Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter despite multiple headwinds: Nine-month revenue reached INR 4,418 crores and net profit INR 592 crores, achieved even as cotton price declines, a sugar-juice ethanol ban, and a cyclone all hit simultaneously.
- Garment order book at an all-time high: The order book stands at INR 1,100 crores, boosted by the addition of Walmart and GAP as major customers, while cyclone-delayed shipments worth ~INR 100 crores spill into Q4.
- Sugar and ethanol face a double squeeze: A government ban on using sugar juice for ethanol and a monsoon-driven 10% drop in cane crushing will together reduce absolute segment EBITDA by 10% to 12%, with the impact felt next year.
- Processing is the strategic bottleneck and moat: Management is investing ~INR 250 crores in processing expansion, calling it the "very, very critical link" that is harder to scale than garments due to pollution and water norms.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the INR 100 crores of delayed garment shipments converts cleanly in Q4, the pace of Walmart and GAP order ramp-up toward full capacity by year-end, and any stabilization in yarn margins.
Garment Business: Orders, Customers & Capacity
- Order book surge: The garment order book hit an all-time high of INR 1,100 crores, with management noting large buyers are concentrating orders on larger players for supply stability.
- Walmart and GAP added: Walmart was added for US exports, and GAP was added as a major customer this quarter for both US and European destinations, supplying T-shirts and nightwear.
- Ramp-up timeline: Full capacity utilization for these two customers is expected by the end of this calendar year, helping fill the new plant commissioned last year.
- Margin profile: Management confirmed these large orders carry regular margins, not lower ones.
- Cyclone spillover: December shipments of ~0.4 crore garments worth ~INR 100 crores were held up at Chennai and Tuticorin ports due to cyclones; this volume will be recognized in Q4.
- Realization pressure: Garment realization dropped to the 160-165 level from earlier highs, driven by a sharp fall in cotton prices (from INR 1 lakh to INR 60,000 per candy) and a seasonal product mix shift from higher-value winter garments to lower-value summer garments.
- Realization recovery expected: Management hopes realization will improve in coming quarters as value-addition processes ramp up, citing a comfort level around the 180 mark.
- Capacity target: Total garment capacity is set to reach 17.7 crore pieces by FY26, including 1 crore pieces of capacity relocated from Ethiopia to India.
- Growth ambition: Management targets 10% to 12% annual growth in the garment segment over the next three to five years, with brownfield expansion completing in six to nine months.
PL Murugappan: "If you look at our order book, it is all time high now, we are running around INR1,100 crores of order book, and a lot of inquiries are going around."
Sugar & Ethanol: Policy Hit and Crop Impact
- Juice ban reshapes ethanol production: The government ban on using sugar juice for ethanol means ~40% of ethanol production may come down during the season; the company will now produce ethanol only from B-Heavy and C-Heavy molasses.
- Offseason production lost: Because all molasses will be consumed during the season for ethanol, there will be no molasses left for offseason production, reducing total output.
- Revenue impact quantified: Management pegged the revenue impact from the juice ban at ~INR 200 crores, though the pre-ban baseline was not provided.
- Sugar price partially offsets: Sugar prices are comparatively better than last year, and management expects some of the ethanol loss to be compensated by higher sugar realizations.
- Cane crushing down 10%: Monsoon impact on the region is expected to reduce cane crushing by about 10% this season, from a base of 26 lakh tons.
- EBITDA impact and timing: Absolute sugar segment EBITDA will be 10% to 12% lower, with the impact felt next year; if the next crushing season starting October is good, it could get compensated.
- Inventory build-up: The significant inventory pile-up on the balance sheet is entirely from sugar production during the last two months, not from textiles.
- No grain-based ethanol pivot: Management is not looking at grain (rice or maize) as an alternative feedstock and will continue with molasses-based production.
- Sugar capex on hold: Management stated it is not currently looking to invest in sugar, calling it a license-oriented business, and is concentrating more on textiles.
PL Murugappan: "Now we are producing ethanol from the molasses, so we will not have molasses for the offseason. So the production will be less in the offseason period."
Processing: The Strategic Moat
- Processing as competitive barrier: Management described processing as the "very, very critical link" in textiles, noting that having a strong processing network makes further expansion in value addition comfortable.
- Harder to scale than garments: While garment capacity can be increased comparatively easily, processing expansion is much more difficult due to pollution control norms, dyes and chemicals regulation, and water availability issues.
- INR 250 crores expansion announced: The company announced a ~INR 250 crores investment to expand processing capacity at an existing site where land is already available.
- Timeline and lead time: The expansion is expected to take 18 to 24 months to become fully operational because machinery is imported with higher lead times; ordering is in process.
- Post-expansion capacity: Processing capacity will reach 37,000 tons once the expansion is complete.
- Sequencing logic: Management indicated that once processing is strong, it can continue expanding garment capacity, reinforcing the bottleneck role of processing in the value chain.
P. Nataraj: "In textiles, processing is the very, very critical link. And when we have, anyone having processing as a strong network, so it is very comfortable for the expansion in the value additions."
Yarn, FASO Brand & Other Segments
- Yarn margin under pressure: Subdued demand in international markets caused a fall in yarn margin, though volumes remain good; margins are expected to stay a little below regular levels.
- Cotton price pass-through: The fall in cotton prices directly reduced yarn selling prices during the quarter.
- FASO brand scaling: The company appointed additional executives and started expansion in North India; in South India, management hopes to scale to a ~INR 10 crores per month run rate in one to two years.
- Printing monetization: The printing and processing capacity expansion completed last quarter has begun monetization.
- Completed capex: Vortex expansion (INR 100 crores), solar expansion (INR 50 crores), ethanol capacity increase from 120 to 250 KLPD, and printing and processing expansion (INR 50 crores) were all completed.
Competitive Landscape & External Factors
- Bangladesh wage dynamic: Management acknowledged that Bangladesh labour costs may reach parity with India in two to three years, which would be an advantage for India, but noted it is too early to confirm any order shift.
- Tirupur competition: With about 3,000 exporters in the region ranging from INR 5 crores to INR 1,000 crores, management stated "everybody is a competitor" and emphasized that cost is the key differentiator.
- Red Sea disruption muted: The company is not seeing much impact currently as most exports are on an FOB basis; no early-shipment requests from customers have been received yet.
- Large-player consolidation: Large garment buyers are concentrating more on larger players for undisturbed supplies, a trend benefiting KPR while smaller Tirupur players face issues.
PL Murugappan: "If you ask me, everybody is a competitor. So cost is important."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Garment segment growth | 10% to 12% annual growth | Next three to five years |
| Total garment capacity | 17.7 crore pieces (including 1 crore from Ethiopia) | By FY26 |
| Brownfield garment expansion | Completion of ongoing expansion | Six to nine months |
| Processing capacity expansion | ~INR 250 crores investment to reach 37,000 tons | 18 to 24 months to full operations |
| Walmart and GAP ramp-up | Full capacity utilization for these two customers | By end of this calendar year |
| Sugar segment EBITDA | Absolute EBITDA 10% to 12% lower due to crushing drop and juice ban | Impact felt next year; could be compensated if next season is good |
| FY24 turnover | 10% to 12% increase YoY | FY24 |
| FASO brand South India scale | ~INR 10 crores per month run rate | One to two years |
| Cyclone-delayed garment shipments | ~INR 100 crores, ~0.4 crore garments to be recognized | Q4 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue (9M FY24) | ₹4,418 cr |
| Net profit (9M FY24) | ₹592 cr |
| Yarn and fabric margin | 15% |
| Garment margin | 27% |
| Sugar margin | 27% |
| Yarn sales volume | 14,000 tons |
| Fabric sales volume | 2,000 tons |
| Garment sales volume | 3.3 cr pieces |
| Garment production volume | 3.7 cr pieces |
| Yarn sales value | ₹355 cr |
| Fabric sales value | ₹60 cr |
| Sugar sales volume | 11,000 tons, value ₹43 cr |
| Ethanol sales volume | 2.16 cr liters, value ₹137 cr |
| Garment order book | ₹1,100 cr, all-time high |
| Garment realization outlook | $2 plus expected from Walmart and GAP |
| Revenue held up (cyclone) | ~₹100 cr, 0.4 cr garments deferred to Q4 |
| Sugar closing inventory | 58,000 tons as of Dec 31 |
| Ethanol production capacity | 5 lakh liters per day |
| Ethanol production plan (FY24) | 7–8 cr liters |
| Expected sugar production (FY24) | ~2 lakh tons |
| Cane crushing drop (current season) | ~10% due to monsoon impact |
| Revenue impact from ethanol juice ban | ~₹200 cr |
| Sugar segment absolute EBITDA impact | 10–12% lower expected |
| Garment brownfield expansion | 3 cr pieces additional capacity, completion in 6–9 months |
| Processing capacity expansion outlay | ₹250 cr, timeline 18–24 months |
| Processing capacity post expansion | 37,000 tons |
| Garment capacity target by FY26 | 17.7 cr pieces (includes 1 cr pieces moved from Ethiopia) |
| Turnover growth guidance | 10–12% YoY increase expected |
| FASO brand target | ₹10 cr per month run rate in South India in 1–2 years |
| Cotton price movement | Fell from ₹1 lakh to ₹60,000 per candy |
| Wind power capacity | 61.92 MW |
| Solar and wind combined capacity | ~100 MW (post 25 MW solar addition) |