Key Takeaways
- Growth returns, NIMs squeezed by design: Asset growth is broad-based and market share is rising, but net interest margins are under deliberate pressure from a mix shift toward lower-yield, higher-quality customers and a costly liquidity buffer carried for protection.
- Asset quality improved sharply: Gross Stage 3 fell from 11.3% to 6.7% YoY, driven by better rural cash flows and a focused collections approach that narrowed the gap between regulatory and Ind AS NPAs.
- A one-time NPA shock from an RBI ban: A regulatory restriction on using third-party repossession agents added ₹900 crore to GS3 in October; management expects no further significant additions and is confident the ban will be reversed.
- Costs are elevated but on a promised downward path: The cost-to-income ratio is targeted to fall from ~3.2% to 2.75% over the next three to four quarters, supported by operating leverage as the balance sheet doubles in three years.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the RBI ban is lifted by Q4 as management expects, the pace of NIM recovery as lending rate hikes take hold, and any further GS3 inflows from the repossession vacuum.
Asset Quality & the RBI Repossession Ban
- GS3 improved structurally: Gross Stage 3 fell from 11.3% to 6.7% YoY because post-COVID customer cash flows improved and the company adopted a slightly different collections management approach.
- NPA gap narrowed sharply: The gap between Ind AS GS3 and IRAC gross NPA shrank from 570 bps to 1.2% because collection efficiency in Stage 2 and Stage 3 accounts improved, arresting forward flow and enabling reversals from Stage 3 to Stage 2.
- The Hazaribagh incident: An accident during a tractor repossession in Jharkhand led the RBI to direct the company to stop using external agencies for repossessions; management states no process breach occurred and an investigation is ongoing.
- One-time GS3 shock: ₹900 crore was added to GS3 in October because the RBI restriction, effective October 1, 2022, caused cases to cross 90 days past due and become NPAs.
- No further significant additions expected: Customers who already became NPAs will not add again in subsequent months; new inflows in November and December are expected to be offset by customers paying overdues to exit NPA status.
- Provision comfort is ample: Even if the GS3 impact were to rise from ₹900 crore to ₹1,500 crore, the P&L would not require any additional provision; a number large enough to require provisioning will never happen, per management.
- Net NPA headroom: Significant headroom exists to remain below 6% net NPA under IRAC norms, given net Stage 3 is around 3%.
- Settlement programme launched: A concessional settlement programme now targets defaulting customers whose vehicles would have been repossessed; it is not an amnesty scheme for anyone to pay a low amount and exit.
Ramesh Iyer: "I also want to let you know that repossession has never been the first act for recovery it is always the last act for recovery and settlement, and it is done with some extremely defaulting customer."
Margin Dynamics & Yield Pressure
- Conscious mix shift to lower yields: The company deliberately entered into financing affluent, high-CIBIL customers with stable cash flows; these bring lower yields but also lower operating cost and lower delinquency, consistent with the three-year strategy laid out in March 2022.
- Product mix diluted yields: Growth driven by cars, commercial vehicles, and SME segments carries lower yields compared to tractors or pre-owned vehicles; tractor share fell from 17% to 14% YoY while car is 20% of the book.
- Liquidity buffer cost: A four-month liquidity chest was maintained to avoid paying much higher prices later, imposing a 25–30 bps holding cost; this position is likely to continue up to March.
- Rate pass-through lagged deliberately: The company delayed pushing up rates during the festival season to acquire good assets without building pressure; rate increases of 40–50 bps on selected auto products have now commenced and further sequential increases are planned.
- Pre-owned vehicle shortage: Low new-vehicle availability means fewer trade-ins, and low repossession activity means less stock from that channel; demand for pre-owned vehicles is high but availability is low, suppressing a higher-yield segment.
- NIM trajectory turning: Management expects the dip in NIMs to be arrested, with every quarter showing either stability or improvement, driven by lending rate increases and a product mix shift back toward tractors and pre-owned vehicles over the next two to three quarters.
Ramesh Iyer: "...we may not want to push up the rates during the festival times when it is the right time to actually acquire good assets and not unnecessarily build pressure by pushing rate so therefore we did delay passing on the rate but we have now commenced pushing up the rate back to the market..."
Operating Costs & Efficiency Levers
- Cost-to-income target path: Committed in March to bring the ratio down to 2.5%; from the 3.2% level it will come to 3% and then to 2.75% in the next three to four quarters, with a downward trend as the balance sheet grows.
- Employee cost catch-up: Increments were muted during pandemic years; the company has now introduced variable and fixed component increases to compensate employees given higher activity levels on disbursements and collections.
- 6,000 employees moved on-roll: Employees previously with manpower agencies, including collection and business executives, have been moved on-roll; the reclassification is cost-neutral as the expense shifts from other expenses to employee cost.
- Investment spending elevated: Investments in technology, digital, and data fronts, plus partnerships like India Post and OEM integrations, are keeping costs elevated but are expected to yield substantial results over time.
- Variable costs rising with activity: Travel costs, dealer reward programmes, and employee incentives grow with business; fuel price increases are also impacting travel costs.
Growth & the Rural Turnaround Thesis
- Broad-based asset growth: Asset growth is returning across the country and across products, not through any single product or geography; market share is being gained in core segments: utility vehicles, tractors, and cars.
- Disbursement momentum: Q2 saw 9% QoQ disbursement growth; October disbursement was the highest ever, though both festivals fell in the same month, so October–November combined should be compared YoY.
- Rural growth and collections move together: In rural markets, growth and collections go hand-in-hand, reflecting marketplace economic activity; collection efficiency is improving alongside growth.
- Macro tailwinds intact: A good monsoon, attractive support prices, and expected farm cash flows support the agri segment; road projects, mining, and construction activity support infra cash flows; tourism is at its best with no new COVID impact.
- Three-year doubling ambition: Management describes this as a turnaround story with a transformation agenda to almost double the balance sheet in three years from March 2022; the 2025 strategy laid out in 2022 is achievable and is not being relooked at.
Ramesh Iyer: "I think on an overall basis we are ready on all fronts to embark on this growth journey, and we do believe that it probably is a turnaround story for us and that is our transformation agenda which we put out in March 2022 to say how we almost double our balance sheet in three years space."
Funding, Liquidity & the Liability Side
- Bank borrowing share rose: The share of bank borrowing in total borrowings increased because market borrowings via bonds and NCDs remained volatile; FD flows, which were exceptionally high during COVID due to flight to safety, have since normalized.
- All-in cost parity: The all-in cost of FDs versus bank borrowing is not materially different because FDs incur third-party brokerage charges while bank borrowings do not.
- Shift to MCLR-linked pricing: On incremental bank sanctions, there is a movement from external benchmark-linked pricing to MCLR-linked pricing.
- FD rates may rise further: FD rates may be taken even higher depending on RBI actions going forward.
- Liquidity buffer to stay: The four-month liquidity chest position is likely to continue up to March and will not be reversed until an easing of the liquidity situation is seen.
Strategic Moves & Regulatory Engagement
- India Post partnership: Announced a partnership with India Post Payment Bank for acquisition, service, and collection, requiring good investment on digital and data fronts.
- MIBL stake buyout: Buying out partner AXA's stake in Mahindra Insurance Brokers Ltd; upon IRDA approval, it will become a 100% subsidiary; described as a great value-creating business that does not consume capital and has a phenomenal ability to provide various insurance products.
- Digital platform upgrades: The mobile app has been significantly upgraded for self-service journeys including pre-approved loan completion and customer service; core tech platforms for loan origination and loan management are being significantly invested in for improved versatility.
- Engaging RBI for ban reversal: Management is engaging with RBI very regularly, providing feedback on Board discussions, an internal deep dive, and gap fulfillment; the company has revisited its entire repossession process internally, found no major gaps, but sees scope for improvement.
- Confidence in reversal by Q4: Management believes that with every correct step taken, repossession activity should be available by Q4, though no specific timeframe can be given on when the order gets reversed.
Ramesh Iyer: "I am very, very confident that once this is seen in totality and seen along with the incident which caused an order. We are sure that there will be a revisit and we would get relief out of that."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NIM trajectory | Dip in NIM will be arrested; every quarter will see either stability or improvement | Over the next two to three quarters |
| Cost-to-income ratio | Reduce from ~3.2% to 3%, then to 2.75% | Next three to four quarters |
| Balance sheet growth | Almost double the balance sheet from March 2022 base | Three years (by March 2025) |
| RBI repossession ban reversal | Repossession activity should be available again | By Q4 FY23, per management belief |
| GS3 additions from RBI ban | No significant additions expected beyond the ₹900 crore added in October | November and December 2022 |
| Lending rate increases | 40–50 bps implemented on selected auto products; further sequential increases planned | Starting this month, continuing sequentially |
| Liquidity buffer | Four-month chest to be maintained | Up to March 2023 |
| CEO succession | Ramesh Iyer's term ends; NRC to engage with Chairman and group; decision well in advance | April or June 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Disbursements | Highest ever in October; growth across products and geographies |
| Assets under management growth | 9% QoQ; broad-based growth across segments |
| Net interest margin | 7.5%, expected to trend toward 7.25% with holding cost impact of 25–30 bps |
| Cost of borrowing increase budgeted | 75 bps for the full year |
| Lending rate increase implemented | ~50 bps on selected products, with further increases planned at 25 bps or higher |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 3.2%, target to reduce to 2.5% over three years; visibility to 3% then 2.75% in next three to four quarters |
| Gross stage 3 | 6.7%, down from 11.3% in same period last year |
| Net stage 3 | ~3%, providing significant headroom to remain below net 6% as per IRAC |
| Gap between Ind AS gross stage 3 and IRAC gross NPA | 1.2%, narrowed from 570 bps three quarters ago |
| GS3 addition from RBI repossession restrictions | ₹900 cr in October; not expecting significant further additions in November and December |
| Collection efficiency (quarterly) | 97–98% |
| Collection efficiency (October) | 91%, similar to last October due to festive season |
| Provision for Sri Lanka JV | ₹50–55 cr, one-time and not repeatable |
| Management overlay provision | ₹1,060 cr consumed into ECL formula; coverage remains the same |
| Employees moved from off-roll to on-roll | 6,000, including collection and business executives |
| Repossession volume (monthly) | ~4,000 vehicles; 2,000–3,000 impacted by RBI order |
| AUM mix: Auto | 31% of total book |
| AUM mix: Tractor | 14%, down from 17% YoY |
| AUM mix: Car | 20% of total book |
| SME as percentage of business | ~5% |
| 5-year deposit rate | 7.25% |
| Excess liquidity chest | 4 months; 25–30 bps impact on NIM expected to continue |