Key Takeaways
- Watch slowdown masks Eigen strength: Watch Components growth decelerated in Q4 on global discretionary weakness, but Precision Engineering (Eigen) grew 25% to INR95 cr with a strong order position, and the new bracelet plant is set to begin commercial production.
- China Plus One is real and KDDL is a beneficiary: Swiss brands actively seek production bases outside China, and KDDL's new steel bracelet factory, India's first, is a direct consequence, with more business expected.
- Eigen targets 20-25% CAGR over several years: Growth will be steady, not a kick-start, and the deliberate customer-by-customer ramp builds a strong competitive moat, though the INR100 cr to INR500 cr journey will take longer than 2-3 years.
- Estima turnaround delayed by a year: The Swiss subsidiary's path to profitability has been pushed out due to an unexpected slowdown in the Swiss watch business, and an impairment provision was taken on the investment.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of bracelet project commercial ramp-up, any stabilization in watch component demand, and the Favre-Leuba global launch timeline in the last quarter of the year.
Precision Engineering (Eigen): The Growth Engine
- 25% revenue growth, export-led: Revenue reached INR95 cr with exports comprising over 70% of the total, and all business segments are witnessing good growth with a strong order position.
- End-industry mix concentrated in growth sectors: Electronics, aerospace, alternative energy and electric vehicles together make up 80% of the business, with alternative energy and EVs expected to grow fastest. Aerospace has been anticipated to take off for 7-8 quarters but has not yet materialized.
- Growth trajectory is steady, not explosive: Management targets a 20-25% CAGR over the next three to five years, but cautions that B2B precision engineering requires building customer relationships from small orders upward, so the INR100 cr to INR500 cr journey will take longer than 2-3 years.
- The moat is built into the model: Each new customer and product requires a dedicated take-off period, which makes the business hard to displace once established. Management prioritizes excellence and quality over chasing a growth number, and growth follows.
- Margins are good but will dilute the mix: Precision engineering margins are lower than watch component margins for now, and because Eigen will grow faster this year, a slight decrease in overall weighted average margin is expected.
- Capex and expansion plans in motion: Factory space expansion and new capability investments are planned in and around Bangalore, with internal funds expected to be largely sufficient. Management is not in favour of expanding to too many locations.
Yashovardhan Saboo: "The important point is that because growing this business requires such a dedicated take-off period, it also builds a very strong moat. So once we have established ourselves with a customer, it is very difficult for someone else to break in."
The Bracelet Project & China Plus One
- India's first steel bracelet factory is ready: The new Bangalore plant has completed trial production and supplies, which were received very well, and commercial production will start very soon. 100% of production will be exported.
- China Plus One is a structural shift, not a rush: Management describes the discussion as "very real," with Swiss brands' mindset shifting toward reducing dependence on China. KDDL has been acclaimed as an alternative for watch components and expects more business to come.
- Ramp-up will be gradual: Reaching the 75,000-unit capacity will take time due to the high skill requirements for finishing and the tool and jig preparation needed for each design. An expansion plan for the bracelet project will probably be discussed soon.
- Watch cases are the next logical step: No high-quality steel watch case factory exists in India, and most global supply comes from Switzerland, China and a few in Thailand. Management plans to move toward setting up watch case manufacturing probably in FY26, not FY25.
Yashovardhan Saboo: "More so for Swiss brands the largest production and purchase is from China. And this structure is one of the consequences of the wish of many brands to establish a production base outside China, there is the so-called China Plus One policy. And we have obviously benefited from this and will continue to have more business coming our way."
Watch Components: Near-Term Headwinds
- Q4 slowdown on global discretionary weakness: Revenue grew 10% to INR247 cr for FY24, but growth decelerated in the last quarter due to market correction and watch sales slowdown in China, Europe and the Middle East. Geopolitical strains and sluggish Chinese demand predict subdued consumer sentiment for discretionary products over the next few months.
- Dials and hands segment modernization: No expansion is planned, but the company is investing in new technologies including lasers and new surface treatment methods to remain at the cutting edge. Management declined to give capacity utilization figures, citing huge diversity in product types and price ranges.
Estima AG & Silvercity Brands: The Swiss Story
- Estima turnaround delayed: The Swiss subsidiary's revenue growth was good and losses decreased, but it remains unprofitable. The turnaround is now expected to be delayed by about a year due to an unexpected slowing in the Swiss watch business. An impairment provision was taken on the investment held through Kamla International Holdings and Pylania SA.
- New leadership installed: Mr. Michel Pauli, an experienced technology and business leader, has joined as Managing Director, and several changes have been made to the operating and leadership team.
- Favre-Leuba acquisition and global relaunch: The iconic Swiss-made watch brand was acquired by Silvercity Brands, which became a subsidiary earlier this year with equity capital increased to CHF 0.6 cr. A global launch of completely new collections is scheduled for the last quarter of this year.
- Manufacturing structure still evolving: Manufacturing will be in Switzerland to retain the Swiss-made designation, but the allocation of production across Silvercity Brands, Estima, or a potential joint venture with a traditional Swiss company has not yet been determined.
- Brand building is a 3-5 year journey: Management expects a 3-5 year period to establish the brand globally before meaningful growth follows.
Yashovardhan Saboo: "What we do know is -- or increasingly, the manufacturing will be in Switzerland, and it will remain a Swiss made watch. But we can't determine right now that which watch will be produced in SCB, which part will be produced in ESTIMA or this part will be produced -- there could be the possibility of a joint venture."
Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns
- Ethos stake sale generated INR193 cr: KDDL received approximately INR122 cr from a direct stake sale plus INR72 cr as a dividend from Mahen Distribution Limited. The company will continue to maintain a majority stake in Ethos, but whether there will be further stake sales cannot be said right now.
- Dividends and reinvestment: A final dividend of INR4 per share is proposed, in addition to an interim dividend of INR58 per share already paid. Post-dividend, approximately INR100 cr of investable surplus is planned for growth and development, including finding ways to reward shareholders.
- Capex of INR45 cr planned for the current year: This covers all businesses. Discussions are ongoing for a judicious combination of rewarding shareholders and investing in the future, with capex plans in Eigen, modernization, and new projects on the anvil.
Ornamental Packaging & Other Segments
- Packaging revenue up 18% to INR15 cr: Growth was driven by a strong improvement in domestic demand. A new facility near Chandigarh is being established, and management believes the segment can develop into an INR80-100 cr business over the next 5 to 7 years.
- Management engagement model: The company declined to hold regular quarterly calls, arguing the business does not change quarterly, but offered to organize factory visits with full-day discussions at least 2-3 times every year.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Precision engineering growth | Maintain 20-25% CAGR | Over the next 3-5 years |
| Bracelet project commercial production | Start commercial production at the new Bangalore plant | Very soon (post-Q4 FY24) |
| Favre-Leuba global launch | Launch revamped watches with completely new collections globally | Last quarter of this year (CY24) |
| Estima turnaround | Achieve profitability | Delayed by approximately one year from prior expectation |
| Watch cases entry | Move toward setting up and getting into watch cases | Probably FY26, not FY25 |
| Packaging segment growth | Develop into INR80-100 cr business | Over the next 5-7 years |
| Capex for current year | Approximately INR45 cr across all businesses | Current running year (FY25) |
| Factory visits for investors | Organize full-day factory visits with discussion and analysis | At least 2-3 times every year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated total income | ₹357 cr, up 16% YoY from ₹307 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹70 cr, 19.6% margin, grew 42% YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹34.8 cr, up 64% YoY from ₹21.7 cr |
| Standalone total income | ₹89 cr, up 2% YoY from ₹87 cr |
| Standalone EBITDA | ₹27.1 cr, 30.4% margin, improved 4.3 ppt YoY |
| Standalone PBT before exceptional items | ₹21.6 cr, up 27% YoY |
| FY25 capex guidance (KDDL only) | ₹45 cr, over and above ₹34 cr CWIP for bracelet plant |
| Final dividend per share | ₹4, in addition to interim dividend of ₹58 per share |
| Investable surplus post dividend | ~₹100 cr |
| Watch Components segment FY24 revenue | ₹247 cr, up 10% YoY from ₹224 cr |
| Precision Engineering (Eigen) FY24 revenue | ₹95 cr, up 25% YoY from ₹75 cr |
| Precision Engineering Q4 revenue | ~₹26 cr |
| Ornamental Packaging segment FY24 revenue | ₹15 cr, up 18% YoY from ₹12.7 cr |
| Eigen growth outlook | 20% to 25% CAGR over next several years |
| Bracelet plant capacity | 75,000 bracelets per year, capex of ~₹35 cr incurred |