Key Takeaways
- Margin gap with leaders narrowed sharply: The EBITDA/ton gap versus industry leaders shrank from over ₹600-₹700 a year ago to roughly ₹200-₹250, driven by internal actions that management says will continue.
- Trade share and premium mix both improved: Trade proportion rose from 52% in January to 60% in March, while premium products reached 27% of trade volume by March, up from 21% earlier.
- Fuel cost tailwind is still in transit: Softer fuel costs have not yet flowed through to margins because the company was carrying higher-cost inventory; the benefit will materialize in coming quarters.
- UCWL rights issue and clinker access are the near-term catalysts: JK Lakshmi will subscribe to its 72% share and backstop any public shortfall, while clinker from UCWL becomes available by December 2023, earlier than previously guided.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the fuel cost benefit actually lifts EBITDA/ton from the flattish Q1 guided, progress on the putty plant commissioning by October, and any concrete move on the Durg expansion decision promised this year.
Margin Bridge & the ₹300/Ton Ambition
- The gap closed, the plan stays: Management attributes the ₹400-₹500/ton gap reduction over the past year entirely to internal efforts and insists the journey continues toward parity with leaders.
- Three levers, one dominant: Of the targeted ₹300/ton improvement over 18-24 months, more than half (roughly 70%) is expected from top-line efficiency: premiumization, geo-mix optimization, price positioning, and direct dispatches. Logistics savings of ~₹70-₹75/ton from reducing lead distance to 375 km and other freight efficiencies form the second leg. Manufacturing savings from AFR (target 16% TSR, up from 4%) and minor heat/power consumption gains make up the rest.
- Phasing the climb: Management expects 60% of the ₹300 gap to be captured by Q4 FY24, with the balance in the first two quarters of FY25, aiming to get closer to ₹1,000/ton EBITDA by FY25. For FY24 specifically, the target is ~₹800/ton.
- Q1 is a holding pattern: Prices are flattish to slightly lower in some micro-markets with no increases, so Q1 EBITDA/ton is expected to be more or less flattish versus March, with only some leverage from fuel cost savings.
- Non-cement drag: RMC, AAC, and POP businesses generated only a 5% EBITDA margin, diluting the consolidated picture.
Management: "If you look at one year back gap margin was more than about Rs. 600, Rs. 700. Now we are around Rs. 200 Rs. 250 with respect to the leaders. So, that is what has come about on account of our internal efforts and that internal effort will continue."
Trade Share & Geo-Mix Optimization
- Western market is the margin engine: The Western region delivers better EBITDA margins than Central or East in both trade and non-trade channels, so maximizing Western sales volume is the first optimization lever. Within that Western volume, shifting the mix further toward trade then lifts the blended trade percentage at the BU level.
- Trade share climbed through the quarter: From 52% in January to 60% in March, averaging 55% for Q4. The stated ambition is to push trade share above 60%, though no timeline was committed.
- Premiumization accelerated: Premium products as a share of trade volume improved from 21% to 26% in Q4, with a monthly trajectory from 24% in January to 27% in March. This directly feeds the top-line efficiency lever in the margin bridge.
- Receivables remain a management focus: At ₹60 crore, receivables are considered on the higher side by internal standards. The company runs a special monthly drive, accepts receivables only where BG/LG is obtained, and otherwise insists on cash back. The plan is to go below the current level.
Management: "In our standard I think still this is on the higher side let me tell you our plan is to go a little below that and in fact I think on receivable front this all receivable only on account of where from we have got BG and LG, otherwise from everywhere we have got our cash back."
UCWL Integration & Clinker Timeline
- Clinker access preponed: Clinker from UCWL will now be available by December 2023, ahead of the earlier Q4 timeline. The grinding unit at UCWL, however, has been postponed by one quarter to Q3 FY24. In the interim, clinker will be sent to grinding stations in Gujarat (Kallur near Ahmedabad, Surat) and an outsourced unit near Palanpur.
- Rights issue mechanics: UCWL plans a rights issue in June/July 2023. JK Lakshmi, as the 72% holder, will subscribe to its entitlement and will cover any shortfall from the public (27%) if unsubscribed. ₹85 crore already deployed as an unsecured loan will be adjusted against the rights entitlement.
- Transfer pricing at arm's length: Clinker supplied from UCWL to JK Lakshmi plants will be priced at cost plus margin, ensuring related-party transactions are on market terms.
- Palanpur is a swing capacity: The outsourced grinding arrangement near Palanpur is small (15,000-20,000 tons/month), has no permanent agreement, and operates on an on-and-off basis. It will be used full-fledged once clinker capacity is available, but no fixed timeline governs it.
Capacity Expansion Pathway
- The 3 crore ton roadmap is organic: JK Lakshmi will reach ~1.8 crore tons once the Udaipur expansion is complete. The remaining 1.2 crore ton journey splits into: 0.3 crore tons of Brownfield at Udaipur, plus two Greenfield projects at Nagor and Kutch (0.3 crore tons each).
- Durg decision this year: A call on Brownfield expansion at Durg will be taken in FY24, with a decision on UCWL expansion possibly one year later. The Udaipur expansion will be announced immediately once railway siding visibility is secured.
- Greenfield land acquisition has begun: Land acquisition activities have started at both Nagor and Kutch. The process requires acquiring a minimum portion of land before seeking environmental clearances, and management acknowledges it will take its own time.
- Near-term capex envelope: JK Lakshmi standalone will spend ~₹200 crore in FY24 and ~₹150 crore in FY25. UCWL expansion capex will absorb ~₹500 crore in FY24.
Management: "As far as Durg is concerned we will do in this current financial year for sure and maybe one year later we will take a call on usable of that."
New Initiatives: Putty, White Cement & Green Bonds
- Alwar putty plant by October 2023: A captive putty plant with ~1 lakh ton capacity is being set up at Alwar, Rajasthan, at a capex of ₹65-₹70 crore. White cement will be produced at the same location using a grinding mill (not a kiln), with additional white cement potentially imported.
- Distribution leverage: The existing putty distribution network built around the outsourced unit will be used, supplemented by new channel partners and manpower. The cement distribution channel provides a natural advantage since putty is B2C and sits in the same footprint.
- Green bond to fund sustainability projects: A ₹200 crore green bond issuance is planned, earmarked for: waste heat recovery adding 3.5-4 MW, increasing TSR from 4% to 16% in phases, 40 MW captive solar power for Durg, and 7 MW solar at Sirohi. The TSR phase-1 target is 10% by October/November 2023, with phase-2 to 16% the following year.
- RMC expansion continues: Two plants are operational in Gujarat (Bhavnagar, Baroda), another is being set up in Sonipat (NCR), and plants are planned for Lucknow and Raipur.
M&A Stance & Balance Sheet
- Open to acquisitions, disciplined on price: Management is open to any acquisition that comes at the right value and makes synergistic sense. When asked about Sanghi Cement (in JK Lakshmi's core Gujarat market), management declined to comment on the specific news item but acknowledged the asset would make synergistic sense if priced right.
- Valuation anchor: If an asset comes at a value lower than JK Lakshmi's own trading multiple (~\$100/ton, barring the recent drop), it would be considered attractive.
- Leverage comfort for deals: Net debt-to-EBITDA may rise to 4-5x during implementation and stabilization of an acquisition, but management expects it to normalize to ≤3-3.5x once EBITDA from the acquired asset flows in.
- No due diligence on Sanghi: When pressed on the status of the Sanghi Cement divestment process, management stated they are not aware of the process and have not conducted any due diligence.
Management: "We are always open to any acquisition opportunity provided for two things. 1) If it comes at the right value one and 2) it makes synergistic sense for this. So, the asset which you are talking of yes does make lot of synergistic sense, but if it comes at the right price certainly why not."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA/ton improvement | ₹300/ton total, 60% (~₹180/ton) captured | By Q4 FY24 (balance in Q1-Q2 FY25) |
| FY24 EBITDA/ton target | ~₹800/ton | FY24 |
| Clinker availability from UCWL | Clinker production begins | December 2023 (preponed from Q4) |
| UCWL grinding unit | Commissioning | Q3 FY24 (postponed one quarter) |
| Putty plant at Alwar | ~1 lakh ton capacity, ₹65-₹70 cr capex | October 2023 |
| TSR increase (phase-1) | From 4% to 10% | October/November 2023 |
| TSR increase (phase-2) | From 10% to 16% | Following year (FY25) |
| Durg Brownfield expansion decision | Go/no-go call | FY24 |
| UCWL expansion decision | Go/no-go call | ~One year after Durg (FY25) |
| Udaipur expansion trigger | Announcement upon railway siding visibility | No date (conditional on siding) |
| Volume growth | 19% cement sales growth | FY24 |
| Green bond issuance | ₹200 crore for WHR, solar, TSR projects | Not specified |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated cement sales volume | 31.56 lakh tons, total consol sales 33.88 lakh tons including clinker |
| Standalone cement sales growth (FY23) | 12%, from 0.91 cr tons to 1.02 cr tons |
| Consolidated cement sales growth (FY23) | 11% |
| Trade share | 55% for FY23; 52% in Jan, 54% in Feb, 60% in Mar |
| Premium product share of trade volume | 26% in Q4, up from 24% in Jan to 27% in Mar |
| Lead distance | ~400 km for Q4; 398 km for FY23 |
| Non-cement revenue | ₹128 cr for Q4; ₹478 cr for FY23 |
| RMC revenue | ₹62 cr for Q4; ₹225 cr for FY23 |
| Non-cement EBITDA margin | 5% |
| Fuel cost (kilocal) | 2.42 in Q4; forecast ~2.31–2.3 for Q1 FY24 |
| Fuel mix | 30% coal, 53% petcoke, 17% others |
| Clinker production | 17.28 lakh tons in Q4; 67.16 lakh tons for FY23 |
| Clinker utilization | ~100% |
| EBITDA per ton | ~₹700 for FY23; targeting ₹800 in FY24, ₹1,000 by FY25 |
| Cement volume growth target (FY24) | 19% |
| UCWL rights issue size | ₹450 cr, JK Lakshmi holds 72% |
| UCWL peak debt expected | ~₹1,500 cr (₹1,600 cr minus ₹100 cr repayment) |
| UCWL project CAPEX spent | ₹850 cr up to now; balance ~₹800 cr (₹500 cr in FY24, ₹300 cr in FY25) |
| JK Lakshmi standalone CAPEX (FY24) | ~₹200 cr |
| AFR / TSR | 4% currently; Phase-1 target 10% by Oct–Dec 2023, Phase-2 target 16% next year |
| Green bond issuance | ₹200 cr for green projects (WHR, AFR, solar) |
| Receivables (standalone) | ~₹60 cr vs ~₹34–35 cr last year |