Key Takeaways
- Yarn margins squeezed, demand intact: Cotton price volatility compressed yarn margins, but management reports good demand and goods movement, with January margins recovering to 14–15%.
- Garment volumes on track, full capacity reached: Nine-month volumes rose ~10% YoY, the new Chengappalli unit is fully ramped, and full production is expected from FY24.
- Sugar & ethanol deliver standout margins: Q3 EBIT margin hit 33.5% on peak-season power production and full ethanol utilization, and the board approved a ₹150 Cr expansion to 250 KLPD.
- Three capex bets placed for FY24: A Vortex viscose spinning mill (₹100 Cr), a 12 MW solar plant (₹50 Cr), and a processing debottlenecking (₹50 Cr) were all approved, funded internally.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether yarn margins sustain the January recovery, garment Q4 volumes hit the seasonal uptick, and cotton prices settle enough to shift inventory strategy.
Yarn: Margin Pressure in a Surplus Market
- Cotton volatility is the culprit: Cotton prices swung from ₹40,000–₹50,000 to a peak of ₹105,000 and back to ~₹66,000, making margins "skewed" even as demand and goods movement stayed healthy.
- Export shutdown floods the domestic market: India normally exports 40–50% of its yarn production, but absent export demand, all manufacturers are selling domestically, capping price recovery despite lower cotton costs.
- Low-inventory defense: Management is holding only two months of cotton stock to limit exposure to price swings, and will only rebuild inventory if prices reach ~₹60,000.
- Early recovery signal: January yarn margins improved to 14–15%, and management hopes stabilization in cotton prices will lift margins further in coming months.
Murugappan: "Even though the prices of cotton has come down substantially, the demand also more or less in line, but the price is not going up because the export demand is not there. So all the yarn manufacturers are coming to domestic market."
Garments: Steady Volumes, Stable Order Book
- Volume growth delivered: Nine-month FY23 garment volumes rose ~10% YoY, and the new Chengappalli unit (₹250 Cr total cost) completed its ramp-up during the period.
- Full capacity achieved, full production next year: The new facility has reached full capacity; management expects to hit 3.5–3.6 crore pieces per quarter, with full production flowing from FY24.
- Pricing locked in, no cotton tailwind: Garments are produced against fixed-price orders, and most Q3 output used fabric manufactured and dyed when cotton costs were higher, so the cotton price drop will not flow through to margins.
- Order book resilience: The order book stands at ~₹1,000 Cr, representing 5–6 months of visibility, with no signs of demand drop, down-trading, or ASP shift in the basic garment segment.
- Q3 production vs. sales gap: Production ran at ~3.2 crore pieces but sales were ~2.9 crore, a small stock-build difference; Q4 volumes are seasonally higher and expected to close the gap.
- Sustainable margin target: Management sees a sustainable garment EBITDA margin of 22–24%; Q3 came in at ~21%, with the nine-month average at ~24%.
- Expansion decision on hold: Further garment capacity expansion is delayed pending clarity on the Ukraine war, Europe slowdown, and a new government policy on the Mudra Scheme.
Murugappan: "We are operating in a regular garment and the basic garment segment. We are not seeing much of a fluctuation in the demand for the product. We are operating with an order book of about Rs.1000 Crores, maybe somewhere around for 5, 6 months kind of order book, we are maintaining continuously."
Sugar & Ethanol: High Margins, Big Expansion
- Seasonal peak delivered: Q3 EBIT margin of 33.5% was driven by higher power production during the crushing season and full utilization of ethanol capacity.
- Structural advantage vs. peers: Full ethanol capacity and a 90 MW cogen power plant provide a margin edge that pure-play sugar mills lack.
- Ethanol expansion to 250 KLPD: The board approved a ₹150 Cr project to nearly double ethanol capacity from 130 KLPD to 250 KLPD, eligible for interest subsidy, with completion targeted by FY24.
- Post-expansion, molasses fully captive: Once the expansion is complete, all molasses will be utilized internally rather than sold, adding ~₹50 Cr in sugar division revenue initially and ~₹100 Cr from FY25 onward.
- Sugar recovery and exports: Gross recovery in the catchment area is 10.5–10.75%; of the 27,000-ton export quota, 20,000 tons were shipped in Q3 and the remaining 7,000 tons are contracted at ~₹35/kg for Q4.
- Full-year sugar EBITDA margin expected at 22–25%.
Capex & Strategic Investments
- Vortex viscose spinning mill: ₹100 Cr project approved, expected completion by FY24, funded through internal accruals.
- 12 MW solar power plant: ₹50 Cr captive-consumption project, expected completion in 2023, delivering ~₹12 Cr in annual cash savings.
- Processing division debottlenecking: ₹50 Cr project to increase capacity by 20%, output to be consumed internally.
- All three projects are internally funded, with no external debt indicated.
Balance Sheet & One-Offs
- Depreciation step-down: Consolidated depreciation fell ~₹21 Cr QoQ because certain sugar-business assets completed their useful life and a capital subsidy with underlying conditions was written off; going forward, depreciation is expected around ₹40 Cr per quarter as new capex kicks in.
- Negative inventory changes explained: The negative change in inventory over recent quarters reflects higher inventory costs from the cotton price spike, not a signal of large upcoming orders.
- Australia revenue share decline: The percentage drop is a denominator effect from overall garment revenue growth; absolute business is roughly flat.
- Garment job-order stock-in-trade of ₹137 Cr (Q2 standalone) has been sold; the factory is now fully running.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Yarn margin recovery | January margins at 14–15%; improvement if cotton stabilizes | Coming months |
| Garment quarterly production | Reach 3.5–3.6 crore pieces per quarter | Not specified |
| Garment full production | New facility at full production | FY24 |
| Integrated EBITDA margin | Around 23% level | Sustaining (nine-month level) |
| Ethanol expansion revenue | ~₹50 Cr initial, ~₹100 Cr from FY25 | FY24–FY25 |
| Solar plant cash saving | ~₹12 Cr per annum | From 2023 completion |
| Sugar full-year EBITDA margin | 22% to 25% | FY23 |
| Sustainable garment EBITDA margin | 22% to 24% | Ongoing |
| Top-line and margin growth | 10% year-on-year | FY23 |
| FASO brand breakeven | Ramp-up on track | FY24 |
| Ethanol capacity expansion | 130 KLPD to 250 KLPD, ₹150 Cr cost | FY24 |
| Vortex spinning mill | ₹100 Cr project | FY24 |
| Depreciation run-rate | ~₹40 Cr per quarter | From Q4 FY23 onward |
| Cotton inventory strategy | Stay at ~2 months stock; increase if price reaches ~₹60,000 | Until prices settle |
| UK business (FTA benefit) | 10–15% immediate improvement hoped | Upon FTA signing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated as a consolidated figure for the quarter |
| Integrated EBITDA margin | ~23% for 9M FY23, expected to be around this level |
| Yarn margin | ~14%, margins skewed due to cotton price fluctuation |
| Garment margin | ~21% for the quarter |
| Sugar segment EBIT margin | 33.5% for the quarter |
| Sugar segment EBITDA margin (full-year expectation) | 22% to 25% expected for full year |
| Garment EBITDA margin (sustainable) | 22% to 24% expected sustainable margin; 9M FY23 was ~24% |
| Garment order book | ₹1,000 Crores, representing 5 to 6 months of orders |
| Garment sales volume | ~2.9 crore pieces for the quarter |
| Garment production volume | ~3.2 crore pieces per quarter, expected to reach 3.5 to 3.6 crore pieces |
| Yarn sales volume | 15,000 tons |
| Yarn sales value | ₹450 Crores |
| Fabric sales volume | 1,700 tons |
| Fabric sales value | ₹55 Crores |
| Sugar and ethanol sales | ₹252 Crores for the quarter |
| Sugar sales | ₹115 Crores for the quarter |
| Ethanol sales | ₹102 Crores for the quarter |
| Sugar sales volume | 34,000 tons, of which 20,000 tons was export |
| Sugar consolidated average realization | ₹33.5 per kg |
| Ethanol volume | 1.58 crore liters for the quarter |
| Depreciation | ₹29 Crores for the quarter, declined from ₹50 Crores in Q2 FY23 |
| Expected depreciation run rate | ~₹40 Crores from Q4 FY23 onwards |
| Sugar recovery rate | 10.5% to 10.75% gross recovery |
| Cotton yarn share of production | ~95%, manmade yarn negligible |
| Distillery operating days | 300 days per year |
| Cogen power capacity | 90 MW |