes on board, with indications of rollout starting mid-to-end of Q3 FY25.
- 5G from the largest customer is normalizing, not stopping: Additions will not be at the speed of the last 1–1.5 years, but some orders continue to come. FY2024 growth is not repeatable every year, yet rollouts this year remain on the higher side historically.
- In-building and small cell solutions are expected to grow as the telecom infrastructure landscape evolves, though no quantification was offered.
Prachur Sah: "Sanjesh, it is hard to predict. Of course, the amount of growth we have seen in FY2024 is not going to be repeated every year. However, if you look at rollouts that have happened this year, they still remain on the higher side than what we have done in the past and looking at order book, I believe we will continue this momentum."
Market Share and Competitive Positioning
- Incumbency is the moat: Management asserts Indus remains in the prime position to capture majority market share from VIL and BSNL rollouts because of its strong tower rollout history and the availability of second and third tenancy at existing towers.
- No visible competitive disruption from industry consolidation: When asked whether the consolidation of the number two and number three player had changed rental terms or triggered tenancy migration, management said they have seen no such thing.
- Renewal discounts are steady and not lumpy: A bulk renewal happened in FY2022; there has been no major lumpy renewal in the last two financial years. Discount levels on renewals are very similar to what was worked out then and are not very significant.
- Commercial competitiveness is asserted, not detailed: Management declined to discuss whether bulk discounts or competition would affect new VIL tenancies, stating only that Indus remains competitive both commercially and operationally.
Prachur Sah: "I cannot give you a number Sanjesh. However as I mentioned earlier because of the rollouts that we have done in the last one and a half years and we have a significant amount of tower rollouts done, we remain in the prime position in terms of the second tenancy and third tenancy being available at the towers so from an availability point of view, we remain in the prime position so we will continue to make sure that tower operation performance keeps us in the pole position to get the majority market share."
Margins: The Real Operating Picture
- The headline margin is distorted: Reported EBITDA margin of 65.7% includes the ₹1,080 crore provision write-back. Adjusted for this, EBITDA grew only 1.2% QoQ, and the underlying margin is materially lower than the reported figure.
- Energy margins are a seasonal headwind: Q1 and Q2 were impacted by heavy rainfall and monsoons. Management expects recovery in Q3 and Q4, supported by ongoing cost efficiency initiatives.
- Cost efficiency levers are in motion: Diesel consumption reduced 2% YoY, though weather disruptions limited the reduction. Solar site count exceeded 25,000 with quarterly additions close to 4,000. Conversion of sites from indoor to outdoor and electrification of non-electrified sites continued.
- ARPT is stable with offsetting forces: Upside from 4G-to-5G loading and annual escalation is offset by mix effect from new low-capex towers with lower ARPT than the legacy portfolio, and renewal discounts. A second tenant increases average revenue per tower but per-tenancy ARPT should be stable or slightly declining because the new tenant may not come with the same load.
- Maintenance capex is stable year-on-year with no lumpiness, reported as a separate line in the investor pack.
Capital Allocation: Buyback Done, Dividend Later
- Buyback completed: 5.68 crore shares bought back at ₹465 per share. Post buyback, Bharti Airtel's shareholding increased to more than 50%.
- Free cash flow was strong: ₹1,440 crore in Q2, aided by higher collections and lower capex.
- Dividend decision deferred to year-end: The company has a clear policy to distribute free cash flow, but free cash generated in H1 was already used for the buyback. The Board will take a call at the end of the year in line with policy.
Regulatory and Contingent Liabilities
- GST show-cause notice received: Questions GST credit on passive infrastructure assets including diesel generators, AC, and battery banks. Management believes the liability is remote and the matter is sub-judice, disclosed only due to the large number involved.
- Favorable regulatory developments: DoT notified the Bharat Nidhi Rules 2024 enabling the Digital Bharat Nidhi fund. Right of Way Rules 2024 were notified under the Telecommunication Act 2023. The Green Open Access Policy has been adopted by more than 21 states.
Prachur Sah: "…based on our assessment, we believe that the liability currently is not evolving on the company, and we consider this as remote."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Energy margin recovery | Improvement expected in later part of the year after seasonal Q1/Q2 drag | Q3 and Q4 FY25 |
| Vodafone Idea active equipment tenancy | Rollout indications point to start; tenancy shows up when equipment comes on board | Mid-to-end of Q3 FY25 |
| Colocation additions from other customers | Momentum expected to pick up | Coming quarters |
| 4G-to-5G and 2G-to-4G loading | Has started to materialize; momentum expected to pick up | Coming quarters |
| Tower and tenancy growth momentum | Expected to continue based on order book | Near to medium term |
| Past overdue collection | Engaged with customer to get overdue paid as fast as possible; no quantified timeline | As quick as possible |
| Dividend distribution | Board will take call at end of year in line with policy to distribute free cash flow | End of FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹7,470 cr, +4.7% YoY and +1.1% QoQ |
| Core rental revenue | ₹4,710 cr, +8.5% YoY and +1.5% QoQ |
| Reported EBITDA | ₹4,910 cr, +42% YoY and +8% QoQ |
| Reported EBITDA margin | 65.7%, +17.3 ppt YoY and +4.2 ppt QoQ |
| Adjusted EBITDA growth (ex-provision write-back) | +6.9% YoY and +1.2% QoQ |
| Provision write-back of doubtful debt | ₹1,080 cr |
| Reported profit after tax | ₹2,220 cr, +71.8% YoY and +15.5% QoQ |
| Adjusted PAT growth (ex-provision write-back) | +13.8% YoY and +4.6% QoQ |
| Pre-tax return on capital employed (rolling 12 months) | 22.9% |
| Post-tax return on equity (rolling 12 months) | 29.0% |
| Free cash flow | ₹1,440 cr |
| Trade receivables | Decreased by ₹90 cr |
| Past overdue collected from major customer (last 12 months) | More than ₹2,300 cr |
| Provision for doubtful debt | Reduced to about ₹3,500 cr |
| Macro towers added | 3,748 |
| Net co-location additions (including leaner towers) | 4,490 vs 6,832 in Q1 |
| Total macro towers base | 229,658, +12.5% YoY |
| Total collocations base | 379,236, +7.3% YoY |
| Tenancy ratio | 1.65 |
| PAN-India uptime | 99.96% |
| Diesel consumption reduction | 2% YoY |
| Solar site count | More than 25,000, quarterly additions close to 4,000 |
| Gender diversity | 14.3% vs 11.2% in Q1 |
| Maintenance capex | ₹290 cr |
| Buyback completed | 5.68 cr shares at ₹465 per share; Bharti Airtel shareholding increased to more than 50% |