Key Takeaways
- Tough quarter, base-effect driven: Revenue fell 19% YoY as festive sales shifted into Q2 and the prior-year base was inflated by COVID unlocking and pre-GST-hike buying.
- Profitability held up despite the top-line drop: Gross margin improved ~400 bps YoY to 41.6%, and 9M PAT grew 250% YoY, helped by softening raw-material costs and cost control.
- The mass-market customer is under pressure: Footfall is down 30% over several years, volume is degrowing in both retail and distribution, and the company cut distribution prices 5–6% to match competitors.
- Premiumization is reshaping the retail mix: Sub-brands like Pro and British Walkers now drive 60% of retail sales value, up from a lower share before, while the mother brand Khadim is being selectively repriced to defend volumes.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the guided 10–12% retail and ~15% distribution growth for FY24 materializes, and whether the price cuts on the mother brand arrest volume degrowth without eroding the margin gains.
The Top-Line Decline: Base Effects and Demand Weakness
- Festive-season timing shift: The majority of Pujo sales were booked in Q2 FY23 rather than Q3, pulling revenue forward and leaving Q3 optically weak.
- Distribution hit by a triple headwind: The segment de-grew 36% YoY because (1) a GST rate increase from 5% to 12% in January 2022 triggered a mass offtake in December 2021 that inflated the base, (2) Tier II and Tier III demand stayed muted, and (3) inflation squeezed the mass-market consumer.
- Volume degrowth is structural, not quarterly: Footfall has fallen 30% over the last few years, and volume is declining in both retail and distribution, driven by persistent inflationary pressure on middle- and lower-income households.
- Retail held up better: The retail portfolio grew 31% YoY in 9M, partly offsetting the distribution weakness.
Burman: "And this third quarter was a bit tough quarter as we have mentioned in the opening speech as well. But we are hoping for better, slowish but better recovery in the months to come."
Margin Resilience and the Path to 15% EBITDA
- Gross margin improved sharply: Raw-material prices, while still trending higher, are witnessing gradual softening, allowing the company to hold gross margin above 40% despite inflation.
- EBITDA margin stable sequentially: At 11.2%, Q3 EBITDA margin was flat QoQ after posting the highest-ever level in the prior quarter; 9M EBITDA margin improved 320 bps YoY.
- Finance cost rose on lease accounting, not debt: The increase reflects IND-AS 116 treatment after shifting a warehouse and factory from owned to rented premises, where rent is now booked as depreciation and interest.
- Other expenses benefited from a one-off: A profit from the sale of properties was adjusted in other expenses, flattering the cost line.
- FY25 EBITDA margin target of ~15%: The ~4 percentage-point improvement over two years is expected to come from economies of scale as sales volume increases, plus premiumization and a 1–2% gross-margin uplift in retail.
- Distribution gross margin target trimmed: Reaching 40% gross margin in distribution "at present looks difficult" given sales-price pressure after the GST increase; the plan is to improve by 100 bps from the current ~35% level over the next year.
- Segment-level EBITDA undisclosed: Management declined to share retail and distribution EBITDA margins on the call, offering the data only on a one-to-one basis.
Chaudhuri: "In the retail, we stand by it. We are already doing 54% margin in retail. But in the distribution business there is a pressure in the sales price also after the GST increase. Everyone has taken a hit in the sales price. So reaching 40% at present looks difficult, but we'll gradually try to increase the margin."
Pricing and the Premiumization Pivot
- Price cuts to defend the mass segment: The company took a blended price cut of ~5–6% in distribution because competitors cut prices 10–12% in the ₹150 flip-flop segment, though Khadim’s prices were already ₹10 lower on a like-to-like basis.
- Mother brand repriced, sub-brands protected: Management is reducing prices on mother-brand Khadim products (chappals, flip-flops) while keeping margins intact, and holding ASPs high on sub-brands like Pro sportswear and British Walkers premium leather.
- Sub-brands now dominate retail value: 60% of retail sales value comes from sub-brands, with 40% from the mother brand, a mix shift that supports the premiumization strategy.
Burman: "So over the years, some of the prices of our products had become way too expensive. So we want to keep our ASPs high mainly in our sub-brands like, Pro and British Walkers. But when it comes to our mother brand Khadim, we are reducing some of the prices keeping the margin as it was before in order to reduce the volume degrowth."
Leadership Change
- CEO resigned: Ms. Namrata, CEO, stepped down citing personal reasons; the Board accepted the resignation.
- Promoter takes operational charge: Mr. Rittick Roy Burman, Whole-Time Director from the promoter group, now leads day-to-day operations and executive leadership, with functional heads remaining in place across all operations.
- Strategy unchanged: Management stated that strategy for both distribution and retail business remains the same, and Rittick will take an active role in merchandising.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| FY23 gross turnover | Reach ₹750 crores | FY23 full year |
| Retail revenue growth | Grow 10% to 12% | FY24 |
| Distribution revenue growth | Grow ~15% | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin target | Achieve ~15% (before IND-AS 116 impact) | By FY25 |
| Distribution gross margin | Improve by 100 bps from ~35% level | Next year (FY24) |
| Retail gross margin | Maintain at ~55% (already at 54%) | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹149 cr, down 19% YoY |
| 9M FY23 revenue | ₹501 cr, up 15% YoY |
| Gross margin | 41.6%, improved almost 400 bps YoY |
| 9M FY23 gross margin | 41.2%, improved almost 400 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹17 cr, down 22% YoY |
| 9M FY23 EBITDA | ₹56 cr, up 60% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 11.2%, sequentially flat |
| 9M FY23 EBITDA margin | improved 320 bps from 8% in 9M FY22 |
| PAT | ₹5 cr |
| 9M FY23 PAT | ₹13 cr, 250% growth YoY |
| Distribution business revenue growth | -36% YoY |
| Retail portfolio 9M FY23 revenue growth | 31% YoY |
| Retail gross margin | 54% |
| Distribution gross margin | 35%, expected to improve 100 bps in the next year |
| FY23 gross turnover expected | ₹750 cr, translating to around ₹670 cr net (per an analyst's math) |
| Q4 FY23 net revenue implied | ₹170–180 cr (per an analyst's math) |
| Price cut in distribution segment | 5% to 6% on a blended basis |
| Retail store tally | 838 as of Dec 31, with 73 stores added in 9M FY23 |
| Company-owned stores | ~220 |
| Franchise stores | ~500 |
| Distributor network | 682 as of Dec 31 |
| Sub-brands share of retail sales value | 60% |
| EBITDA margin target for FY25 | ~15% (before rent/IND-AS 116 impact) |