Key Takeaways
- Highest-ever disbursements, asset quality healing: Disbursements hit a record while Gross Stage 3 fell to 5.9% from a peak above 15%, driven by customer settlements and improving rural cash flows, not repossessions.
- Margin stability despite rate pressure: NIMs held steady even as borrowing costs rose; the company passed on ~80 bps of rate increases but sees no urgency to bridge the remaining gap, expecting rates may ease.
- AAA upgrade unlocks funding advantage: The rating upgrade should lower borrowing costs and widen the lender base, supporting margin defense and growth.
- Succession announced 15 months ahead: COO Raul Rebello named MD and CEO designate, taking over when Ramesh Iyer retires on April 29, 2024, following the group's structured transition norm.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the repo ban lift accelerates Stage 3 cleanup and provision releases, the pace of borrowing cost pass-through as rates stay high through H1 FY24, and early traction in the leasing and digital finance verticals.
Asset Quality Turnaround
- Stage 3 down to 5.9%: Gross Stage 3 improved from a peak above 15% to 5.9%, with Stage 1 rising to 85.5%–85.7% and Stage 2 falling to 8.4%. The improvement came through customer settlements, not repossessions, since the ban was in place all quarter.
- Settlements beat repossession economics: Settlements come at a slightly lower loss than repossessing and selling vehicles from high delinquent accounts, so the ban period actually supported better recoveries.
- Repo ban lifted, cleanup to accelerate: RBI has now allowed repossessions; the company will target long-outstanding delinquent accounts, which should release further provisions from the book.
- January NPA held flat: Normally the first month of a new quarter sees an NPA increase, but January levels were maintained at December levels, signaling sustained collection momentum.
- New-vintage quality is clean: Delinquency from loans originated in the last 12–18 months is negligible, confirming underwriting quality has improved materially.
- Long-term normal around 3%–4%: Given the exposure to tractors, 3-wheelers, pickups and the full vehicle range, management expects a normalized gross NPA of 3%–4% on a regular basis.
- At least 100 bps more improvement ahead: Further gross NPA reduction is expected over time, driven by repossessions and settlements on high-age buckets.
Ramesh Iyer: "I'll take you back to -- a few quarters back when our NPA had gone to the highest level, and then we have made a commitment that how we see things changing. And then on, every quarter, we have seen things going in the right direction as envisaged by us. And it's not by chance, it's going in the direction."
Margins, Rates & Borrowing Cost
- NIMs held steady despite compression fears: Margins were maintained even as wide-ranging expectations of compression played out in the market.
- ~80 bps passed on, gap remains: Rate increases were implemented from November onward and passed through to consumers, but a gap still exists between lending rates and borrowing costs. Management does not believe that gap needs to be bridged in urgency.
- Rate-cut expectation shapes patience: The company expects interest rates may start coming off in the next couple of quarters; if not, it can always decide to pass on more.
- High rates here through H1 FY24: Management expects the high interest rate scenario to continue at least for the first half of the next fiscal.
- Borrowing cost to rise another 15–20 bps: On a weighted average basis, another 15- to 20-basis point increase in borrowing cost is expected over the next 3 to 4 quarters.
- Yield benefit is gradual, not overnight: Rate increases apply to month-on-month disbursements, so the full NIM benefit won't materialize until the past fixed-rate book matures and the new book builds up.
- Product mix can compress NIMs but pays elsewhere: Low-yield products like personal-segment cars are high in volume and compress NIMs, but that is more than offset by lower operating cost and lower credit cost.
- AAA upgrade to help on both cost and access: The rating upgrade should bring benefit on borrowing cost and the ability to borrow from a wider set of fund providers.
Ramesh Iyer: "But there is still a gap, but we don't believe that that needs to be bridged in urgency. And our expectation is in the next couple of quarters, we may probably start seeing the interest rates come off. If not, we can always take a decision to work more and how much more to really pass on."
Growth & Demand Environment
- Record disbursements: The company clocked its highest-ever quarterly disbursements in Q3 FY23.
- Rural cash flows are holding up: Good monsoons, good yields, supportive MSP announcements, infrastructure activity opening up across states, and no pressure on tourism or people movement are all supporting farm and contracting cash flows.
- Supply improving, footfalls high: Vehicle availability has increased after a period of shortages, and dealership footfalls continue to be high, resulting in good retail volumes.
- Pre-owned vehicles a growth engine: Demand for pre-owned vehicles is high and the segment is expected to be a growth driver for the year.
- OEM price increases to lift disbursements: Vehicle and tractor price increases expected in the next 12 months will bring higher disbursement for the same unit volume.
- Market share improved across most product lines: The company continues to maintain leadership positions in most products in its market.
- Large-base segments show slower growth: Sluggishness in growth rates for auto/utility vehicles, tractors, and cars reflects their already large base numbers, not any loss of market share or leadership; growth depends on underlying market volumes.
- Manthan personal loans to outgrow digital vehicle finance: The personal loan product offered to existing good customers with 12–18 months of clean repayment history is expected to grow faster than digital growth in the vehicle and tractor business.
Ramesh Iyer: "And our confidence is that, in the times to come, rural market is a place to watch, and it will have the continuity of the positive buoyancy in the segment that we see there."
New Verticals & Subsidiary Turnarounds
- Leasing business built early: The company has already underwritten more than 200–250 corporate clients for employee CTC vehicle leasing and sees an advantage from entering earlier than other NBFCs.
- Digital finance vertical still sub-scale: Launched over a year ago with processes and technology well tested, but numbers are too small to report; management expects it to become a distinct growth vertical within the next year.
- Housing finance strategy reset: A conscious call was taken to exit certain rural segments that caused enormous pain and move up the ladder; the future book will be 40%–50% affordable housing (₹8 lakh to ₹15 lakh ticket size) with the rural segment shifted to ₹2 lakh–₹5 lakh, a more affluent customer base.
- Housing finance turnaround in 3 years: Management expects a dramatic change in the housing business over the next 3 years, driven by the new segmentation strategy and stronger legal collection practices being put in place.
- MIBL awaiting regulatory changes: The insurance broking subsidiary's bottom line is depressed by commission structure; a good turnaround is expected once certain regulatory changes come through.
- SME book at ~₹4,000 crores: The company has set out a clear plan for the SME segment over the next couple of years and sees a great growth opportunity.
Ramesh Iyer: "It's just that this disruption caused them enormous pain, and we have realized that this is not the segment that we should go after."
Operating Efficiency & Collections Transformation
- Collections shifted from cash to digital: The company used to be 90%+ cash-collecting; now roughly 40% is cash and 60% through digital means, which helps improve cost going forward.
- Other opex declined sharply QoQ: Driven by two factors: a contra between employee cost and other opex as outsourced payroll resources were taken on payroll, and the absence of third-party repossession agency costs during the repo ban quarter.
- 20–30 bps opex improvement targeted: Productivity is kicking in as disbursements and AUM grow; the company is cautiously working on opex improvement, though transformation project investments will keep costs a little elevated in the coming year.
- Trade advances normalized post-festive season: Trade advance levels were elevated at end-Q2 due to the incoming festive season; much of that credit has now converted into retail, so trade advances normalized by end-Q3.
Credit Cost & Provisioning Outlook
- Credit cost worry receding: Future delinquency improvement will come from high-age buckets that already carry higher provisions, so incremental provisioning pressure should be limited.
- Long-term structural credit cost likely lower: As asset quality, customer segments, and business mix change with more SME coming in, the structural P&L provision charge should move below the past guidance of ~180–200 bps in normal times.
- PCR is formula-driven and will self-correct: Provision coverage ratio is based on historic 4-year data under the ECL model; as each year passes and a better year enters the lookback window, PCR will start getting corrected. The overlay is now zero, with everything completely driven by the ECL model.
- FY24 credit cost hard to forecast: Management declined to give a specific credit cost number, focusing instead on collecting from what has been provided and targeting high delinquent accounts through repossessions.
Ramesh Iyer: "So our view is that we may not have to necessarily over worry on the credit cost front going forward. What we really have to focus on is the opex coming down and the NIMs being protected by better borrowing, by better lending rates and better product mix management, and that will collectively lead to an improved ROA that we would like to see."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross Stage 3 improvement | At least another 100 bps reduction from current 5.9% | Over a period of time |
| Normalized gross NPA | 3%–4% in this market given product mix | Long-term steady state |
| Borrowing cost increase | Another 15–20 bps on a weighted average basis | Next 3–4 quarters |
| High interest rate environment | Rates to stay elevated | At least through H1 FY24 |
| Housing finance turnaround | Dramatic change in the business expected | Next 3 years |
| Housing finance mix shift | 40%–50% of future book from affordable housing (₹8L–₹15L) | Going forward |
| Digital finance vertical | Become a distinct, reportable growth vertical | Within the next 1 year |
| Strategy 2025 | On course for achieving most parameters | Run up to 2025 |
| ROA improvement | Driven by opex reduction, NIM protection, product mix management | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total loan income to average profit (yield) | 13.7%, up from 13.4% QoQ |
| Cost of funds | Over 7.2% |
| Borrowing cost increase passed to consumers | ~80 bps |
| Expected increase in weighted average borrowing cost (next 3–4 quarters) | 15–20 bps |
| Gross Stage 3 NPA | 5.9%, down from 6.7% QoQ |
| Stage 3 provision coverage ratio | 59% |
| Stage 2 assets | Close to ₹6,500 cr, 8.4% of asset book, down from 9.7% QoQ |
| Stage 1 assets | 85.5%–85.7% of book, up from 83.5% QoQ |
| Expected improvement in gross NPA | At least another 100 bps over a period of time |
| Other opex YoY increase | 1.1% |
| Opex improvement being targeted | 20–30 bps |
| SME book | Close to about ₹4,000 cr |
| Leasing business clients underwritten | More than 200, 250 |
| Live customer base | Close to about 20, 22 lakh |
| Average monthly customer additions | Upward of 60,000-plus, good months 70,000–75,000-plus |
| Cash collection mix | ~40% cash collected, 60% through digital means, down from 90%+ cash historically |
| Rural housing subsidiary affordable lending mix | About 50-50, 45-55 |
| Manthan personal loan product monthly customers | About 5,000 or maybe even 6,000 |
| Tractor industry market share | 30%, 35% |