Key Takeaways
- Pricing weakness defies strong demand: North India demand is the best among regions, yet a planned ₹20–30/bag price hike failed, with only ~₹5/bag net sustained. Management sees “no plausible reason” for the pressure.
- Panna ramp-up is the central operational story: The new kiln was commissioned late November and is stabilizing; full stabilization is expected only by Q1 next fiscal, with one-off costs of ₹20–25 Cr in each of the next two quarters.
- White cement and putty margins are structurally resetting: Putty is commoditizing under competitive pressure from paint companies and new entrants, while white cement margins, once 25–30%, are now at par with grey and expected to align with paint company margins going forward.
- Power and fuel costs spiked but relief is promised: Per-Kcal cost rose from ₹2.40 to ₹2.60 QoQ, adding ~₹400/ton; management expects a minimum ₹0.20/Kcal reduction in Q4, returning to prior levels.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised Q4 fuel cost reduction materializes, the pace of Panna’s stabilization and cost normalization, and any sign of pricing discipline returning to the North and South markets.
Pricing & Demand Paradox
- Strong demand, weak pricing: North India demand is described as better than any other region, yet a November attempt to raise prices by ₹15–20/bag yielded only ~₹5/bag net. South saw increases then a dip, with further pressure ongoing. East and West, by contrast, saw good price increases.
- Volume is demand-driven, not price-driven: Management pushed back on the idea that players are cutting prices to chase volume, stating cement volume is a function of demand, not price elasticity.
- No explanation for the weakness: Management acknowledged the pricing failure is puzzling during peak construction season and offered no plausible reason, noting they had hoped for a ₹20–30/bag increase that “somehow did not happen.”
Saraogi: “We really do not see any plausible reason especially I would say that the North demand could be better than any other region, and in spite of that the prices have not taken place at least what was expected and definitely we were hoping that we would get a price increase of minimum Rs.20 to Rs.30 a bag, but somehow it did not happen we are just waiting.”
Panna Ramp-Up: Progress, Costs & Timeline
- Kiln commissioned, stabilization underway: The Panna kiln was commissioned in the latter part of November 2022 and is under stabilization with teething troubles. By January, most clinker requirement was being met from Panna itself, a shift from December when clinker was supplied from North plants.
- Waste heat recovery still pending: The WHR plant is yet to be commissioned; a shutdown for its integration is planned for March–April, which will further delay full stabilization.
- One-off costs to persist: Higher operational costs at the subsidiary stem from no WHR (higher power cost), fuel wastage during kiln firing, and high-cost imported pet coke inventory that cannot be averaged out. Standalone branding and market development costs were ~₹20 Cr this quarter, with ₹20–25 Cr expected in each of the next two quarters.
- Lead distance reduction ahead: Current lead distance is ~475 km, elevated because Panna markets were being served from existing North plants. Post-Panna stabilization, overall lead distance should reduce by ~30 km, possibly up to 50 km, reaching ~440–450 km.
- Utilization confidence: Management is confident of reaching ~50% capacity utilization in Q4 and ramping faster than expected thereafter, with full stabilization in Q1 of next fiscal.
Saraogi: “We are confident that we would be ramping up our capacity in a new market region at a rate which would be far more than expectation and we will do it faster.”
White Cement & Putty: Structural Margin Reset
- Putty commoditization: The putty segment is transitioning from a specialized product to a commodity. Paint manufacturers remain very aggressive, a grade-2 grey cement producer (Wonder Cement) has set up a putty plant in Rajasthan, and JK Lakshmi commissioned a putty plant near Alwar last week.
- Margin squeeze from both sides: Raw material costs are rising (white cement prices up, chemical costs up due to rate increases and rupee devaluation on imported chemicals), while stiff competition forces higher incentives to match paint companies’ dealer margins. New entrants are expected to pass on additional margin.
- White cement margins normalized: White business margins, which historically enjoyed a 25–30% advantage, are now at par with grey business margins. Going forward, they are expected to be marginally in line with paint companies’ margins.
- Strategy shift to volume defense: The focus is now on securing present volume and capturing market growth rather than defending premium. Bridging the premium with other brands is necessary to maintain volumes.
Saraogi: “Putty is getting from a specialized product to a commodity, and once it get into commodity we cannot have that edge... our premium cannot be very high, the bridging of the premium with the other brands has to be there to maintain the volume numbers.”
Costs: Fuel Spike & Promised Relief
- Power and fuel cost rose sharply: Per-Kcal cost increased from ₹2.40 to ₹2.60 QoQ, translating to a ~₹400/ton rise. Pet coke share increased to 55% by volume and 75% by heat.
- Q4 reduction expected: Management expects power and fuel cost to reduce by a minimum ₹0.20 per Kcal in the current quarter (Q4), returning to previous quarter levels.
- Panna-specific fuel drag: The subsidiary carries high-cost imported pet coke inventory that cannot be averaged out on a standalone subsidiary basis, adding to cost pressure during ramp-up.
Paint Business: Investment & Loss Trajectory
- Cumulative spend overshoot: Cumulative spend on the paint business this fiscal will be ₹275 Cr versus the originally planned ₹175 Cr, driven by the Acro Paints acquisition on an equity basis. Total capex remains well within the ₹600 Cr Board approval, and next year’s investment will be lower.
- Acro acquisition reduces loss expectations: Earlier projections assumed substantial operating losses for the first three years. With Acro (which is not loss-making), expected losses should be substantially reduced, and market development expenditure savings are anticipated.
- Topline ambition: Management expects at least a 50% increase, possibly 75%, on topline by end of FY2024 from Acro’s base of ~₹70–80 Cr net.
Saraogi: “We do not expect huge losses in the paint business in the first year... we expect end of FY2024 we should be able to do a total at least 50% increase may be 75% increase on the topline.”
Capacity Expansion & Merger Updates
- Debottlenecking on track: Capacity increase of 0.2 crore tons is expected by the last fortnight of March (end of FY23), with normal utilization from Q1 FY2024. This will provide flexibility to expand existing markets in North and South.
- Panna merger with standalone: The matter is listed with NCLT, with the next hearing on the 10th; everything has been submitted from the company side. The effective date of the merger is April 1, 2021. State governments must reconfirm subsidies and transfer of mining leases as abundant precaution before the actual effect of the merger. March quarter numbers may not reflect Panna as part of the standalone entity because actual effect may take time.
- Panna incentives: Incentives will kick in immediately once the order copy is provided; authorities are aware of the merger.
- Consolidated disclosures: Management agreed to start sharing consolidated grey business numbers (volume and net sales) going forward.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Power and fuel cost reduction | Minimum ₹0.20 per Kcal reduction, returning to prior quarter levels | Q4 FY23 |
| Panna capacity utilization | Reach ~50% utilization | Q4 FY23 |
| Panna full stabilization | Plant fully stabilized after WHR commissioning and teething troubles resolved | Q1 next fiscal (FY24) |
| Panna one-off costs | ₹20–25 Cr each quarter for stabilization and market development | Next 2 quarters |
| Debottlenecking capacity | 0.2 crore tons additional capacity operational | Last fortnight of March (end of FY23) |
| Debottlenecking utilization | Normal utilization of extra capacity | Q1 FY24 |
| Lead distance reduction | Reduce by ~30 km, possibly up to 50 km, to ~440–450 km | Post-Panna stabilization |
| Paint business topline | At least 50% increase, possibly 75%, from Acro’s ~₹70–80 Cr base | End of FY24 |
| Paint business capex | Lower investment than current year; well within ₹600 Cr Board approval | Next year (FY24) |
| White segment margins | Marginally in line with paint companies’ margins | Going forward |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated grey volume | 36.61 lakh tons |
| Consolidated grey net sales | ₹1,789 Cr |
| Standalone grey net sales | ₹1,739 Cr |
| 9M revenue | ₹5,636 Cr, +31% YoY |
| 9M EBITDA | ₹974 Cr, -14% YoY |
| 9M EBITDA margin | 15.11%, vs 21.46% in 9M FY22 |
| 9M PAT | ₹403 Cr, -26% YoY |
| 9M EPS | ₹52.10, vs ₹70.46 in 9M FY22 |
| Net price increase in North | ~₹5/bag during the quarter |
| Power and fuel cost per Kcal | ₹2.60, up ₹0.20 QoQ |
| Rail movement share | 19% |
| Lead distance | 470 km |
| Pet coke share | 55% by volume, ~75% by heat |
| Panna subsidiary volume | 1.15 lakh tons |
| FY23 capex spent | ~₹1,600 Cr of ₹1,900 Cr plan; ₹200–250 Cr remaining for Q4 |
| Short-term borrowing (standalone) | ₹350–400 Cr |
| Short-term borrowing (consolidated) | More than ₹500 Cr |
| Panna branding and market development cost | ~₹20 Cr incremental in standalone |
| Paint business capex this fiscal | ₹275 Cr, vs earlier plan of ~₹175 Cr |
| Acro Paints current topline | ₹70–80 Cr net |
| Paint business topline expectation by end of FY24 | At least 50% increase, maybe 75% increase |