Key Takeaways
- Spinning margins collapsed, but the worst is over: Gross margin contracted sharply as cotton yarn spreads fell to ~₹80/kg, well below the ₹110–120 ideal. Management declared the cotton price crash over and expects spinning margins to recover to 19–20% this year.
- Europe is 60% of sales and slowing, yet orders are consolidating with scale: The Ukraine war shifted European purchasing toward basics, and demand has softened for 3–4 months. Even so, large customers like Primark increased orders, and management believes the European worst is behind them.
- A ₹500 Cr capex cycle is nearing completion: Modernization, a rooftop solar plant, ethanol expansion, and a new viscose vortex spinning mill are all due online within FY24, adding stable-margin capacity and reducing power-cost volatility.
- Management is deliberately not chasing China Plus One with big capex: Despite analyst pressure, leadership is waiting 3–6 months for market clarity before committing to the next garment Greenfield, citing war uncertainty and a preference not to risk idle assets.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised spinning margin recovery to 19–20% actually begins, the June–July order cycle for garments, and any decision on the next garment capacity expansion after the 3–6 month watch period.
Spinning: The Margin Shock & Recovery Bet
- Gross margin hit: Sharp contraction driven entirely by the spinning business (yarn and fabric), where volatile cotton prices and subdued demand crushed realizations and profitability.
- Cotton price whiplash: Prices surged past ₹1 lakh per candy, then crashed, before stabilizing at ₹60,000–62,000. Management says the worst is over, with hope for improvement in the next quarter or two.
- Spread still depressed: The current cotton yarn spread is around ₹80/kg, far below the comfortable ₹110–120 range. Full-year spinning margin was 17%, below the 19–20% management considers normal.
- Farmer price floor: Farmers are holding back roughly 50 lakh bales, slowing market arrivals whenever prices dip below ₹60,000, effectively putting a floor under domestic cotton. Domestic and international prices are near parity, but an 11% import duty makes imports unviable.
- Industry running below capacity: Mills have operated 10–15% below normal for 4–5 months because yarn demand was slow and prices were falling.
- Inventory overhang cleared: All previous-season cotton inventories have been fully consumed; only current-season stock remains, removing a source of high-cost inventory drag.
Nataraj: “I can say that the worst is over because cotton prices went up to more than one lakh per candy and they just came down.”
Garments: Steady Volume, Shifting Logistics
- Volume growth modest, realization-led revenue: Garment volumes grew 5–7% last year, but a large part of revenue came from higher realizations, reaching nearly ₹200 Cr. About 10% of that was cotton price pass-through, expected to continue.
- Chengapalli ramp is slow by design: The large new unit takes 12–14 months to ramp because training is phased and production must align with customer delivery schedules; it cannot go all at once.
- Customers now use KPR as a warehouse: Buyers keep inventory at KPR’s factory. KPR produces and holds roughly 2 months of stock, shipping only when the customer issues a schedule. The order book duration is unchanged; only the shipping cadence has shifted.
- Order book visibility: Current order book covers about 6 months; the next order cycle begins June–July, with inquiries and discussions at expected levels. Management expects to produce 15 crore pieces this year.
- Value addition creeping up: Printing technologies, embroidery, and whole-body printing have been introduced, lifting value addition by around 10%.
- Single-shift preference: Management prefers to keep operations on single shift, deflecting analyst suggestions to add a second shift to capture more volume.
P. Nataraj: “Sir, generally if you see the China Plus One, everybody we are talking since long and overall, the sentiment is that the customers are looking for a large customer. Another very important issue is the inventory which is a big issue now.”
Capex: Finishing One Cycle, Hesitating on the Next
- ₹500 Cr program nearing completion: Modernization and expansion across the board, plus a ₹50 Cr rooftop solar plant already commissioned. Processing and printing expansion completes in H1 FY24; the ethanol expansion starts before the October 2023 sugar season; the vortex spinning mill finishes within FY24.
- Vortex spinning: stable margins, less risk: The new ₹100 Cr mill uses viscose fiber, not cotton. Viscose has far less price fluctuation, so management expects steady 18–20% margins, testing the model before potentially expanding further.
- Ethiopia machinery coming home: An attempt is underway to relocate machinery from Ethiopia to India; management hopes it happens quickly but gave no timeline.
- Next garment Greenfield on hold: Management is watching the market for 3–6 months before deciding. Any new expansion would be similar in size to previous ones (3.5-4 crore pieces) and in the same region.
- Brownfield as a safety valve: A small Brownfield addition of 1-2 crore pieces can be done quickly with sewing machines and balancing equipment in existing space, executable within 12–14 months including land, infrastructure, and labor.
- Mega textile park waiting on policy: Development activities have not started in Tamil Nadu; management will decide only after final notifications and benefits are announced.
P. Nataraj: “We don’t want to just invest hundreds of crores, and anything happens, so we don’t want to put the investment and keep it idle or struggle for getting orders and all these things.”
Geography & Trade: Europe Dominates, FTAs Loom
- Europe is 60–61% of sales and growing: Existing customers like Primark increased orders after the new plant was commissioned specifically for their requirements. KPR is historically strong in Europe because the Tirupur region is volume-driven.
- European demand softening but consolidating: The Ukraine war shifted purchasing from passion to basics, and the last 3–4 months have seen a slowdown. However, orders are moving toward large players, and management expects the worst in Europe is more or less over.
- US still small, growing slowly: US business only started expanding 3–4 years ago; management hopes the North America share will increase over time.
- Australia FTA already delivering: One customer relationship predates the FTA; after duty removal, order flow increased. Raw cotton imports from Australia have also begun because the FTA removed the import duty.
- UK FTA: unquantified upside: Management expects the FTA to bring more orders and better pricing once duty is removed, but declined to quantify the financial impact.
- Japan and Korea not a focus: Those markets are niche, not volume-based; Tirupur exporters focus on Europe and the US instead.
Sugar & Ethanol: Mixed Quarter, Normal Year Ahead
- Q4 margin dip is a mix shift, not a problem: Q3 margins were higher because most sales were export and ethanol, which carry higher margins. Q4 had very high sugar sales volume, which have lower margins, pulling the blended number down.
- Ethanol capacity coming online: New capacity will commence before the October 2023 sugar season, which should lift the blended margin when ethanol-based sales rise again.
- Sugar recovery expected at ~11%: For the current season, gross recovery is expected around 11% at the composite unit level.
- FY24 outlook: too early, but normal expected: Management declined to give sugar guidance, citing monsoon dependency, but noted last year’s rain and sowing were good, and expects a normal year in North Karnataka.
- High sugar inventory on books: Close to 1 lakh tonnes of sugar stock and molasses held for the off-season, contributing to elevated balance-sheet inventory.
Balance Sheet & Costs: Inventory Heavy, Power Pinched
- Working capital is seasonal, not structural: Working capital loans are higher because it is season-end; the company is holding stocks for the next 4–5 months and will regularize in coming periods.
- Three drivers of high inventory: High cotton inventory at elevated prices, roughly 2 months of garment stock held for customers, and sugar plus molasses stock for the off-season.
- Power cost spike: Other expenses rose substantially because no wind power was available in Q4, forcing reliance on higher-cost grid power. The new rooftop solar plant partly addresses this going forward.
- Depreciation step-up: Increased because new machinery came into operation during Q4, while in Q3 some older machinery had completed its useful life, temporarily lowering the charge.
- Debt comfort but no borrowing appetite: Management is comfortable up to 0.5x debt-equity but does not intend to borrow much because internal cash generation is strong.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Spinning margin recovery | Recover to 19–20% from 17% full-year FY23 level | During FY24 |
| Ethanol capacity commencement | New capacity operational | Before October 2023 sugar season |
| Processing & printing expansion completion | Project completed | H1 FY24 |
| Vortex spinning mill completion | ₹100 Cr mill operational | During FY24 |
| Garment production volume | 15 crore pieces | FY24, based on current order book |
| Next garment expansion decision | Decision after watching market | 3–6 months from now |
| Brownfield garment expansion execution | 1-2 crore pieces, including land, infra, labor | Within 12–14 months of decision |
| FASO brand revenue target | ₹100 Cr | Within 2 years |
| Revenue growth | Double digits | FY24 (hoped, not guided) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,327 cr (garments ₹200 cr, yarn ₹500 cr, fabric ₹70 cr, sugar ₹327 cr, ethanol ₹155 cr) |
| Garment segment margin | 25% |
| Yarn and fabric segment margin | 10% |
| Sugar segment margin | 20% |
| Blended sugar segment margin | 22% to 23% |
| Full-year spinning margin | 17% |
| Garment order book | ₹1,000 cr |
| Garment production | 13.3 cr pieces in FY23 |
| Garment sales | 12.8 cr pieces in FY23 |
| Garment capacity (India) | 14.7 cr pieces |
| Garment realization per piece | ₹211 |
| Yarn realization | ₹265 per kg |
| Fabric realization | ₹310 per kg |
| Cotton yarn spread | ~₹80 per kg, ideal spread ₹110–120 per kg |
| Cotton inventory cost | ~₹54,000 per candy (4 months' inventory) |
| Cotton price (current) | ₹60,000–62,000 per candy stabilized |
| Europe sales contribution | 60% of total, UK 15% of that 60% |
| North America sales contribution | 20% |
| Australia sales contribution | 14% |
| Sugar sales | 1 lakh tonnes (domestic 63,000, export 37,000) |
| Ethanol sales | 2,38,00,000 litres, entirely through juice |
| Cane crushed (current season) | 26 lakh tonnes |
| Combined sugar realization | ₹32.40 per kg |
| Ethanol realization | ₹65.33 per litre |
| Total CAPEX outlay | ₹500 cr (vortex ₹100 cr, solar ₹50 cr, processing ₹50 cr, ethanol ₹150 cr, modernization ₹100 cr) |
| Term loan | ₹590 cr |
| Working capital | ₹735 cr |
| Debt-equity ratio | 0.37%, comfortable up to 0.5% |
| Blended cost of debt | ~6% |
| FY24 ethanol plan | 10 cr litres, 50:50 juice and molasses |
| Spinning industry capacity utilization | 10% to 15% below normal |