Key Takeaways
- Group premium collapse drives headline decline: Total premium fell 10.72% YoY as group business dropped 30.90%, a cyclical swing management insists is not competitive loss and expects to recoup by year-end.
- Product mix shift is real but margin-neutral so far: Non-par APE grew 19.77% and its share of individual APE crossed 10%, yet net VNB margin stayed flat at 14.6% because annuity repricing and lower risk-free rates offset the mix benefit.
- Embedded value delivers a standout quarter: EV grew 21.7% YoY, one of the best prints management has seen, powered by equity gains and an 11.8% operating return on EV.
- Banca channel stumbled on macro, not strategy: Individual NBP from banca and alternate channels dipped ~2% as banks prioritized deposit-gathering amid NIM pressure; regular premium from the same channel grew 37%, so the underlying franchise held.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised H2 group business recovery materializes, if non-par margin stabilizes after the sharp drop from 68.7% to 50%, and any sign that persistency decisions from FY20–23 are converting into visible improvement.
Group Business: The Quarter’s Gravity Well
- Cyclical, not structural: Group business premium fell from ₹1,02,718 crore to ₹70,977 crore, a 30.90% YoY decline driven by the lumpy, cyclical nature of employee-benefit funding flows rather than competitive displacement. Management was explicit that premium did not migrate to competitors.
- Market share took the hit: Individual market share held relatively steady (40.35% vs 42.31%), but group market share dropped from 80.34% to 70.26%, amplifying the optics of the premium decline.
- Recovery plan is operational, not strategic: The corporation has increased follow-up with existing entities for premium collection and is working with new entities, aiming to show growth over the prior year by FY24 end.
Doraiswamy: "You can't ascribe it to that. It's not that the business -- the premium that has come to us has gone to any competitor. And though competition is felt in every sphere of our business activity... this degrowth or this impact that we are seeing in the current year cannot be ascribed to the increased competition."
Product Mix & VNB: The Margin Math
- Non-par is the growth engine: Non-par APE rose 19.77% YoY to ₹1,575 crore, with its share of individual APE moving from 8.98% to 10.76%. Three new non-par products launched in H1, including Dhan Vriddhi (single premium, ticket size above ₹2 lakhs) and Jeevan Kiran (return of premium).
- But non-par margins compressed sharply: Non-par margins fell from 68.7% to 50%, driven primarily by product repricing and secondarily by lower risk-free rates. Management framed this as a deliberate balance between margin rate and volume elasticity.
- Annuity repricing added pressure: Annuity products were repriced to offer significantly improved benefits to policyholders, described as among the best returns in the market, which compressed margins. Volume growth did not fully compensate.
- Par business is stable but small: Par margins were broadly unchanged and the segment contributes only 10% of VNB. Growth was subdued due to market conditions and carry-over effects from Q4 FY23.
- Net result: VNB margin flat at 14.6%: The mix shift toward higher-margin non-par was exactly offset by repricing within non-par and annuity, plus adverse assumption changes from falling risk-free rates, partially cushioned by improved mortality experience in group term.
Pant: "When you start the margins that you have restarted with high margins, then you have to also see ultimately, we have to work towards the value of new business itself. So, it is a balance between margins, and elasticity of that to the volume of sales, which happens."
Embedded Value & Profitability
- EV growth of 21.7% YoY was described as one of the best prints the corporation has seen, with a large contribution from the equity component alongside an 11.8% operating return on embedded value from core business performance.
- PAT of ₹17,469 crore includes ₹13,768 crore (net of tax) from accretion transfer to the ASM. Stripping ASM income from both periods, comparable Q2 PAT rose 9% QoQ from ₹7,261 crore to ₹7,925 crore.
- Expense ratio improved from 16.69% to 15.14%, reflecting operating leverage even as the top line contracted.
- Employee cost contained a one-off: Around ₹2,600 crore was provided for additional pension liability accruing to family pension holders. Regular employee cost follows IAS 15 and is always funded; one-off costs receive differential treatment based on approvals.
Pant: "This embedded value growth of around 21.7% is perhaps one of the best we are seeing around at this point of time."
Distribution: Agency Holds, Banca Stumbles
- Agency remains dominant: ~96% of policies and new business premium still flow through the agency channel, which sold 77.68 lakh policies. The channel is expected to absorb the impact of the 10-10-D regulatory change without much difficulty.
- Banca and alternate channels dipped ~2% in individual NBP during Q2, driven entirely by banks prioritizing deposit mobilization amid NIM pressure and rising cost of deposits. The hit was concentrated in single premium business; regular premium from the same channel grew nearly 37%.
- BAC channel showed green shoots: Grew 4.02% in NB premium and 18.33% in policies sold, signaling early progress in channel diversification.
- Agent non-par capability is building: The percentage of agents selling non-par products increased 3–4% over the last year, and senior agents are being trained. Ticket sizes rose across product categories, partly due to higher minimum sum assured and minimum ticket size in some plans.
Persistency & Policyholder Metrics
- 13th and 37th month persistency improved on both premium and policy basis, while 25th month persistency declined. Management expects decisions taken between FY20 and FY23 to produce visibly improved outcomes near the end of this year.
- Composite license ambition remains directional: Management acknowledged the need for a solution-based product basket covering the full customer lifecycle, but noted that a final regulatory call on cross-selling between insurance companies or allowing all insurance and financial products is still pending.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Group business recovery | Recoup H1 degrowth and show growth over prior year | By FY24 year-end |
| Banca channel improvement | Better show in subsequent quarters, both regular and single premium | H2 FY24 and beyond |
| Persistency visibility | Decisions from FY20–23 to show visible outcomes | Near end of this year |
| Non-par margin trajectory | Margins expected to rise as non-par share increases further | Unspecified (direction stated) |
| Product basket completeness | Complete basket covering all life-cycle requirements, yielding good results | Within FY24 and thereafter |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total Premium Income (H1 FY24) | ₹2,05,760 cr, decline of 10.72% YoY |
| Individual New Business Premium (H1 FY24) | ₹25,184 cr, vs ₹24,535 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Group Business Total Premium (H1 FY24) | ₹70,977 cr, decrease of 30.90% YoY |
| Profit After Tax (H1 FY24) | ₹17,469 cr, includes ₹13,768 cr (net of tax) from accretion on Available Solvency Margin |
| Profit After Tax (Q2 FY24 comparable) | ₹7,925 cr, increase of 9% QoQ vs comparable Q2 FY23 figure of ₹7,261 cr |
| Indian Embedded Value | ₹6,62,605 cr as on Sep 30, 2023, increase of 21.74% YoY |
| Net VNB (H1 FY24) | ₹3,304 cr, vs ₹3,677 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Net VNB Margin (H1 FY24) | 14.6%, vs 14.5% in H1 FY23 (rounded to 14.6%) |
| Solvency Ratio | 1.90 as on Sep 30, 2023, vs 1.88 as on Sep 30, 2022 |
| Assets Under Management | ₹47,43,389 cr as on Sep 30, 2023, growth of 10.47% YoY |
| Market Share by First Year Premium (H1 FY24) | 58.50% |
| Market Share in Individual Business (H1 FY24) | 40.35%, vs 42.31% in H1 FY23 |
| Market Share in Group Business (H1 FY24) | 70.26%, vs 80.34% in H1 FY23 |
| Non Par Share of Individual APE (H1 FY24) | 10.76%, vs 8.98% in H1 FY23; Non Par APE growth of 19.77% YoY |
| New Policies Sold (H1 FY24) | 80.61 lakh, vs 83.59 lakh in H1 FY23 |
| Total Agents | 13.46 lakh as on Sep 30, 2023, vs 13.35 lakh as on Sep 30, 2022 |
| Agency Channel Share of NBP (H1 FY24) | ~96% |
| BAC Channel NB Premium (H1 FY24) | ₹858.55 cr, growth of 4.02% YoY |
| BAC Channel Policies Sold (H1 FY24) | 1,70,751, growth of 18.33% YoY |
| Overall Expense Ratio (H1 FY24) | 15.14%, vs 16.69% in H1 FY23 |
| 13th Month Persistency (Premium Basis, H1 FY24) | 78.49%, vs 77.62% in H1 FY23 |
| 61st Month Persistency (Premium Basis, H1 FY24) | 62.53%, vs 62.77% in H1 FY23 |
| Additional Pension Liability Provision (Q2 FY24) | ~₹2,600 cr, for family pension holders |