Key Takeaways
- Revenue down, margins up: Revenue fell 9.8% YoY in Q4 as the company deliberately shrank its distribution business and faced muted retail demand, yet gross margin expanded 180 bps YoY on a richer retail mix.
- The distribution reset is a double-edged trade: Cutting ~₹30 cr of distribution sales improved receivables quality but dragged the topline; management expects to claw back to FY23 distribution levels this year.
- Premiumization is working, but only on mix: Sub-brands rose from 57% to 59% of sales and ASP moved from ₹528 to ₹539, yet absolute sub-brand revenue was flat because overall volumes declined, concentrated in the lower-price Khadim category.
- The lower-end volume problem is structural, not cyclical: Price hikes in the entry segment pushed volume down and some demand shifted permanently to the unorganized sector post-COVID; management is considering cutting prices there to win volume back.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the post-election demand recovery materializes as the industry assumes, whether the athleisure pilot in 40 stores gains traction, and whether the NCLT demerger order arrives within the 3-4 month window.
The Distribution Reset
- Conscious shrinkage: Distribution sales were reduced by ~₹30 cr from the prior year as a deliberate call to bring down receivables, not because the channel lost viability.
- Product refresh underway: New products introduced into distribution are seeing demand, and management expects the distribution loss to "drastically come down" this year, targeting a return to FY23-level distribution sales.
- Distributor network still growing: The company added 81 distributors in FY24 to reach 753, signalling the reset is about quality of sales, not abandonment of the channel.
Chaudhuri: "This is a genuine call taken by us to reduce our receivables also. But this year, I think the product category also changed. We have introduced new products and in the Distribution that product is in demand."
Retail Demand & the Volume Problem
- Muted footfall, multiple headwinds: Retail demand was suppressed by macroeconomic conditions, a heat wave in eastern India restricting store visits, and a month-long election process that disrupted normal purchasing.
- East held up better: While growth came from all zones, the bulk came from the East, the company's main base, where sales were "almost similar" and did not degrow as much as other regions.
- Lower segment volume collapsed: Price hikes in the entry-level segment reduced volume, and demand in franchisee stores and Tier 3/Tier 4 cities has "gone down drastically." Some demand shifted to the unorganized sector post-COVID on price.
- Possible price cut to revive volume: Management is considering cutting prices in the lower segment to bring volume back, but the strategy is not finalized; market research and consumer feedback are underway first.
- No price hikes planned: With muted demand and volume degrowth, the company took no price increases on running products; new products were introduced with fresh price ranges for the festive season.
Chaudhuri: "Maybe some part of the demand has gone to the un-organized sector because with the COVID generally people in the lower segment and the middle segment has changed their footwear from the — from organized to unorganized due to price."
Premiumization & Sub-Brand Performance
- Mix shift, not absolute growth: Sub-brands grew from 57% to 59% of retail sales, but absolute sub-brand turnover was flat at ₹228 cr to ₹230 cr because overall retail sales declined, with the drop concentrated in the core Khadim category.
- ASP inched up despite the lull: Retail ASP rose from ₹528 in FY23 to ₹539 in FY24, driven by mix improvement toward higher-priced sub-brands even as volumes softened.
- Higher price points led: Within the sub-brand portfolio, the higher price brackets increased more, while the lower end of the sub-brand range saw pressure.
- COCO premiumization push: In urban company-owned stores, the plan is to introduce higher-priced sub-brands to capture more affluent footfall.
- Management declined to quantify premium growth rate: When asked for the percentage growth of premium brands, management said "it's a bit hard to comment on exactly how much percentage we have grown" and offered only the absolute turnover figure.
Store Expansion & Refurbishment
- 94 stores added in FY24: The network reached 868 stores, split 223 company-owned and 645 franchisee.
- FY25 expansion plan: Around 25 new COCOs and 70 franchisees are planned, with management expecting 6% to 7% value growth from this expansion alone.
- COCO/franchisee ratio steady: The ratio will remain in the 60:40 range going forward, so the expansion does not signal a strategic tilt toward one format.
- Refurbishment pilot: 22 stores will be refurbished this year, with 16 done in the first two quarters (8 per quarter). Results will be assessed three months post-refurbishment before the remaining 6 are taken up.
- Retail growth ambition: Management targets 12%-15% annual retail growth, aiming to reach ₹650-700 crores in retail with a 17%-18% EBITDA margin over the next three years.
Athleisure Wear Launch
- New category under sub-brand Pro: Garments and athleisure wear (T-shirts, Polo T-shirts) priced at ₹500-₹750 will launch in Q2, rolling out initially across 20 COCO and 20 franchisee outlets in urban markets that have space.
- Test case, not a bet: The launch is explicitly a pilot; if it performs well in the initial 40 outlets, the company will expand it further.
- Margin will start lower: Athleisure margins will initially be below footwear margins; a call on better margin will be taken only if the category proves itself.
- Sports footwear performed well: Ladies sports shoes and boys sports shoes saw strong YoY performance, with products kept across price brackets (below ₹1,000, ₹1,000-₹1,499, ₹1,499-₹2,000), providing a foundation for the athleisure adjacency.
Burman: "It's too early to comment how much percentage will that be of the sales, but we have kept the prices very attractive in the athleisure wear category. So, we hope that people will like it."
Margins & Profitability
- Gross margin expanded sharply: Up 180 bps YoY in Q4 and 350 bps YoY for the full year, driven by a higher contribution from retail leading to a favourable product mix.
- EBITDA margin improved despite revenue decline: EBITDA grew 2.6% YoY in Q4 with margin up 140 bps YoY; full-year EBITDA margin up 50 bps YoY.
- Net profit fell hard: PAT down 75.5% YoY in Q4 and 63.9% YoY for FY24, with PAT margins down 200 bps and 170 bps respectively, suggesting below-the-line pressure even as operations held up.
- FY25 margin outlook flat: Margins are expected to be more or less the same as no price hikes are planned; the focus is on increasing volume. New products are being launched within the same margin range.
- Raw material tailwind: Margins are expected to improve with softening of key raw material prices.
- Operating leverage promise: Management stated that with sales growth returning, margin will "definitely improve by 100 basis points."
BIS Regulation Overhang
- Pre-BIS inventory partially cleared: Most hoarded pre-BIS inventory has been sold; some remaining stock is being liquidated with discounts during the EOSS season.
- The overhang is not fully resolved: BIS was implemented in a "mixed way": micro and small factories received a one-year extension. When those factories come within the regulatory orbit, there will again be pre-BIS stock to liquidate, potentially creating another round of discounting pressure.
Demerger Progress
- Stock exchange approvals secured: BSE and NSE have approved the demerger; the matter is now pending with the NCLT.
- Timeline: Management expects 3 to 4 months for the NCLT demerger order, with listing of the demerged entity to follow.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Distribution recovery | Return to FY23-level distribution sales; loss in distribution to "drastically come down" | FY25 |
| Store expansion | Open ~25 COCOs and ~70 franchisees, delivering 6%-7% value growth | FY25 |
| Retail growth target | 12%-15% annual retail growth, reaching ₹650-700 cr with 17%-18% EBITDA margin | Next 3 years |
| Margin improvement | Improve margin by 100 bps as sales growth returns | Conditional on sales growth |
| Store refurbishment | 22 stores refurbished; 16 in H1, results assessed 3 months post-refurbishment before next 6 | FY25 |
| Demerger order | NCLT order expected in 3-4 months, followed by listing of demerged entity | 3-4 months |
| Athleisure expansion | If pilot succeeds in initial 40 outlets, expand further | Conditional on pilot performance |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹143.6 cr, down 9.8% YoY |
| Gross margin | 46.2%, up 180 bps YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹16.8 cr, up 2.6% YoY |
| Operating EBITDA margin | 11.7%, up 140 bps YoY |
| Net profit | ₹1.05 cr, down 75.5% YoY |
| PAT margin | 0.7%, down 200 bps YoY |
| Retail sales contribution | 61% of revenue in Q4, 65% for full FY24 |
| Distribution business contribution | 35% of revenue in Q4, 31% for full FY24 |
| Franchise/retail sales | ~₹93 cr |
| Distribution sales | ~₹50 cr |
| Total store count | 868 stores, added 94 stores in FY24 |
| COCO stores | 223 stores |
| Franchisee stores | 645 stores |
| Distributor count | 753 distributors, added 81 in FY24 |
| ASP (retail) | ₹539, up from ₹528 in FY23 |
| Sub-brand share of sales | 59%, up from 57% last year |
| Sub-brand sales | ₹230 cr, versus ₹228 cr last year |
| COCO-to-franchisee sales ratio | 56% COCO, down from 61% previously |
| Retail business size | ~₹500 cr |
| Lower-segment share of retail sales | ~25% of retail sales |
| Stores planned for refurbishment in FY25 | 22 stores |
| Planned store additions (FY25) | 25 COCO and 70 franchisee |
| Expected growth from expansion | 6% to 7% in value terms |
| Retail growth plan (annual) | 12% to 15% |
| Retail EBITDA margin target | 16% to 17%, rising to 17% to 18% |
| Retail revenue target (3 years) | ₹650 cr to ₹700 cr |
| Athleisure wear price range | ₹500 to ₹750 |
| Demerger status | NCLT approval pending, expected in 3 to 4 months |