Key Takeaways
- Top-line miss, bottom-line held: Revenue grew 15.4% YoY to ₹178.4 cr, missing the 18–20% guidance by 3–4% due to a dull apparel market, but EBITDA margin held at 19.1% and management expects to cover the shortfall in Q2/Q3.
- Volume growth masks mix-driven realization drop: Apparel volume grew 10.3%, but average realization fell 12% because a surge in low-realization accessories pulled the blended average down.
- Gross margin stable despite cotton tailwind: Gross margin was nearly flat at 43% as the benefit from lower cotton prices was absorbed by preponed sales; management calls margins sustainable.
- Store network being reshaped, not just expanded: 27 net EBOs were added, but 22 K-Lounge stores were closed, with a strategy to convert some to Killer, Integriti, or Lawman single-brand formats.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 18–20% full-year revenue guidance stays on track after the Q1 miss, the pace of K-Lounge-to-single-brand conversions, and any concrete news on the kids wear launch or an acquisition.
Demand & Revenue Performance
- Broad slowdown hit topline: Management acknowledged a dull apparel market and weakened consumer sentiment, which caused the 3–4% revenue shortfall versus the 18–20% full-year guidance.
- Volume growth concentrated in jeans and accessories: Jeans and the "others" category drove growth; shirts grew at a lower rate (~11%) due to season planning, and T-shirt sales typically decline in Q1.
- Accessories surge depressed blended realization: The 12% decline in average realization is purely a mix effect: accessories had tremendously high volume but much lower realization, pulling down the blended average.
- Sales preponement absorbed cotton benefit: Yearly sales started in June, earlier than usual, which supported Q1 revenue but absorbed the benefit of lower cotton prices; management does not expect this to hurt Q2 because fresh and discounted sales will follow.
- Secondary sales improving sequentially: Secondary sales have improved from July onwards and are in a better position compared to April, though not yet at April levels.
- North market is winter-skewed: North business is 60% weighted to the winter season; East is the #1 market, followed by North, West, and South.
- Competitive aggression protected volumes: April was very bad for competitors; the company was very aggressive in sales in June, taking a 1–2% EBITDA margin hit to avoid slowing down.
Hemant Jain: "Good quality, better price, good service and for a brand what more it can be to make the growth. And you are converting the weakness of the other brand into positive, that is the growth path of any business."
Margins & Cost Structure
- EBITDA margin held steady: EBITDA margin improved slightly to 19.1% from 19.0% YoY; management says margins are sustainable and expects 18–20% for the full year.
- Gross margin nearly flat despite input tailwind: Gross margin was 43% vs 43.2% YoY; the benefit from lower cotton prices was realized in Q1 but was absorbed by the impact of preponed sales.
- No price hike taken: Management chose not to raise prices in jeans because cotton prices had normalized; a few prices were even reduced, and the priority was protecting market share.
- Manufacturing expenses down sharply: Manufacturing expenses reduced by almost 22% YoY; management advises viewing this through a COGS bifurcation lens.
- Working capital improvement sustainable: Working capital days declined YoY, driven by lower inventory days; management expects this to stay at 120–130 days.
- S&D expenses to remain range-bound: Selling and distribution expenses will stay in the 5–6% of operating revenue bracket.
Pankaj Jain: "I would not deny that there haven't been a slowdown. There has been a slowdown and that is the reason we have missed our estimates on a top line basis. But we have ensured that in terms of changed scenario and price bracket scenario, we have been able to achieve it on EBIDTA levels and feel that we will be able to achieve it on the annualize basis atleast."
Store Network & Channel Strategy
- Net store addition positive despite closures: 27 net brand EBOs were added in Q1, taking total Killer EBOs to 249 and overall EBOs to 454.
- K-Lounge rationalization underway: 22 K-Lounge stores were closed: 6–8 were converted to single-brand formats, 6–8 were under renovation, and 6 were permanent closures.
- K-Lounge strategy being redefined: Close to 70% of K-Lounge stores fall under a 5-year vintage; management is revamping the strategy, with some converting to Killer, some to Integriti, and some to Lawman; K-Lounge will operate under a different policy going forward.
- Conversions are gradual to protect sales: Management is converting stores slowly to avoid losing sales; 2–4 stores from the current pipeline may go under conversion.
- 50-store pipeline progressing: Work on an additional 50 identified EBOs is ongoing and expected to launch in coming months, with most opening by Q2 or Q3.
- K-Lounge conversions are low-CAPEX: Since K-Lounge stores are franchise-model, converting them to single-brand stores does not cost the company much CAPEX; well-performing K-Lounge stores may not be converted.
Hemant Jain: "We are doing conversions slowly because we do not want to lose our sales. And K-Lounge will be a different policy. So, in future we will talk to you about K-Lounge separately."
Brand Portfolio & New Initiatives
- Kids wear launch imminent: The company will launch kids wear "very soon"; management will not share numbers until the business is established over 2–3 seasons.
- Kids first, then ladies: The first focus is on kids wear; a ladies wear launch may follow later.
- Other brands being professionalized: Professionals have been hired for Lawman, Integriti, and Easies; teams are built and management expects strong future growth, though it is too early to provide specific targets.
- Integriti positioned for value-segment growth: Integriti should grow at a higher rate because the value-price segment is a high-growth area, though management did not provide brand-specific guidance.
- Brand trade show completed: A trade show for Killer, Easies, Lawman, and Integriti showcasing SS'24 trends was held in July 2023 and received an overwhelming response from channel partners.
- World Cup sponsorship limited: The company is currently sponsoring the T20 West Indies series; management declined to share specific World Cup plans.
Acquisitions & Capital Allocation
- Actively scouting for acquisitions: A team is working on finding acquisition opportunities, focused only on the garment business.
- Open to both loss-making and profitable targets: Management is open to loss-making companies if a turnaround is feasible, as well as profitable companies, with valuation approached differently for each.
- Ticket size not limited to cash balance: When asked if acquisition size would be limited to cash on hand, management said they are ready to invest more if a good opportunity comes.
- No deal finalized yet: Management will announce when anything is finalized; the 18–20% growth guidance is organic and does not include any acquisition contribution.
Hemant Jain: "It consists of 2 to 3 things. Any Company which is a loss making Company and if there is a confidence that we can turnaround it, then its valuation will be X or will be X- and if it is a profitable Company then its valuation will be different, we have to look at it in a different way. But we are open for both the things."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 18–20% YoY (organic, excluding any acquisition) | FY24 full year |
| EBITDA margin | 18–20% | FY24 full year |
| Q1 shortfall recovery | Cover the 3–4% topline miss | Q2 or Q3 FY24 |
| Net store additions | 80–100 (net of closures) | FY24 full year |
| Average realization growth | 4–5% | FY24 full year |
| Working capital days | 120–130 days | Sustained |
| S&D expenses | 5–6% of operating revenue | Sustained |
| Pipeline store openings | ~50 identified EBOs to open | Q2 or Q3 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹178.4 cr, +15.4% YoY |
| Gross margin | 43%, vs 43.2% in Q1 FY23 |
| EBITDA | ₹34.1 cr, +16.4% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 19.1%, vs 19.0% in Q1 FY23 |
| PBT | ₹41.4 cr, +58.0% YoY |
| PBT margin | 21.9%, vs 17.0% in Q1 FY23 |
| PAT | ₹33.8 cr, +56.8% YoY |
| PAT margin | 17.9%, vs 13.9% in Q1 FY23 |
| Other income | ~₹11 cr, higher due to fair market value of FDs and mutual funds |
| Revenue growth guidance (FY24) | 18% to 20%, organic, short by 3% to 4% in Q1 |
| EBITDA margin guidance (FY24) | 18% to 20%, similar to revenue growth |
| Apparel volume growth | 10.3% |
| Total quantity growth | ~50%, includes accessories (per an analyst's math) |
| Average realization decline | 12%, due to mix with high-volume, low-realization accessories (per an analyst's math) |
| Same store sales growth (SSG) | ~4%, for EBOs only |
| Total EBOs | 454 as of June 30, 2023, net addition of 27 brand EBOs |
| Killer EBOs | 249 as of June 30, 2023 |
| K-Lounge store closures | 22 stores closed; 6 to 8 converted, 6 to 8 under renovation, 6 closed |
| Store addition target (FY24) | 80 to 100 stores, net of closures |
| Stores under development | 50 stores, expected to open by Q3 FY24 |
| Working capital days | 120 to 130 days, expected to sustain |
| Sales and distribution expenses | 5% to 6% of operating revenue, grew 18% YoY |