Key Takeaways
- Stable quarter, margin and growth momentum positive: NIMs improved 20 bps sequentially and the quarter was characterized as stable, though asset quality remained range bound with GS3 ticking up 10 bps.
- A one-time ECL model benefit flattered provisions: A $434 crore provision write-back, driven by a programmatic LGD decline from a large June '21 pool entering the 42-month calculation, caused PCR to drop 900 bps. Management says this benefit is now fully baked in.
- The 7.5% NIM target is officially dead: Management reset the long-range NIM target to 7%, citing a deliberate shift toward prime customers and product choices that make the old aspiration unachievable.
- Diversification bets are early and expensive: SME lending grew 60% YoY off a low base, and new fee streams from insurance distribution and co-branded cards are building, but OPEX investments will stay elevated to fund these long-term plays.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether PCR begins its guided gradual uptick from the 51-54% range, execution on the 20% used-vehicle sourcing target, and the detailed 3-4 year roadmap promised at Q4 results.
The ECL Provision Write-Back: Mechanics and Consequences
- The trigger was mechanical, not discretionary: The company's ECL model calculates LGD using cash flows over a rolling 42-month period. This quarter, the June '21 pool (with roughly $4,000 crores in additions) entered that window for the first time, and its demonstrated high collection efficiency caused a programmatic drop in LGD.
- The P&L impact was material: The LGD decline drove a $434 crore provision reduction, pulling PCR down by 900 bps. Management stated this benefit is "fully baked in for now" and was a known, anticipated outcome of the model's mechanics.
- PDs are trending the other way: Provision coverage is a function of both PD and LGD. While LGD provided a tailwind, management noted that PDs generally trend upwards in the current macro environment, creating a natural offset in future periods.
- No further PCR decline expected: With the LGD benefit realized, management guided for PCR to move gradually higher from here, staying range bound between 51% and 54% in the near future and not exceeding 54%.
- Management overlay was considered and rejected: The company contemplated creating overlay provisions to smooth the volatility but decided against it, not wanting to do "artwork on top of the model." They left the door open to build buffers at the right time.
Raul Rebello: "We did contemplate it. We just felt we'd be being a bit too cute and trying to basically do artwork on top of the model."
NIM Trajectory and the Target Reset
- Sequential yield improvement of 20 bps: The uplift came from optimizing incremental pricing, a favorable mix shift, and fee-based income from the new corporate agency license, which has been a healthy contributor even after normalizing for MIBL's contribution.
- Cost of funds remains a headwind: COF increased 10 bps sequentially as lower-priced lines ran off and leverage stayed elevated. Management is trying to secure incremental funding at lower levels with reasonable success.
- The 7.5% NIM target is abandoned: The target, set at FY22-end, was recalibrated after 2.5 years of elevated cost of funds. Management now sees 7.5% as incompatible with the deliberate choice to pursue prime customers and specific product mixes. The new long-range target is 7%, with 6.5-6.7% expected for this fiscal.
- Higher-NIM segments are the priority: The strategy is to double-click on tractor and used-vehicle financing, both of which carry higher NIM capability, to support the revised margin profile.
Raul Rebello: "I don't think 7.5% with the kind of choice metrics that we have shared on the profile of incremental customers as well as the kind of product choices that we are making for the future will achieve a 7.5%. So, 7% is more like the long-range target."
Asset Quality: Range Bound with Pockets of Stress
- GS3 moved up 10 bps sequentially: While tractor saw a sequential reduction in GS3 (last quarter's spike was characterized as a delay, not a default), other asset categories added to the stock.
- The collection environment has softened: Management acknowledged the environment is not as rosy as Q3 last year, making collections a big priority. End losses have remained on a declining trend, and write-offs have been declining over the last couple of years.
- A sticky gap between GNPA and GS3 persists: The roughly $1,700 crore difference has been range bound for 3-4 quarters. These assets carry Stage-2 provisions but are IRACP NPAs where getting 3 EMIs is difficult. The collection team has been reconfigured to be product-specific, with a stated goal to reduce this number.
- Used-vehicle prices are holding, with caveats: No sharp decline seen overall. New-vehicle discounts in PVs have had some rub-off effect on used-vehicle prices, but nothing worrisome. Used CV and tractor prices have held firm.
- Slippage details were withheld: Management declined to disclose net slippage numbers or a product-wise breakdown of the $670 crores in slippages, telling analysts to compute it themselves.
Growth: Farm and SME Lead, Wheels Hit a Ceiling
- Growth returned after two soft quarters: The comeback was led by the Farm business (tractor) and Passenger Vehicles, supported by a revival in the underlying industry and efforts to improve dealership and geographic coverage.
- SME is a bright spot off a low base: The SME book grew 60% YoY, with LAP now constituting the majority of the business and coming in at a good clip.
- The core Wheels business is structurally constrained: At 93% of the book, CV has seen prolonged stress and is range bound, used-vehicle growth was soft this quarter, and PV growth is concentrated in the price-conscious extreme prime segment with an upper ceiling.
- Used-vehicle execution was soft: Management admitted execution could have been better and set an incremental sourcing target of 20% of incremental disbursement for used PV, CV, and tractor.
Raul Rebello: "Nevertheless, in our mind, we could have executed better on this. We want to make sure that incremental sourcing of used PV, CV tractor is 20% of our incremental disbursement. It was a soft execution, one that I would call it."
Diversification and the Long-Term Investment Cycle
- New partnerships are stacking up: The quarter saw an exclusive EV lending partnership with M&M for Born Electric vehicles, a co-branded credit card partnership with RBL Bank, insurance distribution tie-ups with 9 providers, a FASTag partnership with IDFC Bank, and in-principle approval for a TPAP license from NPCI.
- Fee-based income is becoming material: The corporate agency license has delivered healthy fee-based income over the last 7-8 months, contributing to the yield improvement even after normalizing for MIBL.
- Mahindra Rural Housing Finance is being restructured: A senior resource from Bajaj Housing Finance has moved full-time to the entity, manpower has been significantly reduced, and OPEX is expected to come down. Asset quality is starting to see positive changes.
- These are long-term, deliberate investments: Management framed the spending on diversification, underwriting, risk, compliance, tech, and collections as necessary for an organization with a $1,15,000+ crore loan book that aims to be a holistic financial services player.
Raul Rebello: "Many of these are long-term initiatives and long-term investments that we think we have to make at a certain size and scale, having a loan book of INR 1,15,000-odd crores, and from an organization, which is looking at playing a much more holistic financial services play for the foreseeable future."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Credit cost | 1.3% to 1.5% range | FY25 and going forward below 1.5% |
| NIM | 6.5% to 6.7% | FY25 |
| Long-range NIM target | 7% | Long-range (no date) |
| PCR range | 51% to 54%, not to exceed 54% | Near future |
| ROA | 1.8% to 2% | FY25 |
| Long-term ROA aspiration | 2.5% | Long-term |
| Asset growth | Mid- to high teens | Ongoing |
| OPEX range | 2.5% to 2.7% | Ongoing |
| Branch additions | 15-20 more branches | FY25 |
| Used-vehicle sourcing target | 20% of incremental disbursement | Ongoing |
| Detailed 3-4 year roadmap | Strategy across growth, asset categories, digital, AI | Q4 FY25 results |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY25 |
|---|---|
| PAT | ₹899 cr |
| Disbursements | +25% QoQ, +7% YoY |
| AUM / Loan book | ~₹1,15,000 cr |
| NIM | 6.6%, +10 bps QoQ, -20 bps YoY |
| Yield (loan and fee income) | +20 bps QoQ sequential improvement |
| Cost of funds | +10 bps QoQ |
| NIM target for FY25 | 6.5% to 6.7% |
| Long-range NIM target | 7% |
| GS3 | 3.9%, +10 bps QoQ, -4 bps YoY |
| GS3 addition | ₹216 cr sequentially |
| Credit cost for the quarter | ₹9 cr added |
| Provision reduction (ECL model LGD benefit) | ₹434 cr |
| PCR | 50%, down from 59% QoQ |
| PCR expected range | 51% to 54% in the near future |
| Credit cost target for FY25 | 1.3% to 1.5% |
| ROA target for FY25 | 1.8% to 2% |
| Long-term ROA aspiration | 2.5% |
| Wheels business share | 93% of the organization |
| Tractor disbursement growth | +24% YoY |
| Passenger vehicle disbursement growth | +8% YoY |
| CV disbursement growth | -5% YoY, +27% QoQ |
| SME disbursement growth | +60% YoY |
| Asset growth target | Mid- to high teens |
| Collection efficiency | 95%, stable |
| Write-offs for the quarter | ~₹450 cr |
| Net slippages for the quarter | ~₹670 cr (per an analyst's math) |
| End losses for 9M FY25 | ₹52 cr lower than 9M FY24 |
| Stage-2 coverage | 9.1%, down from 10.6% QoQ |
| Total ECL provision on balance sheet | ~3%, down from 5% over 7-8 quarters |
| Tier-1 capital | 15% |
| Branches added in Q3 | 25, 35 YTD; plan to add 15-20 more in FY25 |
| Employees certified for insurance cross-sell (POSP) | 4,000 |
| Applications moved to cloud | 40% |
| Employees completed digital dexterity program | 49% |