Key Takeaways
- Toughest NPA quarter, recovery promised: GNPA rose as elections and heat waves stalled collections and SARFAESI proceedings, but management calls it the trough and expects improvement from Q2 onward.
- Deposit engine firing: Deposits grew 41% YoY and CASA ratio crossed 20%, driven by new senior citizen and HNI products in a seasonally slow quarter.
- Secured pivot accelerates: Secured assets grew 8% QoQ while unsecured shrank 1%, moving the mix to 62% secured with a stated target of 80%.
- PAT held up despite provisioning: PAT of ₹171 crore came after building an additional ₹54 crore provision buffer, reflecting a deliberate choice to strengthen the balance sheet as the bank grows.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether secured NPA normalizes as SARFAESI resumes, whether BC partners deliver on their collection guarantees, and the pace of unsecured stabilization.
Asset Quality: The Quarter’s Central Story
- Secured NPA spike was operational, not credit-driven: Secured GNPA doubled from ₹90 crore to ₹181 crore because elections and heat waves paralyzed SARFAESI proceedings, court processes, and police assistance for repossession. With portfolio LTV at 57%, management expects recovery to normalize in Q2.
- BC book stress concentrated in specific pockets: BC microfinance GNPA rose ₹56 crore (₹114 crore to ₹170 crore), attributed to certain geographies, discipline issues, and possibly faster growth by some BC partners. BCs carry collection and service guarantees backed by deposits, and management is confident they will resolve it next quarter.
- Own unsecured book stayed stable: Unsecured NPA rose only ₹4 crore (₹291 crore to ₹295 crore) because the bank never grew this book fast, with unsecured CAGR at roughly 2% from March 2018 to March 2024.
- Collection trajectory improving: April and May were tougher; June got better; July got even better. Q1 recovery run rate of ~₹35 crore is expected to hold or improve through the remaining three quarters.
- Group loan NPA drop had mixed drivers: The decline from 7.1% to 1.2% reflects both recovery (last year ~₹200 crore recovered) and a ~₹50 crore technical write-off, per management, not write-offs alone.
- Credit cost expected to decline: The 1.89% credit cost includes precautionary provisioning that takes future provisions into the present. Some recovery flows through other income (fully written-off accounts), so the provision number alone overstates the net cost.
Kanwal: "This will be our toughest NPA quarter or this was our toughest NPA quarter. Things will only get better from here."
Deposit Franchise & Liability Build-Out
- CASA crossed the 20% threshold: CASA grew 9% QoQ versus 4% for term deposits, lifting the ratio from 19.7% to 20.4% in what is normally a slow quarter for deposits.
- New products are landing: The Legend product for senior citizens (offering monthly interest at 8.25%) and exclusive HNI programs acquired nearly 5,000 HNIs in the quarter, both contributing to CASA growth.
- Affluent branch model being tested: A Khar branch in Mumbai is being built as a large liability branch targeting ₹2,000–₹3,000 crore in deposits, with a focus on transactional CASA and digital marketing.
- Deposit concentration flagged but not detailed: The 20 largest depositors account for 20.7% of deposits; management noted 96.6% of bulk deposits are non-callable and 90.7% are one year or longer, but did not characterize the nature of those depositors.
Secured Pivot & Portfolio Reshaping
- Mix shift is deliberate and accelerating: Secured assets grew 8% QoQ while unsecured declined 1%, moving the secured share from 60% to 62%. The stated target is 80% secured.
- Home 360 anchors the cross-sell strategy: The affordable housing loan now serves as an anchor product to sell two-wheelers (100% LTV), pre-approved business loans up to ₹5 lakh, and other products to the same customer.
- Unsecured growth will stay disciplined: Management is explicit that if more challenge appears in unsecured, the bank will continue to grow negative. Unsecured CAGR from March 2018 to March 2024 was roughly 2%, a strategic choice.
- Microfinance growth to stay muted: Future microfinance growth will be "very small single-digit sensible growth," and the urban microfinance group model is a firm no.
Kanwal: "I can tell you with great amount of comfort that if we see more challenge in this business, we will continue to grow negative. If we need to do that, we will certainly do it."
BC Book: The Strategy’s Stress Test
- BC book is 8%–9% of the total book by design: The model pays BCs a higher percentage of revenue than the bank would earn on its own, but this pays off during stress because the bank’s team stays focused on secured business while BCs manage collections.
- BC book GNPA is ~8% versus the bank’s own ~3%: The gap exists because the bank was highly selective and had negative growth in its own microfinance book between March 2018 and March 2024, while BCs grew faster and faced pressure from other lenders in some geographies.
- BC guarantees provide a backstop: Contractually, BCs provide service guarantees of 4%–5% backed by deposits. Management does not believe the current environment will exhaust those guarantees, noting that only during COVID did 2–3 BCs go beyond their provided guarantee.
- Recovery timeline is 6–12 months: BCs are expected to recover at least 2%–3% back, though not necessarily in the next 3–6 months. The book is not expected to get worse from here.
Kanwal: "And remember to get this small stress out of the way, we didn't have to pay a premium all these years because we were shelling out the percentage of our revenue to these BCs higher than what we would have made as a bank. And that has all come through today because in the time of stress, like I said, the team is still focused on what they need to do in secured etc. and our minds are not getting wavered somewhere else."
Margins, Profitability & Capital
- NIM held at 8% despite funding cost pressure: Cost of funds rose from 7.5% to 8.0% YoY, but NIM improved from 7.6% to 8.0% due to improved asset mix and lower interest in suspense. QoQ NIM was marginally down from 8.1% due to slightly elevated NPA.
- Cost-to-income improved to 55.5% from 58% in Q1 last year, with more operating leverage expected through the year.
- Provision buffer built deliberately: PAT of ₹171 crore was after creating an additional ₹54 crore provision and adding net DTA of ₹10 crore. Management chose to continue building a good provision buffer as the bank grows.
- No tax until 2027: PBT equals PAT until then, supporting capital generation.
- ECL preparedness already in place: Provision cover on unsecured is 80%, and loss-given-default calculations show a number "a lot lower" than 80%. No anticipated incremental ECL provision on either unsecured or secured.
Kanwal: "Raman has given a straight answer, Shailesh, which is irrespective of what we are doing, even as you speak, we are well covered for an ECL guideline to come in."
Universal Bank & Structural Milestones
- Universal Bank application within reach: The bank has met the one-year hurdle of 0.5% net NPA last year. If net NPA stays below 1% this year, all conditions are met to apply next year. Management is very certain net NPA will be below 1% by March 2025.
- Brand royalty renegotiated and capped: The Jana brand royalty contract was renegotiated and approved by shareholders. The new contract starts 1 November 2024 at ₹3.81 crore plus GST, static with no escalation. The bank is not forced to use the brand and may consider rebranding next year or when turning Universal.
- CGTMSE guarantee program to cover unsecured: From September, some individual loan customers who are small businesses (Udyam registered) will join the CGTMSE guarantee program with SIDBI at a cost of 0.3%–0.5%. This will become "not an insignificant number" in the next 12–24 months.
- Branch network rationalized: Several unbanked rural branches that were not working were closed, reducing outlets from 808 to 780. UBR percentage remains at 34.4%, above the 25% norm for scheduled commercial banks.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| PAT growth | 30%–40% | FY25 |
| AUM growth | 20% | FY25 |
| Deposit growth | 20% | FY25 |
| Secured asset mix | Move toward 80% secured | No date (strategy underway) |
| Net NPA | Below 1% | By March 2025 |
| Universal Bank application | Apply if net NPA below 1% | Next year (FY26) |
| BC book stress | BC partners to resolve; not expected to worsen | Next quarter (Q2 FY25) |
| Secured NPA normalization | SARFAESI and collections to improve | Q2 FY25 |
| Credit cost | Expected to go lower from 1.89% | As stabilization is seen |
| Unsecured growth | Will grow negative if more challenge seen | Ongoing discipline |
| CGTMSE coverage | "Not an insignificant number" of unsecured book under guarantee | Next 12–24 months |
| Brand royalty | ₹3.81 crore + GST, static, no escalation | From 1 November 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| PAT | ₹171 crore, after additional provision of ₹54 crore and net DTA of ₹10 crore |
| PBT growth | 77% YoY |
| ROA | 2.1% for the quarter |
| ROE | 18.8% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 55.5%, vs 58.0% in Q1 FY24 and 57.4% for full FY24 |
| NIM | 8.0%, up from 7.6% YoY; marginally down from 8.1% QoQ |
| Cost of funds | 8.0%, up from 7.5% YoY and 7.8% QoQ |
| Advances growth | 25% YoY, 4% QoQ |
| Deposit growth | 41% YoY, 5% QoQ |
| CASA growth | 47% YoY, 9% QoQ |
| CASA ratio | 20.4%, up from 19.7% in March |
| Secured asset composition | 62% of total advances, up from 60% in March |
| Secured asset QoQ growth | 8% |
| Unsecured asset QoQ growth | minus 1% |
| Capital adequacy | 19.3% (Tier 1 at 18.2%); 20.2% if Q1 PAT included |
| LCR | 296% |
| Gross NPA | 2.5% overall; BC book at 7.8%, secured book at 1.1% (up from 0.6% in March) |
| Net NPA | 61% of net NPA is secured loans |
| Provision coverage ratio | 62.7% |
| Net credit cost (annualized) | 1.89% of AUM, vs 1.96% in March quarter and 2.78% a year ago |
| Technical write-off (Q1) | ~₹50 crore |
| Recovery run rate (Q1) | ~₹35 crore |
| LDR | 102%, reduced from 109% |
| Retail deposit proportion | 65% of total deposits |
| Bulk deposits non-callable | 96.6% |
| Bulk deposits one year and above | 90.7% |
| Number of outlets | 780, down from 808 |
| Micro LAP book | ₹4,910 crore, average ticket size ₹6.3 lakhs |
| Affordable housing book | ₹4,738 crore |
| MSME book | ₹3,486 crore, grew 5% QoQ |
| Unsecured advances QoQ growth | minus 1.2% |
| BC book size | ~₹2,189 crore |
| BC book average ticket size | ₹27,664 |
| BC service guarantee | 4% to 5% of BC book, contractually |
| Individual loan gross NPA | 4.4%, net NPA 0.7% |
| Agri loan gross NPA | 3.2% |
| Average products per customer (Home 360) | 3.6 |
| CASA penetration (housing and micro LAP customers) | 99% |
| Average balance (housing/micro LAP customer accounts) | ₹16,100 |
| Digital transactions | 98% of transactions conducted digitally |
| Loans digitally processed | 92% |
| Brand royalty cost (new contract from Nov 2024) | ₹3.81 crore plus GST annually, static with no escalation |