Key Takeaways
- Volume deliberately trimmed, not lost: Q4 consolidated volume was nearly flat because management stopped selling from a Punjab outsourced grinding unit and cut low-margin Amethi volume, not because of weak demand. Standalone utilization hit 89% with an optimal 66:34 blended-to-OPC mix.
- EBITDA per ton gap is closing: An 18-month effort to bridge the margin gap with peers is now yielding results, with multiple cost levers still ramping.
- Capacity-led volume growth of ~10%+ targeted for FY25: The newly commissioned Udaipur grinding station (0.25 cr tons) plus Surat expansion (0.14 cr tons coming by Q4) underpin a 70% consolidated utilization target, excluding outsourced units.
- Power and fuel costs have likely bottomed: Management sees international pet coke and coal prices as range-bound to slightly up, with geopolitical supply chain risks persisting.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-election demand and price recovery materializes as management expects, the pace of TSR improvement toward the ~10% consolidated target, and progress on the Durg railway siding (September commissioning).
Volume & the Outsourcing Reset
- Q4 volume was managed, not market-driven: Consolidated volume was almost flat YoY because the company deliberately stopped selling from an outsourced grinding station in Punjab (taken over by another player) and substantially reduced volume from the Amethi outsourced plant, where margins were unsatisfactory.
- Standalone performance was tight: JK Lakshmi standalone utilization reached 89% in Q4, with a 66:34 blended-to-OPC ratio that management called optimal. Udaipur Cement Works grew volume 33%, making consolidated the right lens for growth.
- FY24 consolidated volume grew ~5%: The full-year figure reflects the deliberate Q4 trim; management declined to give standalone volume guidance for FY25, pointing investors to the consolidated level.
- FY25 volume growth target is ~10%+: With 0.4 crore tons of additional capacity (0.25 from Udaipur grinding already commissioned, 0.14 from Surat expansion coming in Q4), management targets 70% consolidated utilization in FY25 and 80% in FY26, both excluding outsourced units.
Cost Levers & Margin Bridge
- The 18-month margin catch-up is working: Management has been trying to bridge the EBITDA-per-ton gap with competitors, and efforts across multiple areas are now well-directional and yielding advantage.
- TSR is the headline cost lever: Q4 TSR reached 11.27%, up from 4.11% in FY23 and 7.01% last quarter. The FY25 target is ~10% consolidated average (JKLC >12%, Udaipur ~7-8%), a 4-percentage-point increase. TSR costs about 1.2x versus conventional fuel at 1.8x+, with blended at ~1.68x.
- Renewable energy expansion underway: Another 7-megawatt solar capacity addition is planned at Sirohi, with other locations under planning.
- AFR facility at Udaipur commissioning September: This adds another lever to reduce fuel costs and carbon footprint. The first phase of AFR is already concluded.
- Cement-to-clinker ratio improving: The ratio moved from ~1.43-1.44 in FY23 to 1.46 in FY24, with an endeavor to reach close to 1.5, further reducing clinker cost per ton of cement sold.
- Non-cement revenue is small and low-margin: Q4 non-cement revenue was Rs. 154 crores (RMC Rs. 86 cr, AAC Rs. 68 cr, POP Rs. 21 cr) with an EBITDA margin of just 5%.
Shukla: "We are a very responsible corporate and we have committed to be carbon neutral by 2047. So, in a way, this is also going to help us to reduce our carbon footprint. So, over and above, cost efficiency is also kind of renders our responsibility towards our commitment to mitigate carbon footprint."
Pricing & Demand Environment
- Q4 pricing fell ~5% QoQ: Full-year FY24 pricing was down ~1.5% versus FY23. The trend has persisted into Q1 FY25 due to low demand during the national election period. Industry players have taken advantage of softening fuel costs and efficiencies.
- Post-election recovery is the base case: Management expects demand to improve once election results are out on June 4, with Q2 FY25 expected to be better than Q2 FY24. Prices are expected to inch up with demand improvement.
- West market pricing seen as rational: Management believes the West market will not behave irrationally and expects no radical change in price dynamics.
Management: "Once that election is over and results are out on 4th of June, demand will improve... Once demand improves, then prices also will inch up. This is what I believe because that is good dynamics of demand and price."
Power & Fuel: The Floor Is In
- Costs are not expected to fall further: International pet coke and imported coal prices are moving slightly upward, with geopolitical supply chain issues adding uncertainty. Management sees costs as range-bound or slightly up from here.
- This marks a shift in the tailwind: The fuel cost deflation that supported industry margins is ending, making self-help cost levers (TSR, renewable energy, AFR, blending ratio) the primary margin drivers going forward.
Management: "I don't think that that is going to go down further. Maybe this is going to be kind of around range bound, it will go a little bit up maybe or may be stable. That is what I see. But definitely is not going to go down from here."
Capacity Expansion Pipeline
| Project | Capacity / Scope | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Udaipur grinding station | 0.25 cr tons | Commissioned 28 March 2024 |
| Surat grinding unit expansion | Doubling to 0.27 cr tons (first phase 0.07 cr tons) | Phase 1: October 2024; Phase 2: March/April FY26 |
| Durg Railway Project | Clinker loading and dispatch hub | First phase concluding very soon; clinker loading already started |
| Durg conveyor belt (SAIL Bhilai) | Direct clinker transport from steel plant | Final approvals expected in 1-2 months; ~6 months to commission thereafter |
| Railway siding at Durg | Rail connectivity for clinker, inbound coal/gypsum | Commissioning September 2024 |
| Durg & Prayagraj grinding units | 1.2 MTPA each | Last quarter FY26 |
| Agrani Cement (Northeast) | Greenfield integrated plant, Rs. 1,500 cr project cost | Clearances by March/April 2025; 2-year construction; commissioning ~March/April 2027 |
- Railway siding unlocks market access and cost savings: Once commissioned in September 2024, the siding will replace costly road transport for clinker to Odisha and open access to Eastern MP, Bihar, and Jharkhand markets with better pricing and lower distribution cost. Inbound coal and gypsum logistics also benefit. Management has not yet quantified the savings.
- Northeast project is a long-dated call: Land acquisition and environmental clearances are still in process. Rs. 200 crores of the Rs. 1,500 crore project cost is due this year for the balance acquisition payment, with some land acquisition spend also likely. The balance capex falls in the next two years.
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Net debt will rise: Management acknowledged net debt will increase due to ~Rs. 4,000-odd crores of capex in the pipeline across multiple projects.
- Project-wise capex breakup not disclosed: When asked for a split across railway siding, WHRS, solar, maintenance, and expansion, management declined, saying it had not given a project-wise breakup.
- Consolidated clinker production figure was deflected: Management pointed to the press release rather than providing the number on the call.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidated volume growth | ~10%+ (excluding outsourced units) | FY25 |
| Consolidated capacity utilization | 70% | FY25 |
| Consolidated capacity utilization | 80% | FY26 |
| Consolidated TSR | ~10% average (JKLC >12%, Udaipur ~7-8%) | FY25 |
| Cement-to-clinker ratio | Close to 1.5x | No date; endeavor stated |
| AFR facility at Udaipur | Commissioning | September 2024 |
| Railway siding at Durg | Commissioning | September 2024 |
| Surat grinding unit Phase 1 | 0.07 cr tons operational | October 2024 |
| Surat grinding unit Phase 2 | Balance capacity operational | March/April FY26 |
| Durg & Prayagraj grinding units | 1.2 MTPA each commissioned | Last quarter FY26 |
| Agrani Cement greenfield | Commissioning | March/April 2027 (subject to clearances by March/April 2025) |
| Carbon neutrality | Net zero | By 2047 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | Non-cement revenue ₹154 cr |
| Non-cement EBITDA margin | 5% |
| Standalone cement capacity utilization | 89% |
| Consolidated volume growth (FY24) | ~5% YoY |
| Trade share | 56% |
| Blended cement share | 66% |
| Cement-to-clinker ratio (FY24) | 1.46, improved from ~1.43-1.44 in FY23 |
| Power & fuel cost per Kcal | ₹1.68 |
| Power consumption | 69 units per ton of cement |
| TSR (group level, FY24) | 7%, up from 4% in FY23; Q4 alone was 11.27% |
| Renewable energy share (group level) | 47% in Q4; JKLC 39%, Udaipur 46% |
| Lead distance | 372 km, reduction of more than 25 km YoY |
| Udaipur Cement Works Q4 sales volume | 7.56 lakh tons (cement 6.42, clinker 1.14) |
| Consolidated clinker sales (FY24) | 8.7 lakh tons; no clinker purchases |
| FY25 CAPEX guidance (JK Lakshmi) | ₹1,200 cr, including ₹600 cr for Durg expansion |
| FY26 CAPEX guidance (JK Lakshmi) | ₹1,000 cr |
| Durg expansion total cost | ₹2,500 cr for 0.23 cr clinker and 0.46 cr cement capacity |
| Northeast greenfield project total outlay | ~₹1,800 cr (₹1,500 cr project cost plus ₹325 cr acquisition) |
| FY25 consolidated volume growth target | ~10% plus, targeting 70% utilization |
| Q4 cement price trend | Down ~5% QoQ; FY24 prices down ~1.5% vs FY23 |
| Q1 FY25 price trend | Down ~1% to 1.3% vs Q4 FY24 average |