Key Takeaways
- Pricing pressure concentrated in the North: Gray cement realizations fell ~6.8% QoQ, driven by the company's heavy Northern exposure where price hikes arrived late and sustainability is uncertain.
- Volume growth on track, capacity build-out accelerates: First-half volume growth hit ~10%, matching full-year guidance, while the board approved 0.55 crore tons of new capacity via debottlenecking and greenfield grinding units.
- Fuel costs spiked, savings deferred: Fuel cost per Kcal rose ~20% QoQ; any relief from lower petcoke prices will only appear in Q4 and depends on prices not rising further.
- Panna is the central story for the next two years: The greenfield plant enters its first full quarter in Q4, with market seeding already underway, but ramp-up to 75-80% utilization will take until the end of year two.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the late-October North price increase holds, the pace of Panna's volume ramp and stabilization costs in its first full quarter, and any concrete timeline for the paint business entry.
Pricing & Realizations
- Northern exposure amplified the dip: Gray realizations declined ~6.8% QoQ because pricing pressure was most acute in the North, where the company has its largest footprint, resulting in a steeper drop than peers with more diversified regional mixes.
- Price recovery is patchy and fragile: Increases of Rs. 15-20 per bag occurred in the South and Rs. 10 in the West, but the North saw no increase until two to three days before the call, and management explicitly flagged that sustainability there is unproven.
- White cement held up better: September was the strongest month due to festival-season demand, and while Q3 is expected to see a marginal dip, realizations should remain broadly comparable to Q2.
Management: "South is about Rs. 15 to Rs. 20 a bag and Western region is for Rs. 10 and so is the Northern region, but for North we have to wait and see whether we are able to sustain the price in North."
Panna: Ramp-Up, Costs & Market Seeding
- Ramp-up is a two-year journey: As a greenfield plant, first-year utilization is targeted at 50-55%, possibly reaching 60% if execution is strong; exit by the end of year two should be close to 75-80%.
- Stabilization costs will weigh on near-term margins: The first full quarter (Jan-Mar) will carry higher costs from low-capacity operation and power plant commissioning; the April-June quarter will still be above normalized levels, with the cost advantage materializing only from Q1 of the next fiscal.
- Market seeding de-risks the ramp: The company has been supplying Panna's future markets from existing plants, incurring ~Rs. 10 crores per quarter in additional marketing and office expenses, which management argues will enable trade-segment volumes of 40,000-50,000 tons per month right from commissioning, something impossible without pre-seeding.
- Trade mix target stays high: The company aims to maintain above 65% and close to 70% trade ratio across the whole company, with Panna's major portion directed to trade sales.
- Clinker supply chain taking shape: Ujjain grinding unit will be supplied from existing Nimbahera and Mangalwar plants, not Panna; Hamirpur and Prayagraj will be serviced from Panna, reducing lead distances once fully operational.
Management: "Whatever we have done the seeding from the existing plant of the new markets that will help in early settling of the Panna plant otherwise when we have just commissioned the plants we should be able to even in trade segment in the normal month we should be able to get a volume of 40,000 tons, 50,000 tons. So, that would not have been possible if we are not seated the market."
Capacity Expansion
- 0.55 crore tons approved over two years: The board sanctioned debottlenecking of existing plants (0.02 crore tons), a new greenfield grinding unit at Ujjain (0.15 crore tons), a greenfield grinding unit at Prayagraj (0.02 crore tons), and a clinker capacity increase at Panna.
- Timeline is staggered: The 2-million-ton debottlenecking completes by March 2023; Ujjain grinding unit is expected by March 2024; Prayagraj is targeted for end-Q1 or Q2 FY25.
- Clinker factor to improve structurally: With more split grinding units coming online over the next two years, management expects to produce around 2.2 crore tons of cement from 1.45 crore tons of clinker capacity, a meaningful efficiency gain.
- Utilization strategy requires headroom: The company operates at 85-89% average utilization over the year, which demands running at full capacity in peak months; without surplus grinding capacity, that average is unattainable.
Costs & Fuel
- Fuel cost jumped 20% QoQ on a Kcal basis: Petcoke comprised 50% of the volume mix, and the quarter carried a blend of old, higher-cost inventory.
- Near-term savings are elusive: Management cautioned that any fuel cost saving will only become visible in Q4, and even that depends on petcoke prices not rising further from current levels, which are already ticking up.
- Panna's cost advantage is back-end loaded: The plant's power plant commissions around end-March, and the first two quarters of operations will carry elevated per-ton costs before normalizing in FY25.
Management: "Very difficult to say I mean because there is some fuel saving, but again the petcoke prices are again on the increase. So, it could be some marginal variation, but we do not going to see that in the third quarter there will be any saving in terms of power and fuel because still we have a mixture of some old inventory of petcoke. So, any saving in power and fuel would only be visible in the last quarter and that too it depends on going forward there is no substantial increase in the petcoke pricing."
UAE & International Business
- Marginal improvement this quarter: Performance picked up as the company established facilities in Africa and began tapping that market; previously, COVID disruptions and high container freight had blocked supply despite healthy demand.
- Outlook is cautiously optimistic: Demand remains good and supply capability is restored; management is hopeful of sustained improvement driven by the Africa initiative.
Paint Business & Other Updates
- Paint entry still in planning phase: No major CAPEX has been deployed yet; the company is analyzing all aspects and expects to have a definite timeline for market entry within this calendar year.
- Panna merger pending at NCLT: The hearing is being actively pursued, and management is hopeful the merger will complete within this fiscal year.
- Karnataka WHRS on track: A 20-megawatt waste heat recovery system at Muddapur is scheduled for commissioning by March 2024.
- CAPEX trajectory: Total CAPEX for this fiscal year has been raised to Rs. 1,900 crores, with Rs. 1,400 crores planned for next year; peak borrowing is expected around March or June next year, staying within Rs. 3,500 crores.
- Cash flow divergence explained: The ~Rs. 190 crore difference between standalone and consolidated cash flow from operations stems from an investment of ~Rs. 200 crores into the Panna subsidiary this quarter.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 10% for FY23; first-half performance supports this | FY23 |
| Debottlenecking completion | 0.2 crore tons at existing plants | By March 2023 |
| Ujjain grinding unit | 0.15 crore tons greenfield | By March 2024 |
| Prayagraj grinding unit | 0.02 crore tons greenfield | End-Q1 or Q2 FY25 |
| Panna ramp-up | First-year utilization 50-55%, possibly 60% | First full year of operations |
| Panna exit utilization | Close to 75-80% | End of second year |
| Panna cost normalization | Cost advantage to materialize | Q1 of next fiscal (FY25) |
| Panna merger | Completion via NCLT | Within this fiscal year |
| Karnataka WHRS | 20 MW commissioned | By March 2024 |
| Peak borrowing | Within Rs. 3,500 crores | March or June next year |
| Maintenance CAPEX (FY25) | ~Rs. 300 crores | FY25 |
| Paint business timeline | Definite time frame for entry | Within this calendar year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹2,110 cr, vs ₹1,836 cr in previous year |
| EBITDA | ₹303 cr, vs ₹359 cr in previous year |
| EBITDA margin | 14.49%, vs 19.95% last year |
| Profit before tax | ₹167 cr, vs ₹249 cr in previous year |
| Profit after tax | ₹135 cr, vs ₹189 cr in previous year, a drop of 26% |
| EPS | ₹16.16, vs ₹21.85 in previous year |
| H1 revenue from operations | ₹4,315 cr, +24% YoY |
| H1 EBITDA margin | 16.8%, vs 22.38% last year |
| Sales volume | 36.44 lakh tons |
| Volume growth guidance FY23 | 10%, first 6 months in same region and expected to continue |
| Gray realizations | ~6.8% QoQ decline |
| Fuel cost per Kcal | ₹2.40, up ~20% from previous quarter |
| Petcoke consumption | 50% of fuel mix by volume |
| Lead distance | 477 km |
| Rail mix | 19% |
| Gross debt (standalone) | ₹2,686 cr, vs ₹2,550 cr as on 31st March 22 |
| Net debt (standalone) | ₹1,709 cr, vs ₹1,606 cr as on 31st March 22 |
| Net debt-to-equity | 0.39, same as last year |
| Consolidated gross debt | ₹3,853 cr, vs ₹3,434 cr as on 31st March 22 |
| Consolidated net debt | ₹2,839 cr, vs ₹2,150 cr as on 31st March 22 |
| CAPEX FY23 | ₹1,900 cr, increased from earlier estimate; ₹1,200 cr already spent |
| CAPEX FY24 | ₹1,400 cr |
| Peak borrowing level | within ₹3,500 cr, expected by March or June next year |
| Capacity addition approved | 0.55 crore tons over next two years |
| Post-expansion cement capacity | ~2.42 crore tons |
| Post-expansion clinker capacity | ~1.45 crore tons |
| Average capacity utilization | 85% to 89% historically |
| Trade sales target | above 65% and close to 70% of total sales |
| Panna ramp-up initial volume | 15,000–16,000 tons per month, ramping up over 6 to 9 months |
| Pre-Panna marketing expenses | ~₹10 cr per quarter for servicing markets from existing plants |
| Standalone cash flow from operations | ₹146 cr |
| Consolidated cash flow from operations | ₹280 cr |
| Investment in Panna from JK Cement | ₹200 cr in this quarter |