Key Takeaways
- Accounting change distorts standalone optics: A shift to conversion-charge accounting for UCWL-supplied clinker eliminated double-counting, making standalone realizations and costs appear sharply higher QoQ. Consolidated numbers strip this out and show a more normative picture.
- Cost inflation bites, peak still ahead: Power and fuel cost hit ₹11,700/ton, up ~₹400/ton, and management expects another ~20% QoQ increase in Q2 before softening begins.
- Realization gains partly real, partly noise: Consolidated realization rose 12% QoQ, which management called "normative," but the specific drivers of such a large sequential jump were not fully explained when pressed.
- Balance sheet repair underway: Standalone net debt is expected to reach zero by end-FY23, and the UCWL expansion is fully funded with ₹1,300 crores of CAPEX remaining over two years.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether power and fuel costs actually peak in Q2 as guided, the trajectory of monsoon-hit cement prices, and any clarity on which brownfield or greenfield project breaks ground first.
Accounting Change: UCWL Conversion Model
- What changed: From Q1 FY23, UCWL charges JK Lakshmi only a conversion fee for clinker it processes into cement, rather than selling the clinker outright. This eliminates the double-counting of clinker and cement sales that previously inflated both entities' standalone top lines.
- Standalone distortion: The change caused standalone clinker sales volume to drop sharply, making standalone realization appear to spike ~16% QoQ (₹700/ton) and standalone expenditure look higher. These are accounting artefacts, not underlying price or cost moves.
- Consolidated view is clean: On consolidation, inter-unit transactions are eliminated, so the accounting change has no net effect. Consolidated realization moved from ~₹4,900 last year to ~₹5,400 now, and cost from ~₹4,300 to ~₹4,900, both described as normative increases, with the cost increase partly linked to volume.
- Unresolved pushback: Two analysts pressed on why consolidated realization still showed a 12% QoQ sequential increase even after the accounting change was supposedly neutralized on consolidation. Management acknowledged the 12% figure and called it "normative" without detailing the specific drivers.
Costs & Margins
- Power and fuel: Cost rose to ₹11,700/ton from ₹9,000/ton, exceeding the earlier expected ₹200–250 increase. Driven by continuously rising fuel prices and scarcity of domestic coal, which makes up only 7–8% of the coal mix.
- Fuel mix: 46% coal, 41% pet coke, 13% alternate fuel. Most coal is imported because domestic coal is scarce and wagons are unavailable.
Management: "Not only the coal is a scarcity commodity in India but the wagons are also not being available."
- Peak still ahead: Q2 FY23 is expected to see the peak power and fuel cost, with another ~20% QoQ increase baked in. Some softening in fuel prices has started, and management hopes the decline continues unless the trend reverses.
- Employee cost: Standalone employee cost hit ₹92 crores, up from ~₹82 crores quarterly average in FY22, reflecting a normative 10–12% annual increase. The prior quarter had been lower due to an aberration in provisioning. This ₹92 crore level is the run rate for coming quarters.
- Other expenses: Consolidated other expenses rose to ₹207 crores from ₹149 crores QoQ, driven by ~20% volumetric growth in production-linked items plus inflation.
- Other income: Declined to ~₹7 crores from a ₹15–16 crore run rate because funds were deployed toward CAPEX for the UCWL expansion.
- BCG cost project: Completed; all targeted savings are already captured in results.
Pricing & Demand Environment
- Quarterly price trajectory: Most markets saw price increases in April and May, driven partly by industry-wide cost pressures. June brought price correction and demand decline.
- Monsoon pressure: Prices fell ~₹10 per bag in the last month of the quarter. Gujarat faced significant rain and price pressure, Northern markets were also affected, and Chhattisgarh saw minor pressure. Prices have not yet stabilized.
Management: "I would not hesitate to say that the price fall would have been in the range of Rs. 10 a bag. Even now I don't think the prices have one can be very sure that they have stabilized"
- July demand: Demand is stabilizing with growth over the corresponding month last year. A usual rainy-season impact is visible but a definite growth pattern versus last year is emerging.
- Product mix shift: Blended cement mix increased to 67% from 65% in Q4. Premium cement stands at 14% of total sales (North only); the previously cited 25% figure was as a percentage of trade sales, not total sales.
- Trade share ambition: Target to increase trade share by 4–5% in FY23, a gradual process that management is hopeful about but acknowledges does not happen overnight.
Expansion & Capacity Vision
- Vision 2030: Target to reach 3 crore tons capacity via a combination of brownfield and greenfield. Brownfield potential includes a third line at Udaipur, an additional line at Sirohi, and an additional line at Durg. Greenfield potential rests on newly allotted mine blocks at Nagaur (two blocks) and Kutch (one block).
- UCWL expansion: All external clearances are in place except airport authority approval. Construction has begun, with clinker expected by Q3 (December) and phases completing in 2Q and 4Q of 2024. Balance CAPEX of ₹1,300 crores (₹1,650 total less ₹350 spent) to be spread over the next two years.
- Next project sequencing: Brownfield expansion at existing locations may begin roughly one year before UCWL completion. Greenfield land acquisition work has already started. The decision on which project to take first will weigh the demand-supply situation in different areas, with no specific timeline committed.
- Amethi grinding unit: Now operational and available exclusively to JK Lakshmi. The company sells clinker to the unit and buys cement back to preserve the unit's state incentive. Expects about 6 lakh tons of cement in the first 12 months, depending on clinker availability. The 10-year agreement carries a first right of refusal and is renewable at the company's choice.
Balance Sheet & Corporate Structure
- Standalone net debt: Expected to become debt-free on a standalone net-debt basis by end of FY23.
- Group simplification timeline: JK Lakshmi and UCWL will remain separate listed entities until JK Lakshmi exhausts its ~₹250 crores MAT credit entitlement, which may take 2–3 years depending on profitability. Once JK Lakshmi graduates to the 25% tax rate, that will be the opportune time to merge the two entities.
Management: "Moment we exhaust this MAT Guide Entitlement which will be maybe 2 to 3 years' time depending on the actual profitability in these 3 years then JK Lakshmi can also graduate to 25% and that will be the opportune time for us to collapse the structure and merge the two entities."
- Mine lease renewal post-2030: Only one mine comes up for renewal. Management does not foresee significant cost escalation or non-renewal risk, expecting the government to adopt better systems giving existing operators first right.
- Brand strategy: A brand integration strategy is in place but no immediate rationalization is planned. Brands cater to individual niche consumers and work in harmony; Platinum brands from Udaipur command better pricing and have loyal consumers.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Standalone net debt | Become debt-free on standalone net-debt basis | End of FY23 |
| Power and fuel cost peak | Q2 FY23 to see peak; softening has started | Q2 FY23 |
| Power and fuel cost QoQ | Increase ~20% QoQ in Q2 FY23 | Q2 FY23 |
| UCWL expansion completion | Clinker by Q3 (Dec); phases in 2Q and 4Q | 2024 |
| UCWL balance CAPEX | ₹1,300 crores spread over next 2 years | FY23–FY25 |
| Full-year volume growth | 7% to 8% target, dependent on demand and fuel prices | FY23 |
| Full-year profitability | Endeavor to reach ₹1,000 per ton, dependent on coal and pet coke prices | FY23 |
| Trade share increase | Increase by 4% to 5% | FY23 |
| Group merger | Merge JK Lakshmi and UCWL after MAT credit exhaustion | 2–3 years |
| Amethi grinding unit volume | ~6 lakh tons cement in first 12 months | First 12 months of operation |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Standalone cement volume | 26.91 lakh tons, plus 0.9 lakh tons clinker, total 27.86 lakh tons |
| Consolidated cement volume | 29.37 lakh tons, plus 0.95 lakh tons clinker, total 30.32 lakh tons |
| Consolidated revenue per ton | ~₹5,400, up from ~₹4,900 last year |
| Consolidated cost per ton | ~₹4,900, up from ~₹4,300 last year |
| Power and fuel cost per ton | ₹11,700, up from ₹9,000 earlier |
| Power and fuel cost Q2 FY23 outlook | ~+20% increase expected, peak anticipated in Q2 |
| Fuel mix | 46% coal, 41% pet coke, 13% alternate fuel |
| Domestic coal share | 7% to 8% of coal mix |
| Standalone employee cost | ₹92 crores quarterly run rate, normative 10-12% annual increase |
| Consolidated other expenses | ₹207 crores, vs ₹149 crores in Q4 FY22, partly volume-linked |
| Consolidated net debt | ₹662 crores, total debt ₹1,800 crores, cash ₹1,150 crores |
| Standalone net debt | ₹20 crores (per analyst's math), total debt ~₹920 crores, cash ₹900 crores |
| Blended cement mix | 67%, up from 65% in Q4 FY22 |
| Trade mix | 56% |
| Premium cement share of total sales | 14% (North only) |
| Non-cement revenue | ₹118 crores, including RMC of ~₹55 crores |
| Lead distance | 393 km |
| UCWL expansion CAPEX spent | ~₹350 crores of total ₹1,650 crores |
| UCWL clinker line timeline | Q3 FY24 (December) |
| Amethi grinding unit expected volume | ~6 lakh tons in first 12 months, capacity ~0.1 crore tons per year |
| MAT credit entitlement | ~₹250 crores, expected to exhaust in 2-3 years |
| Full-year volume growth target | 7% to 8% (prior guidance) |
| Full-year profitability target | ₹1,000 per ton (prior guidance) |