Key Takeaways
- Best-ever quarter, industry-leading margins: Net EBITDA margin hit 54.3%, up 648 bps QoQ, while PAT surged 151% QoQ to INR 48.6 crore, making Q3 FY23 the strongest quarter on most key metrics.
- Pricing power is structural, not cyclical: ARR rose 17% QoQ and 24% vs Q3 FY20, driven by a supply pipeline capped at 5% for four years against branded demand growing 12–14% annually; replacement-cost economics make new builds unviable at current ARRs.
- Keys acquisition is a margin-recovery story: Acquired mid-Q3 with a “very mediocre” product, Keys dragged group occupancy but offers a clear renovation-led upside: INR 30 crore spend is expected to yield over 100% EBITDA return per year and lift ARR by at least INR 1,000.
- Corporate-to-retail mix shift is deliberate: Corporate share of room nights fell from 61% to 55% vs Q3 FY20 as low-rate corporate business was churned out; retail now accounts for 45% and carries higher ARR, with down-trading customers retained within the group’s chain.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 occupancy hits the guided 75% at a higher ARR than Q3, the pace of Keys renovation execution, and any sign that foreign travel (still 40% down) begins to recover.
Demand & Pricing Environment
- Demand-supply imbalance is the core thesis: Branded hotel supply growth is capped at 5% for the next four years while branded demand is growing 12–14% annually; many hotels that shut during COVID have not returned, and management explicitly states occupancy improvement is not linked to revenge travel.
- Pricing power is rooted in replacement cost: No new supply will come at current ARRs because building a Lemon Tree Premier equivalent today requires ARRs of INR 8,000–INR 8,500 to be viable, given construction inflation and high debt costs; current ARRs remain 15–20% below that threshold.
- Business hotels, not leisure, are driving the rebound: 85% of inventory is business hotels, and these have bounced strongly; management believes revenge travel for leisure may have occurred in the first 6–9 months but will not continue at that level now that international travel has reopened.
- Four days a week, hotels are sold out: Unconstrained demand exceeds supply, so the bottom 10–15% of lowest-rate business is continuously churned out, driving retail segment ARR growth; no slowdown is visible despite inflation.
- IT exposure is small and may be turning: IT accounts for only 5–6% of total business, so even a 20% drop would have limited impact; management noted signs of IT picking up and indications of strong hiring this summer, which would benefit Bangalore’s Electronic City and Whitefield micro-markets.
- Foreign travel remains a drag: Foreign travel is still 40% down and foreigners account for 10% of revenue; management expects foreign travel to return from the coming year, but the timeline is uncertain and tied to the war ending and inflation easing.
Patanjali Keswani: “No supply will come in at current prices. Because the cost of replacement, cost of building a hotel today with the kind of inflation we have seen and the high cost of debt, nobody will build a hotel at the current rates, ARR — even at the current ARRs.”
Pricing Strategy & Customer Retention
- A ~40% price hike was executed over nine months: A ~20% rate hike was taken in H1, followed by a further 17–18% hike in Q3; this led to some churn of low-rate customers and muted occupancy, but ARR rose 24% vs Q3 FY20.
- Higher-category rooms were pushed to corporates in Q3: When occupancy was high, lower-category rooms and rates were not offered, so even corporates received higher-category rooms; this drove a corporate ARR increase of ~13% and an “others” increase of ~20% on a weighted-average basis.
- Customer down-trading stays within the group: Price hikes cause 5-star customers to move to Lemon Tree Premier, Premier customers to Lemon Tree, and Lemon Tree customers to Red Fox; the entire movement stays within the group’s chain, so no customers are lost.
- ARR tier migration is structural: Lemon Tree Premier’s Q3 FY20 ARR now equals Lemon Tree Hotels’ Q3 FY23 ARR; Lemon Tree Hotels’ Q3 FY20 ARR equals Red Fox’s Q3 FY23 ARR; Red Fox’s Q3 FY20 ARR equals Keys’ ARR today. Customers seeking old price points simply shift down one tier.
- Red Fox deliberately shed low-rate business: ARR increased 20% vs Q3 FY20 while occupancy fell 5 pp; management avoided very low-rate business, and at INR 4,300 ARR, Red Fox is now “touching parts of the Lemon Tree.”
- Dynamic corporate pricing begins October 2023: Top 20 key accounts (filler accounts, ~20% of total room nights) may see rates up 8–10%; other corporates (~15–19% of room nights) will get a discount off the website rate of 10–20% depending on account size, making pricing automatically dynamic.
Patanjali Keswani: “We are not losing any customers. We may go down at the ARR of the lower hotels, but we are getting enough customers at Lemon Tree Premier from the 5 stars.”
Keys Acquisition & Renovation Plan
- Keys was acquired mid-Q3 with a weak product: Occupancy was lower because the product is “very mediocre,” certain markets (Kerala, Ludhiana, Visakhapatnam) have very low demand, and Bangalore IT districts (Electronic City, Whitefield) were subdued; occupancy fell vs Q3 FY20 and RevPAR fell 10%, though ARR was repriced up 18%.
- Renovation spend of INR 30 crore over two years: INR 5 lakhs per room for half the portfolio, INR 1 lakh per room for the other half; some spending has already started, and new room designs are complete for all hotels.
- Post-renovation ARR expected to rise by at least INR 1,000: Half the portfolio will move to Red Fox’s current ARR level of ~INR 4,300; fully renovated ARR will be even higher, and occupancy is expected to exceed the Q3 FY20 level of 66% with a price increase of at least 20%.
- Renovation strategy differs by market: In Kerala, Ludhiana, and Visakhapatnam, the market itself is down and the product is even more down, so the strategy is occupancy-led; in Pune and Bangalore, the product needs an upgrade to enable repricing, so the strategy is both occupancy and pricing.
- 75% of renovation spend is treated as opex: Depreciation of about INR 110 crore per year is effectively cash profit; EBITDA fluctuates depending on whether a hotel is in a renovation year or not, so some EBITDA gets reduced by renovation activity.
Patanjali Keswani: “We feel that by spending INR 30 crore we will get a more than 100% return in EBITDA per year from Keys.”
Portfolio Growth & Pipeline
- Signed 7 new hotels in Q3: Locations include Thekkady, Haridwar, Jamshedpur, Dehradun, Chandausi, Banswara, and Tezpur; operationalized 3 hotels: Lemon Tree Kalina (Mumbai), Lemon Tree Mukteshwar, and Keys Lite Vishakapatnam.
- Aurika, MIAL is on track for October 2023: Construction is proceeding; October–November will be very low months due to Diwali and Dussehra, so the first stable year will be FY25 with an expected ARR of INR 12,000–13,000.
- FY23 signings target: Confident of signing a total of 26 hotels with 1,400 rooms by end of Q4 FY23.
- FY24 pipeline ambition: Expect to sign another 35 hotels with about 2,000 rooms, open 23 managed hotels with about 1,500 rooms, plus open the Mumbai International Airport hotel; from the current 87 hotels, expect to grow to 111 hotels by end of FY24.
- Long-term target: 100 cities and 25,000 rooms in the next four years, focused on the 2-to-4-star and upscale segments, aiming to saturate the Indian mid-market.
- Managed-fee income is scaling rapidly: Total fee from managed hotels in 9M FY23 was INR 25.1 crore, up 94% vs 9M FY20; FY23 management fee expected at INR 35–36 crore, with 50% growth next year and an intent to hit INR 100 crore by the year after next.
Profitability & Cost Structure
- Net EBITDA margin reached an industry-leading 54.3%: This was 648 bps above Q2 FY23 and 1,265 bps above Q3 FY20; 9-month net EBITDA already crossed 50%, and Q3 net EBITDA was nearly 53%.
- Cash profit surged to INR 72.1 crore: Up 63% QoQ and 114% vs Q3 FY20, driven by cost optimization and margin expansion; management highlighted robust internal accruals as the funding source for both the APG buyback and Aurika Mumbai capex.
- All-in costs stabilized at INR 105–110 crore per quarter: Variable costs rise 10–12% with occupancy and 30% with food sales; room revenue contribution is 90%, F&B contribution is 70%, and other revenue contribution is 40%, so driving room sales first keeps pushing EBITDA margins higher.
- Management claims lowest-cost-operator status: This enables north-of-50% EBITDA at current ARR and occupancy levels, though some EBITDA gets reduced by renovation spend; the company has no plans for wellness stays or spa expertise (spa is outsourced), staying focused on the domestic Indian consumer.
- APG CCPS buyback funded internally: 60% of APG’s CCPS will be bought back via merchant-banker valuation; slump sales are no longer tax-effective and transfer costs were extremely high, so the buyback route was chosen; debt levels will not change significantly.
Kapil Sharma: “There are a robust internal accrual in the company, which can take care of this acquisition as well as the capex which is required for the Aurika, Mumbai property. So that is not much different from the debt level, which would happen.”
Market-by-Market Performance
- Same-store RevPAR was 18% above Q3 FY20 vs industry at 2% above: Outperformance was recorded in Mumbai, Hyderabad, Delhi, Bangalore, Pune, Gurgaon, and Chandigarh; Chennai and Goa underperformed.
- Bangalore IT micro-markets were subdued: Hotels in Electronic City and Whitefield were soft for both Keys and Lemon Tree; management expects IT hiring to pick up this summer, which would benefit these areas.
- Gurgaon has picked up fully in Q3: No further detail provided, but the market is now performing strongly.
- Leisure portfolio is small and performing fine: Very little leisure exists in the owned portfolio; in mixed leisure-business markets like Aurangabad, Jaipur, and Chandigarh, performance is quite fine, with Chandigarh over 80% occupancy.
- Key demand segments are broad-based: Financial services, pharma, auto, retail, and large services sectors are all growing very fast; the retail segment is growing “super-fast.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 FY23 group occupancy | Over 75% (Lemon Tree at ~80%), ARR above Q3 levels | Q4 FY23 |
| Q4 FY23 Keys RevPAR | RevPAR will catch up in Q4 | Q4 FY23 |
| FY23 hotel signings | 26 hotels with 1,400 rooms | By end of FY23 |
| FY24 revenue growth | Better than 20% higher than FY23 | FY24 |
| FY24 net EBITDA margin | Above FY23 net EBITDA margin | FY24 |
| FY24 PAT | 40–50% higher than FY23 | FY24 |
| FY24 hotel signings and openings | Sign 35 hotels (~2,000 rooms), open 23 managed hotels (~1,500 rooms) plus Aurika MIAL | FY24 |
| Aurika, MIAL opening | Construction on track | October 2023 |
| Aurika, MIAL first stable year | ARR of INR 12,000–13,000 | FY25 |
| Keys renovation spend | INR 30 crore, yielding over 100% EBITDA return per year | Over next 2 years |
| Keys post-renovation ARR | Increase by at least INR 1,000; half the portfolio at Red Fox ARR level (~INR 4,300) | Post-renovation |
| Keys post-renovation occupancy | Exceed 66% (Q3 FY20 level) with at least 20% price increase | Post-renovation |
| Managed-fee income | INR 35–36 crore in FY23; 50% more next year; INR 100 crore target | FY23 / FY24 / year after next |
| Dynamic corporate pricing | Top 20 accounts up 8–10%; others at discount off website rate | From October 2023 |
| Long-term room target | 100 cities, 25,000 rooms | Next 4 years |
| ARR doubling (conditional) | Base case if inflation comes under control and war ends with regular foreign travel resuming | Hoped from October 2023, may go to October 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹234.1 cr, 19% over Q2 FY23 and 15% up versus Q3 FY20 |
| Net EBITDA margin | 54.3%, 648 bps above Q2 FY23 and 1,265 bps above Q3 FY20 |
| PAT | ₹48.6 cr, 151% over Q2 FY23 and 338% up versus Q3 FY20 |
| Cash profit | ₹72.1 cr, 63% up versus Q2 FY23 and 114% up versus Q3 FY20 |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | Better than 20% higher revenue over FY23 |
| FY24 PAT growth guidance | 40%–50% higher than FY23 |
| Gross ARR | ₹5,738, 24% increase over Q3 FY20 ARR of ₹4,644 |
| Group occupancy | 67.6%, compared to 71% in Q3 FY20 |
| Lemon Tree division occupancy | 71.4% |
| Keys division occupancy | 50.6% |
| Same-store RevPAR growth vs Q3 FY20 | 18% up, versus industry at 2% up |
| Corporate vs retail room-night mix | 55% and 45%, shifted from 61% and 39% in Q3 FY20 |
| Managed hotels fee (9M FY23) | ₹25.1 cr, 94% up versus 9M FY20 |
| Hotels signed in FY23 (year to date) | 20 hotels, about 1,100 rooms |
| FY23 full-year signing expectation | 26 hotels with 1,400 rooms |