Key Takeaways
- Core business delivers, new initiatives wait: Revenue growth was driven by healthier collections, with full-year FY23 collections up 44.3% YoY. Management is prioritizing the core search business to generate healthy free cash flows, while new transactional platforms are technologically ready but will only scale when unit economics make sense.
- Traffic surge supports monetization thesis: A revamp of mobile and desktop platforms, plus richer search content, has driven impressive organic traffic growth. Management is confident this will support monetization in coming quarters.
- Margins set to improve from here: Employee costs jumped 22.6% YoY on headcount, incentives and increments, but headcount has been flattish for three quarters and cost ratios are expected to moderate, driving margin improvement through the year.
- Cash pile strategy remains undefined: The company holds INR4,160 crores in cash, optimized for near-term tax efficiency, but has made no decision on distribution versus deployment for organic or inorganic opportunities.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the MyJio integration goes live and delivers a traffic bump, the pace of employee cost moderation, and any signal on capital allocation from the Board.
Core Search Business & Monetization
- Revenue engine: Growth is driven by healthier collections, with second-half FY23 collections up ~56% YoY. The company targets 20-25% sustainable top-line growth as a mix of paid campaign growth and ticket size increases.
- Realization upside: Average realization is ~INR1,500 per campaign per month, which management calls highly affordable. Ticket size growth of 12-18% is the target, with mid-teens realization growth expected.
- Traffic tailwind: A recent revamp of mobile and desktop platforms, plus richer content on search pages, has driven impressive traffic trends. Organic traffic is growing healthily, which management calls a positive for monetization.
- Tier 2/3 catch-up: Non-top 11 markets are growing 46-47% YoY versus 25% for the top 11, partly due to a base effect. These markets were entered with entry-level pricing and have significant scope to raise realizations toward Tier 1 levels.
- Seasonality note: Q4 is historically the strongest quarter for monetization as many SME customers renew annual subscriptions in March. Q1 typically starts weaker, and deferred revenue has even dipped sequentially in past Q1 periods.
- B2B ambition: B2B revenue is expected to grow faster than B2C over the next 2-3 years, with higher realization growth because B2B ticket sizes are much lower than industry benchmarks.
Bansal: "So organic, what we call as free traffic has been growing very healthily for us, which is a positive."
Cost Structure & Margin Path
- Employee cost spike: Employee expenses rose 22.6% YoY due to a ~9% headcount increase, revenue-linked incentives and increments. The sequential increase in Q1 was "a bit chunky," led partly by increments.
- Cost moderation ahead: Headcount has been flattish for the past three quarters, and management does not expect meaningful sales headcount additions for the next 1-2 quarters. Employee cost as a percentage of revenue should moderate going forward.
- Second-half variables: The second half could see headcount additions, especially in sales, plus additional revenue-linked incentive costs. Increments due in Q3 should not meaningfully increase costs.
- Other income normalization: Other income stood at INR81.4 crores versus a loss of INR60 crores in the same quarter last year, when rising bond yields had hit mark-to-market treasury gains.
- Tax rate detail: The effective tax rate was higher at 21.4% because the bulk of treasury MTM gains are short-term in nature and provisioned at short-term capital gains slabs. A tax strategy shift just before March 31 locked in higher yields; after three years, when gains become long-term, the effective rate should drop to ~12-13%.
Bansal: "pre-COVID, this business used to generate about 25% plus EBITDA margins. We have been able to achieve our pre-COVID numbers or surpass those numbers for traffic"
New Initiatives: Ready but on Hold
- Platform readiness achieved: The first phase of new initiatives, platform readiness for JD Shopping, JD Xperts and JD Real Estate, is complete. These platforms now have the capability to get products delivered or services fulfilled.
- Capitalization shift: About INR30 crores of intangible assets under development were shifted to fixed assets and are now being depreciated. Only ~INR1 crore was capitalized this quarter, and no further intangible asset-related costs are expected to hit from coming quarters.
- Scaling discipline: Management will not scale these platforms until visible unit economics exist in the medium-term. The Xperts platform has delivered over 100,000 bookings in the last 3-4 quarters, but the company sees no business sense in spending INR200 to earn INR100 on each transaction.
- No big-bang launch: There will be no large advertising spend to drive adoption. The platforms are technologically ready, but the focus remains on the core business generating healthy free cash flows.
- Xperts economics: The typical expected take rate is 20-25%. The biggest cost is advertising to acquire first-time and repeat users. Management declined to provide customer acquisition cost figures, saying it is not appropriate to evaluate these numbers while platforms are in pilot/beta stage.
Bansal: "Whether we think that to earn INR100, we should be spending INR200 on each transaction, at this point of time, we don't think that makes business sense."
Reliance Integration & Strategic Levers
- MyJio integration imminent: Integration with the MyJio app is in "almost final stages" and likely to go live soon. Other integrations with Reliance Group transaction-led platforms are in the pipeline.
- Rich content rollout: Service catalogs for businesses, price points and other rich content in listings will roll out through the year, supporting both traffic and monetization.
- Sales footprint: The company covers most meaningful areas pan-India. The difference versus pre-COVID is density of feet on the street in existing geographies, not entry into new geographies.
Capital Allocation
- Cash position: The company holds INR4,160 crores in cash. The treasury has been optimized to earn about seven quarters of tax-efficient yield, but no decision has been made on distributing cash to shareholders or deploying it for opportunities.
- No buyback discussion: Management has not put any thoughts around a share buyback and said it would not be prudent to comment on whether that is the right strategy. The Board will discuss capital allocation in future quarters.
- Inorganic optionality: Nothing is on the table on the inorganic side as of now, but cash could be utilized for organic or possibly inorganic opportunities in the future.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 20-25% sustainable top-line growth, mix of ticket size and campaign growth | Ongoing, full-year target |
| Ticket size growth | 12-18% average realization growth | Ongoing |
| EBITDA margin | 25%+ margins, achievable with 25% revenue growth and no substantial cost changes | By end of FY24 |
| Employee cost ratio | Moderation expected from Q1 levels | Coming quarters |
| Sales headcount | No meaningful increase | Next 1-2 quarters |
| B2B vs B2C growth | B2B revenue growth and realization growth to outpace B2C | Next 2-3 years |
| New initiatives spending | No material spend until visible unit economics exist | Medium-term, undated |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Operating revenue | ₹247 cr, 33.1% YoY and 6.2% QoQ |
| Adjusted EBITDA | ₹36.3 cr, margin of 14.7% |
| Profit before tax | ₹106.1 cr, 10.6% QoQ |
| Profit after tax | ₹83.4 cr, versus loss of ₹48.4 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| Effective tax rate | 21.4%, higher due to short-term capital gains provisioning on MTM gains |
| Other income | ₹81.4 cr, versus loss of ₹60 cr in Q1 FY23 |
| Employee expenses | +22.6% YoY, led by ~9% headcount increase, revenue-linked incentives, and increments |
| Advertising expenses | ₹5.4 cr |
| Cash and investments | ₹4,159 cr at quarter end |
| Deferred revenue | ~₹450 cr, all-time high, +27.5% YoY |
| Active paid campaigns | ~548,000, +13.4% YoY, +10,000 QoQ |
| Monthly ECS collection | ~₹47 cr per month, versus ₹33 cr a year ago |
| Total traffic | 17.14 cr unique users, +16% YoY and +7.6% QoQ |
| Mobile traffic | 14.65 cr users, +17.5% YoY |
| Revenue split: top 11 cities | ~60% of revenue, grew ~25% YoY |
| Revenue split: non-top 11 cities | ~40% of revenue, grew ~46-47% YoY |
| B2B revenue contribution | ~26% for the quarter |
| B2B campaigns | ~120,000-125,000, ~22% of total campaigns |
| Monthly plan sign-ups | ~68% of contracts sold |
| Average realization per campaign | ~₹1,500 per month |
| Tier 2/3 realization vs Tier 1 | ~45% of Tier 1 levels |
| Q1 collections | ~₹258 cr, +27-28% YoY |
| JD Xperts bookings | 100,000+ delivered in last 3-4 quarters |