Key Takeaways
- A self-confessed disappointing quarter: Revenue missed by $6 million, EBITDA margin halved from 26% to 16%, and the Chairman acknowledged investor disappointment, attributing the miss to platform-transition accounting and last-minute deal slippage.
- The platform transition is compressing reported growth: Platform revenue now 62% of LTM revenue, but its deferred recognition model and shrinking implementation cycles are structurally suppressing near-term license and services revenue.
- Pipeline and deal quality are the bull case: Pipeline grew 36% YoY to ₹6,500 cr, measured against the corresponding quarter last year, 9 of 14 wins were platform deals, and the company is now in the last three stages of four large European core banking deals, competing head-to-head with Thought Machine and Temenos.
- Costs are rising faster than revenue, with no quick fix: Talent costs are inflating via quarterly increments, the tax rate jumped from 16% to 26%, and management expects costs to keep rising even as it acknowledges a market slowdown.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the $3.1 million in deals closed but not contracted convert to revenue, any movement on the four European core banking pursuits, and if the full-year 20% rupee growth and 20%+ EBITDA margin commitments hold.
The Q2 Miss: Platform Transition Meets Market Slowdown
- Revenue slipped on two fronts: $2.9 million of platform deal wins had near-zero accounting recognition because platform revenue is recognized over time, not upfront, and $3.1 million from two license deals were closed but not contracted before the 30 September auditor cutoff.
- License revenue dropped sharply: Q2 license revenue fell from ₹86 cr to ₹68 cr YoY, driven by the structural shift from license to platform deals and last-minute deal closure delays caused by high inflation and elongated decision cycles.
- Platform subscription revenue stayed flat despite signing 9 platform deals because revenue starts flowing only 3 to 6 months after booking, when the customer begins consuming the platform.
- Implementation revenue is structurally shrinking: iTurmeric is reducing implementation cycle times, shifting deal composition from 50-50 license-to-implementation toward 65 to 70% license and 30% implementation, compressing services revenue.
- The company is not immune to the slowdown: Management acknowledged it is "passively sitting in the same island of technology companies where some slowdown is happening," with high inflation in Europe and low growth indexes weighing on technology spending.
- Decision cycles are lengthening for two reasons: the broader market environment is causing delays, and cloud technology availability means clients now demand proof-of-concept with real-time scenarios, adding 3 to 6 months to the sales cycle after boardroom evaluation.
- Competitive shift adds timeline pressure: The company has moved into the "big boy category," competing with Temenos and Thought Machine for large destiny deals spanning multiple countries and product lines, which have inherently longer win timelines than earlier deals against smaller competitors.
Arun Jain: "Looking at the quarterly numbers, and you look at it, I feel that a lot of investors on the street would be disappointed. I acknowledge that disappointment based on the numbers which are there."
Platform Transition: The Accounting Drag on Growth
- Platform revenue now dominates the mix: LTM platform revenue grew to 62% of revenue (₹276 cr to ₹448 cr), driven by the strategic shift from products to platforms articulated at Technology Days 2021.
- ARR is the forward indicator: LTM ARR grew 35% to ₹792 cr, and Q2 ARR grew 22%, driven by platform and AMC revenue streams, providing visibility into future revenue as platform deals convert to subscription streams over 3 to 6 months.
- Dollar growth is structurally lower during the transition: Management stated that 20% dollar growth may not be the right number to look at over a 2 to 3 year horizon because the platform transition could make growth structurally slower during the shift.
- Unbilled revenue is rising because contextual payment deals book a 5-year deal on signing date per accounting principles but contracted payments are annual, and more customers are moving to outcome-based deliveries with milestone payments linked to UAT sign-off or business go-live.
- Implementation cycle compression is a double-edged sword: It improves customer time-to-value and competitive positioning but reduces the services revenue stream that previously accompanied license deals.
Arun Jain: "We consistently communicated that as a heavily focused license revenue company which is adding a portfolio of platforms, it may result in too few quarters where we will not be sure of the final number..."
Deal Wins & Pipeline: The "Wide Window" Thesis
- Pipeline grew 36% YoY to ₹6,500 cr, with more deals in higher value tiers (over ₹50 cr) and advanced-stage evaluation or negotiation in several of these deals.
- 9 of 14 Q2 wins were platform deals, including marquee logos: the largest sovereign wealth fund in Europe for iESG, a top-3 UK bank for payments, a Canadian bank for payments, a top-3 UAE bank for mobility upgrade, a digital core win in Africa, a US insurance client for underwriting, Saudi Arabia for cash cloud and debt management, and Egypt for lifestyle banking.
- Four large core banking deals in Europe: Intellect is in the last three stages (shortlisted) in four deals, competing with Thought Machine and another competitor; no deal won yet, and management is "cautiously optimistic" but has no timeline.
- Three "wide window" growth vectors are performing simultaneously: Intellect AI (iESG, data, underwriting platforms) with near-zero current revenue but lead-indicator wins; Intellect Digital Core competing head-to-head with Thought Machine and Temenos; and Consumerization of Corporate Banking with 25+ leads generated in a 3-day event.
- The iESG win is a lead indicator, not a revenue event: Winning the largest sovereign wealth fund in Europe for AI-driven ESG assessment against American and European competition generated zero revenue for the quarter but signals platform competitiveness.
- 14 digital transformations went live in Q2, with accelerators (iTurmeric, Canvas) delivering 25 to 40% faster go-live cycles.
- 20 accounts identified for cross-selling digital transformation using composable and contextual technology.
Arun Jain: "We are calling this as a wide window moment internally... It very rarely happens when companies are able to present something in December 2021 and what the market is looking for is what we presented that time."
Margins & Costs: Pressure Without a Quick Reversal
- EBITDA margin halved: Q2 EBITDA dropped 29% YoY, margin fell from 26% to 16%, because of the revenue shortfall, talent costs rising more than anticipated, and the tax rate moving from 16% to 26%.
- Gross margin declined from 58% to 52% because revenue growth of 17% outpaced gross margin growth of only 5%.
- Talent costs will keep rising: The company does quarterly (not annual) salary increments, so talent costs will continue to rise; a $2 to 3 million cost increase is visible for the next two quarters due to Q1 and Q2 salary raises flowing through.
- Total cost structure reached ₹443 crore and may go up by ₹0.2 to 0.3 crore per quarter for new talent, platform, DTM, and POC costs; Q3 will have additional marketing costs up to ₹3 crore for Sibos and other events.
- Operating cash flow halved from ₹94 crore in H1 last year to ₹45 crore in H1 this year, primarily because of a higher bonus payout (due to ~27% growth last year), higher salary costs, and increased travel costs.
- DSO increased by ~13 days in H1, attributed to quarter-to-quarter fluctuation in a product business; management expects normalization to the 115 to 125 day sustainable range with advance payments, large deal payments, and project closures.
- Pre-sale investment is expensed, not capitalized: SNM cost (~₹150 cr this quarter, annualized ~₹600 cr) embeds pre-sale investment and flows through the P&L.
- Management declined to commit on whether 16 to 17% EBITDA margin should be considered the new base, saying only that full-year will be 20% plus and that they "can't commit right now."
Management: "It's difficult give me an exact number, but it will 20% Plus for the full year."
Competitive Positioning: Rubbing Shoulders in Core Banking
- Now competing in the top tier: Management stated Intellect is "rubbing shoulders with Thought Machine" and Temenos on architecture, APIs, microservices, and cloud, while competing with the largest player on depth of product functionality.
- Targeting the $16 billion core banking market, participating in 8+ deals in Europe, with pipeline running into double-digit million-dollar license numbers.
- Incremental platform investment is lean: Less than $3 million per platform in the last 6 months to compose new platforms; iESG was built within 6 months.
- Data platform launched in the US for insurance: End-to-end commercial lines insurance platform running fully on AWS, 100% subscription business, including risk analyst product, magic submission platform, and iRT (API platform extracting information from insurance documents using AI).
- Consumerization of corporate banking launched with 3 customers signed before the announcement and 25+ leads generated in a 3-day event; a large UK bank deal was won for building a payment system in the corporate banking space, competing against European players.
Arun Jain: "Now we are rubbing shoulder with Thought Machine. Domino's and Intellect are the 3 players which are rubbing shoulder. On architecture. On API's on micro services on cloud. And on depth of the product functionality, we are competing with the largest player."
Market Reality & Unanswered Questions
- Growth is designed for 20% with a band: The business is designed for 20% growth with a plus/minus 5% band depending on market scenario; dollar growth may be closer to 15 to 20% this year due to the market slowdown.
- The $100 million target and 30% margin target are on hold: Management declined to comment on both, citing market volatility, and said to revisit in 3 to 6 months; reaching $100 million in 8 to 12 quarters is still seen as achievable.
- Next 12 to 18 month demand outlook is unclear: Management asked to "hold on for six months" before commenting on growth trajectory due to current market volatility; no base-case demand number or segment-level behavioral change was provided.
- Cost-revenue mismatch risk was not directly addressed: When asked whether the organization might "run into a wall" with a bloated cost structure if revenues are not running, management discussed Modern Treasury and Thought Machine valuations and TAM but did not directly address the specific risk of cost-revenue mismatch in the current environment.
- No timeline on European core banking deals: When asked when outcomes would be known, management responded "I wish we had the crystal ball" and gave no timeline or probability.
Management: "Let me not comment on it as of now, because the market is too volatile right now. And this, this fluctuations are too much right now. So this quarter will not be right time, maybe another new three to six months, we can come back on to that number..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year rupee revenue growth | 20% growth in rupee terms, without depending on closing big pipeline deals | FY23 |
| Full-year dollar revenue growth | 15–20% range, reflecting market slowdown | FY23 |
| Full-year EBITDA margin | 20% plus | FY23 |
| License revenue growth | 10–11% | FY23 |
| AMC revenue growth | ~11% | FY23 |
| Cost structure increase | ₹0.2–0.3 cr per quarter for new talent, platform, DTM, POC costs; Q3 marketing costs up to ₹3 cr | Next 2 quarters |
| DSO normalization | Back to 115–125 day sustainable range | Near term |
| Platform revenue conversion | Platform deals signed will start converting to subscription revenue | 3–6 months |
| $100 million and 30% margin targets | Revisit and communicate | 3–6 months |
| Next 12–18 month demand outlook | Communicate during annual cycle | ~6 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹528 cr, +17% YoY |
| Gross margin | 52%, vs 58% last year |
| EBITDA | ₹84 cr, -29% YoY from ₹118 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 16%, vs 26% last year |
| PAT | ₹46 cr, vs ₹70 cr last year |
| Revenue shortfall | $6 mn, comprising $2.9 mn from platform transition and $3.1 mn from deals closed but not contracted by Sep 30 |
| Platform revenue | ₹119 cr, +33% YoY |
| License revenue | ₹68 cr, vs ₹86 cr in Q2 last year |
| AMC revenue | ₹90 cr, +11% YoY |
| Annual recurring revenue growth | +22% YoY |
| Total wins | 14 wins, of which 9 were platform wins |
| Go-lives | 14 digital transformations went live during the quarter |
| Pipeline | ₹6,500 cr, +36% YoY from ₹4,800 cr |
| Key deals above ₹20 cr in pipeline | 66 deals, up from 54 YoY, with more deals in the over ₹50 cr tier |
| DSO | 128 days; India customers 164 days, rest of world 154 days |
| Collections | ₹472 cr |
| Sales and marketing investment | ~₹150 cr for the quarter, up ₹7 cr QoQ |
| Tax rate | 26%, up from 16% previously, impacting PAT margins |