Key Takeaways
- Retail-led margin recovery: Gross margin expanded 680 bps YoY to 44.4% in Q4 as retail mix improved, driving PAT up 66% YoY despite a tough demand environment.
- Volume remains the open wound: Retail pairs sold reached 76 lakhs in FY23, still well below the pre-COVID ~1 crore benchmark, with pairage degrowth concentrated in lower-price tiers and Tier III/IV cities.
- Premiumization is the margin engine, affordability the volume fix: Management is launching sub-brands Pro and British Walker to lift ASP and margin, while simultaneously introducing ₹399–₹599 products under the mother brand to arrest volume decline in price-sensitive markets.
- Distribution is structurally low-margin and shrinking: Wholesale volume fell from 2.80 cr to 2.42 cr pairs YoY, and management explicitly ruled out margin expansion there, calling price competitiveness the binding constraint.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹70 cr government receivable actually lands in July, whether the new lower-MRP products reverse the Tier III/IV volume slide, and whether the 12.5% EBITDA margin target for FY24 stays on track as the festive inventory build begins.
Retail: The Margin-Volume Tightrope
- Gross margin leap: Q4 retail gross margin hit 44.4%, up 680 bps YoY, driven by a favourable product mix shift toward higher-ASP products; full-year retail gross margin reached 41.9%, up 470 bps.
- Volume still sub-scale: Retail pairs sold grew from 70 lakhs (FY22) to 76 lakhs (FY23), a ~10% increase, but remain far below the pre-COVID ~1 crore pairs benchmark; management attributes the gap to COVID-era footfall reduction, closure of 15–17 bleeding COCO stores, and ASP rising from ₹420 to ₹650, which hit demand in Tier III/IV cities.
- Two-speed strategy: In metro/mini-metro and Tier I markets via COCOs, the plan is to premiumize and increase ASP; in Tier III/IV via franchisee BOs and some EBOs, the goal is to restrict volume degrowth and aim for some increase over last year by introducing products at ₹399, ₹499, and ₹599 under the Khadim's mother brand.
- Growth arithmetic: The 10–12% retail growth target for FY24 breaks down into ~8–10% value growth and only ~1–2% volume growth; same-store sales growth is assumed at 4–5%, with new stores contributing 6–7%.
- SSG ceiling acknowledged: Management stated that 10% same-store sales growth is not possible in the next 2–3 years under current inflationary conditions; higher SSG becomes achievable only if inflation eases and lower-segment demand returns.
- Store expansion disciplined: The company plans to open 100 stores in FY24 (12–15 COCO, balance franchise), having added ~100 net stores since pre-COVID to reach 840; management explicitly rejected opening 200 stores per year as unwise, citing the risk of subsequent closures.
Chaudhuri: "The 10% SSG in this scenario and this -- with the inflation effect is not possible for the next 2-3 years."
Distribution: Margin-Constrained and Shrinking
- Volume degrowth: Wholesale volume declined from 2.80 crore pairs to 2.42 crore pairs YoY, and distribution sales fell from ₹260 cr to ₹235 cr.
- Margin expansion ruled out: Management stated that gross margin improvement in distribution is not foreseeable because price competitiveness is the binding constraint; passing full price increases to customers impacts volume, and the business must stay competitive to maintain sales.
- Strategic de-emphasis: The retail-to-distribution mix is expected to shift from the current split toward 70:30 over the next three years, with retail proportion increasing and distribution becoming a smaller part of the portfolio.
- Profitability over volume: Management will not reduce price to chase volume in distribution; the stated intent is to maintain margin and run it as a profitable, if smaller, business.
Burman: "So if I give very optimistic gross margin updates, especially pertaining to the wholesale business at this moment, it would be a wrong guidance. So in wholesale, we'll have to be competitive in order to increase the volume and the sales..."
Sub-Brand Premiumization & Product Strategy
- Pro (athleisure): Currently contributes 16–20% of retail turnover; management hopes to increase this share through the sub-brand's sports and athleisure positioning.
- British Walker (leather shoes): Relaunched to capture share in the leather shoe segment; expectation is to increase contribution going forward.
- Mother-brand affordability: Limited articles at ₹399, ₹499, and ₹599 are being launched under the Khadim's brand to ensure Tier III/IV stores have economical products, without which, management argues, opening stores in those markets makes no sense.
- Margin trade-off: The premiumization push via sub-brands is expected to lift retail gross margin by 1–1.5%, partially offset by the introduction of lower-MRP products.
Burman: "So we will increase the gross margin through premiumization, but there will also be introductions of... limited articles have to be launched to make sure that these Tier III, Tier IV, we are expanding, if we do not make sure that some economical products are launched for them, then what's the point of opening so many stores."
Balance Sheet & Working Capital
- Debt composition: Debt of ₹116 cr is entirely working capital with no term loans; management expects to reduce it to ₹80–90 cr over the next 2–3 years, a reduction of roughly ₹30 cr.
- Government receivables overhang: ₹70 cr in institutional debtors remains pending; the UP government fund transfer was delayed when a server crashed on March 31; payment is expected in July.
- Cash flow constrained: Cash flow from operations was ₹39 cr, lease payments absorbed ₹34 cr, leaving net ~₹5 cr; high working capital investment, driven by the mix of EBO, franchisee, and distribution credit terms plus the ₹70 cr government receivable, was cited as the reason.
- Incremental working capital need: Pegged at 20% of sales growth.
- Capex: ₹12–13 cr planned over the next 1–2 years for retail expansion, retail modernization, and factory.
- Advertising spend: ₹15 cr budgeted for FY24; management stated that increasing it to ₹25 cr would not drive incremental volume under current inflationary pressure, so spend will stay disciplined and flex only if business conditions improve.
Chaudhuri: "If we increase from ₹15 crores to ₹25 crores, the volume and all this will not increase. So depending on the situation and demand, we will do that."
Market Position & Competitive Context
- West Bengal: Volume increased over FY22, so market share has improved; Khadim and Bata are the two main organized retail players in the state.
- South India: Volume was more or less flat; management could not claim market share improvement. With new product lines coming, the goal is to plug volume degrowth and drive some growth.
- No formal market-share data: Management acknowledged that no agency tracks market share in the footwear industry, so all share commentary is based on internal volume trends and ASP movements.
- ASP as a demand signal: Management interprets rising ASP as evidence that customers are willing to pay more for better products, framing it as a brand-strength indicator even as volume lags.
Burman: "People are liking our products that's why they are willing to pay more money to buy some better product."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Retail revenue growth | 10–12% growth (₹500 cr to ~₹560 cr) | FY24 |
| Distribution revenue growth | 15% growth | FY24 |
| Net revenue | ~₹750 cr (gross sales target ₹900 cr) | FY24 |
| Store openings | 100 total stores (12–15 COCO, balance franchise) | FY24 |
| Retail gross margin | Improve by 1–1.5% via premiumization | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | 12.5% (up from 11% in FY23) | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | 15% (on course) | FY25 |
| Retail:Distribution mix | 70:30 | Within 3 years |
| Debt reduction | Reduce from ₹116 cr to ₹80–90 cr | Within 2–3 years |
| Capex | ₹12–13 cr for retail expansion, modernization, factory | Next 1–2 years |
| Government receivables | ₹70 cr payment expected | July 2023 |
| Retail volume | 85–86 lakhs pairs | FY24 (next year) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹159 crores, +2% YoY |
| FY23 revenue | ₹660 crores, +11.7% YoY |
| Gross margin | 44.4%, up 680 bps YoY |
| FY23 gross margin | 41.9%, up 470 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹16.4 crores, +28.2% YoY |
| FY23 EBITDA | ₹72.5 crores, +51.7% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 10.3% |
| FY23 EBITDA margin | 11% |
| Profit after tax | ₹4.3 crores, +66% YoY |
| FY23 profit after tax | ₹17.5 crores, +171% YoY |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 10%–12% in retail, 15% in distribution |
| FY24 EBITDA margin target | 12.5% |
| Total store count | 846 stores, 18 added in Q4, 91 added in FY23 |
| Retail business growth | 5% in Q4, 12% in FY23 |
| Retail pairs sold (FY23) | 76 lakhs pairs, up from 70 lakhs in FY22; pre-pandemic peak 1 crore pairs |
| Wholesale business volume (FY23) | 2.42 crores pairs, down from 2.80 crores in FY22 |
| Distribution network | 700 distributors as of March 2023 |
| Retail sales contribution (FY23) | 63% of total revenue |
| Distribution and institutional contribution (FY23) | 34% of total revenue |
| E-commerce contribution (FY23) | 3% of total revenue |
| Franchise-operated stores | 74% of total stores |
| Company-owned outlets | 26% of total stores |
| Athleisure segment contribution to retail turnover | 16% to 20% |
| FY23 price hike | 5%–6% |
| Current debt | ₹116 crores |
| Capex planned for next 1–2 years | ₹12 crores – ₹13 crores |
| Advertising budget for FY24 | ₹15 crores |
| Store-level EBITDA | 25% |
| Institutional debtors pending | ₹70 crores out of ₹188 crores receivables |
| FY23 gross sales | ₹775 crores |
| FY23 retail sales | ₹500 crores |
| FY23 distribution sales | ₹235 crores, degrowth from ₹260 crores |
| FY19 ASP vs current ASP | ₹420 pre-pandemic, ₹650 currently |