Key Takeaways
- Asset quality spike, but management frames it as delay: GS3 rose sharply, with 40% of the increase from tractors in agrarian states hit by disrupted cash flows. Management calls this a delay, not default, citing a similar Q2 pattern last year that reversed in H2.
- Credit cost confidence rests on falling end losses: H1 credit cost is 1.9%, but full-year guidance is held at 1.3%–1.5%. The bridge is a declining stock of flow-forward to write-off, not an assumption that slippages stop.
- Growth is muted and the outlook is cautious: H1 disbursement growth was just 2%, and full-year disbursements are expected to be flattish. Book growth will still benefit from strong past disbursements, but management is "not too bullish" on a strong H2 recovery for wheels.
- Margins are inching up from multiple small levers: NIM rose to 6.5% and is guided to 6.7% for the full year, helped by incremental IRR pass-through in PV, a rising used-vehicle mix, and structural fee income from the new insurance corporate agency license.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive season delivers enough collection improvement to validate the delay-vs-default thesis, and whether the H2 credit cost compression actually materialises given H1 slippages already match last year's full-year total.
Asset Quality: The Delay-vs-Default Debate
- Tractor stress concentrated in agrarian states: 40% of the GS3 increase came from the tractor segment in MP, Maharashtra, Gujarat, AP, and Telangana, where late rains disrupted cash flows for customers on half-yearly repayment schedules aligned with harvest cycles.
- Monthly-repayment states are holding up: In states where tractors are used for haulage plus agriculture and customers repay monthly, the same stress is not visible, reinforcing the view that the issue is a timing mismatch rather than a fundamental inability to pay.
- LCV and CV customers also squeezed: Beyond tractors, 70–80% of the customer base is self-employed non-professionals, many with small commercial vehicles, whose income levels have seen disruptions and overall leverage levels are slightly high.
- Slippages are high, but the credit cost bridge is end losses: H1 slippages already match last year's full-year figure of roughly ₹1,500 crores, yet management holds credit cost guidance because the stock of flow-forward to write-off is declining, and end losses have consistently trended down.
- Coverage ratios held, improvement promised in H2: ECL coverage on Stage 1, 2, and 3 was maintained this quarter, and management reiterated that improvement in overall LGD numbers and coverage ratios will come in the second half.
- A collection warroom is being set up: Management is establishing a dedicated collection warroom, similar to the one deployed post-COVID, to ensure the company is prioritised by customers for repayments in a year where underlying cash flows are not as strong as the past two years.
Raul Rebello: "I don't want to shy away from the fact that this is not a year equivalent to maybe last year or the year before last, where underlying constraints or underlying kind of cash flows are as rosy as they were in the past."
Credit Cost: The H2 Compression Bet
- H1 at 1.9%, full-year guided at 1.3%–1.5%: The compression relies on the same pattern as last year, when credit cost ended at 2.3% and was brought down, driven by a declining stock of GS3 flow-forward and the LGD play within the ECL model.
- Slippages and credit cost are not one-to-one: Management pushed back on mapping slippages directly to credit cost, arguing that credit cost has two variables: provision write-off and the LGD play, so higher slippages do not mechanically translate to higher credit cost.
- No artificial provision release in the base: An analyst asked whether a prior-period ECL model refresh had flattered the comparison; management clarified that only about ₹80 crores was released in Q3 FY24 from the annual model refresh, and it was not an intentional overlay.
- End losses are the confidence anchor: The summation of what moves from the existing GS3 portfolio to write-off at 36 months is expected to trend down further from ₹1,700 crores because the stock of flow-forward itself is reducing.
Raul Rebello: "The reason why we have a certain confidence in the credit cost, which, let's say, for H1 is at 1.9% which we say will come down from 1.3% to 1.5%. You would have seen something similar last year when we ended, let's say, credit cost at 2.3% and we brought it down."
Growth: Muted Disbursements, Book Still Expanding
- Disbursements flattish for the full year: H1 disbursement growth was just 2%, and management expects full-year disbursements to be flattish or muted, with a maximum possible upside of about 200 bps if they buy more market share.
- Book growth benefits from a strong past pipeline: Despite muted current disbursements, book growth is still expected to reach the 2x AUM target for the full year because of strong disbursements over the last two years feeding into the portfolio.
- Underlying commerce, not market share loss: The disbursement outcome reflects underlying auto, tractor, and CV commerce, and in some segments the company is only about 2 percentage points below the industry, not losing material share.
- PV growth subdued, but NTC scorecards offer scope: PV is not expected to have a strong outing from a disbursement standpoint, but management sees room to participate in new-to-credit and close-to-prime customer segments with reasonable confidence in the newly developed NTC scorecards.
- East region slowed by design: Disbursement acquisition in the East reduced by roughly 200 bps due to a complete review of the Northeast playbook and risk mitigation following the Mizoram incident last fiscal, plus underlying weakness in some markets.
- H2 wheels outlook is cautious: Management is not too bullish on a very strong recovery for wheels businesses in H2, citing an underlying demand-side squeeze, though some traction is possible in the festive period and in specific segments like tractors.
Margins: Small Levers, Steady Uptick
- NIM guided to 6.5%–6.7% for the full year: H1 closed at 6.5%, and a 10–15 bps improvement is expected in H2 from a combination of incremental IRR pass-through, a higher tractor mix, an 18% used-vehicle mix, and fee-based income.
- Yield increases are selective: In Q1 and Q2, incremental IRRs were passed on steadily in the PV segment, but in tractor and other segments where rates are already high versus banks and other NBFCs, no increases were made to remain competitive.
- Fee income is now structural: Fee income was strong this quarter, driven by the new insurance corporate agency license with tie-ups across six partners in life, health, and motor insurance, and management expects this income stream to grow going forward.
- Cost of funds relief is slow: Incremental cost of funds is okay, but the debt-equity mix is playing out and consuming more capital, so the stock-level cost of funds does not move rapidly.
- Cost-to-income improving toward target: The ratio has come down to roughly 40% from a peak of roughly 43%, and management wants it in the 38%–40% range, with new businesses adding cost but the denominator growing faster.
Raul Rebello: "I mean, ideally for a business like us being lower than 40% would be better, somewhere between 38% to 40%."
Diversification & New Businesses: Below Plan but Building Blocks in Place
- Diversification at 6% vs a 15% target: Management admitted the plan was quite aggressive and has not played out exactly as planned, though it will go up marginally for the rest of the year.
- Building blocks are in place: MSME and leasing businesses have encouraging trends, the mortgage business has a new chief business officer from Bajaj Finance, and the insurance corporate agency license is contributing to fee income.
- Rural housing is in repair mode: GS3 in rural housing came down from 12% to roughly 9% year-on-year, but the denominator is not increasing much as the focus is on collections. The organisation has been rationalised from roughly 10,000 to roughly 3,500 employees, exiting most low-ticket housing loans, with no growth compulsion at the moment.
- Co-lending partnerships for prime segments: Partnerships with SBI, Bank of Baroda, and other banks allow the company to put distribution on the table for prime PV and CV fleet customers where it may not want to use its own balance sheet, with a medium-term aspiration of ₹25–40 crores monthly throughput per partner.
Raul Rebello: "The plan was quite aggressive at 15% of the overall mix. And this number on reflection is something which has not played out exactly as per plan."
People, Technology & Process
- Senior leadership strengthened: New hires include a Chief Risk Officer from HDFC and Yes Bank, a Chief Business Officer for Mortgages from Bajaj Finance, a Chief Business Officer for Leasing and Partnerships, a 20-year RBI veteran, and a Chief Analytics Officer who joined close to a year back.
- New tech infrastructure live: A new loan origination system and loan management system from Salesforce went live, alongside new NTC scorecards developed with the augmented underwriting and risk team and a business rules engine.
- Volatility reduction is an aspiration, not a promise: Management stated it is constantly looking at ways to iron out inter-quarter movements through customer segment choices and loan EMI structuring that reflects harvest cycles, but acknowledged that a business with a decent mix of inherently volatile asset categories like tractors will always have some movement.
Raul Rebello: "It is a stated aspiration that we would like to level down the kind of inter quarter movements. In a business where you have a decent amount of mix on certain asset categories which are subject to inherent volatility like the tractor segment."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Credit cost | 1.3% to 1.5% | FY25 full year |
| GS3 plus GS2 | Come down below 10% | Unspecified |
| NIM | 6.5% to 6.7% | FY25 full year |
| Book growth | 2x AUM, no challenges expected | FY25 full year |
| ROA | 1.8% to 2%, management "more bullish on the 2 range" | FY25 exit |
| ECL coverage improvement | Improvement in LGD numbers and coverage ratios | H2 FY25 |
| Cost-to-income | 38% to 40% | Unspecified |
| End losses | Slide further from ₹1,700 crores | Unspecified |
| Disbursement growth | Flattish or muted; maximum ~200 bps upside if market share bought | FY25 full year |
| Diversification mix | Go up marginally from 6% | Rest of FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| AUM growth (full-year outlook) | ~18% if H1 growth rate continues, could rise another 100–300 bps with late catch-up |
| Disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | 2% YoY, with Q2 degrowth vs Q2 last year |
| NIM (H1 FY25) | 6.5%, full-year guided at 6.5% to 6.7% |
| NIM expected increase | 10 bps to 15 bps for overall NIM in H2 |
| Loan income yield change | +20 bps YoY |
| Fee income yield change | +10 bps QoQ |
| Total yield change | +30 bps QoQ (20 bps loan income, 10 bps fee income) |
| Credit cost (H1 FY25) | 1.9%, with Q2 at 2.3%; full-year guided at 1.3% to 1.5% |
| Credit cost (FY24 exit) | 2.3%, brought down from that level |
| Credit cost (FY25 exit guidance) | 1.3% to 1.5% |
| GS3 | 3.8%, down 50 bps YoY, up 20 bps QoQ |
| GS3 plus GS2 | 10.3%, expected to come down below 10% |
| GNPA as per IRAC | ₹6,000 cr vs stage 3 of ₹4,309 cr, roughly another 1.5% above GS3 |
| Net slippages (Q2 FY25) | ~₹800–820 cr |
| Net slippages (1H FY25) | ~₹1,500 cr, similar to full-year FY24 slippages |
| End losses (FY24) | ₹1,700 cr, sliding further from ₹2,200 cr in FY23 and ₹2,500 cr in FY22 |
| ROA (H1 FY25 exit) | 1.5%, full-year visibility 1.8% to 2%, management more bullish on 2% |
| Diversification mix | 6% of overall mix, plan was 15% |
| Cost-to-income ratio | ~40%, down from peak of ~43%; ideal target 38% to 40% |
| Capital adequacy ratio change | Down 180 bps QoQ |
| Sequential asset base growth | 5.7% QoQ |
| Used vehicle mix | 18% of the mix |
| PV share of disbursement mix | 40% |
| PV disbursement growth (Q2 FY25) | -3% YoY |
| CV disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | -1% YoY |
| Used vehicle disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | 2% YoY |
| Tractor disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | -3% YoY |
| 3-wheeler disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | -1% YoY |
| SME disbursement growth (H1 FY25) | 50%-plus YoY |
| East region disbursement acquisition change | Reduced by ~200 bps |
| Rural housing finance GS3 | ~9%, down from 12% same time last year |
| Rural housing subsidiary employee reduction | Reduced by ~3,500 employees from close to 10,000 |
| Co-lending monthly throughput aspiration per partner | ₹25 cr to ₹40 cr over the medium term |
| Provision release in Q3 FY24 | ~₹80 cr, outcome of model refresh, not intentional |