Key Takeaways
- Sharp profitability turnaround: Net profit swung to ₹3.3 crore from a ₹10.8 crore loss YoY, driven by a 596 bps gross margin jump and retail demand recovery.
- Retail gross margin hits record: Retail gross margin reached 54.1%, up from 50.6% YoY, fueled by premiumization, price increases, and value engineering; management sees room for ~100 bps annual expansion.
- Two-speed consumer reality: Retail demand is resilient because Khadim's affordability-fasion mix has few competitors at its price point, while distribution faces pressure as lower-income consumers juggle essential inflation against branded purchases.
- FY23 guidance reiterated: Revenue target of ₹800 crore (gross, including GST) and 12% EBITDA margin, with a path to 14-15% EBITDA by FY25 as operating leverage kicks in.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether festive season demand materializes given weak monsoons in the East, and whether elevated inventory (104 days) normalizes post-festive as planned.
Profitability Recovery
- Gross margin leap: Overall gross margin rose 596 bps YoY to 41.3%, the highest in company history and now comparable to industry standards for apparel and footwear retail.
- Three drivers of margin: ASP increase via premiumization (retail ASP moved from ~₹500 pre-COVID to ~₹600), requisite price increases to offset raw material and GST hikes, and value engineering to reduce product cost while maintaining fashion and quality.
- EBITDA swing: EBITDA reached ₹17 crore versus a loss of ₹36 lakhs in Q1 FY22, an encouraging recovery that management expects to strengthen through the festive season.
- Employee cost normalization: Salary costs rose as the company moved from COVID-era deductions (75% paid in Q1 last year) to full salary from October 2021, plus annual increments; this headwind is now fully absorbed.
- Other expenses normalizing: Selling costs rose with sales recovery, and travel expenses returned to pre-COVID levels, reflecting a business returning to normal operations.
Chotrani: "The way we talk about it internally is that we look at fashion the way it is working across the country, across the world. We analyze fashion, analyze color, analyze fashion trend, and we try figuring how to Khadimize it."
Retail vs Distribution: Two Divergent Stories
- Retail resilience: Inflation impact on retail was relatively muted because Khadim's core strength is affordability plus fashion; management stated no other brand offers the same product mix at Khadim's price point, a claim based on competitive reconnaissance across most brands.
- Distribution pressure: The distribution consumer (SEC B/C, Tier II/III towns) faces higher essential costs for atta, sugar, and tea without income growth, forcing choices between branded and non-branded footwear; 80% of the distribution product mix is below ₹500.
- Different margin strategies: Retail margin expansion comes from ASP increase and premiumization; distribution margin improvement will come from volume growth and operating leverage, not ASP hikes, because the price-sensitive consumer limits pricing power.
- Sub-brand mix shifting: Khadim mother brand contribution moved from ~50% pre-COVID to ~56% now, while sub-brands dropped from ~50% to ~43%; sport shoes remain the largest sub-brand after the mother brand.
- Retail revenue target: Management expects retail sales to recover to pre-COVID levels of approximately ₹500 crore this fiscal year.
Chotrani: "On the retail side, I don't think there's any other brand that is able to offer the kind of product mix at the price point that we are offering. It is with utmost modesty that I'm stating that because we've done the recce across most brands."
Store Expansion & Geographic Strategy
- Network growth: Store count reached 796 with 25 additions in the quarter; the plan is to add 70-80 new EBOs per year, with almost 90% as franchisee-operated stores.
- Geographic split: Approximately 60% of new stores open in the East (home market), 20-25% in the South, and the balance in North and West; 65% of total stores are already in East and South.
- Seeding new markets: The company is opening stores in Punjab and Ghaziabad with good early response, but the philosophy is to lay seeds now for future penetration rather than attempting rapid expansion in unfamiliar states; concentration risk in any single franchisee partner is also a consideration.
- Category demand returning: Workwear and school shoe demand has come back significantly, athleisure continues to be strong, and pent-up demand is expected to create periodic spurts across categories.
Chotrani: "When you're trying to open a franchisee, if you are too concentrated, in our experience at times, it becomes difficult because all your eggs are in one basket."
Distribution Business & Market Share Dynamics
- Volume-first approach: The distribution strategy prioritizes volume growth from existing distributors by increasing wallet share through existing categories and adding new product categories; the unorganized-to-organized shift is the structural growth driver.
- ASP disclosure declined: Management refused to provide a blended ASP across retail and distribution, arguing the two businesses are fundamentally different: retail ASP is at the COCO/store level, while distribution ASP is the wholesale rate to distributors net of distribution margin.
- Market share question deflected: When asked whether stagnant top-line revenue despite 20-25% ASP increases implies volume and market share loss, management disputed the comparison base as distorted by post-COVID demand surges and supply constraints, and did not directly address the market share question.
- Raw material cost absorption: On the distribution side, raw material prices increased 60-70% over the last few years, yet prices and gross margins were maintained and sales kept at normalized levels, indicating some pricing power even in the value segment.
Chotrani: "Today, he has to juggle with, for lack of better words, atta, sugar, tea at much higher prices than they were being used to. So then they today have, if they're earning ₹100, their income has not increased significantly as much the cost has increased. So today, they have to make a choice of whether they want to go for a branded player or a non-branded player because even if they want to go for branded player, does their pockets allow it."
Marketing & Consumer Engagement
- Strategy shift underway: The company is moving from national brand ambassadors to regional influencers and celebrities, driving the change more through digital channels than offline; experiments over the last couple of years have shown good success.
- Targeted content approach: Marketing now focuses on specific age brackets and genders with product-focused content rather than broad brand campaigns.
- Ad spend guidance: Sales and promotion expense will run at approximately 4-5% of sales, covering sales-driven activities, promotional activities, ATL, and BTL; overall marketing spend will be around 5-6% of sales.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue target | ₹800 crore gross (including GST) | FY23 |
| EBITDA margin target | 12% | FY23 |
| Retail gross margin expansion | ~100 bps YoY growth | Annual, ongoing |
| Store expansion pace | 70-80 new EBOs per year, ~90% franchisee | Annual, ongoing |
| Retail revenue recovery | Reach pre-COVID level of ~₹500 crore | FY23 |
| Medium-term revenue target | Approximately ₹1,000 crore | FY25 |
| Medium-term EBITDA margin | 14-15% | FY25 |
| Inventory normalization | Stock days to come down from 104 days | After festive season (Q3/Q4 FY23) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹166 cr, +88.2% YoY |
| Retail revenue growth | 190% YoY |
| Distribution revenue growth (ex-GST) | 27% YoY |
| Retail revenue growth (ex-GST) | 207% YoY |
| Overall gross margin | 41.3%, +596 bps YoY |
| Retail gross margin | 54.1%, up from 50.6% in Q1 FY22 |
| EBITDA | ₹17 cr, vs EBITDA loss of ₹36 lakhs in Q1 FY22 |
| EBITDA margin | 10.3% |
| EBITDA margin before Ind AS (adjusted for rent) | ~7% |
| Profit after tax | ₹3.3 cr, vs loss of ₹10.8 cr in Q1 FY22 |
| FY23 revenue guidance | ₹800 cr (gross, including GST) |
| FY23 EBITDA margin guidance | 12% annually |
| FY25 revenue target | ~₹1,000 cr |
| FY25 EBITDA margin target | 14-15% |
| Store network | 796 stores, net addition of 25 stores |
| Retail ASP | ~₹600, up from ~₹500 pre-COVID |
| Distribution ASP | ~₹100 |
| Retail pairs sold | 20.5 lakh pairs, vs 21 lakh in Q3 FY22 |
| Inventory days | 104 days, up from 98 days as of 31 Mar 2022 |
| Retail sales mix | 63% of total sales |
| Distribution sales mix | 33% of total sales |
| Online sales mix | 4% of total sales |
| East region revenue contribution | 50% of business |
| South region revenue contribution | 20-25% of business |
| Sub-brand (Khadim) contribution | 56%, vs ~60% pre-COVID |
| COCO store payback (East) | Within 1 year |
| COCO store payback (South) | 1.5 years |
| COCO store payback (North/West) | 2.5-3 years |
| Franchisee store ROI | 22-23% over 5 years |
| Ad and promotional expense guidance | ~4-6% of sales |