Key Takeaways
- Cyclone-hit quarter, volume target intact: Volume growth was severely disrupted by the Biparjoy cyclone and Holi-related labor shortages in Gujarat and Rajasthan, which together account for ~70% of sales. Despite the miss, management held its 19% volume growth target for FY24.
- ₹1,000 EBITDA/ton target reiterated, clock ticking: The 18-month timeline set six months ago remains, with management confident the gap to peers will close once external shocks fade and self-help initiatives kick in.
- Self-help levers are stacking up, not yet paying: Premium product share rose to 26-27%, geo mix improved to 75:25, and fuel costs are falling, but logistics tech, alternate fuel, and renewable energy benefits are still 3-4 months away.
- Clinker is the unlock: UCWL's clinker line commissioning in October will relieve a binding constraint (97% clinker utilization) and enable faster volume growth from Q3 onward.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 19% volume catch-up begins as promised once lean months pass, the pace of fuel cost decline toward ₹2.15, and any concrete progress on the ₹2,500 crore fundraising deployment.
Volume & Regional Performance
- Cyclone and labor hit the core: The Biparjoy cyclone and Holi-related labor unavailability struck Gujarat and Rajasthan simultaneously, regions that contribute ~70% of sales. Unlike peers who could offset with other geographies, JK Lakshmi had no backup from East or North, amplifying the damage.
- Regional divergence was stark: In the East, JK Lakshmi grew faster than the industry (>16% vs ~16%). In the West, performance was in line. The underperformance was concentrated in Central India (Rajasthan, Western MP), where the company lagged the industry.
- Trade share sacrificed for geo mix: Trade share fell to 55% from the 60% target reached in March. Management explicitly prioritizes geo mix over channel mix: if non-trade in high-realization markets pays better than trade elsewhere, they take the non-trade volume.
- Clinker bottleneck caps near-term growth: Clinker utilization is at 97%, while grinding sits at 85%. The UCWL clinker line starting in October will relieve this constraint, with management signaling growth rates will be "much higher" from Q3 onward once clinker flows.
Shukla: "I think there I could have done better volume than what we do normally. What we have done last quarter and also I think different parts of India because post this cyclone, in fact, Rajasthan was also impacted quite heavily."
Margin & Cost Levers
- Operating costs ran hot: A plant breakdown reduced waste heat recovery (WHR) production, pushing power costs higher. Employee costs also remain elevated relative to peers, a structural gap management acknowledges.
- Fuel cost tailwind is real but measured: Fuel cost fell from ₹2.42/kcal in Q4 to ₹2.23 in Q1, with a further decline to ~₹2.15 expected next quarter due to the 4-6 month lag between spot price moves and P&L recognition. Management pushed back on industry estimates of ₹300/ton headroom, calling that too optimistic.
- Geo mix and premiumization are the margin bridge: High-realization area volume share improved from 70:30 to 75:25. Premium product share reached 26-27%, up from 21-22% last year. Realization initiatives have captured ₹50-75 of a targeted ₹250+ improvement.
- Renewable energy build-out underway: Renewable share is ~30% of total consumption, with a plan to reach 37-40%. A 56 MW solar plant in Durg (third-party, 26% equity) commissions in October, and a 42.15 MW captive project in the East concludes in three months. In Chhattisgarh, solar banking delivers a landed cost of ~₹5/unit vs grid power above ₹7.5.
- Rajasthan solar policy is a friction: The state imposes cross-subsidy and electricity duty even on captive 26%-route projects, forcing the company to buy a 7-8 MW project under CAPEX mode instead.
- Alternate fuel ramp begins soon: AFR capability at Sirohi commissions in October, with a plan to lift TSR from 4% to ~10% quickly. Additional AFR capability is coming at Udaipur Cement Works and Durg with low CAPEX.
- Logistics optimization in early innings: Oracle Transport Management (OTM) has been deployed and is starting to deliver benefits. A broader project using technology and distribution network revision is in progress, with benefits expected in coming quarters.
Bidkar: "Your concerns are well founded that we have been talking big and not have been able to deliver, but barring this bad quarter, which unfortunately was for external reasons, we are quite confident we will be able to bounce back and bridge that gap going forward."
Capacity Expansion & Strategic Enablers
- Railway siding unlocks the East: Approval for railway lines in the eastern region has finally been received after all impediments were cleared. This enables faster clinker movement to high-realization markets and supports expansion. Expected in place in 9-12 months, with CAPEX of ₹100-250 crores possible.
- The 3 crore ton roadmap: After UCWL expansion, capacity reaches ~1.8 crore tons. The path to 3 crore tons runs through brownfield at existing locations (Sirohi, then another line in Udaipur) and greenfield at two recently awarded mines in Nagaur (Rajasthan) and Kutch (Gujarat). Mine leases were won almost a year ago with non-exorbitant premiums; land acquisition has started at Nagaur, with Kutch to follow.
- UCWL integration progressing: UCWL's clinker line starts in October, enabling inter-unit clinker sales to JK Lakshmi on a cost-plus basis. The UCWL grinding unit is still 6-8 months away. A ₹450 crore rights issue at UCWL has been completed. The merger with JK Lakshmi waits on exhausting MAT credit (~₹140 crores remaining) and graduating to the 25% tax regime, likely two years away.
- Fundraising resolution passed, deployment pending: An enabling resolution for ₹2,500 crores was passed for organic or inorganic expansion. Management plans to raise funds in about a year's time, not immediately.
- Inorganic appetite is opportunistic, not urgent: Management always evaluates acquisitions if the valuation and strategic fit are right, but declined to set an upper bound on price. On market chatter about bidding for Sanghi, management neither confirmed nor denied.
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Leverage guardrails defined, not fixed: Management is willing to temporarily sacrifice debt ratios for growth. The comfort range is debt/EBITDA of 3-3.5x, with 4x acceptable as a temporary phenomenon if there is clear visibility of EBITDA flow to bring it back down.
- MAT credit steadily shrinking: Outstanding MAT credit narrowed from ₹200 crores to ~₹140 crores, a prerequisite for the UCWL merger and tax regime transition.
- FY24 CAPEX is modest: ~₹400 crores planned, of which ₹50 crores was spent in Q1, plus a possible ₹100-250 crores for the railway siding and conveyor belt.
Management: "For a couple of years, one or two years, it may haywire, but so long as we have the clear plan that it will be narrowed down to the range of about, not the debt to EBITDA not more than 3, 3.5, 4 max that should not be of concern being a temporary phenomenon so long as the clear visibility is there."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 19% growth over FY23 | FY24 full year |
| EBITDA per ton | Reach ₹1,000/ton (excluding fuel cost benefit) | 12-18 months (18 months remaining) |
| Fuel cost | Decline to ~₹2.15/kcal | Coming quarter (Q2 FY24) |
| Clinker supply from UCWL | UCWL clinker line commissioning | October 2023 |
| AFR / TSR | TSR from 4% to ~10% | Quickly after Sirohi AFR commissioning (October 2023) |
| Renewable energy share | Increase from ~30% to 37-40% | Not specified (projects concluding in 3-4 months) |
| Railway siding (East) | Operational | 9-12 months |
| Blended cement share | Reach 75% of volume (from 66-67%) | Not specified |
| UCWL merger | Merge once MAT credit exhausted and 25% tax regime reached | ~2 years |
| Fundraising (₹2,500 cr) | Utilization of enabling resolution | Within a year |
| Debt/EBITDA ceiling | Not to exceed 3-3.5x, max 4x temporarily | Ongoing discipline |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,633 cr, of which cement ~₹1,500 cr and non-cement ₹133 cr |
| Operating EBITDA per ton | ₹610, target of ₹1,000 by exit of FY24 |
| Consolidated EBITDA per ton | ₹615 |
| Volume growth target | 19% over FY23, reiterated |
| Volume growth | ~5% YoY |
| Cement capacity utilization | 85% |
| Clinker capacity utilization | 97% |
| Trade share | 55% |
| Premium product share | 26-27% of trade sales, up from 21-22% last year |
| Blended cement share | 66-67%, target 75% |
| Fuel cost per kcal | ₹2.23, down from ₹2.42 in Q4 FY23 |
| Consolidated net debt | ₹1,000 cr, gross debt ₹1,950 cr and cash ₹950 cr |
| Non-cement operating margin | 4%, down from 5% last quarter |
| CAPEX guidance FY24 | ~₹400 cr, ₹50 cr already spent in Q1 |