Key Takeaways
- Q4 margin miss, but FY24 promises a step-change: EBITDA declined 12% YoY in Q4 on mix and one-off inventory charges, yet management guided to double-digit EBITDA margins for FY24, with an ambition to achieve and perhaps surpass the historic 10–11% band.
- A ₹1,300 Cr order book is the growth engine: 85–90% is new business, 40% is from EV models, and it carries asset turns of ~2.5x, promising a structural lift in returns as it ramps up.
- Revenue growth guided at 20–25% for FY24: This is a deliberate step down from FY23’s 32%, built on volume growth, full-year benefits of recent launches, and only a 10–15% contribution from the new order book.
- Profit expansion is expected to outpace revenue: Management stated operating margins and bottom line will grow at a much faster rate than the top line, with profit expansion of greater than 25% in FY24.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q1 margins stabilize as guided, the pace of high-cost inventory consumption through June/July, and any update on customer compensation for the Q4 design-change inventory charge.
Q4 Margin Miss: The One-Off Drags
- Product mix shift: Raw material cost was higher by ~0.5% QoQ because of a change in product mix, directly compressing gross margin.
- Design-change inventory charge: Raw material consumption spiked in Q4 specifically because of certain design changes on existing inventory; the company is still discussing with customers to get compensation for those changes, so this is a recoverable item, not a permanent cost.
- Mould business deferment: Mould margin compressed to ~17% in Q4 (vs 26% in Q4 FY22) because tooling sales were deferred to the next financial year, pushing profitability out rather than destroying it.
- Backward integration benefit neutralized: The full gross margin benefit from the Bawal electronics facility was not yet visible in FY23 because price changes impacting raw material consumption offset the internal margin expansion; FY24 should see the full electronics benefit flow through.
Anmol Jain: "In FY '24, we are a lot confident that we will be able to not just getting to the double-digit space, but definitely outperform our historic performance in terms of the margins as well."
Order Book: High-Value, High-Return Backlog
- ₹1,300 Cr confirmed order book: 85–90% is new business, 40% is from EV models, and over 90–95% is LED lamps, which carry a higher value contribution than legacy lighting.
- Asset turns step-change: The order book has come at asset turns of ~2.5x–2.6x, significantly above the company’s current ~1.5x; management expects overall company asset turns to improve to at least ~2x in the next 2 years as this backlog converts.
- Ramp-up cadence: Only 10–15% of the order book converts to revenue in FY24; peak revenue conversion of ~60% hits in FY25, making FY25 the year the backlog truly lands in the P&L.
- Capacity to meet it: One greenfield and maybe another brownfield expansion may be seen in the foreseeable future to meet the order book; Chakan Phase 1 alone is expected to add ~₹450 Cr in incremental revenue in a full-year FY25.
Anmol Jain: "On this current order book, the investments we are making, the asset turnover would be significantly higher than the asset turns the company enjoys today."
FY24 Growth Drivers
- Volume growth across key customers: Strong growth expected with Mahindra in FY24, momentum with MG Motors to continue, and the XUV700 supply starts from the new Chakan facility in Q3 FY24, contributing ~6 months of revenue.
- Full-year benefit of H2 FY23 launches: Models launched in the second half of FY23 will contribute for the full year in FY24, adding a layer of growth beyond the order book ramp.
- 2-wheeler segment momentum: FY23 2-wheeler revenue grew ~30% YoY driven by HMSI (~25% growth) and TVS (a new customer, contributing ~25% growth); the company is bullish on established players like Bajaj, TVS, Hero, and HMSI as they launch EV models.
- SUV premiumization tailwind: The strong shift from A/B segments to premium SUVs is a structural demand driver; Maruti, Mahindra, Tata, and MG are expected to remain in the top 5 customer list.
- Industry backdrop: Auto industry expected to grow by high single digits in FY24, supported by a robust domestic environment, GDP expansion to 6.5%, and a pre-election year consumerism push.
Deepak Jain: "I don't think anyone would have envisaged this kind of a very strong shift, which basically happened in the pass car, especially from A, B segments to actually a premium SUV kind of a segment."
Margin Recovery Path
- Gross margin inflection from Q2 FY24: High-cost inventory is expected to be consumed by June/July, after which gross margin should improve; Q1 FY24 margin is implied to be below double-digit as stabilization takes hold through Q1 and Q2.
- Backward integration benefit unlocks: The Bawal electronics facility will see a large chunk fully utilized in FY24, and the benefit of backward integration of electronics will start showing in margins after being neutralized in FY23.
- Operating leverage on a higher base: With 20–25% top-line growth and profit expansion guided at greater than 25%, operating margins and bottom line are expected to grow at a much faster rate than revenue.
- Endeavour to surpass historic bands: Management’s stated endeavour is not just to reach double-digit EBITDA margins but to perhaps surpass the historic 10–11% EBITDA band in FY24.
Anmol Jain: "Definitely, our endeavour is to achieve and maybe perhaps even surpass that bandwidth in FY '24."
Capex & Balance Sheet
- FY24 capex of ~₹300 Cr: Split into ~₹135 Cr for maintenance and brownfield, and ~₹175 Cr for the Chakan greenfield project, all to be capitalized in FY24.
- Chakan funding via debt: The greenfield will be funded through long-term debt of ~₹150 Cr, pushing the debt-equity ratio from 0.16 to ~0.3–0.32, a manageable levered bet on a high-return order book.
- Revenue upside on existing gross block: Per management, there is an upside of maybe about 10–20% on revenue based on the current gross block, implying existing assets can stretch further before new capacity is fully needed.
- Tax rate stays elevated: Full-year FY23 actual tax rate was 32.6% (Q4: 38%) due to deferred tax; the company has not opted for the 25% regime because available MAT credit continues till next year, so the tax rate is expected to remain around 32–33% at least in FY24.
Strategic Positioning
- Gurugram plant closure: A consolidation move, not a revenue loss; the plant, set up in the mid-80s, did not support new technology lamps in terms of technology, space, and infrastructure, and carried significant blue-collar manpower cost; all business moved to another NCR facility.
- Pune greenfield on schedule: Production expected to commence in Q3 FY24, with Chakan Phase 1 SOP scheduled for Q3 FY24 catering to Mahindra and Tata Motors; Phase 2 revenue stream likely from FY26 onwards.
- EV-agnostic lighting franchise: Lighting is powertrain-agnostic, so the company benefits from EV adoption without betting on any single EV OEM; on 2-wheelers, the strategy is to back established players as they transition to EVs while also trying to make inroads with 1 or 2 new-age EV players.
- SL Lumax associate strength: The Hyundai/Kia JV is performing well, with both OEMs strong and the JV as a 100% dedicated single-source supplier; margins of 13% expected to be sustained at least for next year, depending on Hyundai Korea’s purchase strategy.
Deepak Jain: "Lighting is actually powertrain-agnostic. So irrespective of EV or ICE, I mean say we'll continue to do with lighting."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 20–25% YoY growth | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | Double-digit EBITDA margin; endeavour to achieve and perhaps surpass historic 10–11% band | FY24 |
| Profit expansion | Operating margins and bottom line to grow at a much faster rate than top line; profit expansion greater than 25% | FY24 |
| Gross margin inflection | Improvement from Q2 FY24 onwards as high-cost inventory consumed by June/July | Q2 FY24 |
| Order book revenue conversion | 10–15% of ₹1,300 Cr order book converts to revenue | FY24 |
| Order book peak conversion | ~60% of order book converts to revenue | FY25 |
| Chakan Phase 1 SOP | Production commences, supplies to Mahindra and Tata Motors begin | Q3 FY24 |
| Chakan Phase 1 revenue | ~₹450 Cr incremental revenue in a full year | FY25 |
| Asset turnover improvement | Company asset turns to improve from ~1.5x to at least ~2x | Next 2 years |
| Capex | ~₹300 Cr total (₹135 Cr maintenance/brownfield + ₹175 Cr Chakan greenfield) | FY24 |
| Debt-equity ratio | Rise from 0.16 to ~0.3–0.32 on Chakan debt funding | FY24 |
| Tax rate | Remain around 32–33% | At least FY24 |
| SL Lumax associate margin | 13% margin sustained, subject to Hyundai Korea purchase strategy | Next year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹608 cr, +11% YoY |
| Manufacturing revenue growth | +17% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹53 cr, margin 8.8%; degrew 12% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 8.8%, vs 9.6% for full year FY23; impacted by product mix change and higher other expenses |
| PBT before exceptional items and share of associates | ₹24 cr, vs ₹39 cr in Q4 FY22 |
| PAT | ₹21 cr, vs ₹29 cr in Q4 FY22 |
| Gross margin | 35%, RM cost at 65% of revenue; RM higher by ~0.5% due to product mix |
| Mould business margin | ~17%, vs 26% in Q4 FY22; impacted by deferment of tooling sales |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 20%–25%, driven by volume growth and value growth from technology changes |
| FY24 EBITDA margin guidance | Double-digit, endeavour to achieve and perhaps surpass historic 10%–11% band |
| FY24 PAT growth expectation | Greater than 25% |
| Order book | ~₹1,300 cr, 85%–90% new business, 40% from EV models |
| Order book LED share | More than 90%–95% |
| Order book peak revenue conversion | ~60% in FY25; only 10%–15% in FY24 |
| FY24 capex | ~₹300 cr, comprising ~₹135 cr maintenance and ₹175 cr for Chakan greenfield Phase 1 |
| Chakan Phase 1 incremental revenue | ~₹450 cr, expected in full year FY25; SOP in Q3 FY24 |
| Long-term debt | ~₹80 cr currently; expected to increase by ~₹150 cr for Pune plant; debt-equity ratio to move from 0.16 to ~0.3–0.32 |
| Asset turns | 1.5x as on 31st March; expected to improve to at least ~2x with new order book |
| Forex loss (FY23) | ₹2.2 cr, included in other expense |
| Effective tax rate | 32.6% for full year FY23; 38% for Q4; expected to remain ~32%–33% in FY24 |
| LED lighting share (FY23) | 35%, conventional lighting 65% |
| Segment mix (FY23) | PV 67%, 2-wheelers 27%, CV 7% |
| Product mix (FY23) | Front lighting 66%, rear lighting 25%, others 9% |
| 2-wheeler revenue growth (FY23) | ~30% YoY; HMSI +25%, TVS +25% |
| MG Motors revenue growth (FY23) | ~₹73 cr YoY |
| SL Lumax margin | 13% currently; historically ranged 6%–7% to 13% |