Key Takeaways
- Q2 missed expectations on multiple fronts: External demand weakness and pricing pressure combined with internal shutdown costs to produce a quarter that was "not on expected lines," with a one-time cost impact of ~₹45–50 crores.
- Volume growth target cut to 6–7%: Management revised its full-year grey cement volume growth target down from 10%, citing monsoon-driven demand dips in the north and south.
- White cement margins under siege from putty: Asian Paints has captured ~30% market share in putty without owning production, forcing realizations down; JK Cement holds ~22% share and is growing but cannot match the competitor's pace.
- Coal block wins promise a structural cost reset: Two newly won MP coal blocks could deliver fuel at ~₹1.00–1.10 per 100 NCV versus the current ₹1.50–1.60, removing a competitive disadvantage in central India once commissioned.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether October's marginal price uptick holds post-Diwali, the pace of the promised ~₹50/ton quarterly cost reduction, and any progress on the Toshali limestone proposal in December.
Quarterly Performance: What Went Wrong
- External headwinds: Monsoon weakened demand, particularly in the north and south, while industry-wide pricing pressure persisted through the quarter. Central India held up relatively better.
- Internal disruption: A planned 45-day shutdown at the south plant for modifications extended to ~70 days due to continuous rain, forcing clinker purchases from the market to protect trade volumes and resulting in a loss of contribution.
- Panna kiln instability: Excessive rain forced the Panna kiln to run at very low output for nearly a month, with intermittent closures; the kiln operated at normal output only one-third of the month, hurting costs and disrupting the thermal substitution journey that had just begun there.
- One-time cost drag: Incremental one-time expenditure of ~₹30 crores plus clinker purchase costs of ~₹15–20 crores, totaling ~₹45–50 crores, weighed on the quarter and should not recur.
- Realization held up artificially: Realization per ton did not fall despite pricing pressure only because lower volumes allowed the company to cut sales in low-remunerative areas and non-trade segments, especially in the south, while marginally improving premium product mix. This maneuvering normalizes next quarter as volumes return.
- TSR rate optically dropped: The reported TSR rate fell sharply to 13% because Q2 is a maintenance period for all kilns, and the data now covers all 13 plants post-SBTi approval (previously only 9), with Panna, the lowest AFR user, included for the first time.
Management: "The working for the quarter was not on the expected lines. That was mainly on account of both external and internal factors."
White Cement & Putty: The Margin Battle
- Putty realizations under sustained attack: White cement realizations have fallen solely because of putty pricing, where Asian Paints continues to be "very aggressive." A correction expected to bottom out last March did not materialize; after July's paint price increase, some putty pricing improved but hidden discounts persist.
- Competitor without production: Asian Paints has become the largest putty player with ~30% market share despite owning no production facilities, versus ~24% for Birla and ~22% for JK Cement. JK Cement is growing year-on-year but cannot match Asian Paints' growth rate.
- Margin direction disclosed: Management declined to break out grey versus white cement margins at the consolidated level but offered that grey business margins "would be marginally lower in this quarter as compared to the white."
Management: "The paint manufacturers, especially Asian Paints continues to be very aggressive as far as putty is concerned... Asian Paints with all that they have already taken the #1 position in the putty field. They have become the largest player of though they don't have any production facilities. But they are still the largest seller of putty with a market share of close to about 30% as against 24% for Birla and 22% for us."
Cost Reduction: The Path to Recovery
- Logistics savings underway: ~₹22 per ton in logistics savings already achieved; exit by March should reach ~₹45–50 per ton. Green power agreements are in advanced stages.
- AFR economics under review: AFR cost increased because AFR pricing is linked to fuel pricing; with softening fuel prices, management is renegotiating the gap between AFR and fuel prices to maintain the economics of using alternative fuels.
- AFR volume expansion: AFR consumption is increasing in the south, and with Panna stabilization, AFR consumption at Panna should begin, widening the base for thermal substitution savings.
- Unit cost trajectory: Q2 unit cost was exceptional due to low volume and inventory carrying fixed cost elements; sequentially, cost should reduce from Q1 levels. Management expects ~₹50 per ton reduction in each of the remaining two quarters, totaling ~₹100 per ton from the Q1 FY25 base of ₹4,800.
- Exit targets: Exit by March at ~₹60 per ton savings; the balance ~₹90 per ton expected in FY26. Management did not confirm an equal split between the two years when asked.
Management: "Otherwise, it would not be economical to use the AFR, make all the effort of using the AFR."
Coal Blocks: The Structural Advantage
- Two blocks won in Madhya Pradesh: Shahdol (smaller, needs work from beginning) and Mahan (bigger, partially developed). Both remove a competitive disadvantage in central India where peers already own coal blocks.
- Shahdol timeline: Vesting agreement done, team on board, mining lease and land procurement initiated. Management targets commissioning at least 12–15 months ahead of the government's FY29 timeline.
- Mahan timeline: Agreement expected within November, site handover immediately after; commissioning planned in ~30 months.
- Fuel cost advantage: Own coal is expected at ~₹1.00–1.10 per 100 NCV versus the current ₹1.50–1.60, securing fuel for central India, especially the Panna second line expansion. Management is also evaluating whether it makes business sense to feed some volumes to northern plants.
Management: "So, many companies if you look at in that region everybody has a coal block. So, we are fairly at a disadvantage on that concern. So, we will not be at a disadvantage as compared to the competition and maybe if that fuel works out, we are also working out. We can also see whether we can feed some volumes to the northern plants also because it makes a business sense."
Paints Business: Scaling Toward Break-Even
- Record October: The paints business achieved a record sale in October, its main season month.
- Revenue trajectory: Confident of ₹250–300 crores top line in FY25, with a planned loss of ~₹40 crores. FY26 target: ₹400–450 crores. FY27 target: ₹600 crores with break-even.
- Investment capped: Total committed investment of ₹600 crores; no further commitment beyond that. The business should become self-sufficient by FY27.
Expansion & Regulatory Milestones
- 0.6 crore ton expansion: Commissioning targeted by December 2025 / end of Q3 / beginning of Q4 FY26. The Panna second line will become the single largest point for clinker at over 20,000 tons.
- Toshali limestone: Recent meeting held with the Chief Minister and Chief Secretary after a change of guard; discussions had to start afresh. A proposal has been submitted; management expects a response sometime in December and is "hopeful." Finalization will take time and will help formulate strategy for entering the east, but no immediate start is planned. The next investment decision will be taken only after completing the 0.6 crore ton expansion.
- SBTi approval: Received approval covering all 13 plants, up from the previous 9, which expands the scope of reported sustainability metrics.
Management: "I think we should get some their proposal whatever we have submitted their response sometime in the month of December or so. We are hopeful."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Grey cement volume growth | 6–7% for full year (revised from 10%) | FY25 |
| White cement volume growth | No negative growth; 3% growth already in H1 | FY25 |
| Cost reduction from Q1 FY25 base | ~₹50/ton reduction per quarter for remaining two quarters; exit March at ~₹60/ton savings | Q3 and Q4 FY25 |
| Balance cost savings | ~₹90/ton | FY26 |
| Paints revenue | ₹250–300 cr top line; ~₹40 cr loss | FY25 |
| Paints revenue | ₹400–450 cr top line | FY26 |
| Paints revenue | ₹600 cr top line with break-even | FY27 |
| Paints investment | No further commitment beyond ₹600 cr total | Ongoing |
| 0.6 cr ton expansion commissioning | December 2025 / end Q3 / beginning Q4 | FY26 |
| Toshali limestone proposal | Response expected from government | December 2024 |
| Shahdol coal block commissioning | At least 12–15 months ahead of government's FY29 timeline | Target ~FY28 |
| Mahan coal block commissioning | ~30 months from site handover (agreement expected November 2024) | Target ~FY27 |
| Government infrastructure spending | Expected to come in full-fledged | From November 2024 onwards |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Net sales | ₹2,322 cr, down ~9% QoQ and ~6% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹273 cr, down 43% QoQ and 39% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 11.7%, vs 18.7% QoQ and 18% YoY |
| Profit before tax | ₹64 cr, vs ₹292 cr QoQ and ₹246 cr YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹45 cr, vs ₹203 cr QoQ and ₹179 cr YoY |
| EPS | ₹5.80, vs ₹26.2 QoQ and ₹23.1 YoY |
| Half-year net sales | ₹4,877 cr, down 3% YoY |
| Half-year EBITDA margin | 15.4%, vs 16.9% YoY |
| Gross debt | ₹4,664 cr, vs ₹4,592 cr as on March |
| Net debt | ₹2,582 cr, vs ₹3,044 cr as on March |
| Net debt to EBITDA | 1.6x |
| Grey cement full-year volume growth guidance | 6–7%, revised from 10% |
| Grey cement QoQ realization change | -0.8% |
| White cement QoQ realization change | -3% |
| Paints business Q2 turnover | ₹53 cr |
| Paints business H1 EBITDA loss | ₹25 cr |
| Paints business FY25 top-line guidance | ₹250–300 cr |
| Paints business FY27 top-line target | ₹600 cr, with break-even expected |
| TSR rate | 13%, dropped sharply QoQ; now covers all 13 plants under SBTi |
| Putty market share | ~22%, vs Asian Paints ~30% and Birla ~24% |
| Putty volume growth target | 5–6% for the year |
| CAPEX target for FY25 | ₹1,800–2,000 cr, maintained; ₹750 cr spent in H1 |
| Rail-road mix | 9% rail |
| Blended mix | 70% |
| Incentive booked in Q2 | ₹58 cr |
| Fuel mix by heat | ~75% pet coke, balance alternate fuel and imported |
| One-time impact in Q2 | ~₹45–50 cr, including ~₹30 cr incremental one-time expenditure and clinker purchase costs |