Key Takeaways
- FY24 de-grew, but Q4 inflected: Total income fell ~2% YoY to ₹214.42 cr, yet Q4 standalone income, EBITDA, PBT and PAT all rose double digits QoQ, signaling a potential trough.
- A ₹130 cr order book funds a 25% growth ambition: Management guided 25% consolidated growth for each of the next two years, backed by visible orders from John Deere, Honeywell and bi-metal customers.
- Margins sank on structural costs, not volume: H2 EBITDA margin fell from ~25% to sub-20% as permanent staff, electricity and raw material costs rose; management now plans an OEM price increase to restore 23–24%.
- Three verticals, three growth engines: Bearings, aluminium casting (Alkop) and brake linings are confirmed as the standalone structure, with Alkop guided to 45% growth and brakes to 70–75% growth.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised OEM price increase lands and margins begin recovering, the pace of bi-metal order conversion from November–December, and any concrete update on the Brakes India discussion.
Revenue & Order Book
- FY24 top-line dip: Total income fell to ₹214.42 cr from ₹220 cr, driven by a tractor industry slowdown and a recession in Japan that cut exports from ₹12 cr to ₹4–5 cr.
- Q4 sequential recovery: Standalone income rose 6% QoQ, EBITDA 13%, PBT 21% and PAT 16%, suggesting the worst of the de-growth passed by Q3.
- Order book visibility: The ₹130 cr order book is executable over one-and-a-half to two years, and management sees an additional ₹140 cr of business arriving within two years.
- Brake division lumpiness resolved: A QoQ revenue drop occurred because export orders to Bangladesh and Dubai were clubbed in Q3; orders are now flowing monthly and should be regular going forward.
- Others segment gaining share: The Others category (generators, electrical items, compressors, strips) grew from 8.8% to 12.1% of revenue sequentially.
- Revenue trajectory: With year-on-year growth of about 25–26% hereafter, management expects to reach almost ₹400 cr.
Vertical Growth Engines
| Vertical | Growth Guidance | Key Drivers |
|---|---|---|
| Standalone Bearings | ~15% YoY for next 3 years | Market share gains in heavy-duty (Escorts from 40% to 60%, International Tractors toward 100%); Bajaj Auto approached for export-substitute bearings |
| Alkop (Aluminium Casting) | ~45% YoY for next 2 years, ~16–17% in year 3 | John Deere order (₹70 cr over 2 years), Honeywell order (₹15–18 cr), total casting orders ~₹90 cr over 2 years; capacity augmenting from 1,440 to 2,500 tonnes |
| Brake Linings | ~70–75% YoY for next 3 years | Export orders and aftermarket demand; should cross ₹10 cr this year; railways application submitted and under consideration |
| Bi-metal | Supplies start Nov–Dec 2024 | Orders worth ₹40 cr+ for execution over this year and next; customer cancelling prior supplier (Mahle) contract; new capacity expanding from 4.86 cr to ~550 |
- Heavy-duty market share surge: The heavy-duty segment itself is not growing as predicted, but Menon is taking share aggressively, with Escorts raising allocation from 40% to 60% and International Tractors moving from 80% toward 100%.
- China Plus One tailwind: Management noted that many more buyers are approaching the company for sourcing from India under China Plus One and Europe Plus One policies.
Aradhye: "From Escorts now, last month only we got a mail from them that our share of business from 40% it had been increased to 60%. Whereas in international tractors also it was 80% and they are going to increase maximum maybe up to 100% or little less than that."
Margins & Cost Structure
- H2 margin compression: EBITDA margin fell from ~25% in H2 FY23 to slightly below 20% in H2 FY24 on similar revenues, because permanent staff costs, electricity and raw material costs all rose substantially.
- Price increase planned: Management will take up price increases with all OEMs after Q4 completion, calling it a routine practice that OEMs are expected to accept, aiming to restore EBITDA margins to 23–24%.
- Segment disclosure coming: From the next reporting period, margins for Alkop and bi-metal may be shared separately now that the businesses are separated.
Aradhye: "Now is the time after the completion of this quarter we will be taking up the issue with all our OEMs for increasing the prices and as a routine practice, they are also going to accept so that our EBITDA margins will be restored again."
Japan & Export Headwinds
- Japan exports collapsed: Exports to Japan fell from ₹12 cr to ₹4–5 cr in FY24 due to recession, with only one customer (Diedo Metal, which is also a competitor).
- Recovery uncertain: Management said the Japan customer is "slowly recovering" but added "we are not very sure about that," and feelers only indicate a likely improvement "in the near time."
- Brake export diversification: New export markets opened in Bangladesh and Dubai (serving African countries), with orders now arriving monthly, partially offsetting Japan weakness.
Capex, Subsidiaries & Structure
- Three verticals confirmed: The company will operate as bearings/bushes/washers, aluminium pressure die casting, and brake linings, with no hiving off of any unit.
- Lead-free factory: Construction is complete at Menon Bearings and manufacturing facilities have started.
- Alkop factory shed: Construction ongoing, likely completed by 15–30 June 2024.
- CWIP capitalization: The ₹14 cr capital work in progress will be entirely capitalized this year across both bearing and aluminium divisions.
- New business subsidiary: Menon Bearings New Ventures was created with ₹8 cr share capital not yet deployed; it is evaluating proposals including EV charger manufacturing, but nothing is finalized.
- Total turnover capacity: With new infrastructure in place, the company may reach ₹450 cr turnover.
Aradhye: "New business subsidiary will be looking for -- there are several proposals that are coming our way other than engineering businesses like manufacturing of chargers for electric vehicles."
OEM Demand & End-Market Outlook
- Tractor business: Slowly picking up, with signs of improvement in the Japan recession.
- Monsoon-driven optimism: Management is hopeful but notes OEMs themselves are "not very sure" about production plans; a good monsoon is expected to boost HCV, LCV and tractors.
- EV and hydrogen risk dismissed: Management argued that EV adoption in MHCVs and tractors is far off and the company is not exposed to passenger vehicles, so bearing content reduction is not a concern. On hydrogen, the view was that it "will take a lot of time" and is not worth worrying about now.
Aradhye: "Like in hydrogen also, that is a far more -- you see it will take a lot of time like EV still we are not very sure about MHCV and tractors. So, we should not think much about hydrogen just now, that's what I feel."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue growth | 25% YoY | Each of next 2 years |
| Standalone bearings growth | ~15% YoY | Each of next 3 years |
| Alkop division growth | ~45% YoY, then ~16–17% | Next 2 years, then year 3 |
| Brake division growth | ~70–75% YoY | Each of next 3 years |
| Brake division revenue | Cross ₹10 cr | This year (FY25) |
| EBITDA margin restoration | 23–24% | Via price increase after Q4 completion |
| Bi-metal regular supplies | Start of commercial supplies | November or December 2024 |
| John Deere order execution | ₹70 cr target | Over next 2 years |
| Total casting orders execution | ~₹90 cr | Over next 2 years |
| Bi-metal orders execution | ₹40 cr+ | Over this year and next year |
| CWIP capitalization | ₹14 cr fully capitalized | This year (FY25) |
| Alkop capacity | 1,440 to 2,500 tonnes | With announced CapEx |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income (FY24) | ₹214.42 cr, de-growth of ~2% vs ₹220 cr in FY23 |
| EBITDA (FY24) | ₹45 cr, 21.0% margin |
| PBT (FY24) | ₹33 cr, 15.46% margin |
| PAT (FY24) | ₹24.36 cr, 11.36% margin |
| QoQ standalone total income growth | +6% (Q4 vs Q3) |
| QoQ standalone EBITDA growth | +13% (Q4 vs Q3) |
| QoQ standalone PBT growth | +21% (Q4 vs Q3) |
| QoQ standalone PAT growth | +16% (Q4 vs Q3) |
| Consolidated revenue growth guidance | 25% to 26% year-on-year going forward |
| Standalone revenue growth guidance | 15% year-on-year for next three years |
| Alkop (aluminium casting) growth guidance | 40% to 45% for next two years |
| Brake division growth guidance | 70% to 75% year-on-year for next three years |
| Order book (incremental) | ~₹130 cr, executable over next 1.5 to 2 years: ~₹90 cr Alkop, ~₹40 cr Bi-metal |
| Export share of revenue | 28% to 30% of total revenue |
| Japan export revenue (FY24) | ₹4 to ₹5 cr, down from ~₹12 cr historically |
| Cash and bank balances | ~₹24 cr |
| Capital work in progress (closing FY24) | ₹14 cr, to be fully capitalized in FY25 |
| Alkop capacity | 1,440 tonnes, augmentable to 2,500 tonnes |
| Bi-metal capacity (post-expansion) | ~₹550 cr (per an analyst's math) |
| Wallet share with Tata Motors | 60% |
| Wallet share with Cummins | 60% |
| Top 5 customer share in Alkop | ~50% of Alkop business |
| Escorts share of business increase | From 40% to 60% |