Key Takeaways
- PAT surge driven by a one-off transfer: H1FY23 PAT of INR 16,635 crore was lifted by a INR 14,271.80 crore transfer from Non-Par to Shareholders account, not by operating trends.
- VNB margin jumped on assumption changes: Net VNB margin rose to 14.6% from 9.3% YoY, primarily because of a higher risk-free rate assumption, while a large wage provision of INR 11,544 crore was booked.
- Non-Par pivot is accelerating: Non-Par share of individual APE reached 8.99%, up from 7.12% in FY22, with management targeting a 75-25 Par/Non-Par mix within a few years.
- IEV barely moved despite strong VNB: Indian Embedded Value grew only 0.52% over March 2022 as adverse market movements and a fund bifurcation effect offset operating variances.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 13th-month persistency decline reverses after product modifications, the pace of Non-Par product uptake, and any resolution of the unexplained NEP/GWP discrepancy.
The Non-Par Shift: Strategy & Product Engine
- Mix target is ambitious: Management wants the individual portfolio to move from roughly 93-7 Par/Non-Par to 75-25 within a few years, a shift it expects will significantly lift VNB margins and absolute VNB.
- Product launches are filling the basket: Three new Non-Par products launched in H1FY23 (Bima Ratna, Dhan Sanchay, New Pension Plus), plus a close-ended single-premium product (Dhan Varsha) and a full ULIP range now available.
- Non-par savings grew 251% YoY to almost ₹200 crores, while ULIPs grew 79% YoY to ₹1,507 crores, both off small bases.
- Non-par annuity growth was modest at 7.15% YoY on a large base of ₹5,833 crores, and individual Non-Par VNB margins dipped mid-year when annuity pricing was rephrased to be more competitive before recovering to 14.6%.
- Group business is the quiet giant: Fund-based pension contributes ~90% of group business, and group contributes almost as much embedded value as the overall portfolio despite lower VNB margins, which improved to 12%+ this quarter because the growth driver within group was higher-margin annuity products.
Pant: "The immediate goal is that within next few years these product portfolio mix in the individual segment could possible turn around to 75-25 sort of proportion from current 95-5 or 93-7 sort of proportions. That is the ultimate goal."
Embedded Value & The Transfer Mechanics
- IEV grew just 0.52% over March 2022: Market movements pulled IEV down, offset by operating variances including unwind plus VNB; the fund bifurcation effect and a transfer from the ASM fund to P&L caused movement between VIF and ANW without much overall IEV impact.
- The big transfer explained: INR 14,271.80 crore (net of tax) moved from Non-Par to Shareholders account, pertaining to accretions on available solvency margin; roughly INR 4,500 crore of this relates to Q4 FY22 because fund bifurcation happened in January, became effective in September, and accretion since then has been accounted for.
- Unwind expectation set: Management expects the long-run unwind to be close to best-estimate assumptions of 8-9%, though no timeline was committed.
- EV walk disclosure promised: Analysis of Movement will be disclosed on an annual basis in the next reporting period; management declined to give the split on this call.
- All products now modeled in the EV calculation, with no business currently excluded from Embedded Value.
Ashok: "Regarding the question on IEV we are actually you will be aware that the fund bifurcation effect is performed on IEV and that is one of the reasons that initial growth in IEV is little bit slow, but I think the way corporation is performing we can hope to see better numbers going forward."
Persistency: Near-Term Pain, Product-Led Fix
- 13th-month persistency declined ~500 bps QoQ because certain large-selling products had persistency challenges; two products were reviewed and modified with increased ticket sizes and changed structures, and more were revised recently.
- 61st-month persistency improved 150-200 bps to 62.77%, reflecting a focus on retaining policies for longer periods.
- Management expects a fast correction in short-term persistency due to the product modifications and is confident in long-term improvement.
- Death claims fell 45.27% YoY and maturity claims fell 6.60% YoY, providing a tailwind.
Distribution & Market Position
- Market share rose to 68.25% for H1FY23, a 5-percentage-point gain in six months, retaining the No. 1 slot with sequential growth since the beginning of CY2022.
- Agency channel remains dominant, selling over 96% of policies and NBP in H1FY23, with policies sold growing 14.75% YoY.
- Banca and alternate channels grew fast off a tiny base: 39% YoY by number of policies and 63% by NB premium, but still only 1.72% of policies and 3.37% of premium.
- Digital adoption is rising: ANANDA app policies grew 118% YoY, and management says a large part of business procurement and transactions already happens on the digital platform, with Bima Sugam being evaluated for the marketing strategy.
Costs, Provisioning & Regulatory Comfort
- A INR 11,544 crore provision for employee retirement benefits was made because wage revision fell due from 1 August 2022; management clarified this is a prudent, systematic provision, not actual wages paid or a comment on the wage revision outcome.
- Management Expense Ratio rose to 16.69% from 15.33% YoY, partly reflecting the wage provision.
- On the IRDAI draft commission and expense regulations, LIC expects to be well within the proposed framework and says its position becomes more comfortable than before; management is unsure if the 70% limit will remain as discussions are ongoing.
- An income tax refund of INR 25,527 crore (refund of INR 18,900 crore plus interest of INR 6,627 crore) was received, a material cash inflow.
Pant: "First of all, it is a clarification that it is not actual wages, it is prudent step on part of the corporation to provide for it so that systematic provisioning can be made. It does not in any way comment upon actual wage revision or any distribution."
Unresolved Questions
- NEP/GWP discrepancy: An analyst flagged that Net Earned Premium (INR 1.3 trillion) was 30% higher than Gross Written Premium (INR 1 trillion) in Q2, which is unusual since NEP is normally lower. Management did not resolve the question on the call and agreed to take it offline.
- EV walk detail deferred: Management declined to give qualitative comments on the drivers of the broadly stable EV, stating the Analysis of Movement will be disclosed only on an annual basis.
- Group business split withheld: A request for the split of group business between annuity and non-annuity was declined; only overall line-of-business splits are being provided at this point.
- Dividend policy: No prefixed policy exists; the call is taken by the board per the provisions of the Act.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| IEV disclosure frequency | IEV to be disclosed twice a year (March 31 and September 30) alongside financial results | Ongoing from this quarter |
| EV walk disclosure | Analysis of Movement to be disclosed on an annual basis | Next reporting period |
| Product mix target | Individual segment Par/Non-Par mix to shift from ~93-7 to 75-25 | Within next few years |
| Non-Par fund accretions | Future accretions to be regularly accounted for in respective quarters | Going forward |
| Persistency correction | Short-term persistency to recover after product modifications | Expected very fast (undated) |
| COVID-19 reserve review | Continuously reviewing; will reduce when the time comes | Undated, condition-based |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total Premium Income (H1 FY23) | ₹2,30,456 cr, +23.87% YoY |
| Individual New Business Premium (H1 FY23) | ₹24,535 cr, vs ₹21,964 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Group Business Premium Income (H1 FY23) | ₹1,02,718 cr, vs ₹66,296 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Profit After Tax (H1 FY23) | ₹16,635 cr, vs ₹1,437 cr in H1 FY22; includes ₹14,271.80 cr transfer from Non-Par to Shareholders account (net of tax) |
| Transfer from Non-Par to Shareholders account (net of tax) | ₹14,271.80 cr, comprising ₹5,580.72 cr for Q2, ₹4,148.78 cr and ₹4,542.31 cr for preceding two quarters |
| Provision for employee retirement benefits (wage revision) | ₹11,544 cr, prudent provision on account of wage revision due from 1 Aug 2022 |
| Income Tax refund received | ₹25,527 cr, comprising ₹18,900 cr refund and ₹6,627 cr interest |
| Net VNB margin (H1 FY23) | 14.6%, vs 9.3% in H1 FY22 and 15.1% for full year FY22 |
| Gross VNB (H1 FY23) | ₹4,836 cr; Net VNB: ₹3,677 cr |
| Indian Embedded Value (IEV) | ₹5,44,291 cr as on 30 Sep 2022, +0.85% over 30 Sep 2021 and +0.52% over 31 Mar 2022 |
| Assets Under Management | ₹42,93,778 cr as on 30 Sep 2022, +8.69% over 30 Sep 2021 |
| Total market share (H1 FY23) | 68.25%, up from 63.25% for year ended Mar 2022 |
| Individual business market share | 42.31%; Group business market share: 80.34% |
| New policies sold (H1 FY23) | 83,59,029, +13.55% YoY |
| Management Expense Ratio (H1 FY23) | 16.69%, vs 15.33% in H1 FY22 |
| 13th month persistency (premium basis, H1 FY23) | 77.62%, vs 78.77% in H1 FY22 |
| 61st month persistency (premium basis, H1 FY23) | 62.77%, vs 60.57% in H1 FY22 |
| Total death claims (H1 FY23) | ₹11,665 cr, lower by 45.27% YoY |
| Total maturity claims (H1 FY23) | ₹72,988 cr, lower by 6.60% YoY |
| Workforce | 1,01,313 employees as of 30 Sep 2022, 95% in Branch and Divisional Offices |
| Non-Par share of individual APE (H1 FY23) | 8.99%, up from 7.12% in FY22 and 7.75% in Q1 FY23 |
| Non-Par savings premium growth (at Sep 2022) | 251% YoY |
| Non-Par annuity premium (H1 FY23) | ₹5,833 cr, +7.15% YoY |
| ULIP premium (H1 FY23) | ₹1,507 cr, +79% YoY |
| Agency channel share of NBP (H1 FY23) | >96% |
| Banca and alternate channels NB premium growth | 63% YoY |
| ANANDA app policies completed (H1 FY23) | 3,14,955, +118% YoY |