Key Takeaways
- Margin recovery in full swing: EBITDA margin jumped to 22.6% from 10.8% YoY, powered by cost savings exceeding ₹100 per ton and better realizations.
- Expansion bets are placed: The board approved a ₹2,850 crore, 0.6 crore ton expansion in Central India, while the company also confirmed entry into the Bihar market.
- Paint business is a controlled burn: The paint venture crossed ₹100 crores in 9-month revenue but posted a planned operational loss of ₹15 crores, with profitability not expected until FY26.
- Fuel cost tailwind is delayed: Petcoke prices have fallen, but the benefit will only hit the P&L in Q1 FY25 because of 60-75 days of imported fuel inventory.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the expected price increase materializes before the election quarter, the pace of WHRS commissioning at Muddapur, and any progress on the Toshali acquisition dialogue.
Margin Recovery & Cost Structure
- Cost savings delivered: Q3 saw cost savings in excess of ₹100 per ton, partly from a freight adjustment in inventory valuation. Management flagged that the major savings are already affected, with only marginal savings of ₹30-₹40 per ton expected in Q4.
- Energy cost lag: Energy cost per kcal stood at ₹1.80. Petcoke prices have reduced, but the company carries 60-75 days of imported fuel inventory, so the impact is deferred to Q1 FY25. Fuel costs are now at par with Q3 average, so no major drop is expected near-term.
- Employee cost ticked up: Employee cost increased because targeted profit was achieved, triggering an incremental provision for variable pay. Q4 employee cost could be marginally lower as the current quarter carried an additional impact.
- Freight cost pressure: Freight cost per ton increased sequentially due to the busy season, a rail surcharge, increased lead distance from servicing new markets, and a mix shift as south volume was marginally lower. QoQ freight cost should be flattish going forward with no major increase in lead distance expected.
- Subsidy stream: Total subsidy runs at about ₹75-₹80 crores per quarter, or ₹26-₹27 crores per month. Year-on-year, the company should get around ₹300 crores in fiscal incentives for the next few years.
- Inventory normalization: An inventory adjustment occurred as clinker stock returned to optimum levels after Q2 maintenance; management clarified this was not a one-off.
Saraogi: "The petcoke prices have reduced, and we should see some reduction. But it will -- it would be seen only in the first quarter of next fiscal because this is based on the inventory levels looking to -- we are more dependent on imported fuels, so we have 60-75 days inventory with us."
Expansion & Growth Projects
- Central India expansion approved: The board approved a 0.6 crore ton expansion (0.33 crore tons incremental grinding via modifications at Panna, Prayagraj, and Hamirpur) at a total project cost of ₹2,850 crores. Main plant and equipment orders will be finalized within the next 3-4 months.
- Commissioning timeline: Work may start by March/April 2024, with commissioning possible by December 2025, a timeline within 24 months. Cement grinding can be completed earlier, but management sees no point without the clinker line.
- Bihar entry: The company is entering Bihar as a new market, a natural growth direction eastward from Panna with no other options from that location. The grinding location will be frozen within 2-4 months, with land acquisition and environmental clearance taking 6-9 months; the grinding unit can be commissioned within 12 months after that.
- Clinker sourcing secured: Tie-ups exist for all existing grinding locations including the brownfield expansions at Hamirpur and Prayagraj. Only the long-term tie-up for the Bihar unit is still under negotiation.
- Ujjain grinding unit live: A grinding unit of 0.15 crore tons was commissioned at Ujjain during Q3. The Prayagraj grinding unit (0.2 crore tons) is likely to be commissioned by the July-September quarter.
- Future expansion options: Four options are on the table: expansion in the North at Jaisalmer, expansion in the South where the company is operating at high capacity utilization, a Line-3 at Panna, and the Toshali acquisition if it works out. By the time Panna Line-2 is completed, the company will have a clear plan on where to go next.
- Toshali acquisition stalled: Dialogue continues with the state government and the owner regarding transfer of the mining lease, but the government has concerns. The company is working on a long-term limestone tie-up arrangement as an alternate option pending mine transfer.
Demand, Pricing & Volumes
- Demand growth seen at 7-9%: Management sees demand growth of 7% to 9% and believes incremental capacity will be absorbed as demand is increasing.
- Grey volume trajectory: Full year FY24 grey volume is expected around 1.65 crore tons, with incremental volume of a minimum 0.2 crore tons each year in FY25 and FY26.
- Pricing improved QoQ: Pricing was better than the previous quarter, leading to an improvement in realization. However, realization in the current month is marginally lower than the Q3 exit.
- Price increase needed before elections: Management expects some price increase in the current quarter. If it does not materialize, Q1 may be difficult because of elections and other factors.
- Trade mix shift: The trade mix came off from 69% to 64% QoQ. Management maintained market share in trade across all markets; nontrade volumes grew because incremental demand and opportunity is coming from the nontrade segment.
- Central vs North profitability: Central India pricing is slightly lower than the North, but plant efficiencies and subsidy benefits make profitability more or less the same across regions.
Saraogi: "We are expecting that some price increase should take place in this quarter. So if it takes place in this quarter, it will be good. Otherwise, the first quarter may be difficult because of the elections and other things."
White Cement, Paint & New Ventures
- White business steady: The white business grew 5% in 9 months YoY, with profitability more or less flat. Stiff competition persists, especially in the putty segment. EBITDA margins are expected in the 15%-18% range.
- White cement realizations: Realization increased due to a product mix change toward more specialized products like ShieldMaxX premium putty, plus seasonal factors. Putty pricing remains under pressure QoQ.
- Paint business scaling: The paint business crossed ₹100 crores in turnover over 9 months, with Q3 top line at ₹46 crores. The operational loss of ₹15 crores in 9 months is within the planned range, and management monitors the business on a gross margin basis.
- Paint profitability timeline: FY25 top line is targeted at ₹250-₹300 crores, with a marginal profit or loss depending on brand-building spend. The business is expected to become EBITDA positive in FY26, when the top line is closer to ₹400-₹500 crores.
- Fujairah normalizing: Fujairah operations were affected by high fuel and logistics costs, but things are normalizing with fuel cost reduction and value-added products contributing positive revenue. On a consistent basis, if conditions remain normal, annual EBITDA of ₹30-₹40 crores could be sustained, though some Q3 volumes were one-off.
- LC3 readiness: Trial production of LC3 (calcined clay cement) has been done and testing is completed. The product is more or less ready, but commercialization depends on having a proper commercial model and favorable demand-supply dynamics.
Saraogi: "Actually, we've become EBITDA positive in a way in FY26, when we are closer to INR500 crores top line -- INR400 crores, INR500 crores top line."
Power & Fuel Strategy
- WHRS at Muddapur near completion: The new WHRS plant at Muddapur is in an advanced stage and under trial runs, adding 18 megawatts. It will be partially commissioned in Q4, with full benefit from Q1 FY25.
- Renewable energy build-out: Some short-term renewable tie-ups expire March 31, 2024, and the company is entering into long-term PPA agreements. An additional 50 megawatts is targeted by FY25-FY26: 25 megawatts from waste heat (Line-2) plus 25 megawatts of incremental solar. The company hopes to increase solar/wind capacity by around 50-60 megawatts every year.
- Green energy mix targets: By FY26, the green power mix should be closer to 60%, with a 75% green power target for 2030.
- Cement clinker ratio: Expected to range between 0.62 and 0.64.
Balance Sheet & Capex
- Capex guidance revised: FY24 capex is revised to ₹1,200 crores from ₹1,400 crores. FY25 is guided at ₹2,200 crores and FY26 at ₹1,800 crores.
- Debt peak: Gross debt is expected to peak at a maximum of ₹5,600 crores by FY26, with an incremental ₹1,000 crores as the peak debt addition.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Grey cement volume | Full year FY24 around 1.65 crore tons; minimum 0.2 crore tons incremental each year | FY25 and FY26 |
| Prayagraj grinding unit commissioning | 0.2 crore tons | July-September quarter FY25 |
| Central India expansion commissioning | 0.6 crore tons (clinker + grinding) | Within 24 months; possible by December 2025 |
| Bihar grinding location freeze | Location to be finalized | Within 2-4 months |
| Bihar grinding unit commissioning | Grinding unit operational | Within 12 months of location freeze |
| Main plant and equipment orders | For Central India expansion | Within 3-4 months |
| Capex | FY24: ₹1,200 crores; FY25: ₹2,200 crores; FY26: ₹1,800 crores | FY24-FY26 |
| Gross debt peak | Maximum ₹5,600 crores | By FY26 |
| Cost savings | Marginal savings of ₹30-₹40 per ton | Q4 FY24 |
| WHRS Muddapur commissioning | 18 megawatts; partial in Q4, full benefit from Q1 | Q4 FY24 / Q1 FY25 |
| Renewable capacity addition | Additional 50 megawatts (25 MW WHRS + 25 MW solar) | By FY25-FY26 |
| Green energy mix | Closer to 60% | By FY26 |
| Green energy mix | 75% | By 2030 |
| Paint business top line | ₹250-₹300 crores | FY25 |
| Paint business EBITDA positive | When top line closer to ₹400-₹500 crores | FY26 |
| Fujairah sustainable EBITDA | ₹30-₹40 crores annually | On a consistent basis, if conditions remain normal |
| Petcoke price reduction impact | Reduction visible in P&L | Q1 FY25 |
| Fiscal incentives | Around ₹300 crores per year | Next few years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Net sales | ₹2,690 cr, +9% QoQ and +18% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 22.6%, vs 18% in Q2 FY24 and 10.8% in Q3 FY23 |
| Profit before tax | ₹415 cr, +69% QoQ and +363% YoY |
| EPS | ₹37.40, vs ₹23.10 in Q2 FY24 and ₹7.40 in Q3 FY23 |
| Grey cement volume (9M FY24 growth) | 21.3% YoY |
| Grey cement volume (FY24 estimate) | ~1.65 crore tons, full year |
| Incremental grey volume guidance | Minimum 0.2 crore tons each year in FY25 and FY26 |
| White cement business growth (9M FY24) | 5% YoY |
| White cement business EBITDA margin expectation | 15% to 18% |
| Paint business turnover (9M FY24) | Crossed ₹100 cr |
| Paint business turnover (Q3 FY24) | ~₹46 cr |
| Paint business operational loss (9M FY24) | ~₹15 cr |
| Energy cost per kcal | ₹1.80 |
| Gross debt | ~₹4,600 cr |
| Peak gross debt estimate (by FY26) | ₹5,500 cr to ₹5,600 cr |
| Subsidy booked per quarter | ₹75 cr to ₹80 cr |
| Green power share | 50% currently, target closer to 60% by FY26 |
| Freight cost per ton | ₹1,290, up sequentially; last year annualized was ₹1,220 |
| Cement clinker ratio | 66% for the quarter, expected range 0.62 to 0.64 |
| Capex (9M FY24 actual) | ~₹900 cr |
| Capex guidance (FY24) | ~₹1,200 cr, revised from ₹1,400 cr |
| Capex guidance (FY25) | ₹2,200 cr |
| Capex guidance (FY26) | ~₹1,800 cr |
| Fujairah sustainable annual EBITDA | ₹30 cr to ₹40 cr |